News
‘Allah turned girl into dog’
Published: 11.06.05, 16:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
60 Talkbacks for this article
31. This is the picture: No reason for doubt
Said ,   Copenhagen,DK   (06.16.05)
This is the source homepage.. and the story has nothing to do with Palestine/Israel .. It happened in Oman ca. a week ago.. I just found it on a arabic page, google'd it and found you people, flaming each other about racism.. shame.. God bless those who believe .. Link: http://www.alnilin.com/news/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=3841
32. DONT JUDGE PEOPLE JUST LIKE DAT alrite!!
shaheed ,   london   (06.16.05)
u can just judge a huge gruop like dat, that's just being stereotypical, and we dont live in such misery, ALRITE! we're proud to be arabs, and proper MUSLIMS, u jews just care about money, u selfish people, and all jews think they can take on muslims, well u know what, they can't, coz muslims, have more power than jews.
33. "Allah turned girl into dog"
poppy ,   Australia   (06.17.05)
I'm confused. My Mum doesn't believe in it and MOST muslims don't anyway, does Allah really DO this I don't know, THIS is a VERY new information for me!
34. Believe it or not its facts.
Sara ,   london,UK   (06.17.05)
why so many people so shocked and supriesed that they trying to hurt others feelings and some muslims are saying they don't believe it? and ALLAH is not unfair. whats not fair? this story shows that no matter who we are, male, female, mulsims, jews, christain and so one. everyone is equal for god. he made this world to see what fair and unfair we as humans are doing to each other, even thought we all made exactly the same. Does muslims have hearts and christains don't. Do jews breaths and people with other religions dont,do some eat and others don't, althought every human in this planet have sex and experience the same feelings. Scientifictly and to some religion believers that we made of sand no matter what way we the all have same things, just because the girl was muslim and she disrespected the quran doesn't mean she will not get punished althought she will get even more punished bcoz she was frm the same fate.This shows that no matter who you are you get punshied by god. And to my mulism brothers and sisters what will be the different between muslims who are ment do worship allah and the people who disrespect our worshiping. that girl was muslim and she diserved to be punished by disrespecting the quran like that and she didn't just disrespect quran but also her mum, two big sins at the same time and no matter who you are in all religions we are ment to respect our mothers after god. i would say after seeing the picture of the girl and if you dont believe it then please i would love to know if you can prove me which artist took this picture and in which planet he had to go to take this picture and spreeded rumor... http://www.alnilin.com/news/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=3841 believe it or not it the fact. you decide for yourself and keep you bad opionios to yourself. share things that helps all humans not just that gives you pleasure.......
35. To Shaheed #32
thomas ,   usa   (06.18.05)
If you're a Shaheed, why are you still talking? Did anyone actually witness this? No? I didn't think so...
36. did the mother saw her daughter turning into a dog
sophia maddox ,   nashville. t.n   (06.18.05)
ok how can we belive this story did the mom saw her daughter turning into a dog because thats the only thing that could be proved ok write back please
37. Y U LAUGHING 4 SLUT.
namelss & zee ,   none of ur bussiness   (06.18.05)
OI LISSEN #5 Y R U LAUGHIN IT IS NOT FUNNY ALLAH CAN TURN U INTO A DOG ANYTIME SO IF I WERE U I WOULD JUST SHUT UP B4 I TURN INTO A DOG SOON!!!!!!!!!
38. to # 37
barcagrl ,   Tel Aviv   (06.18.05)
hahahahahahahah....I'm so scared!~!!! read your own comment again: "SO IF I WERE U I WOULD JUST SHUT UP B4 I TURN INTO A DOG SOON!!!!!!!!! " You are going to turn into a dog soon? Well at least you have allready a girlfriend then....hahahahahah :)))))) and btw learn how to spell...
39. #34: Picture's not real!
Louise ,   USA   (06.20.05)
The picture of the "doggie girl" is actually of a sculpture -- part of a larger work, "Leather Landscape," by Patricia Piccinini. Check out the "We are Family" exhibit link from her web site: http://www.patriciapiccinini.net/ That somebody would use something like this to deceive people doesn't disprove the religion they're trying to justify. However, the ignorance required for followers of that religion to believe this kind of story (e.g. Respondent #34 & the "reporters" of the Muslim news service #34 provides a link to), seems to suggest something about that same religion...
40. about micheal
MAD MUSLIM ,   west hartford, ct   (06.21.05)
Allah is assisiting. Allah keeps them alive its not tiny and ur probably biased because u are a jew. Im not surprised if ur next in the news being changed into a pig.
41. TO NUMBA 38
to numba 38 ,   SFGDSFDS   (06.21.05)
leave that person alone u little annoying jew just being a bitch hanging around being mean to muslims and i AM TELLING U TO SHUT THE FUCK UP DAMN!
42. dteydet
tutu ,   dydtydty   (06.22.05)
what do you think about it
43. dhfyr
fdhg ,   rdg   (06.22.05)
what do you mean
44. Sure, she can't bring kids to the world...
Asad ,   Karachi, Pakistan   (06.23.05)
.....because she is piece of artifact made by human. but worse time will come for the one who has created it, when on the judgement day he or she will be asked to put a piece of soul inthat artifact to make it alive......pooooohhhh. what will happen then???? all the jewish world is living in a deep FANTASY.
45. To # 36
Asad ,   Karachi, Pakistan   (06.23.05)
How could she? when there is nothing exists in that form.............these artifacts are creations of Patricia piccinini........who probably thinks that these things exist. "Classic Materialism"
46. re:
hamze ,   enfield   (06.25.05)
no the girl turened into the pepole in the stone age
47. Why can't we get along
humira ,   washington d.c   (07.01.05)
Why is everyone hating b/c of an article be it true or just a rumor...Muslims,,in Islam the prophet Muhammad (pbuh) was nice to his Jewish neighbors,,,he never envisioned us to be this way against humanity. I am an Afghan muslim and i can not find any justification in the koran for this hatred and mis treatment..we are all from Abrahamic traditions so stop bringing Islam into land disputes..it is us,,the young generation that can make a difference...both jews and muslims need to point at what they are doing wrong before they blame others...May Allah guide us all...
48. to humira
neha ,   UK   (07.11.05)
humira sis im truly with you well said, im a afghan too, and i believe exactly in that you said dont know why everyone cursing each other, if the prophet was good with his everyone, then who are we to break the rule, let allah judje wats wrong and right,to be honest i cab't believe after long time i heard sum1 talking the right islam and humanity..god bless you...and may allah forgive all the wrong be believe in and forced to believe.
49. am i late?
jay ,   phil   (07.25.05)
obviously, some people here after hearing the news got intrigued and some searched the internet to find out if this is true. some christians or jews here probably has tendency of becoming a muslim if they would know what islam really is. i had met some who got interested after hearing that Mohammed(pbuh) said that Allah doesn't like "people" who considers himself above others and to love your neighbors as you love yourself.so i advise every muslim to study islam, practice it and teach it to those who do not know because some of them might comprehend it better and because it is our responsibility as muslims. Allah can turn anybody into what He wills and He likes those who uses his mind. Muslims must belive in the scriptures but i don't believe in those that we could find now because they changed the comming of Muhammad(pbuh) into holy ghosts and others.
50. A dog?
Jaman ,   New York, NY   (08.17.05)
I believe more in Santa Claus than I do in Allah Where's the ASPCA?
51. what
(10.23.05)
what the hell are you talking about?
52. RE: The Harsh punishment
Juwayriyah ,   England   (01.21.06)
If Allah turned a girl into a dog how come i didnt see it on news? This artivle should have been top in every article published. This is most certainly a headline waiting to be seen by many around the world. Is it possible that the government didn't allow this headline to be released in most countries?
53. yeh why ?
maryam ,   uk   (02.03.06)
it should have been there ages ago perhaps you dint know that time and found out know so.
54. nooo
wajiah ,   uk   (02.03.06)
no i dont think so your believe must be in the air or some where but its your believe what do i care
55. 2 every 1
paki boi ,   uk   (02.07.06)
y dont u believe bout the girl if u have gud faith in ur religion my brotherz and sisters u would now dat allah can do anything. if he can create the whole world den cant he turn a girl in 2 a dog just think bout it.
56. r
Janne ,   Sweden   (02.16.06)
094937645
57. I wish I got turned into a dog
connor benochal ,   bangor,maine   (04.30.06)
I wish I got turned into a dog it would be cool. Although, I would not like to be dumb.
58. girl into dog
Aysha ,   Niles, IL   (10.21.06)
astagfirrullah, i say to Allah. how could you not believe this?
59. you idiot that wats to be a dog
baraka ,   oerope   (02.23.08)
are you a fool allah has created you and you idiot want to be a dog
60. To 55
Jason ,   USA   (07.06.11)
If Allah did turn a girl into a dog. There would be alot more dogs running around.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article