News
IDF: Palestinian bomb, dud may be behind Gaza incident
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 10.06.06, 08:36
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
48 Talkbacks for this article
1. Let’s talk..
Adam ,   Poland   (06.10.06)
Before you start "scoring the points", l'ets talk about the people who are in pain, in pain after loosing their love ones, but who were able to overcome this pain to reach to the others, “the enemies”…: http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article13529.htm
2. Like we have never seen false reports
DANNY ,   America   (06.10.06)
about who killed who. I wouldn't trust anything any Palestinian said about any killing anywhere. We are talking about the same folks who send kids out with toy guns trying to get them shot. We are talking about a whole culture who send kids and women in front of gun fights to make their enemies look bad even when it's proven they themselves shoot their own and still they cry "look what Israel did". What is the saddest about this whole evil culture is people like Ellen Prescott believe the lies and make it worth it in the death cults sick-O's minds. It's all her fault for being gullible!
3. Gaza beach
steven ,   france   (06.10.06)
I am sure and certain,that the Israelis DID NOT,cause these unfortunate deaths,My sincere condolences,to the pals involved..But knowing the present situation,Abbas wanting a referendum,The hammas,the Al -aqsa,and the Jihad Islamique are More than capable of doing this abominable crime ,and therefore accuse Israel,WE HAVE SEEN THIS BEFORE,and it will not be the last time..When will the Palestinians,finally see ,that the Hamas is leading them straight down the path to no return,and they will stop at nothing to achieve their Goals,even murder their own people,they are quite professional at it, Don't you think,Cher readers of Y-NET,that this incident comes at an approriate time???these groupes are the DEVIL himself,;;;;;END
4. IDF
Alen   (06.10.06)
I too have my suspicion that IDF suddenly started firing artillery fire indiscriminely. Could have been stashed mortar shells exploding? Or Al-Qaeda sponsored provocation to kickstart the jihad...
5. jıhad dıd that
usa   (06.10.06)
ısraeL has rıgth to defend hımseLf agaınst bastard hamas
6. thıs ıs ploy of hamas
(06.10.06)
7. Stop killing civilians!
Gush Shalom   (06.10.06)
Stop killing civilians! The Israeli government is drawning us all in a sea of blood and violence Demonstration in front of Dan Halutz’ home Tomorrow, Saturday 10.6.06 18:30 The Israeli army continues its brutal attacks against innocent civilians including children, women and old people. Only today at least 12 people were killed while sitting on the beach and dozens were injured. Together with Olmert and Halutz, Amir Peretz, "a man of peace" and the leader of the working class, is leading a ruthless attack on Palestinian civilians and is committing war crimes no less than the former minister of defense, Mufaz. The Israeli government is doing everything possible in order to avoid negotiations with Palestinian representatives. Now in the face of a possible Palestinian unity around the the "prisoners document" that might influence the Israeli unilateral plans, the Israeli government is determined to provoke Hamas and drag it back to the circle of violence. On Saturday 10.6.06 at 18:30 we will demonstrate in front Dan Halutz’ home in Tel Aviv, Zahala Neighborhood, Baruch Agadati St. 19 B, and call to stop immediately the attacks on Gaza, to end the occupation and to start negotiations. Transportation : Jerusalem at 17:15 Gan Hapaamon (Bell Garden) 17:30 Binyaney Ha’uma Khulood 0547469738 Tel Aviv: if you can’t come by yourself, there is a bus: 18:00 Habima Yonathan 0546327736 For more information call: Yana 050-8575729 Yossi 052-5210184 Adam 0506-709603 Anarchists Against the Wall, Breaking the Silence Courage to Refuse, Coalition of Women for Peace Gush Shalom, Taayush, Yesh Gvul, די לרצח אזרחים! ממשלת ישראל מעוניינת להטביע את כולנו בים של דם ואלימות הפגנה מול ביתו של דן חלוץ בצהלה (אזור תל אביב), מחר (שבת 10.6) ב-18:30 צה"ל ממשיך לתקוף את רצועת עזה ולטבוח באזרחים תמימים, ילדים, נשים וזקנים. רק היום, נרצחו כ-12 אזרחים בעת שישבו על חוף הים ועשרות רבות נוספים נפצעו. יחד עם אולמרט וחלוץ, עמיר פרץ, איש השלום וגיבור מעמד הפועלים, מוביל מתקפה של טרור כנגד אוכלוסייה אזרחית ומבצע פשעי מלחמה בהיקף שלא היה מבייש את קודמו בתפקיד. ממשלת ישראל אשר חוששת מאופק מדיני ומהסכמה פלסטינית על "מסמך האסירים" אשר יתכן ויסכל את התכוניות החד-צדדיות שלה, נחושה לגרור את החמאס חזרה למעגל האלימות לאחר שהאחרון דבק בהודנה מזה למעלה משנה. מחר, יום שבת ה-10.6 בשעה 18:30 נפגין מול ביתו של דן חלוץ בתל אביב רח' ברוך אגדתי מס' 19 ב, בשכונת צהלה. להפסקת התקיפות על רצועת עזה, ליציאה מכל השטחים הכבושים ולכניסה למו"מ. הסעות: מירושלים: 17:15 מגן הפעמון 17:30 בנייני האומה חולוד 0547469738 תל אביב: למי שלא מגיע בכוחות עצמו יצא אוטובוס מהבימה ב 18:00 יונתן 0546327736 לפרטים נוספים יאנה 0508575729 יוסי 0525210184 אדם 0506709605 אנרכיסטים נגד הגדר, תעאיוש- שותפות יהודית ערבית, גוש שלום, קואליצית נשים לשלום, שוברים שתיקה, יש גבול,
8. I knew something wasn't right about this story.
Daisy ,   USA   (06.10.06)
America just like Israel is being falsely accused by the Arabs of intentionally killing civilians. America and Israel wouldn't kill civilians on purpose like the Arab terrorists. We are both too moral and ethical to di such a thing.
9. dont worry..
jason ,   usa   (06.10.06)
ellen is going to comment something usless without reading the WHOLE articel like all the other one she commented on
10. The Palestinians are to blame for this incident
Moti ,   Tel Aviv   (06.10.06)
The death of innocent Palestinian people is deeply regrettable. Unfortunately, we are in a situation in which Israel has to defend itself against the terrorists who fire rockets into Israel from populated areas and therefore, the terrorists are to blame for this unfortunate incident. It is very strange to see how the Palestinian terrorists accuse Israel for their civilian casualties, while their rockets are aimed at Israeli civilian population.
11. general Galant you make me sick(end_
michael ,   jerusalem   (06.10.06)
12. Some still prefers denial
historian   (06.10.06)
When the “good Germans” set on their denial course they had very convincing arguments to silence their conscience: the Jews had apparently declared an economical war against the Germany, so they had to be “interned”, a Jewish terrorist killed a German diplomat in Paris in 1938, so that was the prove of the hostilities, and no one of these “interns” was killed, of course, they all died from diseases and natural causes, some were transfered to the east as labourers and “God knows”, what happened there. No, none of the “good Gernans” was a Nazi, none of the “good Germans” had blood on their hands… The “good German army” just fought the war with “the communists” and “the terrorists” bombing their cities because they wanted to destroy “peace loving” Germany.
13. gaza
Alex   (06.10.06)
I'm sure that hamas or jihad or mooooobark did that
14. Could you stop this hysterics?
veronicka   (06.10.06)
May you stop this dramatics, please? Arabs are killing other Arabs on daily basis. Just look what happens in Iraq, Egypt, Morocco you name… According to statistics average age of Arabs world is about 14-12. So what do you expect from a <> ?
15. This is an Israeli PR fault - Kasam killed family BBC just r
sergey ,   Azerbaijan   (06.10.06)
16. Wrong report
ken   (06.10.06)
Qasam killed pals - BBC just reported
17. Watch the pictures again
(06.10.06)
There is no evidence of an artillery shell, quite the contrary, this looks nothing like a shelling, shells leave holes in the ground and burn the area.
18. TO #1 ADAM
Avinu   (06.10.06)
Remember JEDWABNE in Poland , SO may you can be in pain .......
19. Sure It Was
richard Hitchings ,   methil   (06.10.06)
20. Thats a very small crater for a 155mm artillery shell
(06.10.06)
21. same palestinian lies like in the al duri case
(06.10.06)
22. Gush Schmalom...
Daniel ,   Tel Aviv   (06.10.06)
...There is something wrong with you. Although I admire your courageousness and determination in the hope of peace, I am disheartened by the fact that if it had been a purposeful suicide bombing attack against Israeli civilians, you wouldn't have said much. Remember, Israel is the moral side in this conflict. It was a "stray" shell... It's a tragedy, but not a cold-blooded attempt to wreak death and destruction on the innocent Palestinian bystander....
23. To # 7 Gush shalom
Avinu   (06.10.06)
Just shame of you !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Who occupied who --- O forget you are not Jew ! Who shall stop killing civillians and stop fire rockets daily ?
24. As usual..
Chris ,   Boulder, CO   (06.10.06)
As usual, its the Palestinian's mistake.. they are killed and remain to be blamed.. Good Job IDF...kill as much as you want...Palestinians are not humans as far as Israel is concerned..
25. #11,take an akamol...
stephane ,   france   (06.10.06)
26. Yes, Adam from Poland, let's talk
Kate ,   London   (06.10.06)
Let's talk about the over 3 million Jews murdered by the Nazis with the overwhelming collaboration of Polish citizens. Let's talk about about their property which still lies in the hands of the Poles who stole it. Let's talk about the numerous pogroms in Poland which resulted in Jews being murdered during and even after the Holocaust. Let's talk about the anti-Semitism which is still as widespread as ever in Poland.
27. what's that #7 ??
yoel ,   switzerland   (06.10.06)
is Ynet involved in the political level as leftist militants? I don't care about the message's content, but this appealing to demonstrate in the street doesn't have to do anything in a forum. Would it come from the right or the center, it would be the same. This kind of demonstration can always turn to violent, and Ynet shouldn't be involved in ! Then, we have to be united while facing to this tragedy; and since it's unclear if IDF did it, it's also unacceptable to bring such accusations as an absolute truth. Remember IDF are present for our protection at first, and they also need our support in return! Leftists could also go and demonstrate in front of Hamas' offices after a suicide-bombing blast. Then, they would acquire a litle more credibility.
28. Qassem missiles wound 4 Palestinians today.
Jane ,   UK   (06.10.06)
A number of missiles launched from Gaza at Israel have hit their own people. It even happened again this morning. http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1149572652330&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull Four Palestinians wounded by Kassam rocket in Gaza. 10 June 2006 Four Palestinians were wounded when a Kassam rocket launched by operatives at Israel landed near a home in Beit Lahiya in the northern Gaza Strip. Seven Kassam rockets landed around Sderot and in the western Negev overnight Friday and Saturday morning.......... If the Palestinians have nothing to hide why are they not helping with the investigation into yesterday's tragedy. Not even the time or location of the incident is being supplied. There should be an enormous amount of forensic evidence to show whether the shell/missile responsible was Israeli or Palestinian. If Israel is prepared to come clean why aren't the Palestinians ?
29. Gush Shalom Dhimmis
(06.10.06)
30. Arabs kill their own
Alex ,   LA, USA   (06.10.06)
Remember when kill kill a boy in 2000 and IDF colonel said that it was sorry which was a pretext for killing many Jews. I absolutely sure that Arabs kill their people on the beach. Absolutely sure. Halutz should be dismissed at once.
Next talkbacks
Back to article