News
Caught in the act
By Hanan Greenberg
Published: 20.05.05, 20:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
42 Talkbacks for this article
1. It's good to see them wiped off the face of the earth
(05.19.05)
2. nonsense!
Observer   (05.19.05)
If the Israelis and in particular the so called IDF do not have anything to hide then why won't they accept international observers to see who really is restarting the fire....the Israelis should not expect the Palestinians to wait to be killed...
3. It's a matter of time...
Shai ,   Israel   (05.19.05)
before we hear these were children playing soccer.
4. How credible are these pictures?
AB ,   CD   (05.19.05)
Only a few weeks ago, a similar Israeli clip showed UN ambulances as trucks transporting militants and their stretchers as rockets to be fired at Israeli settlements. This whole clip could have been easily recorded in Israeli military exercise or a Tel Aviv recording studio. POOR PRODUCTION, NO ONE WOULD BUY IT.
5. #2 No Nonsense
Cynthia ,   USA   (05.19.05)
Israel has experience with international observers. When the going gets tough, the observers get going and actually interfere with Israel's ability to apprehend terrorists and protect Israeli soldiers. Good job IDF!
6. HUMAN RIGHT OF DEFENSE FREELY GIVEN TO OTHERS DENIED TO JEWS
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (05.19.05)
It is ABNORMAL. It is HORRIBLE. It is EVIL for a nation to not defend their own people! Are orders being given by the Quartet: U.S. EU. UN & Russia, to not defend the Jewish people??? PLO terrorists were imported into Israel through Oslo to commit mass murder and terrorism. THAT IS WHAT TERRORISTS DO. Does Israel have a death wish??? Jibril Rajoub has run the terror operations of the PLO throughout the intifida. In April 2004, David Bedein reported: "Most recently, Rajoub addressed the board of governors of the American Jewish Committee and, indeed, endorsed terrorism against Israelis who live beyond the 1967 lines, in Jerusalem, Judea, Samaria or Gaza. The director of the AJC Jerusalem office would issue no statement attacking Rajub, saying that Rajoub's appearance was approved by the Israeli government." Colluding with terrorists against Israel's Jews. Jews denied the basic human right to not be murdered. Where are the strong Jewish leaders who will defend Israel and the Jewish people???
7. Another fabrication and pretext
Skeptical ,   Vermont   (05.19.05)
Who knows where this picture was taken, when it was taken, who are in it, and what they were doing? The picture doesn't answer any of the above questions and is similar to Iraq's WMD pictures.
8. You know what they say about Gaza..
Yiftah ,   Israel   (05.19.05)
It's a real blast.
9. To 4
(05.19.05)
Of course it's just one big conspiracy. Israel told these soldiers in mortar training to shoot some rounds and then blew them up to cover up the incident. Do people even listen to themselves. And their is good reason for Israel to have been so quick to accuse UN in the stretcher incident. This is the reason http://www.putfile.com/media.php?n=0511%20-%20PLO%20terrorists%20use%20UN%20ambulances
10. Back to Basics
Max ,   UK   (05.19.05)
The Israelis are Occupiers and those children women infants, men women animals trees are fighting the oppressors , so back to basic, hands off the Palestinian leave them alone they are people who every one twist their story to suet their own interests, and then call them terrorists, savages , uncivilized…and so on, Please “civilized Israelis” leave them alone and stop telling us “but God gave us the right, God promised us, God Chose us” , you know what they do not believe in your God, nor the rest of the Globe…so take note, they are the ones whose accepted you before, when you were rejected by today’s so called friends (Masters)… and history told us what happens to the aggressors specially in that part of the world. Take note and leave alone Civilised western values beholders.
11. actually, Hamas fabricated he video
(05.19.05)
It is all part of their campaign to gain sympathy from the Gazan electorate. The media was duped into believing that they had received the video from the IDF.
12. This is the first time I ever looked at English Y-Net
(05.20.05)
Are there always so many comments from wacky anti-Israel conspiracy theorists and antisemites suffering from various combinations of illiteracy and ignorance?
13. I suppose that all the people I know who were killed or
(05.20.05)
wounded by terrorists were all just pretending in order to make the Arabs look bad.
14. #12: Talk about the issue, please
AB ,   CD   (05.20.05)
Personal insults and labels don’t serve any purpose and don't help expose the truth.
15. yes #12, they get off to it.
erek culbreath ,   usa   (05.20.05)
jesus...it is kind of sad when the people that blow up sbarro pizza restaraunts and buses are, as max said, "fighting back the oppressors". wow...just kind of sad really.
16. WMD's
Adnan ,   Chicago   (05.20.05)
No one told us where such dumm movie been recorded, may be same photos Collin Powel show to the whole world 2 years ago.
17. It's too bad...
Mike Jackson ,   Oklahoma City, USA   (05.20.05)
That the IDF waited so long to hit the site with a missle. It looks like several of the hamassholes got away.
18. what r we waiting for???
avi ,   akko   (05.20.05)
what r we waiting for? we kill a big leder in hamas... r we waiting from hamas to clap for us??? for sure they have to react. we said that a big operation has been stopped by this assisnation... no it's not, i think this will kill the quit period between us and palestinians... we have abo mazen and his authoroty, why we don't tell him to arrest that leader and his group? if we continue in this way, we'll never live on this land peacfully...
19. adnan
erek culbreath ,   tampa, fl   (05.20.05)
mate u realize its not going to be perfect high def quality with dolby digital right? this is taken from a drone, not a damned sony satilite.
20. This is another Sharon trick
Sal Azam ,   Chicago, USA   (05.20.05)
Moosad had created a fake Hamas wing and that was exposed infront of the world. IDF is nothing but a liar. They claimed before that their was a Qassam rocket in a U.N ambulance and it came out to be a strecher. Small bully Sharon plays these tricks to ward the pressure that he is anticipating from President Bush before Mehmood Abbbas visits the White House. Sharon will fail this time and President Bush will press his buttons in his own way.
21. discouraging arabs
franck ,   paris   (05.20.05)
It is discouraging that Arabs worldwide can't face their responsibility. Once again, they come with the idea it's a Mossad invention, a set up, that Sharon want this or that. Come on, wipe the shit in front of your house, listen to the preaches in Gaza mosques. They're vomiting every days on Jews. And it's anyway a fact that your hamas and jihad friends were using ambulances to pass weapons. Then you cry out when a missile hits your face. You're really a vicious people but everyone understands your game. Enjoy life in America
22. Should be much more of it!!
Dave ,   Sydney Australia   (05.20.05)
Should be more of it!! Well done IDF. Get the lot of the bastards. In fact bomb their next rally and get thousands at one hit - otherwise you are simply wasting expensive ammo!!! By the way the only "occupiers" are the bloody Arabs who belong where they came from - Jordan, Syria Lebanon Iraq and Egypt. Aratrash was a good example of an Egyptian. This is the land belonging to civilised people the Jews - Not a single Arab mentioned anywhere in the New or Old Testaments - yeah those two history books!!
23. There will only be peace
Ron ,   Canada   (05.20.05)
when hamas is completely wiped out and the palestinians stop firing rockets. Who is provoking who now ???? There was relative peace before the rockets began lately. Now the IDF will have to take care of business again. The palestinians will never learn. They only want war.
24. To Ron, Canada - I wish you were right
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (05.20.05)
The tragic thing is that there will never be peace for Israel and Jews. There will always be someone who has a reason to kill, maime and persecute Jews for one reason only - that they are just Jews. Look at some the the comments on this article and others.
25. David and Ron
Mustafa ,   Potomac, MD   (05.20.05)
Ron, That's the same rhetoric we use! and it's the following, if the Zionists are defeated then there will be peace...before the IDF attacked the Palestinians there was relative calm...those Israelies never learn...they only want war!! David, Remember that now the magic has turned on the magician and now you're the occupiers and the persecutors...those rhetorics don't work anymore...the world is more informed about the Palestinian struggle then you think...find something else to complain about! Always Salam
26. nonsense?
PC ,   Charlotte, NC, USA   (05.20.05)
You're full of crap. Intern'l observers? Check out the history of the UN's blatant anti-semitism/anti-Israelism, etc., and you know what you can do with your observers. If the Muslims would stop shooting, the shooting would stop. Either open your eyes, or crawl back under your rock. Go IDF!
27. Credible pictures?
PC ,   Charlotte, NC, USA   (05.20.05)
Could'a would'a should's. Yeah, and little green men could have recorded this footage on a George Lucas set. Please. The fact is the PA is daily raining down mortar fire on Jewish settlements. So, obviously they are getting the missles and mortar rounds from somewhere. And speaking of UN ambulances, you must have missed the upclose footage of the UN ambulance being used as a Palestinian troop transport in Gaza last year. Comment on that. POOR PRODUCTION? I'LL BUY IT.
28. Dude, that's gonna leave a mark..
Yiftah ,   Israel   (05.20.05)
29. everyone joins military in ISrael
Mike ,   USA   (05.20.05)
and you have to be JEwish. this is an army based on race- AND RACE THAT SAYS THEY ARE "CHOSEN' ARE WHATEVER.
30. To: 29 Mike you are WRONG!!
Robert Goldman ,   cooper city Florida   (05.20.05)
the army (IDF) has in it's ranks Druze. (Not Jewish) Bedouin (Again Not Jewish) and some christians (Very not Jewish) so tell us all where you get your facts from? I served under officer that were Druze and Bedioun, as well as under Jewish officers and some of them still serve today. so again learn the subject!! and then learn it again or you will be made to write 100 times on the wall that you don't know what you are talking about!
Next talkbacks
Back to article