News
Paris: Gang suspected of killing Jew nabbed
Ynet
Published: 19.02.06, 12:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
94 Talkbacks for this article
1. The French are stupid once again
Greg ,   USA   (02.19.06)
Not anti-semetic.....are they f...ing for real?....Yeah lets join Putin in a big communal hamas love fest
2. #1 The French are not stupid
Roger ,   USA   (02.19.06)
They are who they are. We cannot expect much from them except their constant excuses. However, the Jews who live in France are very stupid. GET OUT OF FRANCE NOW! There is nothing good the Jews can expect from Europe.
3. All Jews are Rich
Johnny Weintraub ,   Sugar Land,Texas USA   (02.19.06)
Every Jew who gets kidnapped is supposed to have Euro 400,000 readily available to pay for ransom. You did not know that?
4. #s 1 + 2:
Michael Steiner   (02.19.06)
You call the French stupid?! Why?? The suspects were arrested only recently so there's not been enough time to put all the pieces together. We also don't know ANYTHING about the suspects. So, to cry anti-Semitism merely because the victim was Jewish makes YOU the stupid one(s). Let me relate a story to you. A couple of years ago a bomb went off in front of an establishment in Prague owned and run by Jews. Morons like you started foaming at their mouths about anti-Semitism, how Prague is no longer safe for Jews, how the police are not doing anything, blah blah blah. You know who planted the bomb? An Israeli mafia clan. Also, remember the story of the Jewish woman who got savagely attacked on the Paris subway by a gang of Arab youths and no-one helped her? Remember our outrage and indignation? Remember the denoument: she'd made up the entire story. Shavua tov and keep working on your prejudices.
5. #4 Michael Steiner
Greg ,   USA   (02.19.06)
Perhaps it is stupid of me to jump the gun and cry anti-Semitism before the facts are in on this case, I'll give you that. But as you say the fact's aren't in so let's see. You can call me a moron that's fine, but only a fool fails to recognize the facts. There is a growing anti-semitism in Europe. And there is no foam coming out of my mouth, have you checked yours lately?
6. Just wondering.....
n/a ,   TA   (02.19.06)
I'm just wondering which etnic background these kidnappers have....wouldn't be suprised if they are muslim though....
7. it is antisemitic
stephane ,   paris   (02.19.06)
we know that this is acts of antisemitism,but of course also for the money.how we know that?because this gang of animals tried to abduct 5 times before they finally succeed to abduct ilan halimi.among the 5 persons they failed to abduct,3 of them were also jewish.so that means that they targeted jewish people because they have an antisemitic "philosophy".they think that if they want a lot of money they must target jews,because in their small brains of animals they suppose that all the jew are billionaire!the girl who went to ilan's shop to trap him was this time an arabic girl.the 5 times before the gang used a french blond girl.and i know something the french media don't want to say because they want to "calm" us:my cousin was a friend of ilan,she talked on the day of his funeral with his mother and here is what she told my cousin: they tortured her son during 24 days,and the bastards called the mother to make her hear what they were doing to her son.and in the same time they were reading the coran!...why do you think they tortured ilan during 24 days?!!!only because their hate and jealousy of the jews.so far the police arrested 15 people of the gang,but their leader who calls himself"brain of the barbarians" is missing.it's(what a coincidence!) a black muslim and the name of this son of a bitch is:youcef fofana...u can see his horrible face on www.lci.fr for example.today the jewish community organize a silent march in the memory of ilan in paris.
8. the french police acted with determination throughout
(02.19.06)
9. #5:
Michael Steiner   (02.19.06)
OK, sorry about the "moron"--my point was to wait and see, and not throw around accusations of anti-Semitism flippantly.
10. #5: you're right
Steiner again   (02.19.06)
about anti-Semitism's prevalence in Europe though. It shouldn't surprise us though. Anti-Semitism is everywhere and has at one time or another reared its head all over the world. Bottom line: we have no friends.
11. Make Aliyah Stephane we wait for you my brother
Gil ,   Tel Aviv   (02.19.06)
12. Abdul Steiner is at it again ! !!!
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (02.19.06)
13. Calm down, the mossad is probably already on it's way ;-b
Yakir   (02.19.06)
14. To Steiner
Francois ,   Paris   (02.19.06)
We also don't know ANYTHING about the suspects. So, to cry anti-Semitism merely because the victim was Jewish makes YOU the stupid one(s). .......... Claiming like the French judge that this is not an anti-Semitic crime because the gang tried to kidnap non-Jews guys is a non-sense as well. Hitler was not only murdering Jews and he was an-Semite. This judge has no evidence that anti-Semitism was not one of their motivations. However, since the policy of the French authorities is to constantly whitewash and deny Muslim anti-Semitism we couldn't trust them.
15. Who recites the Quran ... Give me a break
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (02.19.06)
Frances masses of Muslims They are my neighbors to Geneva, and one of these days France will be called ........ Francistan Sarkozy better get's his act going FAST
16. stephane, Paris: same you say was reported in Geneva news
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (02.19.06)
17. What is NOT reported about this gang
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (02.19.06)
It is well established, that ... Indeed that gang has been operating for just over a year. So what takes the police that long
18. #s 14 + 15:
Michael Steiner   (02.19.06)
#14: so, whenever a victim of a crime is Jewish, it's automatically an act of anti-Semitism?? You're absurd. #15: Adolfelle militating for ethnic cleaning again; this time in Europe.
19. French lies
Francois ,   Paris   (02.19.06)
No French media reported that Ilan kidnappers recited Kuran verses to the family.
20. This is just a taste of things to come
Ezra ,   West Coast, USA   (02.19.06)
I'm afraid WWIII is just around the corner.
21. French logic, whoow that's great
Isac ,   Florida   (02.19.06)
If the situation would not be that serious with one man brutally tortured and murdered, it could almost be comical. Pink Panther move over! The French police excludes that the crimes were motivated by anti-semitic motives, HOWEVER they still have to determine what made the gang to commit the crimes?!@ Now THAT is French logic. If it walks and talks like a duck.... And does it surpise anyone, that Muslims could commit torture and murder, just because the man was a Jew?
22. to # 15
......... ,   TA   (02.19.06)
Why Francistan?? Most countries who end with -stan are former Sovjet Union countries....I don't get it.....
23. To #18
Francois ,   Paris   (02.19.06)
so, whenever a victim of a crime is Jewish, it's automatically an act of anti-Semitism?? You're absurd. ........ When Muslims thugs commit a crime against a Jew, it's likely to be an act of anti-Semitism. The French judge is lying when she claims that this is not an anti-Semitic crime. Right now, the investigation is not yet started so she can't be aware of the gang motivations. Once again, Eurosissies like you are trying to whitewash Muslims crimes.
24. to 22...
stephane ,   paris   (02.19.06)
because afghanisTAN
25. steiner , i wish all jews had brains like yours..
aa ,   london   (02.19.06)
26. YOUR FALSE ENEMY
GEORGE SAMI   (02.19.06)
YOU ALWAYS LIKE TO BE THE VICTIM, WHILE YOU ARE THE SLAUGHTER. LOOK AT NO 12 GABRIELLE WHAT HE CALL STEINER , HE NAMED HIM ABDUL STEINER, AND MOST OF US KNOW THAT THIS IS AN ISLAMIC OR ARABIC NAME, YOU LIKE TO CREATE AN ENEMY TO YOU, TO BE ALWAYS THE VICTIM, BUT YOU MADE MISTAKE NOW BECAUSE YOU CHOOSE TO ESTABLISH YOUR STATE GIVEN TO YOU BY (HASHEM) BY (G-D) BY WHAT EVER THE NAME HE HAVE YOU CHOOSED TO LIVE IN THE MIDDLE OF THEIR WORLD THE ARAB AND MUSLIMS , THEN YOU START TO SHOUT AND CRY THEY ARE YOUR ENEMY , YOU PULLED THE AMERICAN TO HELP YOU IN THIS MATTER , AND THE POOR BELIEVED YOU BECAUSE YOU PUT IN THEIR MIND THAT JESUS OR THE MESSIAH WILL COME ONLY IF THE TEMPLE BUILD , AND IT WILL NEVER BE BUILT BECAUSE IT IS NEVER EXIST , ALL THE RABBIES KNOWS THAT , BUT THE POOR AMERICAN RAN AFTER YOU , THEN WHAT??????
27. #22 TA, about Gabrielle #15
Mo   (02.19.06)
"Why Francistan?? Most countries who end with -stan are former Sovjet Union countries....I don't get it....." Don't worry you're not missing much, Gabrielle just doesn't know much about history and thinks because Pakistan ends in Stan that ALL Muslim countries do, if you read all her previous comments statements like this wouldn't surprise you she's said WAAAAAY dumber things; you must be new to Ynet.
28. Re: "Steiner, I wish all Jews had brains like yours"
Joshua ,   New York   (02.19.06)
Naturally you do. Then your job would be so much easier.
29. Paris - the capital of the Nazified Eurabia
Arie   (02.19.06)
30. Steiner throwing around accusations
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (02.19.06)
A Jew is MURDERED but Steiner warns against "anti-Semitism" at this point. Meanwhile Steiner remains absolutely convinced that "settlers" committed the brazen atrocity of the MYSTERIOUS DISAPPEARING GRAFFITTI.
Next talkbacks
Back to article