News
Survivors recount moments of horror
Ynet reporters
Published: 18.04.06, 16:36
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
57 Talkbacks for this article
31. #1: Bombing is justified because people like u exist!
Palestinian ,   Palestine   (04.18.06)
Do not forget that this Land is not Jewish after all. Most Jews are only recent immigrants to this land in the past 80 years or so. These Jews replaced Arab populations that used to live in Jaffa Haifa and so on... Arabs will not and will never concede these cities... This is part of their land and their heritage. Jews who lived in the holy Land before the start of Zionism were mostly Palestinian. They spoke Arabic and they were only different in faith. Jews were not the only exclusive population in Palestine. Most of this population is Arabic speaking for at least 2000 years! The original builders of Jerusalem and all the cities in the Holy Land are the Canaanite Arabs... You can never deny the Arabs their right in this land. Not now, not in the future. No one will give up his rights even cats and dogs. All will fight for his territory! In summary, you cannot live in peace in the house of somebody who still believes it is his, and as a matter of fact can cause you pain and has the backing of one billion additional Muslims, and one billion sympathizers from China to Latin America. To those with Jewish faith who arrived in the past 80 years to go from where they came. If we will use the Jewish mentality, then we should bring also all Christians to live in this place, not only Jews!! So get it straight. This logic does not work. This land is for those who have been cultivating it for thousands of years!
32. Tears from Heaven
Jill ,   Colorado ,USA   (04.18.06)
My heart breaks for your losses. This is so awful and ungodly. Take comfort knowing that G_d saves all your tears. Here in America we weep with you at the injustice. Blessing to you as you go on in their memory. Jill
33. #31
Ray ,   Texas, USA   (04.18.06)
Nice try! God gave the land to Israel and Joshua and the Army of Israel with God cleaned out all the vermon that were there. If you want Israel to move, you will have to pry it out of God's hand. Good luck!
34. I FEEL UR BAIN
ABO ARAB ,   EARTH   (04.18.06)
I FEEL ALL OF THOSE 9 PEOPLE BAIN, CUZ I LOST FRIENDS, FATHER AND A BROTHER THANKS TO IDF TANKS. 1 DEATH IS ALOT. FOR EACH ACTION THERE IS A RE-ACTION. BUILD UR WALL HIGHER AND LEAVE US ALONE.."POOR, STUPID, IGNORANT ARAB "....WE WILL BE A LOT HAPIER.
35. TSAV 8!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Danny ,   Tel Aviv   (04.18.06)
TSAV 8!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
36. act and response
child ,   jerusalem   (04.18.06)
evry father has a child and every child has a father is right every child has a father and every child became a father it is right evry act has a response and evry response became an act here is the right about the act and response of palastinian and israili all is terror or all is defence all are human has blood not water has children and fathers has mother s and memory sure iam sad
37. We do have families too
atmawi ,   Historic Palestine   (04.18.06)
Guess what? We are human beings too, we have families too, do you beleive that? We have thousands of such tragedic stories, it is just the sh*tt Camera did not capture the picture. NO JUSTICE, No Fairness. The first Victim story says that the guy after he promised his lovely two kids to buy them CDs, Our fathers died while they been trying to get us some bread you ...**
38. Tell Them Abo Arab #34
atmawi ,   Historic Palestine   (04.18.06)
Sharoon admits that it is an ugly occupation, Israelies who think Sharoon (The Murder) is their king have to leave the Land for the Native Palestinians. Let us starve, Please, go the Fu* out of our land, and we will harm no one, we will be so damn busy tring not to starve!!! Haaaa
39. To #38
Roni   (04.18.06)
It's nice to see "palestinian" savages making, albeit slow, a progress in educating themselves. You can now use a computer - good for you! As far as your request is concerned - don't worry, keep your barbaric behaviour up and we will gladly let you starve!
40. say NO to moral equivalence
howard ,   pacific coast, usa   (04.18.06)
The "heroic" Islamist terrorists have been planning this for months, so forget about it being some kind of revenge for recent events. They SPECIFICALLY targetted civilians, so forget it being somehow equivalent of Israel's attempts to stop the Qassam rockets (40 of which were fired at Israel last week alone). There is no moral equivalence. Israel withdrew from Gaza, and the Palestinian terror gangs have responded to this gesture by attacking Israeli civilians from Gaza. Given this behavior, why should anyone expect the terror gangs to do otherwise if Israel withdraws from the WB? They are not out for the 67 borders; they are out for the slaughter of the Jews. So why would they stop this homicidal nonsense in response to a further withdrawal? Answer -- they won't. Islamic Jihad never will. So further withdrawal would be, as much as it pains me to say this, a mistake. When will the Palestinians learn?
41. 31 Falke Palestinian: Stop telling LIES
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (04.18.06)
Now tell us when Palestine was a Sovereign State run by Arabs Who was the elected Leader the - and what currency did they use ? What was their economic growth and what was their backing for economic Growth Who were their representatives to other Governments ? What form of Government was it ? Now I await badly your answers to each single question Please answer fast
42. 38 atmawi: Start to educate yourself
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (04.18.06)
There has never been a State called Palestine Please assure you answer now. When was this State a sovereign State - run by Arabs What was their Governmental set up and it's leaders What was their currency - and it's exchange rate against major currencies If that State did exist, what was it's demise and why did it not survive Who was responsible for the demise Please bring historical figures to answer all the above with Proof Thanks in advance
43. Gabrielle Goldwater
human   (04.18.06)
You have to read the real history and educate youslf, then you will find the results. You have to depend on real history and not the history of zionism.
44. To #41 and #42 Gabrielle
Roni   (04.18.06)
Gabrielle, you are making a mistake in your responses to these so-called "palestinians". You try to present logical arguments to them, to reason with them, to appeal to facts - all these methods of discourse are perfectly fine when dealing with REASONABLE human beings. However, "palestinians" are certainly not reasonable and many of them can not be called "human beings" as well. They simply do not understand the language of logic - they only get you when you speak in terms familiar to them - such as "blood", "revenge", "death", "force", etc. My humble advice to you is to stop reasoning with them - you are wasting your time - and just call them on their bull#$it.
45. To #26 Linda, thank you for your post!
Roni   (04.18.06)
46. Empty rhetoric
Shy Guy ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (04.18.06)
We're waiting for our "real history" lesson. Don't stop. Tell us the truth.
47. 43 human: I can read- but you obvioulsy cannot How come
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (04.18.06)
you still don't know Real History - you are all brainwashed by leaders who lie to you This is what is in your schools: The following is the full version of the Special Information Bulletin dealing with textbooks in the Palestinian Authority; Download PDF file (781 KB) http://www.terrorism-info.org.il/malam_multimedia/English/eng_n/pdf/as_nm_e.pdf This shows the Hate and Lies you teach your children and you did learn After you read that link in detail answer my questions: There has never been a State called Palestine Please assure you answer now. In your teachings: When was this State a sovereign State - run by Arabs What was their Governmental set up and it's leaders What was their currency - and it's exchange rate against major currencies If that State did exist, what was it's demise and why did it not survive Who was responsible for the demise Please bring historical figures to answer all the above with Proof Thanks in advance
48. to#44
human   (04.18.06)
Who is stressing on force Roni. Who is learning about kill, revenge. You have read what the Israeli soldier write on his dress" I born to kill". Thanks
49. 48 human: Not so human idiot change your diapers you craped
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (04.18.06)
into them Has your mumy given you the run of the Internet today You sound like a kid - grow up before you get onto the Internet without any education
50. oh, poooooooooor Jews!!
Ahmad ,   nablus   (04.18.06)
only jews have wives, husbands, children...etc becuase they have red blood. by contrast, Palestinians whom been murdered by the IDF are all faceless monsters without any human connection, right guys...remembe, we the Palestinians are the decentants of Kanaan with blue blood and with 6 fingers!!! to hell
51. #37/38
rob ,   london   (04.18.06)
not to be rude, but sell your computer and cancel your subscription the internet, then maybe you'll have enough money to put 'bread' on your table, also your consideration for the Jewish religion is clearly low by mentioning bread during the festival of Pesach (Passover), I recommend Ebay to sell your computer on, in fact, seeing as it's a 'chag' (festival) i'll do a kind act and buy your computer for you, that way you can feed your family if they haven't already strapped on a belt and tried to make their way to Israel...As for the pictures not being captured, you talk a load of sh*t, because we all know the staged filming and photos that pour out of Gaza and Judaea and Samaria, showing palestinians being attacked...(not saying it doesn't happen, just there's a lot of fake footage that gets seen in the AP)....rant over!
52. #38
(04.18.06)
Arik Sharon is not our king. Our king is god. Arik Sharon was just a prime minister, not a very good one. In god we trust and not in Sharon. And we've been here long before you even knew how to read. Mohammed was a child molestor, and he's your holy prophet, we may be have prophets by they are not as holy as god and we don't idolize our prophets, we idloize what they did for god and what god told them to tell us. That's the difference between us and the rest of the religions. (We are not a war mongering religion, you are, and since we are not a weak religion/people as we were not united in the WW2 time. Now we can and will respond. Try your best but this time it won't go as smoothly I assure you that. Keep crying about your land. Without all the terrorists you wouldn't have had road blocks or any kind of problems. But your leaders prefer to see you starve. The earlier you see this the earlier you guys will have your freedom. Stop the hatred in your heard and listen to your brain for a change. In any case, if we die you die with us, if you prefer that, then so be it.
53. 50 Ahmad , nablus: Get off Jewish Land
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (04.18.06)
Shechem (Nablus) Nablus, known as the site of biblical Shechem. The area of Biblical Shechem can be found in Balata, which is in the eastern section of the city. Historically, Abraham traveled through Shechem on his way to Canaan and offered his first sacrifice to G-d. After the conquest of Canaan, Joshua assembled the Israelites here Inside the area known as Biblical Shechem are the remains of a defensive wall, a 3,600-year-old Hyksos temple and Joseph’s Tomb. The first reference to Shechem in Scripture occurs in Genesis 12:6-8. This passage records how Abram travelled southwards through Canaan until he reached the great tree of Moreh at Shechem in the centre of the land. There the Lord appeared to him and in response he build an altar and offered sacrifices to the Lord. The oak or terebinth of Moreh was to feature significantly later in the Old Testament, During an outbreak of violence in October 2000, Palestinian rioters destroyed Joseph’s Tomb and were reportedly building a mosque on the site to try once more to demolish anything from Jewish history.
54. 51 rob,london : make sure he removes viruses
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (04.18.06)
before you buy anything from the Louse
55. #50
(04.18.06)
To hell it is. It's not that you have 6 fingers or blue blood. It's your brain that got malfunctioned. It made you think like the genocidal monster you really are. We don't murder innocent palestinians, we try to kill the palestinian terror leaders and they hide in civilian areas. They think we won't hit them if they do because then your people will call us murderers. But they also think everyone has the same logic as them. That's where they are wrong, we are not stupid nor weak and we know how to handle terror, the problem is, the palestinians don't, and you suffer for your leaders choices. Maybe it's time you will take a stand against terrorism? once you do, the IDF will not need to kill your people. Now will it? why don't the IDF nuke iran? why don't we blow up jordan? why we don't kill all egyptians? BECAUSE THATS NOT OUR WAY, that is yours. We are not savages. I can tell you right now that the second there are no more terror organizations not only you will get your own country, you will get peace with us and will prosper because your money will go to the economy instead of to the martyrs. Now, tell me if I'm so brainwashed to believe it, or are you brainwashed to not believe it and keep terrorizing thinking it will get you to anywhere. Unlike hitler, you don't have the resources to kill all jews even if you wanted to. And hitler wouldn't have them either today if we were as strong then as we are today. So instead of blaming others for everything that happens (it's like blaming the raped person in being inmodest enough to being raped), you should look at yourselves, as people, and not as a terror organization and do what is for your best interest.
56. "Zichrono livracha."
Simon McIlwaine ,   London, UK   (04.19.06)
We at Anglicans for Israel extend our heartfelt condolences to the families of all those who were murdered in Tel Aviv, and our prayers to the injured. May the G-d of Israel grant them comfort and ease their pain To those like "Ahmad" who gloat at this suffering-shame on you!
57. Tragedy Upon Tragedy
Kelli ,   Newport News, USA   (04.19.06)
It truly breaks my heart that this is happening to a land blessed by G-d, to a people blessed by G-d. Your people are my people, your G-d is my G-d. The land is Israel, given to the Jews by G-d. As more land is given to the Palestinian Arabs, they will demand more, more innocent blood will be shed. It's not my place to judge others. I will say, however, that these suicide bombers are paying for their atrocious deeds right now, that's a fact. If you go against Israel, G-d will punish you. My heart sincerely goes out to the families and loved ones of these victims. I only wish I were with them to comfort them. Shema Israel, Adonai Eloheynu, Adonai echad. Baruch shem k'vod, malchuto, l'olam vaed. Hear Israel, the Lord your G-d is One.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article