News
Who are you, Jamal Abu Samhadana?
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 09.06.06, 09:43
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
45 Talkbacks for this article
31. #19..Brod
lynne   (06.09.06)
someone who fights occuppiers is not a terrorist .. but one who occupies is the terrorist .. If you think that the endless assassinations carried out by US and Israel will stop "terrorism" then you're very mistaken .. they only build up more and more hatered towards them ..
32. #28 Ahmad
Allan ,   Florida   (06.09.06)
Ahmad, time you got this straight. The Palestinians were NEVER a sovreign nation. You were never recognized by the world body as an independent country. You were always either a part of Egypt or a part of Jordan. The land of Israel is the ancestral land of the Jewish people going back to the days of our mutual patrirach, Abraham (Ibrahim, to you). Even your Koran admits to that. So, do us all a big favor and quit your whining. Your people had several chances to have an independent nation, most recently 6 years ago. But predictably, you chose the path of war. There's an old adage: The way you make your bed, that how you lie in it. You made your bed now lie in it and leave us alone.
33. #31 Lynne
Brod ,   USA   (06.09.06)
Who are the occupiers? The historic and biblical homeland of the Jewish people is the Land of Israel that GOD gave them through their forefathers-Abraham, Isaac and Jacob 4000 years ago. Over the millenia, the Jewish people have shed their blood defending their historic and biblical homeland. The Arab Islamist-Jihadists squatting on the historic and biblical land of Israel came from Southeastern Arabia in 700 A.D. In fact, the Arabs have vast swath of land stretching from Yemen all the way to Morocco. They have ample space to accommodate their fellow Arab people squatting in the historic and biblical land of Israel. Just as Spain and Eastern Europe had done in the Medieval when they defended and regained their historic homeland from the Arab Islamist occupiers, Israel has the right to defend and regain their historic and biblical homeland from the Arab Islamist squatters and occupiers.
34. keep up the good work IAF
emd ,   ny, ny USA   (06.09.06)
congrats to the IAF. keep up the good work.
35. No choice.
Joe ,   Atlanta, GA   (06.10.06)
Until the followers of islam recognize the rights of all people to worship as their beliefs tell them what else can the civilized world do?
36. IDF...keep at it. One at a time. Kill them all!
Sabientje ,   Weston, USA   (06.10.06)
37. #33 Brod..
lynne   (06.10.06)
ok .. so it looks like you want to go back thousands of years.. although I never knew that the world moves back in time instead of going forward and developing!! but anyway.. 3,000-2,000 BC Arrival and settlement of the Canaanites.. 1,250 Israelite conquest of Canaan so this proves that Israelis have conquered Palestine in the first place... and that they are not the first people to settle there.. the Israelis who are now claiming that they have the right to be in Palestine are nothing more than Jews from all over the world.. they have nothing in common except the Jewish religion.. the Palestinian Jews have every right to be in Palestine but Jews from all over the world have no right to claim that they lived there.. they come from different countries .. different ethnic groups.. how could they suddenly decide that they have lived there?? as for Abraham, Isaac and Jacob they are not Jewish!! they were before Moses was even descended .. for Muslims and Christians regard Abraham as their forefather.. Judaism, Christianity and Islam are there to complement each other.. Christianity is a development of Judaism and Islam is a development of both religions.. the three religions believe in the same God so thats why God will not ask any of the believers in those three religions to despise each other or kill and occupy lands under the cover of religion.. as for Spain and Eastern Europe they have never flourished as they had during the Islamic souvereign.. and the people have never been given their freedom and privileges except by the Islamic conquerers.. world history has never witnessed conquerers who have built and made the occupied country a capital for arts and culture.. they did not kill the original citizens.. they did not ruin the culture and architecture which they have brought with them before leaving there colonies... if all conquerers were like Islamic conquerers we wouldn't have had half of the problems we suffer of now with the occupiers...
38. #30.. American..
lynne   (06.10.06)
what you call innocent women are children are settlers who have come for POLITICAL reasons and not innocent civilians!!
39. #35.. Joe
lynne   (06.10.06)
Muslims do recognize the rights of all people to worship as their beliefs tell them... what kind of worshipping to you speak of?? is occupying lands and murdering a part of the Jewish religious rituals??
40. #37 Lynne
Brod ,   USA   (06.10.06)
Your knowledge of the history of the Middle East conflict from ancient time to modern needs polishing. I would suggest you read a brilliant book on the subject entitled "Everlasting HATRED: The Roots of Jihad" [2002] by Hal Lindsey. As for the subject on Islam and the nature of Islamist-Jihadists, read a brilliant book entitled "Leaving Islam" [2003] edited by Ibn Warraq and see their related website: www.faithfreedom.org.
41. May Allah bless your soule uncle Jamal!
Joshua ,   USA   (06.11.06)
Sounds to me that most “talkbacks” were written by blood thirsty, people hating, self centered ignorant bunch. To the writer: If the attacks by the freedom fighter Jamal and his organization against the IDF were considered a "terror", how do you categorize the killing of small children by the IDF on June 09!? To all blood thirsty, self centered ignorant in this world, Jamal was not a terrorist; Palestinians did not go to Europe to commit war crimes against the Jews. Israelis came from Europe to Palestine, massacred hundreds of thousands of innocent people, and stole a land from its rightful owners. Israelis take their WMD daily to areas populated with Palestinians, kill old people, young children, and babies! So, why don’t you stand on front of a mirror, take a long look at the creature you see, and ask your self, who are you fooling!? May Allah bless your sole and enter you into his paradise, uncle Jamal!
43. just look at his death body carefuly
gana ,   alx&egypt   (06.15.06)
just look at his death body carefuly from any search on net,i promise u that u'll know whether he's terrorist or a winner champion
44. answer 4#12
palistinian forever ,   tel aviv   (06.21.06)
that is anly what you think for your enformation he is now @ paridais & GOD bless him
45. thank you sooo much 4 you good feeling#41
strong woman ,   gaza   (06.21.06)
i think that you are great man to write this nice talk about my real uncle Jamal abu samhadana thnk you very much AND 4 every body this is the only fact that JAMAL was and still great hero to me and his family aaaand to the whole WORLD may GOD bless him & enter him to his REAL PARADISE ishaallah JAMAL 's DOUGHTER
Previous talkbacks
Back to article