I don't think that the Protocols were a legend..!!!

The Protocols have been on the Nakba website ever since tthe site was updated in May 2004.

in the net there alot of sites about this protocols , why you complain only from this one ?!!!! and this protocols is anti Jews not anti Simitic because the Jews are not the only simitics in world , so pleas not anyone who do not agree with you you call him antisimitic

EVERY DAY SOMEONE TALKS BAD ABOUT THE ARABS, AND MUSLIMS BUT IT IS OK IT FREEDOM OF SPEECH...

Freedom of speech, opinion and very democratic or as Jews say ANTI-SIMITIC. you say there has been no PALESTINE and we say there has been no ISRAEL, so there is no problem, the result of the match is 1:1

but then many of you know nothing but hate , it is a known lie and the PA website is of a Govt. and if that Govt. says it wants peace then why incite hate by publishing this book of lies? once again Abbas and his crew prove they are going insane! and let me ask you all this! if we published a Govt. site stating that you are all gay, and you all mated with donkies would that be something you would tolerate? would you just laugh? it seems not when a us mag published a rumor of koran desacrations,

If someone would tell about you and your family that you are thieves, you would sit idle and not defend against those lies, right??!!! Besides, your second argument about badmouthing Arabs, you just have to watch the daily news of the reactions in the fanatic Arab world to see, that you got a very serious mental problem at your hands. Watch the recent "Newsweek Koran lie...." Here we got another lie again!

John, of course it is a legend. #3, there is a complaint because this is the official site of the PA. If they are spreading these lies on their website they are helping nobody. They need to stop immediately. Ahmed, there is a difference between freedom of speech and incitement, cmon... Libyan guy, you dont deserve a response...

To the previous responers: The Protocols were devised by the Tsarist police in Russia and were plagiarizee from a French anti-Mason novel. There is no truth to them whatsoever--but they have been used by anti-Semites --including the Nazis and for a long time now the Islamic wolrd to "prove" some sort of Jewish consipiracy to conrtol the world. As far as anti-semitism is concerned, the term was invented in France to apply specifically to Jews. Frankly, my problem with this issue is that why the normal Israeli press--such as Ynet and Haaretz have waited until now to take up the issue of the PA and antisemitisim? The information that the PA propogates to its consitutents is, in my mind, an indication of how serious they really are about coming to an accord with Israel. Why do I have to turn to the "loony" press, such as Arutz Sheva in order to get information on some of the things being said in the Arab press and news media? The big quesiton is: what will the PA do after the Gaza pullout? Will there be movenet toward peace or will ther be a step-up in terrorism? As for the wackos who have so far responded to this article on the Protocols: John, Ahmad, Llibyan Guy and Nameless One-- you can believe what you want, but what you believe on this issue is the equivalent of believing that the earth is flat or that 2 + 2 = 5.

Historically speakin, the so-called protocoles were no more than a plan fabricated by some Russian intellectual during the czars reign meaning to increase persecution against the Jews of Russia. The protocols exaggeratingly magnify the danger of "Jews", but doesn't necessarily mean some ethnical discriminiation neither does it consolidate the Jewish ostensible pretext of anti-semitism. The hard measures Israel has been taking against Palestinians was the only reason that stongly brough back such deformed thoughts and hatred against the Jews. Objectively speaking, is Israel purely innocent of the ill thoughts in the protocols? Are the protocols completely wrong, or there something right about them?!!!!!

Israel should give the PA an ultimatum, end this anti-semetic rhetoric or Israel will hold back on something important to the PA. The PA needs to learn this is not how responsible governments operate.

tell me how responsible governments operate? by kiling kids....

I think Islam is the only religion that tolerated jews and accepted jews...this is evedent if you review history you can see that jews thrived during the muslim rule in spain (the sphardeem Jews) also when the spanish kicked jews out the only place to go was the otoman empire..the sultan him self welcomed the jewish refujees...I think islam deserves a thank you from jews.

You know why did the Russians succeed in spreading the protocols? Because there were no objective and real counter attack to prove that they were not true. Look now to the land robbery in the west bank and earlier in 48 territories. They robbed my grandfather’s house and orange field in Yaffa because they claim it's theirs' and they destroy the olive trees and take the land now because it's theirs'. The only way to prove that the protocols are not true is to show the opposite of it not by only denying it. And again to jay how should governments behave? By robbing land and building walls like those around the west bank, Berlin and Warsaw Jewish ghettos?

Israeli occupation actions and crimes against Palestinians speak much louder than any protocol.

Lib guy: the way we were taught to view things is that that government may not be permitted to control the free press (and is there free press in the nondemocratic levant?) but that does not prevent us from calling scum "scum". Too bad you cannot spell "semitic"...

Is there any mystery that Israel agreed to resettle folks run out of Syria, Iraq, Egypt and other places in 1948 but they did not want the folks who left Israel because they were suckered by the Grand Mufti's lies? And these are the same fine folk who cheered on 9/11/01? And you really enjoyed Arafat's lies about his birthplace and stealing money from you? SUCKERS!!!

wHAT ABOUT THE GOVERNMENT THAT SENDS THOSE KIDS OUT ION THE FIRST PLACE AKA THE PA, HAMAS, AND ISLAMIC JIHAD. YOU ARE THE STUPID ONE HERE.

gOVERNMENTS SHOULD NOT BEHAVE THE WAY THE ARAB GOVERNMENTS BEHAVE. THATS FOR SURE. STEALING FROM THE NATIONAL TREASURY, DEPRIVING PEOPLE OF DEMOCRACY, KILLING THEIR OWN PEOPLE.

RIGHT ON OTIS!!!

Snap out of this recycled propaganda and listen to Israeli bulldozers destroying Palestinian homes and neighborhoods. While you are at it, listen also to Israeli tanks fire on Palestinian kids and peace activities in Gaza refugee camps.

This is just another example. If the PA really wanted peace there would have been decades ago, but they dont. They like in fantasyland instead of reality. They dont deal with facts but prefer to make them up. GO home and be happy with your Jordanian-Palestinian Federation. I'd rather be right than popular and its time to ignore the popular Palestinian lies once and for all.

The fact that there there already is a Palestinian State is a truth that people dont want to admit. The fact that Israel is one of the only countries that was in the region before and deserved to be again. The fact that there never was a Palestinian state. The fact that most ARab countries dont deserve to exist. Why not deal with the facts? Because there are too many lies that have replaced the facts. I'd rather be right than popular and there are alot of popular Arab lies floating around the world.

Is that really you, Otis Redding? Actually it makes sense. Still keeping it real.

Take over the world??? Murders, pogroms, ethnic Jew cleansing-expulsions, false accusations, crusades, inquisitions, blood libels, the Holocaust. JEWS HAVE SPENT THOUSANDS OF YEARS JUST TRYING TO SURVIVE. If it were not for G-D, there would not be a single Jew left alive.

Linda, If it wasn't for Muslim Tolerance there would not be a single Jew left alive! And how did the Jews thank us? They did it by stealing our land, massacring our people and turning the world against us. BUT things are changing fast and the truth will emerge soon! most of the world is shitfing their policy in favor of the Palestinian rights and the US will soon follow! Just sit and watch. Salam

Mustafa- If you call 50 years of terror attacks, threats, and wars from other Arab nations, expulsions of jewish populations from Iraq and Egypt tolorance. Not to mention all of the attacks incited by the Grand Mufti before independence, you need to go and look up the word in the dictionary. There are Muslim members of the Knesset, how many Jews could join the Arab parliments?

Mahmood Abas is showing his true colours by not removing the protocols. If he was a real man of peace he would start fighting incitement in the PA areas by starting with his governments website. I look forward to the time when Arab and Jew can live in their countries side by side in peace where the only battles will be fought on the sports field.

Yeah you're right! 50 years of Zionist terrorism against armless Palestinians who were under Ottoman rule and then British rule and deprived from all technologies....facing a Jewish settler occupying the land of their ancestor armed with all the technologies of the time! I definitely call that terrorrism! If I'm armed and I kill civilians and drive them from their houses...I'm definitely a terrorist! I really don't understand how could people who suffered like the Jewish people do the same thing to other people?? I still don't have an answer for that...and I bet you don't have a convincing one!

YOU SAY THE PALESTINIANS WERE DEPRIVED OF TECHNOLOGY. WELL, SOMEHOW THEY ALWAYS MANAGED TO HAVE GUNS, ARTILLERY, AND EXPLOSIVES. IF THE PALESTINIANS AND SOROUNDING ARAB GOVERNMENTS HAD ACCEPTED ISRAEL AND SOUGHT PEACEFULL COEXISTANCE FROM THE BEGINING, 5 WARS COULD HAVE BEEN AVOIDED. ABBA EBAN ONCE SAID "THE ARABS NEVER MISS AN OPPURTUNITTY TO MISS AN OPPURTUNITTY".