News
IDF: Shrapnel found in Gazan boy not from shell
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 21.06.06, 16:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
31 Talkbacks for this article
1. palis killing palis and blaming Jews - daily event
Arie   (06.21.06)
2. Well, isn't that shocking?
Israeli   (06.21.06)
Now here are some questions to the palestinians of you who will say we lie as thats the only thing they can say. 1) Why did you clean the people and sent them to Israeli hospitals without the sharpnels? I don't see why will anyone clean them instead of letting doctors treat these persons (maybe if you had sent them to the hospital right away some of them would've survived, but taking the time to remove sharpnels surely didn't help). 2) Why when Israel wanted Palestinian assitance in the investigation you refused? is it because you knew the right facts? 3) Why every now and then a palestinian tells me they know they did it? he told me an uncle of a friend of his knew about this before the explosion. 4) Why do you keep believing your own leaders after lying and lying and lying for years? you know they lie, we know they lie. Why do you believe it?! you think our government doesn't have liars? we have TONS of them, but we know what to believe and what is fiction. Please see to it. 5) Why the sound was 'fixed' (as in not dynamic) when the camera man went away from the ambulance? 6) why there weren't 155 shells craters near the explosion site? Now, let's see if any of you has the courage to answer those and if you do, lets see if you understand your government is lying. If I won't get a response from you, I will prove that you are nothing but brainwashed persons with no personal opinion. And by not answering you will prove to the rest of the readers what you are really worth. So please, take your time and answer. Thank you.
3. He said, she said...
James ,   TA   (06.21.06)
I don't really care anymore....civilians are dead....terrorists continue to shoot rockets and hide within civilian population areas....the IDF/IAF still shoot back with limited success. The time has come to CUT OFF Gaza completely from all the services they receive from Israel. If the terrorists still manage to operate with no electricity, gasoline, cell phone or internet service then the next step of an IDF reconquest of northern Gaza must take place. Israel's detterence is becoming weaker and weaker everyday....and more innocent lives will be lossed on each side until REAL ACTION is taken by the Israel gov't to protect its citizens.
4. lair, lair, lair
N/A ,   None   (06.21.06)
as a pal, am not sure what to belive any more. Aljzaeria had pics of the ship while in action( pics of ships fireing), which is 100% fake. how hard is it to check boms brands? it says on the damn thing Made in Israel, or USA. in the end i dont care where boms come from, in my mind all boms come from israel( even if hams fired it). Yes Israel, its ur fult that boms go off, kids get sick, my car wont start. Yes we belame EVERYTHING on u.. Build your wall higher and higher and leave us the F.... aloneeeeeeeeeeeee.
5. Pa"lie"stinian claim
Ken ,   Skokie, USA   (06.21.06)
Since Garlasco had previously said that leg injuries suggest a mine as the cause and this "poor victim" had leg injuries, does anyone think that perhaps Garlasco made his initial comments due to his political views with which he prostitued truth?
6. #4
Israeli   (06.21.06)
Those ships WERE shooting. those weren't fake. They just didn't shoot to the shore. They shot to qassam launching sites.
7. Israel: Gaza Beach Investigation Ignores Evidence
HUman Rights Watch   (06.21.06)
http://hrw.org/english/docs/2006/06/20/israb13595.htm
8. to the N/A # 4
Alex G. ,   ROSH HA'AIN   (06.21.06)
Im glad that you posted that you're from the country that has a name NONE. As long as we all understand that there is no country that you're from. You gotta learn either english, or maybe your subject just meant that you're singing something We would love to leave all of you alone, but its not us who are bothering you, but your animal brothers and sisters. Leave us alone, let us finish the wall and stop firing Qassams into our country. Blame your stupid terror government and monkey people that follow anything blindly, as long as there is hate. Long live Israel!!!!
9. BRIT MEDIA HYPOCRITES IGNORE SUDAN'S JIHAD SLAVERY &GENOCIDE
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (06.21.06)
Bible, Leviticus 24:17 "If a man takes the life of any human being, he shall surely be put to death" Black Africans are the indigenous people of Sudan and are the majority population. The black Southern Sudanese Christians explain what "peace" means: If you agree to become a Muslim, you will have peace. If you reject Islam, you are at war. From 1955-1973, 1.5 million Christians were slaughtered by the Arab Muslim government in Khartoum. From 1983-2005, two million more Christians died from Khartoum's jihad. Murdering infidels is not considered a crime. Non-Muslim infidels are regarded as not entitled to human rights. Hundreds of thousands of Christians have been raped. Hundreds of thousands of Christian children and women taken for slaves. In the refugee camps, the Islamo-Fascist religious supremacist Khartoum government requires refugees to become Muslims in order to receive food and water. The genocide has resulted in the largest population of refugees on earth since the Second World War. The jihad in Sudan against Darfur's black African Muslims by Khartoum's racist Arab Muslim regime began in 2003. 400,000 black Muslims are dead. STOP Genocide - STOP Slavery - FREE the Slaves http://www.iabolish.org/ Bible, Exodus 21:16 "He who kidnaps a man, whether he sells him or he is found in his possession, shall surely be put to death"
10. Who does Israel contact to get her reputation back?
Shuki   (06.21.06)
Media outlets that rushed to carry to Palestinian version of these events should be bombarded (no pun intented) with this new evidence until they prominently issue retractions and report on the depth of Palestinian treachery. Just another day that in the miasma that is Gaza...
11. #4, dude. My car won't start either,
S. ,   Tel-viv, Israel   (06.21.06)
should I blame PA? Get sober before you post next time, please.
12. garlasco the "bootlicker",when it's proven that you're wrong
stephane ,   france   (06.21.06)
shut up!!!
13. # 3 - Israeli
Ginette Golden ,   Toronto, Canada   (06.21.06)
I have one simple answer to all of your questions and you are going to like it: Why, why, why...Because Steven Spielberg, they are not! You see, these morons, staged an attack supposedly inflicted by the beautiful, conscientious, strong, unbeatable IDF They did not care that they were killing their own (when do they?), the main objective here was to blame Israel and its army. On the other hand, if even one of them had the talent of Steven Spielberg, then, the World would have thought the worst (again!) of Israel and its People. I for one am glad of those findings so maybe the populace at large will finally realize what kind of criminal, liar monsters Palestinians terrorist really are. (Then again, maybe not!)
14. #7 - As suspected you didn't answer my questions.
Israeli   (06.21.06)
Why will the IDF listen to someone who already said won't help them with the investigation? why listen to someone who is constantly lying and trying to avoid the subject. That's like saying Terrorists are innocent if they say they are. This is not a court, this is an investigation which is led by facts and facts only. By using Palestinian sources it would've scrambled into one big lie. Way to go IDF! and way to go #7 for proving you are nothing but a brainwashed arab with no self opinion.
15. Still waiting for PA's investigation
Cynic ,   USA   (06.21.06)
As all the Israel bshers comes out to criticize Israel's investigation, I am still waiting for the results of any palestinian ivestigation to prove differently.
16. TRUTH is IRRELEVANT to the PA and WORLD MEDIA
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (06.21.06)
Muslim human bomb killers slaughtered such huge numbers of Jewish innocents, the IDF were forced to search for the terrorists in Jenin. 52 Islamists were killed by the IDF. The PA falsely reported to world media that the IDF had killed 1,500 PA Muslims. The anti-Jew world media did not concern themselves to investigate if the false, venomous, slanderous, Jew-hating Jenin report was true. Israel was blasted and condemned around the world. Once again, with the full cooperation of a Jew-hostile world media, the Islamists scored a victory based totally on lies and deception-taqiyya.
17. # 4 We'd love to but...
Jacob   (06.21.06)
Your relatives of the lost Trans-Jordanian tribe will not leave us the f$#@$% aloooone. Stop the terror, have a new idea, build up you cities, and be a productive member of society, try that on for size, and see how it feels. It's easy to be angry and stupid, it requires effort to grow and create, instead of simply destroy, that's all your tribe is good for, destruction. I's a shame we can only build a wall so high, I'd like to see it as high as the upper atmosphere.
18. differences in culture
Arie   (06.21.06)
whil palis continue to kill everyone they can, including each other in the hopes of blaming the Jews as the quran instructs, the Jews go anywhere we can to help others! http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3265757,00.html
19. IDF Lies
Debra Cohen ,   NY   (06.21.06)
thanks # 7 for the link. The Jerusalem Post tried to pull a fast one yesterday, publishing a "news" item that claimed Garlasco of HRW had agreed with the IDF's findings. It did this by clumsily editing his words to suit its needs. The IDF investigation and its conclusions are a whitewash and a coverup.
20. I am still ashamed, regardless, my daddy too
Yair Lappid ,   Rich and Famous   (06.21.06)
21. We're Still Ashamed Too, Yair
tinashkuli   (06.21.06)
of you, and your daddy.
22. At least stop killing if you want us to believe you!!!
Captain London ,   London, UK   (06.21.06)
Why the Israelis are telling different stories? Besides who in the world believe the IDF version of the story? As if we are asking Hitler to investigate his responsibility in the Holocaust, or asking Saddam to investigate his responsibilities in the crimes he committed against Iraqis. This so funny. A neutral American expert came to Gaza last week and proved without doubt that it was an IDF 155mm bomb. Stop twisting the truth...... It is annoying how far the IDF would go to hide its inhumane behaviours.
23. It's called Pallywood; Web sote inside
Chaya ,   Bat Yam   (06.21.06)
Read how the pals manipulate events for the media. www,seconddraft.org
24. to #22
jason white ,   afula,israel   (06.21.06)
This "expert" was proven wrong.And he is not independent.How could someone even compare this to the crimes of hitler or saddam or the british gov't.? I only wish we were as inhumane as all you antisemetic dogs feel. But how can we be inhumane when we are not dealing with humans? Someday soon we will have a real govt.and we will destroy that nest of vipers living on our land. Too bad your limey "army" is not in the same military or moral league as the I.D.F. You bums are amateurs.
25. #7 HRW gives islamists a pass...
dave kafir ,   dallas texas usa   (06.21.06)
I figured you guys(HRW) were islamist butt-kissers and your web site proves it. Way to ignore the religion of murder and death (islam), not to mention the religion of human rights repression(islam). HRW makes me sick. Where does islam do any good in the world? No place that I can see......
26. #22 Captain London, Blease forgive me, I beg you, blease
Yair Lappid ,   Rich and Famous   (06.21.06)
27. Is anybody surprised I didn't get answered?
Israeli   (06.22.06)
28. 22 Captain London: Shut up ypu silly man and get a name
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.22.06)
29. London; You have Hamass mixed up with the IDF.
Daisy ,   USA   (06.22.06)
Arabs always lie about everything!
30. this captain never made it to a war zone
haim ,   mtl canada   (06.22.06)
so where the phoque did he get this title and maybe he should rename himself asshole and go work with ellen
Next talkbacks
Back to article