News
Report: Israel responsible for PA collapse
Ali Waked
Published: 09.05.06, 15:24
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
80 Talkbacks for this article
31. Medication for ill people
Moussa Suwwan ,   Paris/France   (05.09.06)
As a former Anaesthetist I feel shocked and scandalized while reading such information. Not under any circumstances you can refuse medication for ill people. Your country is liable for the palestinians, as long as you are occupying them, and puting Gza under seige. Those who wrote lot of bad stuff to comment on this piece of information must be introduced into tribunal for their shameful writing. And after such deeds you have the courage to pretend that you are a democratic state. read again your Torah and the Old Testament. Shame
32. The jooooos dunnit
JT ,   Central Area   (05.09.06)
In detective novels, it's the butler what's done it - in NGO / charity reports, it's dem joos.
33. Physicians for Human Rights
Sandra ,   Israel   (05.09.06)
Organizations like the above named, make my blood boil. How dare they come out with such outrageous remarks. These Arabs want to destroy my country, and then complain to all and sundry about the mess they've created themselves. We won't deal with a bunch of criminal terrorists.
34. Moussa from Paris...
DR ,   Florida, USA   (05.09.06)
First off, Israel is not longer in the Palestinian terriories, right? Second, Palestinians knew full well that if they voted fo Hamas, they would get this reactino not only from Israel, but from france, The US, UK, etc. Third, the Hamas gov't and other Palestinian leaders have money to fund terror and buy weapons, but can't feed thier people, yet you see nothing worng with this?..hmmmm???
35. # 31 moussa
keren ,   sao paulo   (05.09.06)
Shame is to have people on your door every moment trying to kill you.This is shame!Tell YOUR people! And put in your head that Israel is not occupying them but instead they are occupying Israel. And ,why don't they provide their own care.Can you answer it to me?
36. To Moussa Suwwan
The Truth   (05.09.06)
No you are wrong. The Pa;estinians are responsible for themselves. Israel owes them nothing. Repeat, NOTHING. They are not occupied. There is not one Jew left in Gaza. The border with Eqypt is open. After all the terrorism and threats of annialation, we owe them sh*t.
37. To 31
Shai ,   Israel   (05.09.06)
The Palestinians refuse to be unoccupied. The Jordanians refuse to take back the West Bank. The Egyptians refuse to take back Gaza. Unilaterally withdrawing is considered "an act of war" by the PA. Get it? So before you give us lessons in ethics, Moussa Suwwan, maybe you can provide your brethren with some good counsel on how to take the billions in aid Palestinians have received to build hospitals and educate doctors rather than throw every problem on Israel? Can't you see how the problem the Palestinians are experiencing is DIRECTLY caused by none other than themselves?
38. What the tiny stupid organisation is IRRELEVANT
(05.09.06)
39. resistance??
elias abdallah ,   durham, united state   (05.09.06)
the usage of the word resistance falls under heavy scrutiny when discussing the occupation...please note that when a group is being opressed, the only way out of opression is through resistance....
40. your country???
elias ,   USA   (05.09.06)
your country????i'd like to to remind you ma'am that your country constructed on a stolen land, murdered people, and shattered identitie........"I come from there. i return the sky to its mother, when for its mother the sky cries, and i weep for a returning cloud to know me..."Mahmoud Darwish
41.  Israel is not to be blamed,at all !
Richard Shanks ,   Canada   (05.09.06)
FYI Karen, Isael is a basket case unable to support itself even today! It has received more than 70 billion dollars from the US alone in the last 30 yrs. and would not exsist at all without this support from ignorant Americans. The US should have supported the palistinians equally.
42.  Fault lies 100% in Palestinians. You reap what you sow.
Richard ,   Vancouver, Canada   (05.09.06)
By God I think youve got it David!! Now you know what 9/11 was all about and you've foiled Bin Ladin's master plan, good for you!
43. Physicians For Human Rights Or For Anti-Semitism?
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.09.06)
Physicians For Human Rights Or For Anti-Semitism? Jewish Newspaper Syndicate, November 15, 2002. Gerald M. Steinberg. The flood of anti-Israel propaganda http://faculty.biu.ac.il/~steing/conflict/oped/physiciansforhumanrights.htm NGOs and the Anti-Israel Agenda Similarly, central to Human Rights Watch's Middle East policies are four individuals with a strong anti-Israeli ideological agenda. ... http://www.aish.com/jewishissues/middleeast/NGOs_and_the_Anti-Israel_Agenda.asp
44. 31 Moussa Suwwan: get reality and facts about Israel's
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.09.06)
help in medical for ANYONE - before you comment on a report from an NGO - who is known to be anti Israel and anti Jews Now do you know how many Palis get medical treatement from Israel ? You don't know - Do you know how many of them tried to blow up hospitals and medical centers in Israel - You don't know How many Jews got medical assistance by Arabs - they got lynched instead
45. #31 Hardly. Hamas is spending on weapons, not medicine
Howard ,   Pacific Coast, USA   (05.09.06)
It is hardly under siege. Your buddies in Hamas just choose to buy grad rockets and smuggle bombs into Gaza and then shoot rockets at the power plant that sends them electricity instead of buying medicine, bringing dialysis equipment into Gaza and attacking disease. How is that Israel's fault, exactly?
46. THEY PREFER TO BUY WEAPONS WITH THEIR MONEY
Chaya ,   Bat Yam   (05.09.06)
47. elias; This is my country so get out!
Daisy ,   USA   (05.09.06)
As someone who has American Indian ancestory I have every right to tell you as an Arab occupier to go back home!
48. # 35 Keren
Richard ,   Vancouver, Canada   (05.09.06)
Yes Keren I can answer, the problem is are you willing to listen and at least try to educate yourself about this subject?
49. 31 Moussa Suwwan:France gives out free treatement and goes
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (05.09.06)
Bankrupt in their welfare system - so stop complaining. Do you pay taxes in Israel - to demand medication for all ? NO - do you actually pay taxes in France or are you as most of your type running on that welfare check Israel has and always treated Arabs - but that NO one mentions
50. To 40 - yada yada yada
Shai ,   Israel   (05.09.06)
Listen, Elias. The turd may be on our plate, but I don't think you can make an argument that we aren't trying to give it back. The Palestinians no a good deal when they see it. Refuse 97% of what you want, plus 32 billion dollars, and go on an on and on while the rest of the world bankrolls your protection racket. The rest is commentary, pal. Don't give me your bullshit about stolen land, murdered people, or your poetry. It's all a bunch of self-serving self-righteous tendentious bullshit served up to make you feel like a victim when, living in the US of A, you clearly are not. And yes, as it turns out, your "bullshit" ends up being the turd on OUR plate.
51. Go ahead , Richard # 48
keren ,   sao paulo   (05.09.06)
52. To 39
Shai ,   Israel   (05.09.06)
The alternative to resistence to achieve one's goals is negotiations. Duh.
53. I mean,go ahead with your point of view,Richard 48
keren ,   sao paulo   (05.09.06)
It is never bad to listen others opinions;who knows you bring out something new.
54. Richard # 41
keren ,   sao paulo   (05.09.06)
I have just given you space to speak to me ,but I had not read this comment of yours by then. Hence,I conclude it is better for you not to go ahead at all,because you seem a very ignorant individual. I like to listen only intelligent people. Let me just tell you something:Israel is a superpotence.It has more engeneers ,physitians,etc,than Japan,than US,than any scandinavian country,etc,proportionally speaking;it is technologicaly ahead of ANYcountry in this world,in ALL fields that require human intelligency. So,please...keep quiet.
55. To #41 Richard
The Truth   (05.09.06)
FYI Richard, Israel has to spend all the aid money they receive back in America thus supporting American industry. Plus Israel gives back medical technology, weapons technology, intelligence information, a base to operate in the mid-east, etc, etc. What do the palestinians give back? Terror Please get educated on the subject before you lecture anyone here.
56. Just give the Pals the A Bomb
Had Enough ,   Dallas, USA   (05.09.06)
Preferably with a fuse set to go off as soon as they try to dismantle it. Better yet, send it airborne express at the end of multiple independant re-entry vehicle rockets. Let them shove their katyushas where the sun don't shine.
57. Moussa #31
Mohammad ,   Paris, France   (05.09.06)
You are so full of it! If you are a medical professional why not go to Palestine and help those "poor" people. Oh, I forgot, you are probably too busy burning cars and living off the French. As a Muslim, your comments are offensive and show a lack of character.
58. huh?
lucas ,   Florida, US   (05.09.06)
with everything in the news since Hamas took over, how can you say that Palestinians are autonomous, responsible for their own well being, and their current accute problems aren't caused by israel? Israel has cut off the transfer of tax money that they collect and is rightfully the Palestinians, The US has shut down the international banking system from transfering any money inside the territories. Without money, Palestinians can't get food, water or medical supplies. So until money is allowed to flow back into the OCCUPIED territories, whatever's happening inside them is the responsibility of Israel and the US
59. To #13
Muhammad-Ali ,   Montreal   (05.09.06)
18/04/1996 An Israeli pilot accidently push the fire button and atly hit UNIFIL ce and killed 107 civilians. Who will believe this story.
60. To 41 - Bwah ha ha hahhhh
Shai ,   Israel   (05.09.06)
Listen, shmuck, you have a long way to go before you can accuse anybody else of being "ignorant". The US blows $70 billion in how many days in Iraq, and you want to go back 30 years? Ever consider that at least 2/3 of that was spent in the US as subsidies for American military manufacturers? Ever consider how much the US spent on others in the NATO alliance? Look it up. By any measure, Israel was a bargain, so much so that the golden cage the US government gives us every year gives the average American citizen more say in what my government does than I do. But put that aside - the shekel is strengthening against the US dollar, we are getting world class investors and manufacturers here, and all this goes to prove that the US was RIGHT in not supporting the Palestinians equally, because a small investment with us gets results, while a large investment in Palestinians, or Iraq for that matter, offers only headaches in return. You've clearly got an agenda other than offering information to Karen, Richard, and it isn't to distribute truth - that's clear from your post.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article