News
Israel to transfer arms to Abbas' forces
Ali Waked
Published: 25.05.06, 21:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
62 Talkbacks for this article
1. Insane
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (05.25.06)
"Israel to transfer arms to Abbas' forces" Is Peretz insane? Rabin gave the Arabs guns, too. I feel very ill right now.
2. PA Arms
Neal Rothner ,   Hashmonaim, Israel   (05.25.06)
What! We are giving them guns again! Our Defence Minister is working for the wrong side.
3. TREASON!!!
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (05.25.06)
4. Peretz/Olmert Jewish Blood Is On Your Hands
(05.25.06)
5. With such leaders... allah yustur!
Caligula's Horse ,   Solomon's stables   (05.25.06)
Dont they ever learn from mistakes?
6. Unless Abbas/Fatah Will Exterminate Hamas/Jihad etc
(05.25.06)
thats why there will never be peace, just look at Sadat, he gained back the entire Sinai, and they still killed him. Abbas' days are coming to an end
7. PA =HAMAS=DJIAD ISLAMI = TERRORISTS !
(05.25.06)
8. MADNESS!
Nachash Tsefah ,   Tel Aviv   (05.25.06)
The Jews are meant to be intelligent, thoughtful people. Why then are we repeatedly so stupid as to provide weapons to our arch-enemies? It doesn't matter which side or faction we arm - they all want to kill us, and will put aside their differences in order to do so. Recall the slogan from the mid-1990s when some people could see what was going to happen with this Oslo disaster: "AL TITNU LAHEM ROVIM!" DON'T GIVE THEM GUNS! SIMPLE!
9. Ok So Long As The IDF Gives Them Squirt Guns
Seth ,   Washington, DC   (05.25.06)
10. I hope there was not a deal Made
Sam Weinstein ,   USA   (05.25.06)
I hope that the PM did not make a deal about the 67 Borders with Abbas. That will lead to disaster possibly Civil War on the Israeli side.
11. PERETZ AND PEREZ THE SHAMES OF ISRAEL
(05.25.06)
12. Back your pardon, DM Amir Peretz, but you must be crazy!
Gerd ,   Germany   (05.25.06)
13. GUILTY of PROVIDING Weapons to MURDER JEWS!
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (05.25.06)
THERE IS NO WAR ON TERROR! The war is against Jews and all other innocents! For many years, American and European tax dollars financed the war against the Jews. The military wing of Palestinian Authority Abbas's Fatah party, the Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, is responsible for massive terrorist atrocities against Jewish innocents.
14. Did I read correctly????
keren ,   sao paulo   (05.25.06)
Israel( Defense Minister) to give arms to Palestinians????? This is a nightmare! Will Israel(is) let these mental discontroled governors keep in their mad way? Is there anybody,at least among this site readers, that see a spark of sanity on this all? Submit pals to a refendum based on a prisioner proposal??? 67 borders??? Does Israel accept such a thing? What's going on??? Is somebody understanding?
15. Peace NOW at the Defense ministry
Sasson ,   Ramat Gan   (05.25.06)
What can you expect from a defense minister which was not so long time ago an active Peace Now militant ?? Prepare yourselves, this is just the beginning!
16. Olmert is a fool.
The White Shadow   (05.25.06)
Those of you who allowed this betrayer of the children of Yisrael to come to power should look upon themselves with shame. Those who desire final sovereignty for Yisrael and protection from their enemies should take all necessary and legal action to unseat this fool and establish a leader who will know and protect the true borders of the nation and this nation's true people. How much more of your land, your sovereignty and your lives will be lost while these decisions are being made? What have you to fear? You have one of the most proficient military forces on Earth. You can enforce your right to exist, which no terrorist or madman can remove, for He who is above all has given it. You can enforce your borders, because of He who gave the land to your fathers and to you. Take your soldiers away from the shameful tasks of evicting the children of Yisrael from their own land, and put them to use in defending what is rightfully yours from these fanatic, blind, so-called 'Palestinians', who would hide behind their own women and children to avoid attack. Or will you simply wait for the nation of Yisrael to occupy only a tract one square kilometer in size before you awaken?
17. Weapons for Abbas
Ellen Prescott ,   Southsea, Hampshire   (05.25.06)
Stop worrying already. Abbas is a great humanitarian who has dedicated his entire life and sacrificed the lives of countless palestinian children for the palestinian cause. He deserves weapons. And he is a very accountable and responsible man. You can trust him with money from america or europe, weapons, creating jobs, stopping terrorism, keeping a good standard of living in palestinian jails....lets face it, he is my hero. So please give him weapons, after all, the palestinians have a right to defend themselves....its the jews that don't have that right.
18. wake up to the real world..
jb ,   france   (05.25.06)
They are talking small arms here, to protect someone who is trying to achieve some sort of compromise not canons. How come a nation with atomic weapons is so scared of a few fanatics with pistols?
19. ISRAEL Use their PRISON for HAMAS RALLY for JIHAD
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (05.25.06)
Israel's leaders continue to demonstrate their sympathies are not with Jewish victims. Their sympathies are with Islamic terrorist killers. Israel gave the use of an Israeli prison to promote jihad against Israel's Jewish innocents. For some unknown and terrible reason, Israel's leaders continue to give every indication that they want Israel's barbaric enemies to win. www.jerusalempost.com May. 18, 2006 14:19 | Updated May. 20, 2006 16:20 Another Tack: Lifers here and there By SARAH HONIG ...Israeli prisons are indeed unique. Not only do the most dangerous terrorists therein get hold of phones, but recently Hamas overtly conducted a mass rally in a southern Israeli maximum-security penitentiary, where scores of convicts congregated in the courtyard, which they festooned with Hamas Islamic-green banners and Palestinian flags. A stage and speakers' rostrum were erected. The backdrop decor was a giant collage, displaying the Hamas emblem, portraits of Hamas leaders, slogans calling for Jihad against Israel and pictures of RPGs underscored by the motto "we'll continue." White plastic chairs were neatly arranged for the "audience," who cheered the invective hurled at the Zionist state and freely photographed the occasion - all under the disinterested eyes of passive Israeli wardens. The snapshots are available for viewing on the Web. Terrorist lifers in Israel don't expect to end their existence in captivity...
20. What? Is This Right?
emanon ,   USA   (05.25.06)
Where does Olmert think those arms will end up and what does he think they will be used for? If Abbas is lacking security, that's his problem, not Israel's.
21. MY GOD, DON'T GIVE THE MURDERERS MORE WEAPONS!!!
COMMITTEE TO TRY ,   OLMERT AND PERETZ   (05.25.06)
22. If only one Israeli is killed by this
jason white ,   afula,israel   (05.25.06)
then these mental cases in the govt.should be charged with murder! Look at how other nations are willing to donate guns to terrorists. I like the way they will arm the terrorist bodyguards of ab-ass and we in the Israeli Civil Guard are equipt with WWII m-1s. What kind of sick creatures are running this regime? Maybe they could give them a couple of squadrons of F-15s.We do not use them much.Some tanks,artillery and missiles?They will make better use of them then we do.No shelling of empty fields. From the day they signed the oslo death sentence and we sat silently. We should have risen up as one and threw the dogs out.They are killing us and we let them.I hope all the fools that voted for the regime will wake up and see their error. I will only vote for a political party that will have two platforms.One,punishing all the traitors in govt.and out.Two,the destruction of any palis state.
23. We Jews are very sick people & the world thinks we're smart.
Jeremiah ,   Israel   (05.26.06)
We get what we deserve. I'm surprized Olmert isn't giving the arabs nuclear technology.
24. There are more Likudniks on Ynet than in Israel
Franck   (05.26.06)
25. #23 One that gives up our Holy Land Is Not A Jew
(05.26.06)
But a Erev Rav, who has no true connections with the Torah. Being born Jewish is one thing its another to actually follow the laws.
26. ReJeCt IDF instead for Syria, Iran or Jordan supplies?
Ricot ,   Cambridge   (05.26.06)
I am disappointed in the reaction of the Diaspora and people living in Israel proper to this news report. I'm affected not so much by the negativity per se, but more so because most folk see this as something out of the ordinary and calamitous behavior. I find this condemnation very similar to the negative reaction that U.S. Pres. Bush receives in the US and elsewhere for carrying foreign policies that have been steady in scope, if not methodology, across both US political parties for the past 110 years. The tragic mistake here may indeed, have been disclosure and nothing more. Albeit, readers will frame issues and assign preferential valuation based on reflexive instincts-The reception dilemma of the good news bad news dichotomy. A little juicy but immaterial gossip though, never got anyone thrown out of a good dinner party, eh! These men and women in the Israeli government are doing their best and have a long record of service to the state of Israel; many have literally, put their lives in harm's way for its security and benefit. How dare you condemn them from the trenches of your keyboard? This is even more alarming, because people are "shooting from the hip" and not weighing options. Is it not obvious that Abbas is supported as a countervailing source of moderation to Hamas? Moreover, would you rather Iran, Syria or Jordan be exclusive suppliers of arms for the Palestinians or even worse, Al Qu'aeda? I think not, the absurdity of the later suggestion and the saliency of the former speak for themselves. Of course some of you will recount that the "IDF" once armed Hamas to balance the PLO only to have those arms turned on Israel. Albeit, this point is well taken nevertheless, it is simplistic in that it fails to consider the efficacy of that policy (Hamas) and take into account that the current Israeli administration must address social Palestinian currencies in the security context and use conducive means to ensure the safety of the people of Israel. Furthermore, arming Hamas had a direct effect on the demise fo the PLO. I contend that it is better to have an enemy that puts its cards on the table than one that hides cards under his sleeves. The myriad of contingencies in such a precarious world as ours are not always either or, if they were so, bread would be both free and vegan. The irony here is again, through the intellect, cunning and sacrifices of such men and women, the people of Israel are able to come on this forum and criticize these exact leaders vehemently. In all fairness, please consider that these elected officials have given their entire lives' work for the liberation and betterment of Israel. Such is life, what can one do? Darned if you do and danged if you don't!
27. He would be safer in an Israeli jail than among his friends!
Bunnie Meyer ,   Santa Monica, CA   (05.26.06)
28. Geez Israel why don't you give the Arabs bombs too!
Daisy ,   USA   (05.26.06)
Does Israel want to be wiped out sooner rahter than later? Hitler is in hell laughing.
29. WTF?!?!? Fatah already has PLENTY of weapons!!!
howard ,   pacific coast, usa   (05.26.06)
Let FATAH take some of the weapons away from the lunatics they have attacking Israelis and use those weapons to supply the force that protects Fatah's leader. Fatah has plenty of weapons. It is not Abbas that I am worried about. Abbas is completely passive. But Gaza/WB are awash in guns, and adding any guns to that mess will not protect him any better than he is now. It will just add more guns that will be used against Israelis the 1st time he fails to restrain a lunaticsamong his own people. NOTE: I am far from a Likudnik Franck; if you read anything I write, you know this. Most people posting here are not Likudniks either, or sympathetic to halikud.
30. Arms to Abbas
clarence mance ,   Dublin   (05.26.06)
Absolute insanity. They will both turn weapons on the sate of Israel.
Next talkbacks
Back to article