News
Popular Resistance Committees: Kidnapped soldier alive
Ynet reporters
Published: 26.06.06, 08:58
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
48 Talkbacks for this article
31. #4
Talula ,   Israel   (06.26.06)
belongs with Al-Qieda. That's exactly what they would do. Israelis are better than that, it's what seperates us from them. Plus, it isn't her son that has been kidnapped. She makes me sick.
32. #4. I shake my head only! This is NOT really YOU!
Gerd Schulz ,   Germany   (06.26.06)
33. hi hopes
Andrews ,   Canada   (06.26.06)
These terorists normally kill the victim, unless they are taught that they will be killed for doing this bull.... Comeon Israel, attack these bastards and kill all of them.
34. Rustum, simply put
Caligula's Horse ,   Solomon's Stables   (06.26.06)
He opposes any existence of Jews in their land, he does not want "Two states for two nations", he doesnt want peace, he doesnt want to end bloodshed or any of that nonsense, he want the distruction of Israel, in his eyes the existence of a soveregin state for the Jewish nation in their ancient land is a crime in the firstplace, of course our Rustum will fight until his last breath for the rights of the Kurds, Chechnians, Tibetans and of course, his beloved Palestinians for sovereginity in their homeland, but he defies that same right for Jews. Dear Rustum, that is the exact defenition of anti-Semitism, and there is no way to turn it around.
35. I like #14 - There is plenty of blame to go around....
Andy   (06.26.06)
on BOTH sides. As a Jew, I love and support the State of Israel. As a human being, I believe we need a new way of relating to the Palestinians. Both sides have brutalized and marginalized the other. Palestinians have tolerated, supported, celebrated horrific violence that other Palestinians inflict on Israelis. Israelis tolerate apalling living conditions of millions of people in their midst and under their occupation. I am sure there is another way. Israelis cannot tolerate the bombing of Sderot. Palestinians who are not terrorists are sick of seeing people being killed in "unfortunate incidents." On and on. Killing and more killing. There is no other way but compromise - realizing both sides have alot of reasons to hate the other. Israel is not going to expel the Palestinians from Gaza and the West Bank. Palestinians are not going to eliminate Israel - either violently or through ludicrous "return of refugee" demands or the so-called multinational state. Let's get real and deal with each other already and have two states.
36. Caligula's horse
Rustum ,   London, UK   (06.26.06)
Total and absolute nonsense - the words you ascribe to me. As far as I remember I have not "opposed" anything. I have not "opposed any existence of Jews in their land", etc, etc, etc, It's all your feeble imagination. I have opposed violence. I have opposed the abhorrent racism of so many of the posters here. And actually, Mr Caligula, I don't see how it is anti-Semitic to wish for less Israeli Jews to die violent deaths. I would have said exactly the opposite. the great big anti-Semites here are those like you - who love death, who want the army to go out killing and who completely ignore the fact that killing Palestinians leads to dead israelis. Now that is vile anti-semitism. As for my opinions on the Kurds, Chechens etc - you have not got the faintest idea what i think so kindly butt out. your business, which I'll beg you to mind, is how to stop the cycle of violence - and your contributions help not one whit.
37. #36 You're dodging the question
Caligula's Horse ,   Solomon's Stables   (06.26.06)
Tell me, do you consider the existence of Israel, lets say in 1967 borders, as a Jewish state with a Jewish majority justified? Or is it illegal? If given the opportunity, would you dismantel it (not through war)? Just answer this, yes or no, please dont go on about your poor Palestinians, just answer it. Believe me, I know people and I know leftists and I know rightists and I know Arabs and I know Jews and I know Europeans and I know anti-Semites, and there are some things which are unmistakeable.
38. #6
Jane   (06.26.06)
Hey, now there's a good idea.
39. 30 Talula: The Diaspora helps and funds Israel as well and
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.26.06)
I work for over 40 years with and for Israel with many organizations Now tell me what do you do It is not smart for YOU to fight the Jews who support Israel Your post - doesn't show much intellect
40. abducted soldier
debbie ,   israel   (06.26.06)
Rustum, ah, so you found their "excuse" for blowing themselves and others up in Israel. Great. But what is the excuse of the moslems all over the world for wreaking havoc and murder, kidnapping, and just plain terrorizing people? What was the reason, for example, they blew up, what was it, 280 young people in Bali?Did those youths oppress them? Occupy their land? Why did they murder hundreds of people in Spain and London, just going about the business of getting to work and earning a living? The plain truth is they don't need any reason or excuse. Murder, killing and terrorism for its own sake.
41. #40
Angela ,   The Haque, Holland   (06.26.06)
You are so right. This is not a problem of Israel alone but a worldwide problem. The world have to wake up!!!! Dear Galid, Stay strong. We are all waiting for your safe return to your family, friend and colleques.
42. 40 debbie: You preach to a Muslim extremist who sits in
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.26.06)
London
43. Israeli denial
Yoni ,   Tel Aviv   (06.28.06)
So all my fellow citizens...is it not about time that we realise and honestly admit that we really, really fucked up after 1967.....? I just hope that all the pathetic jews in america who have opinions but not the guts to live here and truely enjoy our zionist nightmare, that they all should just stay quiet. Living in a big lie sucks, actually.
44. Zionism as an American
Haim ,   Washington DC   (06.29.06)
I have been to Israel many times. I have invested my hard earned money into Israel. I have donated time, equipment and expertise. I am after all, A Jew, and American-Jew. I was born here. Do not belittle those that help Israel in their own way. It is small minded and helps the other causes.
45. Please pray for Gilad ben Aviva
R2d2 ,   Jerusaem, Israel   (07.01.06)
I pray to G-d for the well-being and speedy freeing of Gilad ben Aviva. Acheinu kol beit Israel hanetunim betzara uveshivya, ha'omdim bein bayam uvein bayabasha, Hamakom yerahem aleihem veyotzi'em me'afeila le'ora umishi'bud lige'ula, hashta ba'agala uvizman kariv ve'imru Amen.
46. Calling an Arab war against Israel a Cycle of violence
DANNY ,   America   (07.02.06)
Is just Rustdumb parrorting propaganda. And he seems so smart...
47. Winning a war thrust upon you is the only choice or die
DANNY ,   America   (07.02.06)
48. Moral equivalence
Douglas J. Miller ,   Miami Beach, USA   (07.02.06)
Those who don't see a difference between terrorism and defence against terrorism, or between those perpetrating a war of extermination and those resisting extermination are unable to see the difference between good and evil. Gilad Shalit was kidnapped by monsters who murdered 2 and wounded several others of his troop. The criminals are holding him at gun point and making demands. Israel, as every other civilized country would do, is making a courageous, and restrained effort to rescue him and punish the criminals.
49. PLEASE PRAY FOR HERO "JAMAL ABU SAMHADANA"
sunFLOWER ,   GAZA PALESTAIN   (07.04.06)
50. WHAT IS....G-D ???
DOHMANN JOHANN ,   EAST GRAND FORKS, MI   (08.01.06)
THE ..G-D IS THAT SUPPOSED TO STAND FOR 'GOD'?? AND IF IT DOES,WHY NOT WRITE GOD,ITS GOT TO BE PATHETIC,THE WAY THIS IS WRITTEN.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article