News
Paris: Gang suspected of killing Jew nabbed
Ynet
Published: 19.02.06, 12:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
94 Talkbacks for this article
61. Wake up France!
Marc Cortez ,   Texas   (02.20.06)
Do not bend over for these savages like you did with the Nazis! We will not bail you out a second time!
62. #61
john mcnichols ,   sweden   (02.20.06)
Marc, who did you "bail out" the first time?
63. Paris: Gang suspected of killing Jew nabbed
maczmo ,   US   (02.20.06)
Was the gang Muslim?
64. Attack not spurred by anti-Semitism? Come on...
Matthew Chase ,   St. Louis, USA   (02.20.06)
It is absolutely absurd to for authorities to state that the attack on Ilan Halimi was not due to anti-Semitism. It is ironic that your report pointedly leaves out the names of any of the 13 arrested. Only from the statement of the victim's brother do we learn they are Arab or Muslim (surprise surprise) because they quoted the Koran over the phone to the family. This is the regular, unfortunately expected, behavior of Muslims today. Attack, kill, maim, terrorize and destroy, commit horrendous acts against Jews, Israel, America, Christians, the West in general (in that order), and get a pass from the spineless, sycophantic world media. You should be ashamed of the lack of journalistic integrity displayed by not questioning such official statements.
65. #64
john ,   sweden   (02.20.06)
That was quite a harangue Matthew. What do you want the French police or press to do? Everyone is aware that anti-Semitism exists in Europe and that this crime was horrific. To fan the flames of racial hatred or to dwell on this crime as a racist event promotes hate and consequent revenge even more! Revenge is something that the evil are experts in and has very little to do with justice. That this gang, whatever their motive, should receive proper pounishment for their crime is what all your efforts should be concerned with.
66. Jewish man dies in France
Dan ,   Dallas, USA   (02.20.06)
To the French, "STAND & FIGHT"
67. Ilan Halimi Kidnapping/Murder
Papa Bear ,   Detrioit, USA   (02.20.06)
You seem to be overly politically correct and biased in this article. Why is it necessary to describe the victiim as a Jew in the headline but to withold even the suspicion that the murderers were Muslim until the very bottom of the article?
68. I am not surprised...
Bobby ,   San Diego   (02.20.06)
Just another senseless act from the practitioners of the religion of peace, or so we thought. Wake up world !!
69. french need help
Thierry ,   los angeles   (02.20.06)
Hello Guys, Happy to ear your comment about this sad story and the death of this young guy. for the last 50 years the French gouverment encourage muslin immigrants to setlle in our society because of the FRENCH HUMANISM . BIG BIG mistake, this peoples can't fusion with our model of society. They're only agenda It's to convert us or kill us. A lot of French peoples know but they can speak in public about it. The civil war is close, be prepare
70. jews in europe
brian ,   san diego,usa   (02.20.06)
The liberal Jews in America are just as stupid as the ones that live in France.some in France cannot just leave,its the ungrateful ones that live in the U.S. that keep wanting to be like the Europeans is the real problem
71. enjoy your kushi life in america
Brian -Friends   (02.20.06)
you need to learn from history.after europe they will ramp it up in the u.s.a. they wony ask if you are liberal or conservative.jews will unforutnately go first
72. #64 John from Sweden
Joe ,   USA   (02.20.06)
"Everyone is aware that anti-Semitism exists in Europe and that this crime was horrific. To fan the flames of racial hatred or to dwell on this crime as a racist event promotes hate and consequent revenge even more! " So if the Arabs commit a hate crime we shouldn't call it that because it will only cause them to commit more hate crimes? Europeans are idiots. Im going to enjoy watching your racist continent burn.
73. Paris gang
ron ,   Flint, USA   (02.20.06)
Show the girl...that's where the danger starts
74. #70, 71
john ,   sweden   (02.20.06)
Are you on drugs, Brian? Could you try to be just a little.....coherent??
75. #69 Thierry
Joe ,   USA   (02.20.06)
French Humanism? That's what we call an oxymoron. You let them in for cheap labor. Again, I will enjoy watching them cause your country to suffer like you deserve. The Paris riots were a big hit here in the States because you people said during the LA riots that that couldn't happen in France because the French are so tolerant. Obviously not.
76. This was not about the money!
Dr RJP ,   Jacksonville, FL   (02.20.06)
If you read the description of what happened to Halimi (tied to tree, naked, burns on body), then how can you NOT conclude that this was a hate crime against a Jewish man, and was not simply a kidnap for ransom. Was it anti-Semitic? It was inhuman whatever label you give it. My thinking is that the torture of Hamili was most definitely motivated by his kidnappers discovering that he was a Jew. There is no other compelling reason to multilate a total stranger, except to send a message to others.
77. Muslim Governments Fuel Anti-Jewish Hatred
Tim Collins ,   Columbia, MD USA   (02.20.06)
Anyone trying to deny that the default position of Muslims is to hate Jews has their head buried in the sand and is in danger of having it cut off. Look at all the anti-semitic cartoons prevalent throughout the middle east. Some of the people on this board seem to think a problem only exists when the victims finally recognize it. Wake up! By the way, someone said the Jews have no friends. I disagree. I think the USA has been a friend. And I will do all I can to see it remains one.
78. Jane #36
Sandy ,   Dwitzerland   (02.20.06)
You're right Jane, 100%. And we will live to see the day when the new Temple stands. The Bible says so.... and I believe.
79. I think people need to wake up.
Denver Morgan ,   Belmont usa   (02.20.06)
I Think people need to pull there heads out of the sand now and realize the muslim world hates Europe the united states Israel and just about every body else we need to start treating them as as the enemy there acting like it they talk peace but then they send out a sucide bomber I dont think we need to wait to see what they gonna do with a nuke.
80. Blacks
Almaz ,   United States, Israe   (02.20.06)
so are you saying Stephanie that all Blacks are ignorant or just Black Muslims? Your comment sounded a little racist there itself.
81. France
Almaz ,   Israel   (02.20.06)
The French NEVER cared for the Jews and I don't know why Jews are still there. LEAVE that place or you will have more Ilan's these people are animals. And the French are no better they just cover their stink of hatred with designer clothes and perfume. MOVE to Israel Move to the US but LEAVE france. They are making baby after baby after baby. Living on the Dole blaming Jews for all their problems when these idiots bring it on themselves. All that rioting last summer was by people who were for the most part born and raised in France. If France was smart (Which we know they are not) They should Lower a boat and send all those people back. When I was there last year I could not believe how bad Paris looked and how some of the areas that USED to be nice are worse than you would see in any Urban Ghetto in the United States. The French are cowards. It is too late for them. And of course if they are attacked I am sure they would want the US to save them as they did in every previous World War. Israel needs more Jews. I told my cousin 10 years ago to leave France because with all the Muslims there instead of wearing Chanel you will be wearing Chadors and Burkas. People are too stupid to realise that this is the aim of the Muslims to spread their brand of Religion all over the world. They can speak badly of any other religion but if you even Mildly critique theirs they are ready to behead you. People wake up this is NOT a religion of peace. Read the Koran yourself and you will see the contradictions abound. The religion is messed up and the people are no better. These people never cared about Israel until Jews made it prosper. I dont' want to see anymore Ilans. This is terrible. This should be a wake up call to the Jews of France. You should make plans to leave. The French will not miss you for sure. They will be glad that you are gone anyway. Let THEM deal with their beloved Muslims.
82. 80 Almaz
(02.20.06)
You are the only one who read it that way. I guarantee it.
83. Religion of peace
RL ,   washington   (02.20.06)
here is an excerpt from the Koran. Clearly demonstrating the peaceful nature of this religion. Book 041, Number 6985: Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: The last hour would not come unless the Muslims will fight against the Jews and the Muslims would kill them until the Jews would hide themselves behind a stone or a tree and a stone or a tree would say: Muslim, or the servant of Allah, there is a Jew behind me; come and kill him; but the tree Gharqad would not say, for it is the tree of the Jews. Hijacked by a few?
84. deport them ALL
jf ,   nashville   (02.21.06)
DEPORT them ALL!!!!! Clean up Europe by outlawing Islam.
85. PUH-LEEZ
Irene ,   U.S.A   (02.21.06)
You really expect me or any other intelligent person to believe these murderers were not Muslim, and they specifically targeted a Jew? 1.) French police confirmed the murderers recited quotations from the Quran to the victim's family over the phone. 2.) The murderers confirmed to the victim's family over the phone that they were aware of the fact Ilan was Jewish. 3.) These murderers specifically tried kidnapping JEWS twice before. The natural, logical conclusion is that the murderers were Muslim! If you want to play "reverse-psychologist" and conspire some half-cocked love-and-tolerance theory that perhaps some fringe Communist group is trying to restart the cold war by impersonating Jew-killing Muslims, go ahead. However, that foolishness would best be left to Inspector Clouseau.
86. murder in france
marty ,   USA   (02.21.06)
france sucks.
87. Islam and piece
(02.21.06)
islam lives by the sword, they want piece, so they cut off your head,rape 9year old girldslike their great prophet MOHAMMAD; no wonder they walk around in bed sheets and don't use toilet paper in the middle east.If walked around with a sore ass all day, I would hate the infidels too.
88. SAVING ONES LIFE AND FUTURE
robert propp ,   los angeles,ca.   (02.21.06)
B"H Mariel, unfortunately when a boulder starts rolling down the hill you get out OFthe way, The handwriting is on the wall.come to america or go to ertz ISREAL. "IF I AM NOT FOR MYSELF WHO WILL BE FOR ME, IF NOT NOW WHEN",PERKE AVOTH
89. Stereotypical Islamist Cruelty; Typical French Cowardice
gunjam ,   Texas, US   (02.21.06)
This is a sickening tale of sordid cruelty carried out in the name of Islam. The French prosecutor claims he can find no evidence of an anti-Semitic motive. Probably his underwear carries brown stains from fear of what the Islamofascists might do to him if he dared state the obvious. Incidents like this one crystallize why the religion of Islam is so popular amont hardened criminals from Africa to Europe to North America: It is a cult completely bereft of the slightest hint of "repentance." One merely states the obligatory creed of belief in Allah and his prophet, places a Qur'an under his arm, and continues to carry out murder and mayhem as before, only NOW while maniacally shouting "Allahu Akbar." Islam is the only religion that blatantly calls evil good -- as long as it is carried out by a Muslim against an unbeliever. http://jammedgun.blogspot.com
90. to Michael Steiner
HERVE ,   PARIS   (02.21.06)
Michael, Fisrft what you said about the women in the suburb of paris is FAKE, she wasn't jewes women but she said to the police the gang believed she was jewish, she was crazy women. But about the poor Ilan ,about 10 jewish people in Paris wanted to be kidnaped but the gang , one was not jewish, we are only 1% of the population......It's an islamic group, they were praying ALLAH and CORAN on the video they sent to the family.So please don't say bla bla bla they destructed his eyes , his sex (excuse me for my bad english).the gouvernement is afraid of the 12 millions muslims (on 65 millions french) who lived in France so they prefer not say anything about that.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article