News
'They should have killed Amir’
Nehama Duek
Published: 30.10.05, 20:23
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
14 Talkbacks for this article
1. Shouldn't expect much from Gillion
ilan ,   Ariel   (10.30.05)
Gillion is the address for the role Avishai Raviv played in the assasination. Why was Gillion directing an inside inciter to taunt and prode Amir to murder? Perhaps Amir would have done this crime without the encouragement from Gillion via Raviv, but at least it is time to let the truth be told. Time to release the Shamgar report for public review and time for Gillion to be judged for his role in this affair. Until then he calls to examine the role of unidentified "Rabbis" whom had even less influence than Raviv on Amir can only be seen as self-serving redirection of responsibility.
2. carmi gillon
yossy hershkop ,   brooklyn ny   (10.30.05)
face it y amir did not kill rabin it was rabins gurads who killed him and amir is being punished for your criminal acts
3. #s 1+2
Michael Steiner ,   Praha   (10.30.05)
Sure. And 9/11 was organized and perpetrated by haMosad, nachon?
4. Yigal Anir was a Mossad stooge.
Miss Muslima ,   London, England UK   (10.30.05)
5. what a loser
chip ,   israel   (10.30.05)
Only a failure like Gillon would use the primitive and cruel phrase: "shoot him like a dog." But obviously this is the level needed to get ahead, and ultimately fail miserably, in this banana republic.
6. Israeli justice system has a big problem
Logical ,   Haifa   (10.30.05)
It's not just the lack of prosecution against inciting rabbinic authorities - it is truly a systemic issue. Take for example the ridiculously short sentences given to convicted murderers, violent thugs, and serial traffic violators. In addition, these offenders typically receive 1/3 time off for good behavior and furloughs (which are often used for escape). Some local murderers sit in prison for only a decade, are able to marry and start a new life afterwards. Others are released in "peace" deals. What about their victims? This makes the concept of deterrance a joke.
7. What about the coverups in the Rabin Murder
misguidedjihadi ,   London, UK   (10.31.05)
Surely everyone can see through some of the holes in the Rabin murder. Even the number of bullets dont add up in different accounts of the evening. Carmi Gillon was the head of the Shabak at the time and must know what happened that night, not suprising he would have liked amir dead to cover up the conspiracy better. Read some of Barry Chamish's books or columns for more on the Rabin assasination, his writing is off the wall sometime, but the Rabin assasination leaves too many questions unanswered and according to polls the last few years , high percentages of the Israeli public agree with him that there was a conspiracy in the Rabin assasination. I am not a right wing conspiract nut, nor do I support what Amir is supposed to have done. I believe Amir would have done it without remorse, but most evidence points to the fact that the bullets he fired were blanks and a different person fired the killing shots.
8. Yigal Amir
Avi Ratzon ,   Edison, NJ USA   (10.31.05)
Y Amir would actually be smirking if he had indeed been Rabins Killer. He may be taking credit for it, but its highly doubtfull that he was the trigger man, just a scape goat. Maybe he shouldnt be pardoned, but he shoudnt be treated as harshly as he is.
9. Rabin was as guilty as Peres is now. Jewish homes being
Bunnie Meyer ,   Santa Monica, CA   (10.31.05)
stolen from Jews to molify terrorist scum who are thrilled to be part of an irrational cult of barbarians. Oslo was a fraud, Rabin embraced the fraud, Peres and Sharon still embrace the fraud. A pox on all the traitors including the worst of all, peace now, the Jewish arm of the islamic dungheads and the hamas bombers.
10. Carmi, level with us.
Sheeko ,   Ramat Gan   (10.31.05)
Did your guards really make a mistake that night, or were they, too, tired, and scared of the ludicrous, suicidal policies of Rabin?! Who more than than you (and your men) was privy to the grave danger that Rabin was foisting upon the Holy Land? Heck, your boys didn't even shoot Yigal in the foot. Nada! How many of your underlings breathed a sigh of relief upon Rabin's demise? I'll bet quite a few. Betcha some even praised and hailed Yigal Amir. Ya gotta admit, the kid's got guts; even if he wasn't (sic) the actual perp. I say appoint Yigal Amir as next Shabak head. His hands are clean, and.....he will make a glorious leader.
11. #4 Miss Muslima you're an Islamic stooge.
Diana ,   USA   (10.31.05)
12. Miss: Do you have the facts to run your dirty mouth??
Merrill ,   Moscow, Russia   (10.31.05)
What the $%^& do you know? Maybe Sept 11 was also a deed of Mossad? That's so typical of anti-semites to blame everything on Jews.. You are disguising!
13. This man is a vengeful idiot
Proud Member of the ,   Right, Israel   (10.31.05)
1. The point of our society is that it is a democracy and we don't shoot people like dogs. 2. Incitement against the right - which is NOT responsible for the death of Rabin - is just as ugly and wrong as incitement against the left. 3. Carmi Gillon is a frustrated man who never got over the fact that HIS security men screwed up and its easier to blame anyone other than himself...in short - he's a vengeful idiot
14. #12(Merrill) Mr: I do, but Fiction runs your dirty mind
Miss Muslima ,   London England UK   (11.02.05)
" Miss: Do you have the facts to run your dirty mouth?? Merrill , Moscow, Russia " Mr, My mouth is cleaner than your clogged up teeny tiny brain has ever been from "anti-semite" disease, and wayyyyyyyy cleaner than the fogged up lenses clouding your already short sighted vision, Merrill! "What the $%^& do you know? Maybe Sept 11 was also a deed of Mossad? " Is that what your believe? or what you hope? or what you fear? or what you....oh forget it... "That's so typical of anti-semites to blame everything on Jews.. You are disguising! " Well at least you are not "disguising" your ignorance, short sightedness or your pet peeve (antisemitism). Just don't pin all your pecadillio's on me! Take your anti-semite goggles off, and read with a clear mind! Here is a revelation that may shock you into reality THE WHOLE WORLD IS NOT ANTI-SEMITIC Now we can get back on the subject! About Yigal Amir being a Mossad stooge;- JANUARY/FEBRUARY 1998, Pages 30, 111-112 The Ostrovsky Files—Part II Commission Report Leaks Make Strong Case for Complicity of Shabak Officers in Rabin Assassination By Victor Ostrovsky http://www.washington-report.org/backissues/0198/9801030.htm
Back to article