News
Israel: PA not cooperating in Gaza incident probe
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 10.06.06, 11:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
31 Talkbacks for this article
1. Typical Palestinian Arab lies! They always hide
anne ,   USA   (06.10.06)
their crimes!
2. THIS WAS EITHER WORK ACCIDENT /ON PURPOSE ACT BY PALS
ALAN ,   SA   (06.10.06)
3. This is just another Pallywood
Shinto ,   Vancouver   (06.10.06)
There has been many fake news like this around. They claimed this and that but denies access to the crime scene. Its all fake. they're just using civilians as human sheild to push there Anti-Israel agenda.
4. Look at the pictures again
Caligula's Horse ,   Solomon's stables   (06.10.06)
If there is anyone with military experience here he can easly tell that that is no artillery shell, shells leave big craters, scorched ground and if there is one thing they dont leave on a direct hit is whole bodies, I dont know what it was, but it defintaly wasnt an artillery shell, in the video you can see a iron plate looking object which looks like the surface of an anti tank mine, thats all I can tell from the pictures, but it can be just as well a lid for a food basket or something like that, investigation should reveal more.
5. AN INTERNATIONAL ENQUIRY SHOULD HAVE BEEN CONVENED ...
Alan ,   SA   (06.10.06)
Israel should not have given ANY comment whatsoever. Israel should have called for an enquiry by say ROADMAP team before blabbing mouth off. I bet this is like that kid who was killed in Gaza at begining of Intifada.
6. They are terrorist
Henry ,   NY   (06.10.06)
Those children killed at the beach are terrorist. They were preparing to launch some missiles with chemical heads at Tel Aviv. Luckily, the missiles were explodes before launching and that resulted in killing of 2 women, 5 children and injuring some 15 other children who were patroling on the scene.
7. This proves that this was an inside job.
Daisy ,   USA   (06.10.06)
Arabs are really the bottom of the barrel. They possibly can't go any lower.
8. #4 is correct. IT WAS CAUSED BY A QASSAM
MB   (06.10.06)
Once again, the Palestinian propganda machine is in high gear.
9. Pal movimakers don't want the truth to be exposed
(06.10.06)
10. Why Arabs kill their own
Alex ,   LA, USA   (06.10.06)
This has nothing to do with Israel. Arabs kill their own. If you saw the picture of a "wounded" boy posing for the camera, you know what is going on. This is a typical Arab propaganda.
11. Of course they will not cooperate
yakov shani ,   IL   (06.10.06)
lest the truth be known. There is no way that a 155mm shell, fired from an artillery piece in the possession of the IDF, will go west when fired east. It just can not happen. I have gone over in my mind all the possibilities, IDF stated no planes fired missiles, no boats fired missiles, IDF does not lie. Artillery shells is a very far fetched possibilty. Lets wait for the investigation outcome.
12. IT'S AN INSIDE JOB PEOPLE!!!!
(06.10.06)
13. We must be schizophrenic
(06.10.06)
We obviously display mental illness no? We are bombing people and then we help them go to hospital and offer assistence and make inquires into the situation. Get real people, if there was definitive proof this was Israeli artillery shell, then the Palestinians would be parading it in the media. BUT, Qassam rockets are not manufactured by the IDF, wonder who? ;-)
14. # 13 Schizophrenia
yakov shani ,   IL   (06.10.06)
is an illness for which there are medicines that can ameliorate the condition. There is nothing which has a comparable effect on stupidity.
15. Probably 'friendly-fire' by hamass
Arie   (06.10.06)
Wouldn't be the first time: Last year in the hamass inspired teror parade in Gaza, a hamass car filled with explosives blew up killing many palis. Of course the palis blamed the IAF until they couldn't contain their own lies and had to admit it was caused by the hamass-version of friendly fire
16. i feel shamed
azram ,   nablus   (06.10.06)
it was not israili attack at all. my cousins friend was ther he said he see guys running around at beach and then boom,i dont now if true but this is very shame for me,if falestins killing falestins to make israili look bad in media. very shame
17. Who's Really Behind It?
NYC Girl   (06.10.06)
The Israelis had better do whatever is necessary to get to the bottom of this because the story is already being reported all over the media as an Israeli attack. If it turns out it was a Qassam or some such thing, that fact won't get nearly as much attention. And it's particularly suspicious that the Palestinians aren't cooperating. If it were really an Israeli attack, accidental or otherwise, they'd be the first ones in front of the cameras. The fact that Abbas is calling for three days of mourning is a good indication of how they're going to milk this tragedy for every ounce of propaganda value they can get. We've already seen what happened with the killing of Mohammed al-Dura(assuming he's actually dead because even that's in dispute).
18. # 16 Azram
yakov shani ,   IL   (06.10.06)
You should be ashamed of your leaders who do nothing but take you back in time. If these are the leaders you have chosen then you desreve all you get. I feel sorry for you and I would like to help you. I personally many times have held out the hand of friendship but it has always been bitten, never kissed. Sorry.
19. #4 Finaly
Mike ,   Israel   (06.10.06)
Finaly someone sees and understands what the pictures shows.
20. truth about gaza deaths
Ahmad Khulal ,   Canada   (06.10.06)
it was mistake on part of 1 brothers. Due to his mistake, bomb went off, and killed. But to wipe out jews, they make up stories.
21. Another Palestinian work accident?
Cynthia ,   USA   (06.10.06)
A convenient "massacre" for Fatah and Hamas. If Israel was really responsible, the Palestinians would gladly cooperate. Where is the proof this was an Israeli missile instead of a Palestinian kassam? Withholding or hiding information raises suspicions.
22. israel
sameer ,   jerusalem   (06.10.06)
this is israel way of hiding crimes, either by new bigger crime or lies from this kind, who made this crime we need investigation, israel is a criminal state built on descrimination, killing, destruction, blood but have a duper power supporter called USA, israel ubove all lows and rules and nations.
23. #22 - Aren't you hilarious.
(06.10.06)
So what are you doing in Israel?
24. #23
sameer ,   jerusalem   (06.10.06)
iam not in israel, iam in palestinien arabic jerusalem, israel occupayind me and my lands
25. WHO CARES?
SHMU ,   UNHOLYLAND   (06.11.06)
i DONT CARE WHAT THE MEDIA SAYS AND i DONT CARE WHAT THE ARABS WANT ME TO BELIEVE. i KNOW THEY AR LIARS, IT IS A SIGNIFICANT PART OF THEIR CULTURE. PLEASE I PRAY ISRAEL WAKES UP AND DOESNT LISTEN TO WHAT THE WORLD SAYS.
26. dead Palestinians
Hilda ,   USA   (06.11.06)
They are refusing to dcpp[erate in probe because they know that they themselves are to blame for the deaths and not the Israelis. It is so much simpiler to blame the Jews. and look how much more press they get out of it. How mnice to killyour own, blame Israel and get such lovely propaganda out of it. Such monsters.
27. #23 - Your Big Chance
RythmPig ,   Canada   (06.11.06)
You have access to the area here's your chance to clearify any doubt. Go to the site and take pictures of the huge crater that should be there. Or is it 5 craters; the bus driver saw 5 shells hit? Maybe you can question the 1 or 2 camera men and find out how they miraculously got footage even before the Abulance arrived. This is your big chance to make us all look like fools and of coarse demonize Jews.
28. Why hide information?
garron ,   usa   (06.11.06)
the qassam detonated accidently. it's a shame palistinians have thugs for leaders and use their innocent as propoganda. war crimes investigation please!!!
29. so beach shelling in gaza
Clarence ,   san fernando T & T   (06.12.06)
BBC in collabaration with the "Palestine" terrorist are trying for an academy award for special effects. Notice the the aspiring child actress being directed on the beach without a srcath on her face, but is shown after with bruises on her face. s
30. response to Henry, NY
American in L.A. ,   Los Angeles, CA   (06.21.06)
Please provide your source for this information. I would be interested in verifying for myself. Thank you.
Next talkbacks
Back to article