News
‘I won’t expel Jews’
By Ynet
Published: 05.08.05, 09:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
46 Talkbacks for this article
31. to#30
john ,   bermuda   (08.05.05)
do not mix up issues israeli government has been practising collective punishment to stop terror since years so why not in this case also homes were demolished so why not apply it also or you richard one of these hyopcrites lovers of double standards
32. Gred is no nazi, and Tapuah is to blame
Boaz ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (08.05.05)
As for Ahsay there is no need to destroy the killer house (aka terrorist), because we move on our terrorists. We denounce them as such, and arrest and trial them as such. It was our law enforcement personal who stopped the Bat Ain gang.
33. response to post 15
Abdullah ,   Kuwait City   (08.05.05)
Ya, I didn't know of his death until later! But the question is why didn't the Arab mob wait until this Jewish terrorist gets served justice by IG? I am no condoning the lynching but why those people decided to lynch rather than waiting for justice to take its course?
34. response to post 25
Abdullah ,   Kuwait City   (08.05.05)
My apologies for the hard feelings!
35. The perversion of religion
Hiram ,   Tel Aviv   (08.05.05)
This tragedy should be a warning signal to those fanatic religious extremists....The kid killed simply because he HATED the arabs, of a hatred fed into him by religious militants. It is tragic, is is horrible, and it is not excusable. The kid was mentally disturbed.....but yet, full of religious propaganda....a simple terrorist, just like the ones we are trying to fight. Lets remain humble. We should not give lessons to anyone..Let s clean up our mess firts, and change this country into a secular democracy. Religion and state affairs may be " acceptable" for arab countries but should NOT be accepted in developped nations short of posing a threat for our common future.
36. #31 Are you fluent in English ?
Richard Harris ,   San Diego   (08.05.05)
Do you know or just choose to ignore the difference between collective guilt and collective punishment? The people of Tapuah can not be held responsible for the acts of someone from Rishon L'Zion, or in your twisted logic, maybe they are?
37. Soldier in Border Guard Uniform? Will someone clarify?
akiva ,   chicago   (08.05.05)
Reports have come out that he was in a border guard uniform. Doesn't it seem odd that when the Army is throwing every refusenik in jail, this guy gets away with a weapon and a police uniform? Sounds like provacateur.
38. To Yonathan
Sarah ,   London   (08.05.05)
Opening fire on innocent people on a bus... If he is not a terrorist, who is?
39. A note to: YNET, Alex, Abdullah, JENNEY and Sal Azam
T. A. Adams ,   Oklahoma City USA   (08.05.05)
YNET - Whoever wrote this article for you is either one sick individual or a government lackey who’s been told to separate Israel from this young man by painting him evil. Either way, referring to this woman as "the terrorist's mother" was totally uncalled for considering her son was also murdered. No arrest, no trial, just purely and simply a mob lynching… aka murder. Alex - Try a little Thorazine. Actually in your case, you might need a LOT of Thorazine. Maybe then you can calm down enough to get a clue. Abdullah - Your ignorance of yet another situation is hanging out again. The kid who did this was also murdered; by a mob of Arabs. Please note too that he wasn’t raised that way as many Arab children are. Too bad the Arabs who killed him aren't as tough on their own terrorists. JENNEY - I can't help wondering if you're that tough on the Arab terrorists, of which there are more than a 1000 for every Jew who finally snaps. Sal Azam – By your reasoning, are we to assume that you believe that the 800,000+ Jews who had their land, homes and businesses stolen in Arab countries after the world recognized the state of Israel should now have the right to go back to those countries and terrorize the occupiers of their land? Oops, I forgot, they aren’t even allowed back in those countries.
40. #12
(08.05.05)
Just to be sure that you are aware, there is no State of Palestine. Furthermore, Israel has already denounced the terror attack and is not granting him a military funeral. I cannot recall a time when Palestinian terrorists remained alive. Their logic is so flawed that they blow themselves up in order to take down Israelis with them. they are not martyrs, just criminals. Israeli police don't have to kill Palestinian terrorists, they kill themselves.
41. To #16
(08.05.05)
Get your facts right. Israel does not teach hatred in its schools. As for the IDF, it is an army (albiet and army for the sole purpose of defense). If you have read any legitimate newspaper, you would see that the Palestinians put their children out to throw rocks at the Israeli soldiers. The soldiers DO NOT shoot at the children (b/c it would be a PR nightmare). Also, innocent Palestinians are not the targets of the "targeted assissinations". The targets are always terrorist leaders. Palestinians target Israeli civilians, and take as many as possible. The IDF takes precautions to make sure they get the right guy and only the right guy. Get your facts right!!!
42. alex; The Arab Muslims are what's wrong with this world!
Daisy ,   USA   (08.06.05)
You claim to be Jewish but you spew hate agianst Israel and the Jews who live in Judea and Samaria. I'm not Jewish but I support Israel and the Jewish people who have to deal with the Arab barbaric terrorists everyday. The only reason you hate me is because you hate yourself. You would have helped hitler during the holocaust. You're sick!
43. sal; Arabs stole Jewish land!
Daisy ,   USA   (08.06.05)
Get your facts straight and stop occupying my land!
44. re:Daisy
TRUTH_WITHIN ,   Toronto   (08.09.05)
The EDUCATED KNOW, Pontius Pilate spoke Greek!, Jesus spoke Greek: the GOOD book writen in Greek ! Vile=power tripping, Israel does not belong to JUST Jews; do you know any Jew that speeks GREEK?
45. the other way around
ann ,   united states   (08.19.05)
While I in no way say what happened was okay, ecspecially in the timing it came in, with many Israelis already emotional. But I have to ask myself, yes a Jew killed 4 Arabs...it is against what we believe as Jews. But it caught international attention...it got almost as much air time on cnn and bbc and msnbc as did the entire pullout from Gaza. What happens when an Arab murders a Jew? Where is the international outcry when that happens? When Tali Hatuel and her four young daughters were murdered by an Arab gunman on their way home...where was this international outcry? who on cnn or bbc condemned or even reported her murder. So, while I do think the killing of these Arabs was not right, it did not effect me. When Israel could name someone murdered in the hands of the Palestinians almost every day over the last five years...the Palestinians can certainly not do the same. With that...I have been crying watching the Gaza pullout...Zada was right: Jews don't expel Jews.
46. A Hero
Ariela ,   San Francisco, USA   (05.31.06)
BS"D Eden Natan-Zada, Zt"L, is a hero to the Jewish people. He should be an example of what is needed for us to survive in this world. Proaction, not apathy and giving in to the real terrorists, the arabs occupying Israel and many Israeli politicians. May his family be praised for raising a son who was able to gain clarity and strength and a desire to protect his nation.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article