Add talkback 
Print talkbacks 
IDF: We speak the truth    Hanan Greenberg
1. Ashamed of being an Israeli and a Jew
The IDF not only killed those innocent Palestinians which is an undisputed war crime, but made things much much worse by their pathetic denial. Are they trying to tell us that they were shelling the beach all day and then 10 palestinians happened to be blown up there but the two events are not connected? Peace-loving Israelis and jews are ashamed and disgusted by such crimes and big lies. We must admit That we are guilty, apologise sincerely, put the responsible people on trial and pay compensations to the innocent palestinians. Most importantly, End the occupation of West bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem. Daniel, An enlightened jew
Daniel ,   Tel Aviv   (06.17.06)
2. BRITISH HYPOCRITES IGNORE Sudan's JIHAD SLAVERY & GENOCIDE
Bible, Leviticus 24:17 "If a man takes the life of any human being, he shall surely be put to death" Black Africans are the indigenous people of Sudan and are the majority population. The black Southern Sudanese Christians explain what "peace" means: If you agree to become a Muslim, you will have peace. If you reject Islam, you are at war. From 1955-1973, 1.5 million Christians were slaughtered by the Arab Muslim government in Khartoum. From 1983-2005, two million more Christians died from Khartoum's jihad. Murdering infidels is not considered a crime. Non-Muslim infidels are regarded as not entitled to human rights. Hundreds of thousands of Christians have been raped. Hundreds of thousands of Christian children and women taken for slaves. In the refugee camps, the Islamo-Fascist religious supremacist Khartoum government requires refugees to become Muslims in order to receive food and water. The genocide has resulted in the largest population of refugees on earth since the Second World War. The jihad in Sudan against Darfur's black African Muslims by Khartoum's racist Arab Muslim regime began in 2003. 400,000 black Muslims are dead. STOP Genocide - STOP Slavery - FREE the Slaves http://www.iabolish.org/ Bible, Exodus 21:16 "He who kidnaps a man, whether he sells him or he is found in his possession, shall surely be put to death"
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (06.17.06)
3. Military experts
The 3 brit newspapers are well known for their objectivity and their fairness - especially when they have an opportunity to attack Jews and Israel. As for facts, they never allow them to obfuscate their ability to attack everything that has to do with Judaism.
Arie   (06.17.06)
4. paliwood:Produced by the brit anti-Semites
Arie   (06.17.06)
5. ELLEN PRESCOTT IS NOT GOING TO LIKE THE TRUTH !
AVINU   (06.17.06)
6. the only mistake of tsahal is:
...that they said they were sorry too early after what happened.it is STUPID to say you're sorry when you're not sure that YOU did that on this beach! it's like giving honey to our ennemies.when you say you're sorry,it's like you say you're guilty! 2 days after,when the internal inquiry shows that it couldn't be tsahal who killed this family,it's too late,the bad effect already occured,and our ennemies believes what they prefer to believe(arab propaganda as usual)...next time that pals kill their own people,don't apologize before you inquire.because we're sure that idf didn't kill this family,and even it was idf,it's an error like in any war it can happen.
stephane ,   france   (06.17.06)
7. you can't imagine how ethic this army is
few years ago we were stationed in gaza inside bulletproof jeeps. it happened a few times that protesters threw stones at us and came very close to the jeeps. but we were never allowed to shoot, not even rubber bullets! there are so many strict rules, that you think the army is crazy about justice. for example, if a protester is about to throw a molotov cocktail at a jeep, we were only allowed to shoot-to-hurt (not to kill) BY THE TIME the device has left his hand, meaning only then we were allowed to shoot the man in the foot! another example: if a man has a gun pointed down to the ground, we are not allowed to shoot if he holds it with one hand, if he holds it with two hands we are allowed to shoot to hurt (wound), if he aims to our direction, we are allowed to kill. one of my best friend fired at a protester and wounded him because he was throwing an unknown device. but because the chief saw that it was only a rock, he gave him 26 days in a 2nd-level prison in haifa. and this happens on a daily basis. listen people, i was there, in one of the best idf special units working close with the border quards, and we were all following to these strict rules just because its ethic and justified. we were all the time in a mental stress calculating when and what we were allowed and not allowed to. people coming here everyday, posting crap they know shit about. i myself have enough of the settlers and i say it loud, but calling our army un-ethic IS the biggest lie ever. you can believe what you want, i dont care ... i for myself know the truth of this land and its army because i was serving my time there. and you dont know how lucky the palys are that they have such a great "enemy"! any other army had killed them all long time ago. this is jewish land, it was long before there was even the name "islam", and it will always be jewish. and people like ellen, are really poor people that have nothing to do in their life rather than surf the net to provoke and to get others attention, and spread false information. the insident in gaza was just another famous palywood. they even kill themselves to blame israel for it. the truth never burns in fire and never drawns in water ... its pure and will always reveal itself. shalom ve leitraot
yako ,   idf   (06.17.06)
8. were they hit by an Artillery shell, you would find nothing
(06.17.06)
9. as the palestinians say "who benefits most from this?"
using classic palestinian logic, it is clear that the palestinians are behind this blast because it is to their advantage that israel's image is tarnished, seeing how well israel is perceived in the international community lately. actually, they probably believe that the mossad is behind the balast, to kill palestinians and to blame it on them, then cast doubt in order to cover their guilt because they really want to find ways to kill innocent palestinians. that's probably what they all believe.
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (06.17.06)
10. IDF... We Speak the Truth.....lol
Sure they do.
richard Hitchings ,   methil   (06.17.06)
11. It is not new that the English press due to the Pslestinian
It is not new that the English press is due to the Palestinian propoganda. It like to poin the target' - the blame of Israel policy and after the maintain conclusion ask for evidents to prove it and hide and dismiss knowen proves that not support theier conclusion.
s.a.   (06.17.06)
12. Trust me,there is nothing "Independent" in BritishPress
Its all" hate Jews and Israel" in Guardian and Independent and other "me too" newspapers who want to climb on the Arab Muck Cart as well. If you still dont believe me ,read one for a few days and you will see my point!
Alan ,   SA   (06.17.06)
13. Yes! Go investigate the hundreds of Kassams on Israel
Alan ,   SA   (06.17.06)
14. YOU SHALL BE ASHEMED OF BEING A JEW LIKE YOU ARE ! !
PLEASE LINDA RIVERA SEE WHAT A DANIEL A JEW WE HAVE IN TEL AVIV ??
AVINU   (06.17.06)
15. guardian and independent
.. are notoriously biased. In general, media in UK is clearly anti-israeli. Sky News, which is probably less biased, recently reported "one palestinian killed by IDF" with low level "breaking news" status. Needless to say, this "palestinian" was kassam terrorist. When one civilian (arab citizen of israel) was killed in terrorist shooitng attack near Jerusalem 2 days before, it wasn't reported at all.
Vorax   (06.17.06)
16. #1 You are not enlightened, you're stupid
Go on and move to Gaza, people like you make me sick, you're pathetic and disgusting.
(06.17.06)
17. Daniel
Daniel, how are we as Israelis occupying Gaza? There is no army presence in Gaza and the reason that we fire sheels into Gaza is because terrorists fire rockets into Israeli cities every day. What is your response to that? I'm not saying in this case that the IDF doesn't make mistakes and kill Palestinian bystanders but #1 I am more inclined to believe an army investigation than one done by a former "expert" whose salary is now paid for by a very biased anti-Israel NGO. I'm sure that Israelis and the army would love to stop shelling the Gaza strip and as soon as Jihad, Hamas and other terrorists stop attacking us from there then we will.
Ryan George ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.17.06)
18. „Pallywood“ - as always.
Gerd ,   Germany   (06.17.06)
19. It was a 155mm shell, Mr. Kalifi....!!!!!!!
I have read UK newspapers last Thursday, or Wednesday. They said that there is an American expert who came to Gaza after the incident. This expert is convinced that there is 'little doubt' that the massacre was because of an IDF shelling. He examined the injuries, the hole, the sharpnels and he realised it was a shelling. He also found a shell remains with a '155mm' mark. For those who do not know, 155mm artillery is American and only three armies in the world have it. US, Israel, and Lebanon. If we exclude Lebanese, and US armies for reasons we all know, then there is IDF only left. I suggest that the secretary of defence and the chief of staff admit the mistake, apologise and offer compensation. It is better for the IDF image. IDF image in UK newspapers is getting worse especially after 11 were killed in a chase in Gaza streets, which was published last week as well.
Londoner ,   London, UK   (06.17.06)
20. Just beacuse...
...the reports were published in the Times, The Guardian and The Independent makes them true? I don't think so. Remember where these reports were published, in the British media! The most anti-semitic, anti-Israeli media outlets in the world. I will not accept anything written in these tabloids as truth. They publish nothing but negative propoganda against Israel.
Allan ,   Delray Beach, FLA   (06.17.06)
21. End of story...!!!!
It is a very simple equation though: Palestinians don't fire Kassams unto Israel >< Israel does not retaliate !!! If only those so called "Palestinians Supporters" , who presumably "really " care about the pales. could explain this simple solution ( THEY DON'T FIRE ROCKETS - ISRAEL DOES NOT RETALIATE...) End of story...! N.B. The Palestinians buried and planted explosive charges on the beaches to prevent from the IDF any incursion from the sea... needless to remind of the consequences it could have for the Pales. picnicking on these beaches
HawkEye ,   Mediterranean Sea   (06.17.06)
22. To : #16
With people like you around, this country can only go one way and thats down the drain
Brian   (06.17.06)
23. Hey Daniel!
If you're so ashamed of being an Israeli and a Jew, why don't you convert to Islam and move to Gaza? Nobody's forcing you to live in Tel Aviv. The only reason I can think of why you're staying is that the cafe latte in Rafiah isn't up to par with the Shenkin coffee shops. Hypocrite.
Zionist   (06.17.06)
24. Daniel, you are the reason I wish rockets will fall on
Tel Aviv. It seems like only then people like you will understand that the Palestinians an an enemy not a peace partner. I wait anxously for that day to come, when north Tel Aviv will be hit by rocket barrages.
(06.17.06)
25. Let me ask you something Londoner
"They said that there is an American expert who came to Gaza after the incident. This expert is convinced that there is "little doubt' that the massacre was because of an IDF shelling." Now had this SAME American expert said it was not an IDF shelling, would you believe him? I think not. He'd have been accused of working with the Israeli's and you know it. You people are so full of ןא.
Michelle   (06.17.06)
26. 10 Hitchings: You wouldn't se the truth when it hits your
moonbat face You see your thoughts are irrelevant
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.17.06)
27. # 7 - kol hakavod!
Gerd ,   Germany   (06.17.06)
28. #1 Daniel
You are not an enlightend jew,you are a self hating one. I for one am a proud Jew and Israeli,and take pride in the Israeli army
Don Saliman ,   Nahal Oz, Israel   (06.17.06)
29. Daniel is Arab from Shfaram
Take it easy guys. He is an Arab from Shfaram.
Ali ,   Gallil   (06.17.06)
30. #25 the point is the IDF were caught telling a whopper
it doesn't really matter what the accusations are, just the result. no self-regulated inspection should be let unchallenged: IDF's 'findings' are in dispute so the PR spin is the only battle they can maintain, countervailing the actual truth.
wanda ,   montreal   (06.17.06)
Next talkbacks 
Add talkback 
Print talkbacks