News
10 year-old Palestinian girl killed
Ali Waked
Published: 18.03.06, 09:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
81 Talkbacks for this article
1. ANOTHER NASTY WORK ACCIDENT
PILPELET ,   H ISRAEL   (03.17.06)
I HOPE THAY WERE INSURED I HAVE ALWAYS SAID AT WORK THINGS SHOULD BE SHAKEN NOT STIRRED .............OR IS THAT A MARTINA.............NEVER MIND TOO LATE
2. Shame on the dead girl
(03.17.06)
I send my condolences to the family over this unfortunate mistake.
3. . Shame on the dead girl NOT
(03.17.06)
terrorists and islamic killers must not take children along
4. What do you meen shame...
miron ,   ny,usa   (03.17.06)
they say Jews will be killed evrywhere. I don,t care who will be died arabs it does,t matter.
5.  Y NET U CHANGED THE CAPTION
PILPELET ,   H ISRAEL   (03.17.06)
AFTER I HAD REPLYED ...........I WAS REFERING TO THE TWO MEN KILLED MAKING SOME SORT OF EXPLODING DEVICE , IF YOU CHANGE SOMTHING YOU SHOULDNT PUT IN THE REPLY ...................I AM VERY SORRY FOR THE INNOCENT CHILD AND HER FAMILY.
6. Thats what happens
someone   (03.17.06)
When terrorists use children as human shields!
7. this story is confusing
jF ,   nashville   (03.17.06)
was the girl in the taxi and with the 2 other people hurt????? Anyway, I'm not happy about any children hurt. These terrorist need to stop hiding behind them.
8. of course arabs' mistake again #3
(03.17.06)
If it was an Israeli girl, then she is innocent, and Palestinians are monsters, terrorists, etc. But if it is Palestinians, then it is the Palestinians' heartless terrorists taking their children with them to fight. or It doesn't matter if arabs die (as long as the victim is not Jewish, all is fine). You people are retarded, officially are.
9. Nothing New...
KS ,   Lebanon   (03.17.06)
Why is it everytime that the IDF or any israelis do something wrong the story is condsidered confusing and probably not true? common people..wake up...
10. So sorry
Mauricio ,   Brazil   (03.17.06)
The only thing that can be done in fact is to say so sorry. It was a work acccident. Terrorists are almost all Palestinians so this happens and will happen times again. SO WHAT?
11. As usual,
Arie   (03.17.06)
Arabs are well known for using kids as 'human shields'. Now the Father will push to cash in the $25000 the PA promises to all families whose parents contribute a girl to the cause.
12. Arie
Nick ,   USA   (03.18.06)
Stop the non sence, only somebody like you will sell his blood for $25,000 or maybe lass, for god sake, be a human at least once in your life...evry time a kid gets killed always blame terrorist for hiding behind them, the soldies should look closely before firing at young girl in a taxi...after hearing all you guys non human response i say...Concentration Camps was nothing more and cleaning out of some dirty blood.....
13. When will these idiots stop these....
Abdullah ,   Kuwait City   (03.18.06)
disgusting acts of terrorism! It is time for the Palestinians to stop fighting Israeli occupation with terrorism, even if Israel chooses to use it against the Palestinian masses! The key to fighting the Israeli occupation is by a peaceful full civil disobedience and the dispersing of the so called PA or rather PDA (Palestinian Dis-Authority). Peace
14. Did they take little girl with in car as a camoflage?
Alan ,   South Africa   (03.18.06)
15. nonsense
human   (03.18.06)
You Mr., have asked where is the girl killed? She killed by the Israeli soldiers who occupying the land of the Palestinians. She killed near her home. So who is the terrorist ? the soldier who come to your house to kill you or the innocient girl in her father,s car.
16. human
(03.18.06)
wrong name you areanothe human shield hiding behind kiddies
17. stop that sh...
(03.18.06)
what it means they are using children as humanshields ??? the IDF attacking villages full of people and they knew that there is alot of children and women living there but they don'r care ... since when the IDF cares about the Palistinian blood .... how many children have been shot died without having even a stone in their hands .... we all remeber the tragedy of Mohamed El Dora ... which his last pictures will stay forever as black point in the history of the Israelians and will be used oneday as witness for war crimes ... stop find your self reasons for what you are doing .... it will never work .... the intenational comunity knows you well ... in one wekk how many inocents have been killed by the IDF ... the guards of the prison which were just doing their job their and now this girl .... my heart is bleeding for her and her family and for any child in the world fall as victim for some vampiers killers .... God bless her .
18. #17 Muhammad al Dura was killed by Palestinian fire
(03.18.06)
The barrel he was behind was completly out of line of fire of the Israeli soldiers, if you're going to talk crap about Israel at least talk real crap and not invented crap. About the girl : It says specificly that he father and uncle (terrorists) were in the car, meaning that the only option was that she was being used as a human shield, its a shame that Arabs have no value for human life.
19. Arabs have to stop their terrorism - Then they will not lose
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (03.18.06)
Their own children - which many times they intentionally misuse: And then shout in the name of Allah How sick !!!! Using the Children: http://switch3.castup.net/cunet/gm.asp?format=wm&s=F2A8DD0D6B8149268348A1EF7EE27449&ci=13673&ClipMediaID=19647 The Ultimate Child Abuse http://judaism.c.tclk.net/maabuDAaa0OIUa6KtLde/ "Ask for Death" http://www.isratv.com/video/filmpmwadsl.asx
20. 18: here is the link to the Truth who killed Al Dura
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (03.18.06)
Muhammad al Dura was killed by Palestinian fire http://www.palestinefacts.org/pf_1991to_now_alaqsa_dura.php
21. Nick , USA : The sad point is what you call Nonesense
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (03.18.06)
is TRUTH ...... Arabs use constantly their children since it will bring the right propaganda Wake up to reality The Ultimate Child Abuse http://judaism.c.tclk.net/maabuDAaa0OIUa6KtLde/
22. shame on you all
walter ,   UK   (03.18.06)
I it noe surprising to read all those comments mostly blaming every body else except the criminals who with cold blood shot an innocent girl comming back from school in the middle of the day , this is the arrogant mintality which bring more and more hatred and more and more people willing to blow themselves up in order to revenge such atrocities .
23. Transfer would have saved the Arab girl's life
Mr Transfer ,   Yerushalyim   (03.18.06)
The Joshua Solution will eventually be done
24. To Walter: We will continue our fight
Dudu ,   Kfar Sava   (03.18.06)
Yes, and that includes shooting little PLO girls! It says in the Torah that this Land is OURS. All is fair in Love and War
25. walter ,UK : Get your facts right
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (03.18.06)
Should responsible adults have a girl sitting in a taxi with suspects and travel in a combat area ? NO but that's what Arabs do - take their children with them where they become shields so the sick people are those adults who constantly use children in war zones and direct combat zones would you have your children there ? Arabs do this intentionally for it gives them propaganda. Article 28 (Geneva Convention) states that "protected persons may not be used to render certain points or areas immune from military operations," nullifying the Argument that the IDF violates Intl. Law.
26. Dudu, Kfar Sava : Your comment is NOT
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (03.18.06)
the general opinion of any Israeli - your comment is sick - and that of an extremist
27. response to Gabrielle #25
walter ,   UK   (03.18.06)
You need to get your facts right instead of sitting in Geneva lecturing on right and wrong , Al Yamoun is a peaceful village outside Jenin and not a combt area , your blood sucking soldier friends attacked the village sitting in their armed personel carriers , your logic dictates that no body in palestine should go to school or travel in taxis ?just in case israeli sodiers may decide to attck there and change the area into war zone , It is a fact that Israeli soldiers used and still using innocent as people human shields constantly despite the fact that an Israeli court has forbidden that ?, your sick fact changing remarks will not change the facts the occupiers are the crimilnalsand the land owners are the victims .
28. to Dudu - kfar sava
walter ,   UK   (03.18.06)
You represent the vast majority of Israeli public as long the victim is not one of us he or she is worth nothing , congratulation man
29. 25walter , UK : stop tinkling onto the face of the public
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (03.18.06)
and say it rains........ You are just a supporter of terror attacks against Israel - at least stop lying and be honest about your support for those who are terrorists But that isn't producing nor helping peace - You are oblivious to REALITY and TRUTH Peaceful Al Yamoun ......... ???? Al Yamoun village (near Jenin), A PEACEFUL village in your mind only. There have been and still are - terrorist cell of Tanzim and Islamic Jihad from Yamoun village near Jenin. But then one doesn't know what YOU call peaceful ? Among other things, an explosives laboratory was exposed in Al Yamoun Village, which included the body of an improvised Qassam rocket. Very peaceful indeed ...???? There is proven high motivation and scope of the Hamas activity in Samaria to obtain operational capability to launch Qassam rockets into Israel.. right from there ... really peaceful indeed. An Underground Cave!! Intelligence establishment was shocked to learn of the exposure of a plant that manufactured Qassam rockets belonging to the Hamas movement in the village of Al Yamoun ...where there were rockets ready to be launched. Very peaceful indeed !!!!!!! The plant, which was in an underground cave in a blacksmith’s workshop, was attacked following a wave of arrests that included 15 movement activists from the village of Silat Al Hartiya. another eleven members of the terror network in the Silat Al Hartiya village in North Jenin were arrested. Another activist from Al Yamoun village was also arrested. Later, two additional members belonging to the network were arrested. The activities of the arrested men included, among other things, production of Qassam rockets and the establishment of an explosives laboratory. Gee .... very peaceful indeed How is in your idea a peaceful village supposed to be looking ??? Certainly not like this
30. Walter:Yep-very peaceful village-15year old Suicide Bomber
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (03.18.06)
The suicide bomber, a fifteen year old boy from Yamoun was arrested near Ramallah.......... Very peaceful people indeed: terrorist organization Islamic Jihad in The city Of Yamoun near The PA-controlled city Of Jenin Walter .are you a member of the ISM in the UK - it sounds like
Next talkbacks
Back to article