News
Arab MK: Syria will hasten Palestinian J'lem
Roee Nahmias
Published: 30.12.05, 00:56
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
52 Talkbacks for this article
31. #21 makes an excellent point
A. de Metz ,   Haifa   (12.30.05)
The Arab MKs are merely reflecting the views of their constituency. They do not consider themselves to be Israelis, but Arabs living in "Occupied 1948 Lands." It is those Israelis who think that Arabs can be loyal citizens who are blind to the truth. If there is ever to be security in Israel, this 'fifth column' must go to live in Jordan (Palestine.) They would be happier amongst their own - and we would not have to deal with treachery from within.
32. #19
Nir ,   Israel   (12.30.05)
Okay, so what you're saying is: Israel should give electricity and water to the palastinians who bomb us every week plus, we should make sure the palastinians will have better conditions because they are so good to us. And for the record, we don't cut their electricity, it was an idea (in my opinion it was a good idea) in case of bombings. Also, setllers live in Caravans usually and their condition is not much better than palastinians. Here's an idea for you. We'll cut your electricity AND water, and palastine as the independent state you pretend it is, will provide the electricity/water for it's citizens. Also, I have a thing I wanted to say for a long time although it may sounds a little racist/petronizing. Without Israel there is no palastine. You couldn't even have your small 'cities' as they are without us. The second we disconnect your infrastructure you will be helpless. You should be thankful for us keeping your resources running even though you're bombing us. Of course we limit your resources to decrease the amount of bombings possible. But think about it for a sec, lets say you controlled Israel, and terror groups would bomb you every week and claim it was a response for something we did in response to their bombing... what would you do? (retorical question). We also provide you with food, communication abilities and more. If we were as racist as you say we are you would've joined allah a long time ago. I want to see your government even suggesting to compensate Israelies for the destruction you have caused us. Also, I would like you to open a history book and check the where 'Palastine' comes from when you say we occupy them. For your infortmation, they are decendents of Jordan. They have stayed where they are when we conquered those areas for a war ___THEY STARTED WITH US___ So now, after they start a war, and we win (of course..), they want their territory back... just like the Golan and Sinai. WHAT THE HELL DID YOU THINK? ... Did you wake up one morning and said: "What a lovely day. Lets try and open a war against Israel, if we'll win, yay for us. If we'll lose, we'll fund terror organizations to get the territory back to us."? THINK FOR A GOD DAMN SECOND I have no idea how arab leaders manage to brainwash so many arabs in so many ways in so many cultures... but it's getting ridiculous and you need to get a grip of reality. even us as Jews, as much as most of us believe in god, we know the red border, we know when a war has become useless and for a wrong cause. I hope you do realise you've been brainwashed to think this is a religious war... when it is not, at all. And how about Israel being %2 of the middle east and all the rest is arab? If you guys all care so much about the palastinians, how come you're not helping them except in funding their terror? do you think it works for them? did you notice the limitions we've given them each time they bombed us? the more we get bombed, the worse the palastinians will feel. each Kassam into Israel will cause Gaza to stay awake 2 nights as F16 will keep you awake (intentionally), while we do such things to calm you down, you blow up our citizens.
33. #19 - Followthrough
Nir ,   Israel   (12.30.05)
even though I am not religious, I am going to pray for you guys to come to your senses before Israel won't be able to hold back. We've been using about %10 of our army for these operations... the day we'll use %50 of it will be the day you will all vanish. And I really hope we wont get to that, I hope we can somehow get along although I do not believe we can live together sharing one capital. My idea was, as Muslims has no religious connection to Jerusalem, or an history connection, like I said before check your history books, I believe the only connection between Muslims and Jerusalem was some guy who interpreted a verse in the Korean and he _thought_ your Mohammad said something about Jerusalem and Mecca. (Of course the real book didn't use Jerusalem as the name) and of course, it DID use Mecca's name. Just like you won't see Mecca in the bible but you will see Jerusalem at least 40 times. Well, like I started saying before, my idea was: How about the palastinians will get Israeli passport? You don't have to be Jewish to be an Israeli, and if this will end our war I can _ASSURE_ you the rights arabs will have will increase and the limitations will cease. Also, as Israeli Arabs, you can still be muslim, and you can still go to Jerusalem and pray. Instead of pretending the land is yours you should try and compromise before it will be too late. Shalom.
34. sedition con't
Michael ,   Israel   (12.30.05)
it is ironic that Netanyahu is trying to keep feiglin out of the Knesset because he was once charged with "sedition". sedition in feiglin's case was "blocking roads" But Nentanyahu and the rest of the knesset wil remain silent when real sedition "stares them in the Face'". Once again, The Definition of freedm of speech is yet undefined in a Democratic state.
35. #10
Michael ,   Israel   (12.30.05)
Your right something is wrong. For starters. there are 22 rich Muslim countries. Why aren't they helping their brothers. They have no problem giving you money to buyguns and missles. Why don't they invest infrastructure? why have they discouraged the palestinians all these years from talking to the Israelis. All these years while your brothers are making billions of dollars from oil and owning real estate allo ver the world. Living better than Israelis. Yes, there is something wrong but ask of your "Brothers" this question first.
36. Wrong again Bunnie
Hans Steinmeier   (12.30.05)
You are totally wrong Bunnie. Jerusalem will eventually become the capital of Palestine wether you like or not.
37. Throw away the traitors!!!!!!
Gene ,   Israel   (12.30.05)
If I would be the head of state of Israel, Mr. Bishara would have continued his vacation in Lebanon for the rest of his life, and Mr. Barakeh would have been publically stripped of his Israeli citizenship and thrown to the Gaza strip like a filthy dog. In fact its just one more proof in the long history of proofs, about how loyal our arab citizens to the state. If we will continue to play in democracy with people who do not understand it, we will swim into the sea one day.
38. To #30 Steven Wilson
Khaled ,   Palestine   (12.30.05)
We’re gonna send you a dozen packs of kosher eatable condoms, they'll come in handy for you in Alaska... just plz give us your full address.
39. 19 - why are the gazans living conditions so bad?
mike ,   usa   (12.30.05)
never in the history of the world has so much money been given to a people and yet they have not even built ONE hospital. no one to blame but yourselves. your living situation would improve if you'd go for peace. that would solve every last problem you have.
40. He should be deported back to Palestine/Jordan
David Landman ,   Natick, USA   (12.30.05)
Amazing, he doesnt get the facts right. Since Jordan was 78% of historic Palestine and Palestine/Jordan ethnically cleansed its land of all Jews, why doesnt he go back there. Why does Bishara not think this is Jewish land? Afterall, the Temple Mount was there 1,000 years before the Muslims. Jerusalem census from 1840, earliest I can find that seems valid shows Jews are the majority or plurity in the capital. Only reason more Jews havent been around is they were kicked out by Arabs and British. Go back to Palestine/Jordan if you cant be loyal to Israel. Arab minority is welcome. Treason and racists like you are not.
41. khaled KELB
DACON9 ,   HISTORY PROFESSOR   (12.30.05)
THERE ARE A FEW THEORIES TO EXPLAIN THE arab EXISTENCE. 1) DARWIN = YOU EVOLVED FROM A MONKEY 2) ERIC VON DANIKEN = YOU ARE A PRODUCT FROM A SPACEMAN MIXING WITH A EARTH WOMAN 3) TEST TUBE EXPERIMENT THAT FAILED ATTEMPTING TO CROSS BREED 4) mohamed WAS AS CRAZY AS HIS UNCLE BELIEVED HIM TO BE 5) arabs ARE THE RUNT OF THE LITTER OF MANKIND 6) THE FUMES FROM CAMEL DUNG AFFECTED THE SPERM COUNT. THERE ARE A FEW MORE THAN WHAT I LISTED. MAYBE YOU SHOULD LOOK AT YOUR HISTORY TO EXPLAIN WHY YOU CANT PROCESS THOUGHT. oooOH RIGHT. THEY KEEP BLOWING UP BEFORE YOU GET TO INTERVEIW THEM. WELL THEN TRY THE LOCAL ZOO. BRING LUNCH WITH YOU, THEY ARE NOW SUCCESSFUL AT TEACHING APES SIGN LANGUAGE
42. khaled KELB
jerry1800   (12.30.05)
you forgot to add Mohamed the child molestor
43. Damacus,Syria
Jimmy ,   USA   (12.30.05)
Isaiah 17:1-7
44. Re# 39
Ron ,   UK   (12.30.05)
What kind of peace you are talking about.The peace with the Isaeli tanks back and forth. Israel has put tenders to build a new 200 units in Hebron, is this the paece, Gaza is 100 square miles with 1,3 million people and your people are willing to take .15 of this area for security, what kind of peace U are talking about.Isael is the best one to undermind any peace deal.All the world agrees on the road map and Israel puts 14 conditions on it and Israel says that they agree on the raodmap with the 14 conditions that they've put.... It is really nice cheating. For the money U are talking, the Palestininians are doing better job with these money, just for your information, Israel taks more that 40% of the donanted money.For each $1 given to the PA, Israel taks 40 cents, go back to some UN economic reports and U'll reach this conclusion....
45. 44 - what about suicide bombs?
mike ,   usa   (12.30.05)
what have the palestinians done toward peace? nothing. what have the palestinians done with the money? nothing. what do they do? complain. the UN even accepts israel's right to self- defence so what's the problem with that?
46. Freedom
Ron   (12.31.05)
U made me laugh, are the Palestinians occupying Tel-aviv and Israel needs to defend it self???? There are people fighting for freedom or this concept has been dropped from ur dictionary!!!!!
47. Who's family is indigenous?
Frank Adam ,   Prestwich - UK   (12.31.05)
Dear Sir, Is it not time somebody puts the Israeli phone book through analysis and counts all the subscribers named: Turki and Hindi as in the PA generals; and Masri, Mughrabi, Halabi, Sirhan (as in Sirhan Sirhan) and any other Arab town or area. This should at least be an inteesting rough draft of how many Arabs immigrated to Ha Aretz to calculate as a percentage of teh Arab population. Yours faithfully, FDA
48. #44 Show us your "UN economic reports"
Cynthia ,   USA   (12.31.05)
First of all, Israel has made peace with two countries capable of compliance with agreements. The Palestinians can't even maintain a cease fire. You seem to confuse the PA with Israel. Wouldn't it be difficult for Israel to take 40% of the donations which are paid directly to the Palestinians? Please tell us how that works and where you found this information. Israel actually pays millions of dollars in taxes to the PA for Palestinian labor. Post a specific reference to these UN economic reports before people conclude you're fabricating information.
49. to frank
fffffffffffffawzi ,   jerusalem   (12.31.05)
i have ten children one named falastin one macca i have one boy always laghing i shange his name to masri another one is blake i chnge his name to sudani i have a girl known as asia i have another known as rusia i forget the other names can you tell me what they are or i wait 56 years till you look in the telphon book to tell me from where i bring my cheldren whallahe alghazim ana shareefa ]it is enough
50. Israel democracy
Hilda ,   USA   (12.31.05)
In any other country this man would be tarred and feathered but in Israel he is part of the government. Is this democracy or is this foolishment and worse yet is it suicide.? This is the ultimate dath wish to keep traitors like this in the government. IThe difference between him and Bargouti is merely a matter of degree because if he had the chance he would also kill Israelis and who really knows if he indeed does not sponsor the homicide bombers. Isn;t it time to purge these people ??? if that is what you think they are from the country
51. To fffffffffffffawzi , jerusalem
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (01.01.06)
please try to learn spelling ... and then start again you make no sense or use an editor with a spell system
52. to g.g/g.
mother ,   ramalla   (01.01.06)
you are a jew if your mother is a jew whatever your father is even he is from honololo becouse of that there is american jew rusian jew athiopian jew and so on /but we are palastinian related to the father if the mother is your sister the son willbe palastinian the most important to us is [the mother must be sharifa ] i think you get it or not yet i want to tell you why jews are little in noumbers this is becouse the jew is whome mother is jew .the child bearing period to the women is only about 20 years .but to the man at leastthe double
Previous talkbacks
Back to article