News
Bush: Stop West Bank construction
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 20.10.05, 17:54
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
44 Talkbacks for this article
1. Slave Israel Obediently Obeys Master
Marcel ,   Florida   (10.20.05)
The peace is rigged for Israel to lose. Defeated by a fake peace plan and too stupid to get it ! The only one who listens to Bush is the obedient slave Israel which cuts it's own throat to please her false god of false peace. Will the lemmings awaken before it is too late ?
2. I want to apologize to Israelis
AK   (10.20.05)
I appologize to israelis for our Saudi-beholden idiot President, even more so because I voted for him. The only excuse for my own stupidity that I can offer that the alternative candidate was no better.
3. bush is out of the bag!
joe ,   philly ,pa.   (10.20.05)
the great freind israel thought she had in bush ,turns out to be even more double -faced then clinton was.
4. GOOD GOING!!!!
(10.20.05)
The way forward is to stop the JEws from abusing the natives of the area-PALESTINE-- AND especially because its with WITH USA welfare . (poor US citizens) The chutzpah!! and Jews, stop calling anti- semitism, it doesnt work anymore- not only because its just Jews trying to manipulate people and scrae them into silence when they see Jews crimes,but it isnt true! Most people dont like what jews DO as a collective- they like them fine individually ,but Jews get together and they lie and steal and make phony lawsuits and walk around thinking they are 'chosen' LOL.
5. GOOD GOING!!! makes no sense
Michael ,   SF, California   (10.20.05)
Look at the ignorance in the previous posters message. As an American citizen I am proud that my country assists the one and only strong democracy in the middle east. I am a proud that my country supports Isreal and provides peace for the Jewish nation. I am proud to be Jewish, and am fighting mad about what these Palestinians are trying to do to our homeland. The poster is obviously anti-semetic, especially when he says: "Most people dont like what jews DO as a collective- they like them fine individually ,but Jews get together and they lie and steal and make phony lawsuits and walk around thinking they are 'chosen'" This is typical anti-semetic ideology. It is the Palestinians who are murders, terrorists, liars, and thiefs. Again, looking at history, there were plans for peace which Yassar Arafag turned down. Plans for a Palestinian state which would have created peace. The Palestinians are LIARS because they don't want peace. They want to destroy Israel. Don't be fooled by the false peace plan. Personally I am ashamed of Bush. I didn't vote for the schlep, and I personally am against everything he stands for {I'm Democrat}. Look at the scandals surrounding him now... Liars, Cheaters, Stealers, the Bush Administration is. Isreal needs to do what is best for the Jewish nation. They should not act as a puppet. If America doesn't want to support Israel, let us contend with a middle east without Israel. Michael
6. to ak
joe   (10.20.05)
icould n't agree more with everything yuo've just said.
7. Israel/Palestine
P MANASSE ,   MONTE CARLO MONACO   (10.20.05)
Sharon never had any intentions to accept the road map as issued. He asked for 14 amendments which in effect voided the terms of the road map.
8. #7
J K ,   NYC, USA   (10.20.05)
And the Palestinians never even completed one item of the 'Road Map' whereas Israel made many concessions they were forced to end AND they have left the Gaza Strip. If the Fakes dont get their act together (how long have we been saying this now, 12+ years?), they will have a resolution to this conflict forced on them. Maybe they should try looking into the Road Map (worthless junk that it is)
9. to AK
Jason ,   NY   (10.20.05)
I also couldn't agree more with everything you said.
10. Dear editor of Ynet
kook ,   Canada   (10.20.05)
Get off your a... and remove this nr 4 from talkback the way the comments are set they do not deserve to benefit from the Israeli openess to diverse opinions. unfortunately LOL is abusing the internet for racial slurs!!
11. #4
Jane ,   New York   (10.20.05)
Ah, but you're not anti-Semitic. Jews, jews, jews, jews. But you're not anti-semitic.
12. #7
Jane ,   New York   (10.20.05)
but the terrorists' (oh, so sorry, militants) remaining armed and operational is ok. gosh.
13. Michael= jewish bigot
(10.20.05)
"jewish" state? are you a racist? what about the PALESTINIANS that were there first? or the ARABS ? or the BEDOUINS? Shut your racist little mouth.
14. Bush is insane.
NCjews ,   NC USA   (10.20.05)
That's nove, Bush is holding Israel to account for not allowing its citizens to be slaughered once again. Roadside executions of Jews is just fine with Bush. He is an imbecile that most Americans (jewish and non) agree is insane and in the pockets of Saudis. Israel -- ignore his moronic utterings. Follow the path necessary for your survival.
15. #4 speaking like a true anti-Semite
Roger ,   USA   (10.20.05)
The anti-Semites, however, have some value. They demonstrate the idealistic Jews their reality.
16. Bush the wolf in sheeps clothing!!
Naomi ,   Haifa   (10.20.05)
17. AK & Michael
Billy ,   Burlington, Canada   (10.20.05)
I don't think AK should be ashamed nor Michael be proud! Realistically, States as any other country should be looking after what's better to its national interest! That's Kosher! If Saudis, Palestinians or Egyptians are serving better States' strategy, then naturally they'll be favorable. But this is not the case; Israel is still & will be American's best interest because it earns it. Not because of the Lobby, not because of loving Israel. Because Israel earned it. No salves or masters here, it's just getting benefs with no blame!
18. #13
Jane ,   New York   (10.20.05)
Since we only have 1, not 22 arab/islamic judenrein terrorist entities, i think it is you who should, in fact, shut up
19. To Kook
Billy ,   Burlington, Canada   (10.20.05)
I think #4 meant "Lots Of Laughs" by ending his talkback by LOL. I don't agree with your request to eliminate his talkback because it defeats the purpose of "talkbacks" itself. Democracy is a right for everybody, whether her or his country is providing it or not. Although I don't agree with one word of what he said, I would argue that he has an equal right to post his opinion as anyone else. Thanks!
20. stop the israeli murder craziness
Ahmad Abouali ,   nablus   (10.20.05)
eversince trhe calming down, the Israeli terror army did not stop, not even for one minute, of killing our youth and children...so, before calling on Abbas to proot palestinian "terror" maybe it is better it stop and maybe uproot the Zionist terror, after all, numbers speak fro themselves. Bush should be ashamed of himself
21. #13 ignores historical facts and sides with terrorists
David Landman ,   Natick, USA   (10.20.05)
Dont you you know that the natives are Jewish to the area? These so called Palestinians are just other Arabs invaders. They build a mosque of Judaisms holiest sites. They destroy Jewish villages. This is Jewish land that Israel has been happy to share, and the Arabs have been happy to steal. Why dont you read a book about history first instead of making it up. Why does Israel give so much and get so little? Why do the Arabs give so little and expect so much? There already is an Arab Palestinians state and it comprises 78% of historic Palestine. Jewish villages were destroyed there and no Jews are allowed citizenship. Palestinians should go home to it and stop complaining. You arent even the natives to the area. Your whole history is made up. You werent even called Palestinians until about 40 years ago. Jews were. Go home.
22. To AK # 2-
Adina Kutnicki ,   NJ, US   (10.20.05)
To AK # 2 - I am in EXACTLY the same boat as you. I voted for Bush and campaigned ! for him. Israeli brothers & sisters - mea culpa. I truly believed that he would not sell Israel down the river, and that he would fight terror WHEREVER it emerged. Apparently terror against Jews doesn't qualify as worthy of fighting against, all his platitudes notwithstanding. Osama, Zarqawi are terror fiends, yet the Fatah, PA/PLO terrorists (Abbas's minions) are NOT considered terrorists. They only kill Jews. This is the real issue here. The fact that he still sees Abbas as a "peace" partner for Israel, and that he said he will basically punish Israel if they do not make the lives of the PA Arabs easier ! leaves me outraged beyond belief. I suspect, to my great dismay, that Bush will only change his tune when the PA Arabs are found to have a hand in another devastating attack on the US. There is NO doubt that Hamas & its hydra groups are operating and waiting to pounce in the US. Too bad for all Americans that Bush will only learn when more Americans are slaughtered.
23. #2 May God bless you for your courage.
Leah ,   Jerusalem   (10.20.05)
This is more than most those supposed republican supporters of Israel dare to admit. Pathetic, hah? They keep their mouths shut while at the same time knocking Liberal's when in affect they are no better. Bush duped Jews to vote for him. He has gone back on his promises therefore like #16 wrote, he indeed is/WAS a wolf in sheep's clothing. While he bombs the living hell out of insurgency in Iraq(which is fine) he with his so-called 'moral' standards tells Israel otherwise. He should be ashamed. While on several occasions talks about those who harbor terrorists....he excuses it from Abbas when Abbas over and over says he will not disarm terrorists. Get a load out of this. He complimented Abbas for order in Gaza after the disengagement. Hey George, it is not a good thing to lie. Your words are recorded. But then Israel and the war on terror are two different things. In your words you as much as admitted it. As a duel citizen of Israel and the US am terribly ashamed I voted for him. Clinton, Papa Bush and Carter were pretty bad to Israel but this Bush will go on record as being the most two faced of all US presidents when it comes to Israel. Now I hear the Palestinians according to Reuters are praising Bush for something Bush should will be sorry for....... PA: "Satisfied Bush didn't`t publicly back PM call to ban Hamas from PLC vote." Every other terrorist in the world is bad according to Bush (ha ha except the Saudi's) but Hamas deserves legitimacy. As for the Palestinians. There last intifada/slaughter of Jews brought them acclaim from the world and of all people, George Bush the so-called good friend of Israel. Lastly, if Israel loses Jerusalem this too will be on the charge of George. Quite an evil legacy he is leaving. " Israel should not undertake any activity that contravenes its road map obligations, or prejudices the final status negotiations with regard to Gaza, the West Bank, and Jerusalem. This means that Israel must remove unauthorized posts and stop settlement expansion. It also means that the barrier now being built to protect Israelis from terrorist attacks must be a security barrier, rather than a political barrier. Israeli leaders must take into account the impact this security barrier has on Palestinians not engaged in terrorist activities. " http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2005/10/20051020.html
24. RE:GOOD GOING
anonymous ,   sf, US   (10.20.05)
u are one racist son of a bitch! check it out the israeli's have been here for fifty seven years they give all palestinians living in israel rights. the equal rights of any other israeli. The palestinians dont care about the law in Israel and build giant houses for themselves, their housing areas are filled with the biggest homes in all of Israel. Israelis help eachother regardless if you are a russian israeli, palestinian israeli, or arabic israeli.there is peace within Israel. they have constantly given back peices of the land to try to make the palestinians happy but they just want more and more. they are never content, yet they are treated like kings inside of israel. funny thing is that they love the land so much, yet only a rare few of them contribute to anything good to the land. they only take they don't give back. so where exactly do you want all these people to go? the people who constantly were kicked around and even murdered in masses for continuous years. there is not one race on this planet that doesnt have a home land. are you trying to say that the israeli's don't deserve one?
25. To the familes of slaughtered Israelis.
Tamar ,   Israel   (10.20.05)
Bush calls the terrorists who took the lives of your loved ones ARMED GANGS. As an Israeli who lost a good friend from a heartless terror attack, I urge everyone who reads this to contact the WhiteHouse. Tell them the killers of Israelis are the same as the terrorists Bush is after in his supposed war on terror. Tell him that the lives of Jews are every bit as important as those who lost their lives in 9-11 and other world wide terror attacks. Tell him if terrorists snuff the lives out of others, then terrorist snuff the lives out of Israelis. Tell him he should be ashamed for calling them ARMED GANGS. Thank you.
26. Bush of Arabia
Chrisona ,   Chicago.IL   (10.20.05)
"Without elaboration, the president said Israel would be 'held to account' for any actions that hamper peacemaking or burden the lives of Palestinians." At least Bush and Abbas didn't hold hands or smooch.
27. IDIOTIC REDNECK PIECE OF GARBAGE, BUY CHINESE
(10.20.05)
28. Retarded Bush actually believes that "Palestinians" exist!
Daisy ,   USA   (10.20.05)
His mind is messed up because of cocaine! http://www.sullivan-county.com/id3/palestine.htm
29. y'all voted 4 Bush! so y kvetch now!
(10.20.05)
30. Peace is the way.
Rob ,   Philidelphia, PA   (10.20.05)
I see many feel very strongly about this issue. That comes as no surprise. However, I urge everyone to refrain from violent speech, no matter how deserving you feel the recipient to be. I suspect you are all compassionate people and whatever your point of view is on this subject I am sure it comes from good intentions. But, once the agressive and violent language starts up, it really spreads, and we react with equal measures, without thinking first. This is exactly how people who consider themselves to be adhereing to the highest morals, come to perpetrate the basic human rights of their fellow human beings. I met with two former IDF soldiers this week, both of whom served in Hebron. They had some very enlightening things to say about their experiences and I urge you to visit their website: www.breakingthesilence.org.il (in english and hebrew) It is never as simple as one point of view. Always seek to see things from others' eyes and respect thier opinions and you will be doing more to help bring about world peace than posting angry messages on a website. I sincerely hope we can learn from our own violent outbursts, why violence is so hard to stop once it starts. I was walking around in downtown Philly the other night and I saw a banner hanging from a lightpost that read: "There is no way to peace. Peace is the way"
Next talkbacks
Back to article