News
Hamas' Haniyeh has 3 Israeli sisters
Tzvi Aloush
Published: 24.04.06, 10:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
24 Talkbacks for this article
1. Israel vs. West Bank/Gaza
Josh ,   Jerusalem   (04.24.06)
Of course none of Haniyeh's family wants to move to the disputed territories. What idiot in their right mind would want to move from a free, prosperous and democratic country to a repressed, devastated and murderous country? The fact is that not one Israeli Arab would be willing to give up the good life in Israel to move in with the Palestinians. This simply proves that Israel treats all its citizens fairly because it is a true democracy. On the other hand, there are no Jewish Palestinians in the disputed territories because, well, they would be dead by now anyway.
2. please send them to him
(04.24.06)
terrorist's families don't belong here.
3. haniya sisters
(04.24.06)
i don't believe it, can you prove it?
4. Who really cares? Report something worthy.
Jeremiah ,   Israel   (04.24.06)
5. Those sisters know where their bread is buttered
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (04.24.06)
may be they have a more normal brain ?
6. Hitler too was democratically elected
Jean ,   Brussels, Belgium   (04.24.06)
The victory of Hamas shows only who are the neighbours of Israel. If israeli citizens are proud of the election of Hananyeh-Hitler, may be that their place is NOT in Israel
7. GGGGG only thinks of materials.
(04.24.06)
You think that it only matters where your bread is buttered? no principles, no values, no spirituality. You are ....... forget it.
8. Haniyeh and his sisters
Yarden ,   Neve Daniel   (04.24.06)
Sounds like an awful Woody Allen Movie
9. haniyeh`s family
keren ,   sao paulo   (04.24.06)
"Two of them have a lot of children, and all – I have to say – are successful. Some of them are successful businessmen, others are successful in education..." All´s above in Israel...hmmm I guess haniyeh should be advised that the next atack carried in Israel ,and proved to be on his orders,his family will go to ramalah ,or where ever,to meet him and build their good lives out of Israel. Is it correct to shelter these people in Israel whereas their so near relative preaches for Israel´s end? I wonder...
10. Makes you wonder
Arie   (04.24.06)
They are all successful, enjoying the benefits of a free and democratic Israeli society. Just imagine if they were living under the rule of hamass: their money would be gone and their daughters would be virgins in search of a terrorist. I understand clearly why they stay where they are!
11. Keren Keren Keren...
Ramzi Sfeir ,   Bethlehem, Palestine   (04.24.06)
Keren, you are sounding ridiculous! Do you know that most of the ultra-religious israelis don't believe in israel? don't you want to send them out of israel ? well....if one day you think of this possibility, think about sending them to ramallah, we will give them the best treatment ever, because our society is not based on race or religion, unlike yours! Every PALESTINIAN no matter what language he speaks, what religion he follows, what color his skin is etc...has the same rights! Its a fact that you ignore! and i have reasons to believe that you are far far away from being the only one!!!! I suggest that you learn more about us!
12. I have a few points to make
Chaya ,   Bat Yam   (04.24.06)
1. Ramzi: If your society is so 'equal,' then why are Christians being persecuted and leaving in droves. Hamas wants the YMCA out of Kalkilya! It wants ALL non-Muslims out! We, on the other hand, accept all into the Jewish people no matter what they look like. 2. In spite of the problems the Bedouins have here (as do other Arabs), they still know that they are better off here. Here, the women don't have to go around dressed covered from head to foot. 3. Arabs with Israeli citizenship can't be 'Israelis' much the same way that I could get citizenship from China; but that wouldn't make me Chinese!
13. #11
(04.24.06)
And every Israeli on palestinian territory gets killed. Happend before. Plenty of times. Stop being so full of it. You are nothing of a tolerant society.
14. 11Ramzi Sfeir,Bethlehem: a question If you all have the
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (04.24.06)
same rights ??? - why then do you have anarchy - people kidnapping each other - lynching each other - doing honor killings since obviously they don't have same rights different religions - what about Jews - since when they move you murder them if they are close by What about the Christians that get molested - murdered etc... by you people just for being Christians Why do you also kidnap Foreigners and try to burn down Foreign missions ? Gee you want me to carry on ? I think you best answer the above first Now get back with proper answers OK
15. Arabs kill the Jews!
#11 Arab kill kids ,   Arabs kill women   (04.24.06)
There is one industry where Arabs excel the most - murdering the innocent civilians.
16. Haniyeh's sisters
Moussa SUWWAN ,   Paris/France   (04.24.06)
I read with amusement all the commentaries on this piece of information. Give me one saying from your Torah that incites people to punish some one for the deeds of an other persone I do believe that the main reasons for violence in our region are the occupation, the daily humiliations and vexation of Palestinians. The truth is as simple as this: as long as there is no comprehensive and just peace between Arabs and Israelis, bloodshed will continue for long time. Quel dommage!!!!!!
17. oh ... # 11, I know you very well !
keren ,   sao paulo   (04.24.06)
I have Jews friends who were expeled by your "race" from Egipt,once( 1956?),and lost ALL their properties and goods ,because they had to leave the country in on week;I have friends who were expeled by your "race" from Tunisia,once,in the same situation of those above exemplified;I have friends who were expeled by your "race" from Argelia... Yes,you are right,I have to learn more about you ,in order to keep on the list of exemples on how you treat others different from you and even others like your self. About Israel,only a liar like you can say the same. Ask anyone,Jew or not ,how do they live in Israel.Even the family of a thug live there,as you can see in this article , and Israel leave them to live in peace. But ,listen you,I wish these days are gone,and Israel will get rid of all their cynics and suckers enemies for once and for ever. You can be sure,soon you all will be far from there and we will live as we deserve: betwen friends,ONLY!
18. Moussa is telling Fairy Tales
Chaya ,   Bat Yam   (04.24.06)
read with amusement all the commentaries on this piece of information. Give me one saying from your Torah that incites people to punish some one for the deeds of an other persone I do believe that the main reasons for violence in our region are the occupation, the daily humiliations and vexation of Palestinians. The truth is as simple as this: as long as there is no comprehensive and just peace between Arabs and Israelis, bloodshed will continue for long time. Quel dommage!!!!!! Moussa ======================= Moussa: You couldn't be more wrong! The Arabs in Gaza had an incredible opportunity - to take the areas that Israel left and do something with it. What did they do? They are launching rockets from there instead of planting food and building homes! That is insanity! And the hothouses that were left - built by Israelis - were destroyed!! So, please, keep your fairy tales to yourself. The pals have nobody to blame but themselves for their misery!
19. To Chaya, Bat Yam
Moussa Suwwan ,   Paris/France   (04.24.06)
Iam not telling fairy tails, as a matter of fact i do agree on some of what you wrote, but i still believe that givin a real chance in a peaceful envirnoment, the Palestinians will do better, and construct their lives in a different way. Don't push them to become the hostages of fundumintalism, it is a very dangerous situation which will lead for more bloodshed. leila tove....
20. ARAB BLOOD IS STRONG!
SAMUEL BLAIR ,   BOCA RATON USA   (04.24.06)
ANOTHER FIFTH COLUMN INSIDE ISRAEL. HOPEFULLY THEY ARE BEING MONITORED. EVERY EMAIL EVERY CALL. MURDER IS OK IF IT IS JEWS BEING MURDERED! ABU-RAKIK IS A PROSPECT AND ALSO SHOULD BE MONITORED. STUPIDITY MUST BE WATCHED!
21. well I HAVE A FEW ANSWERS...
Ramzi Sfeir ,   Bethlehem, Palestine   (04.25.06)
First of all, to all of you who talked about my religion, you are wrong! I am not a muslim, i am a christian Palestinian! aha...to your surprise , i'm Christian! But who cares? i'm PALESTINIAN as far as you are concerned! i have never been persecuted by my fellow palestinians! NEVER , not me, not my friends, not my family! Never! The christians who leave , run away from israel not from muslims, and those who claim muslims are the problem are better outside of palestine! We don't need racists! This myth about us being persecuted is a big big invention of israel! Its your young soldiers who create this hate between brother and brother! When a christian comes near a checkpoint, he gets a better treatment than a muslim! This is not racist? This is just 0,0000001 Percent of the discrimination we face everyday by the israeli occupation! I am PALESTINIAN , we are PALESTINIANS before being anything else! And if this is not clear, let it be clear now! I personally started breathing tear gas since i got 3 years old! Yes, in the first intifada! I had my first encounter with an occupation soldier when i got 5! and now i'm way much older and i still face the same discrimination, i've seen my grandfather ( Refugee from jerusalem) FORCED (under the threat of Guns) to clean graffitis on a wall in bethlehem, my grandfather who is 95 now ! i've seen my father getting humiliated by your soldiers! I've seen my mother getting yelled at, i've seen my friend getting killed just because he passed next to a window and an israeli snipper shot him in the neck, TWICE! I've seen the hate in the eyes of israeli soldiers! I got the special treatment we get each time we meet one of your soldiers! I had to cue for more than 10 hours in order to get a 2 hours permit to enter jerusalem for very important papers! I got questionned by israeli intelligence because i was going back home from a trip outside the country! I was forced to watch a WALL getting built around me! I even got the chance to see a gun between my eyes, just because the soldier wasn't sure i had a permit! I GOT INSULTED many times! ....no matter what my religion is, this makes me the Palestinian person i am today! Being a Palestinian is not only a nationality, it's a state of mind! Whether you accept it or not,we exist, we have rights! HUMAN RIGHTS! I accepted the fact that my grandfather's house in the middle of jerusalem is LOST ! I dont want it anymore! but i cant accept to loose my dignity! You can build walls, checkpoints, etc...but you will never be able to take away my freedom for my freedom is inside my head! I CALL ON EVERY HUMAN BEING TO LISTEN TO THIS CALL : WE WANT OUR RIGHT TO EXIST, TO LIVE DECENT LIVES , TO BE FREE.....we are VICTIMS! For the person who said that we murder israelis each time they approach us : I CAN GIVE YOU NAMES OF ISRAELIS WHO VISITED ME and who are still alive! I never killed anyone and i dont have any intentions to kill!....But if an israeli approaches me as an occupier, as a settler, steals my land, kills my family and burns my trees, i hold the right to defend myself, thats how life is! In everyone of you there is a Palestinian! no matter who you are, in every one of you there is someone fighting for liberties, for freedom, for dignity , for life! In every one of you there is someone wanting to exist, wanting to count! Thats the palestinian in me! And i'm sure that the Palestinian in you says the same thing! You can fight and maybe exterminate the palestinian nationality! BUT THE PALESTINIAN DREAM The palestinian state of mind is unbeatable! And i am PROUD TO HAVE IT! Thats probably why i wake up every morning! Thank you
22. # 21
keren ,   sao paulo   (04.25.06)
You have already a state:Jordan! Fight for that,and fight to behave decently in order to be accepted by YOUR state . Why do you stick in Israel?because it is better ,of course! Put shame on your face and leave ,you cynic suckers ones!
23. Keren...dear Keren
Ramzi Sfeir ,   Bethlehem, Palestine   (04.25.06)
Your last post shows really what kind of mentality you have, First of all, remember to have some respect for yourself! I was born here, my dad was born here, my grandfather was born here and my great grandfather was born here. i will never leave! and who ever said that i was living in israel? I live in Palestine! By the way, i was wondering...how old are you? 15 ? GROW UP! We were here, we are here and WE ARE STAYING FOREVER AND EVER AMEN....and you will be judged one day for the racist atrocities you mention in your posts! Then you talk about shame...Shame on you.....By the way, Jordan was never and will never be my state! No matter what lieberman and your likes believe!!!!LIVE WITH IT! and GET REAL......Palestine FOREVER!
24. and Keren...
Ramzi Sfeir ,   Bethlehem, Palestine   (04.25.06)
Hitler had the same arguments as you! He wanted to " Clean" the german society and live between FRENDS! Don't you feel sick now? For god's sake! Someone with some sanity has to say something! STOP HER! those who don't talk against her arguments will one day be guilty for the atrocities such people can cause! WAKE UP PEOPLE! i'm talking to you JEWS! you cant allow anyone of this mentality to talk in your name! her attitude has nothing to do with being Pro israel! IT is simply being extremly RACIST! I suggest that she comes to live in the region for 3 days only! 3 DAYS! maybe she will have a better knowledge of what is happening over here! does she know how to locate israel on a map ? does she know how to locate the Palestinian territories???? I Really doubt it!
Back to article