News
Egypt: West ignores Israeli nukes
Reuters
Published: 17.01.06, 20:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
23 Talkbacks for this article
1. Egyptian HYPOCRISY
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (01.17.06)
Iran, publicly and openly declare they want to wipe Israel off the map with their nuclear weapons. Israel does not want to wipe any nation off the map! Israel wants only the HUMAN RIGHT to DEFEND her citizens from genocidal murderers. The Islamofascists, along with powerful non-Muslims want Israel reduced to a state of complete indefensibility.
2. TRUE- JEWS HAVE NUKES BUT ARABS CANT
(01.17.06)
3. Israel has yet to use one Nuke yet !
Marcel ,   Florida   (01.17.06)
Egypt is understandablly nervous and for good reason see's Israeli nukes as a threat to themselves. Israel without nukes in this deadly and dangerous neighborhood would have already ceased to exist. Mubarak knows this and know the next time Egypt attack Israel Cairo is gone forever. So it's not surprising that he points this problem of Israel's qualitive deterrent capability to Cheny . Mubarak expects the puppet master to remove nukes from Israel for their final coup de grace without jeapordizing Cairo.
4. The UN is useless
G   (01.17.06)
The UN is a place to put politics and self interest over world security. As long as Iran keeps moving oil to the world they will all turn a blind eye. Is this world completely insane?
5. Egypt worried about Israeli nukes?
barry ,   tokyo   (01.17.06)
They are the reason why Israel had to resort to developing nukes in the first place for fear of being butchered by wild invading Arabs! Israel will never be the first one to use nuclear weapons in the middle east.
6. And Egypt does NOT have nukes?
Steve ,   USA   (01.17.06)
B"H With El Bereidi an Egyptian national looking over Iran's program, what makes the world think that Egypt does NOT have nukes? They just may not test them to have confidence that they work. As Linda said, what hypocrites, trying to take attention off clearly beligerant Iranian nuclear development. As for peace, one does not need Uranium Hexaflouride for peace missions, as peaceful electricity-generating reactions do not need this material. This centrifugal process the Iranians are working on is clearly dedicated towards war preparation.
7. Come on this is a pathetic argument.
(01.17.06)
8. Meanwhile....
J K ,   NYC, USA   (01.17.06)
DEBKAfile’s Washington sources: The Bush administration is cutting off the multimillion dollar grant covering Egypt’s security operations in the Gaza Strip and the Gazan-Egyptian border
9. Why??? only Israel have the bomb?
(01.17.06)
10. Hypothetical situation.
Food for thought ,   Yummy hmmm.   (01.17.06)
#1, all the Arabs put down their weapons, result, peace in the middle east. #2, all the Jews put down their weapons, result, peace, it will be silent all right, silent as a grave...
11. ISRAEL SHOULD HAVE A MILLION NUKES!
Daisy ,   USA   (01.17.06)
As a Catholic American I trust Israel but not the Arabs!
12. Israel HYPOCRISY
Egyptian ,   Egypt   (01.17.06)
Israel will never be the first one to use nuclear weapons in the Middle East. What a pile of B.S. Iran can say the same thing. You ask other people to trust you based on what? Missing live or your very high standard Israel try to use their nuclear bombs during 1973 war and USSR threaten that he will wipe Israel of the map if they use their nuclear weapon against Egypt or Syria.
13. Amen to #4 and #10
Matthew ,   New Jersey   (01.17.06)
The UN is a evil organization. Israel I hope the have nukes and a few of them. I HOPE even more that the world is 100% free of nukes. BUT the last few country to get rid of theirs should be the USA and Israel...2 very trust worthy countries. To #10..i have been saying that statement for years and everytime i say and hear i honestly believe more.
14. Is this not the same person that the Gullable Israelis ?
Nachm Sanow   (01.17.06)
Made a peace treaty ??? Is this not the same person that the Gullable Israelis Gave over the phildelphi security and thus allowed the smuggling of weapons ??? Is this not the same person that uses billions in grant money for weapons to be used against (Ask the Gullable Israelis) And finall this person is asking the gullable Israelis just one more little request give up your Nuclear Deterrant Wonder Why ????????
15. Hypocrisy
G ,   shomron   (01.18.06)
why does everyone make hypocrisy seem so bad? Double standards exist because certain groups act in such a way that leads to the requirement of more than one standard. One country makes statements to wipe a country off the map, and another one does not !!!
16. Arab demands
Warren ,   USA   (01.18.06)
Minimum Arab territorial demands from Israel would leave Israel indefensible by conventional means. Israel could not absorb an attack and effectively repel it, and indeed, would have no warning of such. Israel, after satisfying the above, would be even more dependent on nuclear weapons for purposes of deterrence and reprisals. Egyptian Arab and Iranian warlords have repeatedly said Israel has "no strategic depth". Egypt's problem is that it harbors a deep desire to launch violence against Israel on a scale that would legitimize the use of ANY available means in response. Mubarak seems to have an obsession with nuclear, as opposed to biological, chemical and other weapons. The other ones must be a OK. Egypt, whether or not led by the current regime whose legitimacy is increasingly questioned after decades of absolute rule, remains a hostile enemy state despite the existence of a "peace" treaty.
17. To the Egyptian
Christopher ,   Boston MASS USA   (01.18.06)
As usual, the Arabs do not present coherent arguments. First of all, you say Iran can say the same thing. They could, but they've already stated they want to see the destruction of a free State, namely Israel. I defy you to list when Israel ever openly threatened the existence of a State. As for Russian "threats," merely Egyptian conjecture. As it was, you got your asses kicked by ARIEL SHARON who only stopped because of US interference. Had he continued, perhaps Egypt too would be a democratic state, something most Arabs seem to oppose violently. One more issue - why do the Egyptians get such glee when persecuting their Coptic Christian citizens? Sorry..obvious answer!
18. Why does Israel need between 200-300 nukes?
Chris ,   Toronto   (01.18.06)
I can see having a few for defense, but having enough to completely wipe the Middle East off the map doesn't look defensive.
19. We need to defend Israel LOL
(01.18.06)
"I defy you to list when Israel ever openly threatened the existence of a State"....except Gaza. They only destroy States that can not defend them selves. They don’t threaten, they just tell the USA to do it for them. They do it by proxy, because anything else would cost them precious MONEY i.e. their GOD. Why is it that most Arabs hate Israel? If Israel and the USA would stop killing their innocent women and children maybe there would be peace. If the Arabs wanted to destroy Israel they would have done it already. Do you think nukes are hard to obtain? All anyone would have to do is smuggle it in a crate of heroin, with a timer, then they could get it delivered anywhere in the world! LOL Please, you make me sick. If I killed children I would need to defend myself too!
20. stop bickering
Egyptian ,   Egypt   (01.18.06)
As usual, the Israelis do not present any facts in their arguments, just the bed time stories that their mother told them. First of all during 1973 the condition on the ground was not in your favor this much, and your legendary leader actually try to occupy two empty cities Suez and Ismailia and he fail in every attempt and your forces suffer massive losses. By the way the leader of the 2nd army that was fighting Mr. Sharon was Christian Coptic. By the way the word Coptic means Egyptian. I think you have to read some books before you open your mouth. If you read your country men comments all of it are just threats. I didn’t say anything about targeting any Israeli civilians; in contrast to that the only selective democracy in the region is threaten to target cities. If we have any plans for you we will not strength the economic relations. If you don’t like us this much why you bagging us for relation normalization? Every time I met an Israeli he always says I’m your neighbor and he keeps joking with me. Based on this I thought your society is actually ready for peace, but after all of this comments I don’t think so. Just stop bickering and assume your country is an island.
21. Reply to Egyptian #20
Daniel ,   Israel   (01.18.06)
Like most Arabs you ignore the basic fact that the Arabs have started all Arab-Israeli wars with the aim to destroy Israel. Israel managed to stop the Arab aggression in 1973 and had the upper hand when the Russians came to save their Arab clients. Widespread anti-Jewish racist hate propaganda is rampant In all Arab countries including Egypt which signed a "peace treaty" with Israel in 1979. As long as the vile anti-Jewish racist nazi propaganda and hate lies about Israel in the Arab world, genuine peace will remain a dream.
22. Israel has had nukes for decades
Digital Heretic   (01.18.06)
It shows that Israel can be trusted. Can the same thing be said for Arab countries? Possibly Egypt. Possibly Jordan. However enither of them really feel threatend by Israel. Egypt's peace with Israel came at the end of the 6 day war and to my recollection, there has been no significant conflicts between the two since.
23. To Egyptian and Canadian
DR ,   Florida, USA   (01.19.06)
It is funny that you tell people to read books before they speak. The books you read are fabrications of history by your lying government. Of course you believe what you read to be true, but the rest of the world has a different reality...the true reality. Ignoring the facts and the truth is the arab/muslim way. It has been this way for centuries and it is the main reason for lack of Arab success. Your country will soon face economic sanctions for not running fair, democratic elections...talk to us then. To the guy from Toronto...You really don't need to speak about the middle east...the US has it covered...just sit back and watch your Hockey and drink your Labbat;s blue ok... ey???
Back to article