1. Jewish identity is not "versus" justice of any people
Anti semitism has recently been enacted against Rabin's grave site
The same mentality that would deface Rabin and Leah's gravestone(s) is comprable to who and what defaces Jewish gravetones around the world.
I personally do not know any "self loathing " Jews
My Israeli friends are "non loathing " Jews
Whoever defaces Rabin's tombstone = "loathing Jew" and should not be supported i n any form or example of "Jewish" values and spirit, especially in example to children
M
| Mary La Rosa , |
NYC, USA |
|
(04.22.05) |
|
|
2. Yehoshua article sparks storm
Mr. Yehoshua's conclusion that if all Jews lived in Israel there would be no anti-Semitism after 50 years because people would not have known the Jews at all is a fallacy. Since when does one have to know Jews to hate them? There are many Jew-haters in the world who have never seen a Jew. How many people in the Arab countries have ever met a Jew? Yet their hatred of us is fierce. For that matter, the rampant anti-Semitism in Europe is not due to the fact that these people have had personal contact with Jews. It's because they 'know', a priori, that Jews and especially Israelis are bad.
The comparison with the Tibetans is ridiculous. We have not been brainwashed to hate the Tibetans. It has nothing to do with knowing them or not.
| Ora W. Hall , |
Tel Aviv, Israel |
|
(04.23.05) |
|
|
3. NO Jews lived outside Israel?
What's he talking about? If all Jews lived in Israel there'd be no antisemitism?
What kind of nonsense is that?
The Arabs are then going to accept Israel and stop the demonization of Israel and Jews? Lol!
And suddenly the Europeans are going to forget about their engrained hatred of Jews?
What planet does he live on?
I live in the US and antisemitism is undetectable, other than the demonization of Israel at college campuses.
Mike
| Mike , |
Englewood, New Jerse |
|
(04.24.05) |
|
|
4. A.B. Yehoshua: OLD TIME SECULAR ZIONIST=OLD TIME IDIOT...
YEHOSHUA CONTRADICTS HIMSELF, AS THE "OLD TIME RELIGION" SECULAR JEWISH NATIONALISM ITSELF DID. ON THE ONE HAND HE WANTS ALL JEWS TO LIVE IN ISRAEL (A NOBLE GOAL), BUT THEY SHOULDN'T BE RELIGIOUS (I.E. CONNECTED TO JEWISH HISTORY AND CULTURE). WHY WOULD SUCH A "CULTURE EMPTY JEW" WANT TO MOVE TO ISRAEL? AND THOSE SAME "AMORPHOUS" JEWS WOULD SUDDENLY BE "ROOTED" AND "STABLE-BORDERED" IN SECULAR-LIFESTYLE ISRAEL? WAKE UP A.B... WITHOUT A TRADITIONAL JEWISH "RELIGIOUS" IDEALOGICAL LIFESTYLE, JEWS ARE TRUELY AMORPHOUS, EVEN DISAPEARING...BUT THEN WITHOUT "BORDERS" I.E. TORAH, WHO CARES???
|
|
5. A. B. Yehoshua
Mr. Yehoshua is correct on one point: Jews should not be afraid of looking at themselves. On the larger point, however, he misses the boat. Anti-Semitism exists only in Christian and Muslim countries, not Hindu and Buddhist countries. The reason is quite simple: Christian scriptures state, quite plainly, that Jews rejected the Christian god, Muslim scriptures state that Jews rejectedt he Muslim god and are his enemies. By contrast, Hindu and Buddhist scriptures are silent about Jews.
When Christian and Muslim children are taught that God hates Jews, they will absorb the teaching and many will act on it. To end anti-Semitism, Christians and Muslims need to change their religions to make some other unfortunate nation the object of their wrath.
Sincerely,
Seth E. Watkins
| Seth Watkins , |
Menlo Park, USA |
|
(04.27.05) |
|
|
6. Yehoshua article
The fault is not with the Jews Mr. Yehoshua; the fault is with the gentiles--basically the Christians and the Moslems.
With their cruel and racist theology stating only they have the truth, Moslems and Christians have slaughtered others in the name of that truth since their invention.
We reject them because we have our own identity, therefore they hate us.
Their problem although we must learn to survive around their murderous theology. But not succumb to it.
|
|