News
‘I won’t expel Jews’
By Ynet
Published: 05.08.05, 09:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
46 Talkbacks for this article
1. So very sad
Ann C. ,   USA   (08.04.05)
QUOTE: "I will wait for the picture to clear." Me too. And meanwhile, I send my heartfelt condolences to all who were injured in any way by this attack.
2. "Mother of the terrorist?"
Yonatan ,   Los Angeles   (08.04.05)
Is YNet News insane?!
3. Ynet
Yisraeli   (08.04.05)
Maybe Im wrong but I get the impression that Ynet is having a field day here. Finally they keep reminding us we have a "Jewish Terrorist" and we must make a seperate section in Ynet titled 'Jewish Terror'. and to link him with settlers wow achla what a bonus. I dont know all the details of the incident and I dont condone it but I sense a celebration here by the media and arab commentators here in other threads. Already Baruch Goldstein is brought up and pic of him. Settlements are mentioned etc. etc. Ynet finally found a seir le azalzel. Maybe you should break out the champagne its been too long since Baruch G.?
4. Severely emotionally disturbed
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (08.04.05)
My condolences to the victims and their families. In the Bible, G-D commanded:: "You shall not murder" Ecclesiastes 12:13-14 "fear G-D and keep His commandments, because this applies to every person. For G-D will bring every act to judgment..." This young man was clearly severely emotionally disturbed. What he did was terribly wrong. Knowing that the murderers of your people are not to be punished, but instead rewarded with forcible ethnic Jew cleansing. Seized Jewish land and assets given to the murderers is extremely difficult for any human being to deal with. The maimings and murders of THOUSANDS of Jewish innocents is about to be rewarded with an Islamist terror state in the Jewish Holy Land. Palestinian Authority Minister Mohammed Dahlan is in charge of coordinating the withdrawal with Israel. Dahlan is responsible for the bomb attack on the Israeli school bus in November 2000 in which two school teachers were murdered and three children from the Cohen family lost their legs. If Jesus Christ lived today, from the time Jesus was in his mother's womb, he would be targeted for murder by the Islamofascists for being a Jew living in his homeland of Israel. The Palestinian Authority hailed as heroes the terrorists who brutally murdered the beautiful and innocent 8 months pregnant Jewish Gaza mother and her four little daughters. The Palestinian Authority teach the murder of Jews-the brothers and sisters of Jesus Christ, as a religious obligation through their mosques, media and public education system. Broadcast from Gaza mosque, Oct 13 2000, Dr. Ahmad Abu Halabiya, on Palestinian Authority TV (transcribed by Memri): "Have no mercy on the Jews, no matter where they are, in any country. Fight them, wherever you are. Wherever you meet them, kill them. Wherever you are, kill those Jews and those Americans who are like them..." Bible, Obadiah 1:15 "For the day of the L-RD draws near on all the nations. As you have done, it will be done to you. Your dealings will return on your own head." Jonah 3:8 "let men call on G-D earnestly that each may turn from his wicked way and from the violence which is in his hands."
5. The only punishment
Ahsay ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (08.05.05)
His families house should be bricked in, the same as we do to the Arabs who commit murderous attacks.
6. Re: Terrorist's Mother
Alex ,   Boston   (08.05.05)
This terrorists mother has no business accusing the IDF of anything. "Go to hell" she says? "Where was the army all this time" she asked? I have a question for her...where were you the last nineteen years of the boy's life that you couldn't have taught him better ways to handle his problems then to kill women and innocents? Answer that lady....oh what a poor poor terrorist's mother you are!!! You couldn't have been there for him if he was so upset and confused? Some nerve it takes to be that selfish of a person, how about condolences to the families of the victims and an apology to start with lady? As if the IDF was supposed to babysit your son for you? Bad parenting is responsible for this entire conflict.
7. It's Sharon and the Arab terrorists fault.
Daisy ,   USA   (08.05.05)
This young man was seeing the destruction of Israel and his people right before his eyes. He also saw the barbaric Arabs murder Jewish women and children without remorse. This boy was also a victim. His actions were horrible but the Arabs savagery is to blame for this.
8. Re: Linda
Frank ,   UK   (08.05.05)
When Israeli terrorist killed Palestinians,he is emotionally disturbed, and when it is done by Palestinian, he is a strng terrorist.I can't imagine how U judge your staff.I can bring U alot of article written by jews to show U who is the real terrorist. Isreal ust yesterday demolished three houses and in another area in Hebron, they just uproot olive trees and ordered people to leave their farm to built a new sttlements. All these crimes are approved by the Israeli govenment and by the terrorist prime minister. Saying this and U still blame Palestinians for attacking Jews, simply these people only understand the language of force and U are naieve if U think the conflict will be solved after the pullout, Isreal will never give up the West Bank and the conflict will continue...just keep these infos at the back of your mind....
9. What a shame!
Abdullah ,   Kuwait City   (08.05.05)
This murdering thug should be put in jail for the rest of his pathetic life! Nothing justifies murder, NOTHING!
10. Daisy #7
Alex ,   Boston   (08.05.05)
You can't be serious! You are using this event to spew your ONE SIDED GARBAGE!!! I couldn't possible say what you just wrote without having my insides come exploding out through my mouth and sphincter. It is just that very type of garbage that allows this conflict to continue and my Jewish brothers to die. Everything you said could've been said by a Pal, about a suicide bomber, every single time. Do us all a favor and disappear back into the same cloud of ignorance that you spawned from, k? You are the problem Daisy, you personally are the problem with the whole entire world. You.
11. TO#5
Yosef ,   Houston   (08.05.05)
12. Jewish terror
Noor ,   Nablus, Palestine   (08.05.05)
This accuses that the Israeli police of double standards. If this attack had occurred in a Jewish neighborhood and the attacker was Arabic, he would have been killed immediately by Israeli police. The police came and they didn't do anything... They were holding the terrorist alive in the bus. One important question, are Israel polices going to destroy his families house in the same way they do it for Palestinians or they are going to give them a medal !!!!
13. You don't see expelling Jews as a Crime-You're sicker
(08.05.05)
14. A bit of perspective:
Bunnie Meyer ,   Santa Monica, CA   (08.05.05)
arab mothers WANT their children to murder Jews, this Jewish mother WANTED her son to be found and his rifle taken away. islamic bus bombers and other retaurand bombers killed hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of Jews while the world was as quiet as a whisper. One Jew unjustifiably murders four arabs and the world should forget the children killed by islamic terrorists in Chechnya, the people bombed on the trains in Spain by islamic terrorists, the people in New York that died when islamic terrorists few their planes into the Twin Towers, the people bombed in the subway and on buses in England? islam has thousands and thousands and thousands of terrorists and the Jews have one. Just put it in perspective.
15. TO #9 abdullah
Yisraeli   (08.05.05)
you said "This murdering thug should be put in jail for the rest of his pathetic life!" humm in case you havent noticed he was LYNCHED by the mostly arab mob.
16. Linda Rivera needs to shut up
Mark ,   Canada   (08.05.05)
You keep repeating stories from the news and ignoring the other facts. Palestinians are killed daily and Israel teaches killing children in an institution called IDF and schools. As for Jesus, if you do not know who wanted to kill him, you are an idiot. Do not blame this on the muslims, at least this one the whole world knows about.
17. 'Jewish Terror'
JENNEY ,   NORWAY   (08.05.05)
THIS IS IT, FINALLY THE JEWS TERROR APPEARD TO EVERYBODY!!
18. couse and treatment
amin ,   bit lahim   (08.05.05)
when return to the cause just to find the treatment no more
19. Alex, don't attack Daisy
Ann C. ,   USA   (08.05.05)
As a matter of fact I've noticed that all you do in your posts is attack people and call folks names. Let's see.....earlier you called someone a prick, and to be honest your HATE for humans just doesn't belong here. You really do need professional help. Please, for your own sake, seek treatment now.
20. ayfah v'ayfah!!!!!
(08.05.05)
Why is every, single article slot on Ynet related to this shooting? When many more Israeli JEWS were murdered a few weeks ago there was only ONE article. Holding Jewish lives, and actions to a different standard is anti-Semitism.
21. for daisy and others like them
Sal Azam ,   Chicago, USA   (08.05.05)
When you occupy someone else land in the name of God and kill and steal and destroy and they react with terrorism killing innocent people you call it terrorism and when you kill them after occupying their land what should they call you? Zombies, butchers, nazi zionists, extremists bent upon destroying yourself.
22. What a shame!
milton ,   chicago,usa   (08.05.05)
I HOPE YOU FEEL THE SAME ABOUT ARAB TERRORIST MURDERERS OF INNOCENT ISRAELI CITIZENS.
23. You are all blind!
Annoymous   (08.05.05)
You know, I'm disappointed with what the awol soldier did, but did anyone notice how barbaric the mobs were. What happen to the rules of law. After he ran out of bullets, he should have been detained once the first rock hit his head. But instead the whole arab mob came down on him like an animal. No rule of law, no nothing. Just plain hatred.
24. KAHANE IS ALIVE !!!!!!
YOSEF ,   HOUSTON   (08.05.05)
25. to #9
Tal ,   Paris,France   (08.05.05)
Well, I agree. Except the tiny fact- he´s dead! Nothing justifies halfread articles, NOTHING!
26. Honest report
Richard Harris ,   San Diego   (08.05.05)
Murder is a crime, whether it be the murder by Edan or his murder by the crowd. Both are to be condemned. Ynet deserves credit for putting honest information about this and not engaging in speculation as to Edan's motive's and mental state. Something which is not known.
27. Shame on all of Tapuah!
Gerd ,   Germany   (08.05.05)
I blame all of you in Tapuah! You are responsible too! ------------------------------------------------- My condolence to the victims and their families!
28. He was a murderer
Micha Sloman ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.05.05)
The teenager who commited this act was a murderer. He took a gun and murdered innocent people on a bus. This is true irrespective of whether or not he was mentally disturbed. It was reported on the radio that he had recently become a religious Jew. However what he did had absolutely nothing to do with Judaism. The first teaching in the Bible is that all human beings are created in the image of G-d.
29. occupiers
soldiers mother ,   rehovot israel   (08.05.05)
Oh dear Oh dear, all these condemnations of Israels occupation of Palestine. Have our American readers forgotten that they are living on occupied lands that rightfully belong to the native american? the same is true for the british in northern Ireland! Although I am totaly pro pull out, I am getting a bit tired of they hypocracy i read everyday from those who dont practice what they preach.
30. So Gerd are you a Nazi?
Richard Harris ,   San Diego   (08.05.05)
If collective guilt is a valid principle then indeed the people of Tapuch should be ashamed of themselves. And how many more times would that apply to Germany?
Next talkbacks
Back to article