News
PRC: Leave Gaza or we’ll kill kidnapped settler teen
Efrat Weiss
Published: 28.06.06, 03:29
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
67 Talkbacks for this article
1. ynet-our homegrown al jazeera
Arie   (06.27.06)
2. but Condi Bush puppets says:
Eva ,   Central Israel   (06.27.06)
"American administration urges Israeli restraint over kidnapping of Israeli soldier, calls government to 'give diplomacy a chance.'" .........the rest of the two faced nations follows. Folks it is not the dangerous left or the ranting liberal media who we must fear but world leaders who have certainly set the stage for double standards upon Israel. Wonder why the world hates us. Think again. World leaders with their arm twisting are the real devils. The rest are simply followers.
3. Israeli Youth Negligence
Dave Levi ,   Burbank. USA   (06.27.06)
This is tantamount to negligence, almost criminal, on the part of some Israeli youth. They, like some of their elders just don't get it. Israel is at war with the Palestinians. When will these naive persons wake up? First of all, they cause undue grief. Secondly, their lives are in danger. 3rd, it costs money to find them (police have to be paid). Why in heavens name are they continuing this inexcusable behavior? They could take precautions. But I have suggested for years, Israel should declare Marshal Law (perhaps in stages), and stop all this precarious behavior. Also, kidnapping, like our Lindbergh Law, should be a capital offense...a 12.00 noose and last meal are all that is needed for convicted felons. Oh, don't release them as part of an "exchange", as is being discussed right now with the Hamas murderers.
4. I'd call these people animals
Floyd   (06.27.06)
but that's an insult to animals. So I'll stick with savages.
5. Beware Kidnappers!!
Jewess ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.27.06)
Last week, two girls were saved from a kidnapping and we read just yesterday or maybe the day before about another girl who jumped out of a car because she felt she was being abducted after accepting a ride. One of my son's students survived an attempted kidnapping in the last few days. Who knows how many more there may have been since surely not every incident is publicized. The public should beware!
6. US. Restrains Israel From Any Action
Marcel ,   Florida   (06.27.06)
Bush - Listen Ehud ,number one ,you can't go in and defeat the Palestinian's you just can't ,that'll screw up all my plans ,got that ? Olmert - Yes Mr. President Bush- Before I forget ,great job distancing me from your. ..what's it called now divergence ? convergence ? The stupid Zionists , Jewboys are too dumb to tie it to my Road Map final solution plan ,great job taking the heat for me, that's loyalty Ehud. It means alot to me ,your loyalty............ So you got trouble in Gaza ? Olmert -Yes sir . Bush - Just stall , it's only one soldier,don't let it get out of hand ,remember the plan ,restrain the IDF ,build up the Pal's. A weak Israel is our main goal. Olmert - Mr. President I know I promised not to escalate and to keep the IDF restrained ,but things have changed ,I've to to act. They're already percieving me as weak. Bush - I know you have problems in Gaza, Ehud ,but you just can't go in ,it will ruin our success and destroy momentum for Israel's destruction, oops, I mean for the Road Map peace plan. Olmert - But Mr. President, I'm under great pressure to do something. Bush- Just talk tough and mass your troops on the border with Gaza and do nothing else or I will cut you (Israel)off. There are many there ready to take your place ,remember that . I want to make it abundantly clear that you are not to go into Gaza,a small limited and restrained response is all that I will allow you to appease your citizens. Also I want you to crush without mercy the right who are the only opposition to my Final Solution Road Map for Israel. Demonize them ,arrest them,harass them and hound them ,kill them if you have to. Adolph would be proud of my clever plan , it has successfully flown under the radar and the majority of Christian's and Jews are completely off guard and asleep. Even as I protect the Palestinian terrorists and keep Israel from defeating them under threats and hard pressure they still support me. These fools are so easy to decieve and seduce . They voted for me and I work day and night to bring about haSatan's New World Order. Israel has no place in this plan. Olmert - Mr. President, I went along with your plan to send thousands of weapons and ammunition to the P.A. and I went along with Amona ,but I'm afraid some of my Military Commanders are wakeing up to what is going on . Bush- Don't worry ,if you got a problem I'll send some of my best silencers over there and take care of it for you. We've got to neutralize Israel to get the Arabs on base with our global agenda and thats the only way they'll stay on board. We've got to deliver . Olmert - Yes sir Mr. President, I'm happy to serve you and your glorious plan. I am your obedient servant.
7. who are these people !!!!
Kim Madeen ,   London ,UK   (06.27.06)
as a jew , I am outraged at this policy israel in conducting in the occupied area's of the West Bank , every town ,village and is turned into a big concentration camp .....that is unacceptable ,one day its going to explode in our faces , its surely tainted our image in the eyes of the world , and no amount of PR will cleanse our soul ....and by the way what was this dude doing in the West Bank ??????
8. #3
Gavin ,   LA   (06.27.06)
Your assuming there was negligence. How heartless are you. In the event they declare marshal law, it wouldnt have prevented such a thing from happening anyway. There is no exchange being discussed with the Hamas murderers, that was vetoed a long time ago by Olmert. Get your facts straight.
9. When was a ONE solder returned ALIVE by the Arab ?
Nebojsa Yitzchak M ,   Toronto   (06.27.06)
Whining and indulgence into BIZARE but malignant DEDICATION to IDIOCITY really amazes me.. Arab return our boys in 200 peaces we send them 200 murderers alive why? BECAUSE IDIOTS have made a mockery out of justice. Country is at brink of anarchy, because Stalinists need “terror” to “justify” their oppressive measures to protect the last Stalinist entity on this planet. This government is busy to split wedge amongst the Jewish communities instead to defend THEM. Negotiation with the terrorists in Madrid, Oslo and the Camp David, brought just more anarchy in Israel. Once when terrorists were released myriads of potential terrorists learn while fighting and killing the Jews there are no consequences, being friendly to the Jews brings a certain DEATH to Arab in Israel. So “negotiations” are creating army of murderers which have no fear of JUSTICE. It is the job for them! If one kills a Jew he goes to jail? He spends there what year or few but then he is released HE WLAKS on the “STUDENT EXCHANGE PROGRAME” his colleagues kidnap a soldier or civilian whatever and promise that they will return all PIECES of him if you release 278 of their colleagues (murderous thugs). Well this character is now well educated in the Jail how to kill more Jews without being caught. Now he can kill 10 Jews and he will get BICYCLE and a job as a police officer. Job gives him an great opportunity to grow in career by killing 100 Jews he got a car (most likely your stolen car) and he become an “moderate official” that government idiots are now negotiating with. If he succeed (like Arafat) to kill 1,000 Jews Israel will give him 1/3 of a country and Jet escort and a respect of a “statement”. Is this story bizarre? Or are the LOCAL idiots gone amok.. Negotiation with the terrorists is partnership in CRIME.
10. Urge this condi...
Israeli   (06.27.06)
11. #7
(06.27.06)
Good point, I guess I will go out now and kidnap every Israeli Palestinian I see. Be back later.
12. What a sad dilemma
Kirk ,   Tel-Aviv, Israel   (06.27.06)
Itamar residents, the ones who attacked our soldiers and tore our flag by cursing and refusing The State of Israel, now need the state and its security forces to rescue one of them. Thanks god that I'm not a soldier, I wouldn't move my finger for them..
13. # 3
(06.27.06)
You did of course mean martial law although perhaps with Marshal law we would get lots of money.
14. missing teen
marijke ,   libanon   (06.27.06)
what is doing this teen in west bank?
15. Hitch-hikers in West Bank should be arrested
Karen R ,   USA   (06.27.06)
Enough already. Hitch-hiking in the West Bank in spite of terrorists declaring they are going to kidnap Israelis? We need a military crack-down on settlers flouting both the law and common sense. When we (hopefully) get this boy back he should be prosecuted, and maybe his fitness for the army should be questioned. Do we really want someone this foolish commanding a tank and risking the lives of his soldiers? Maybe also, his parents should be prosecuted, and the leaders of his school and youth groups punished for not making sure their kids don't risk their lives. Right now IDF soldiers are risking their lives to find this idiot, as opposed to those trying to find the soldier who was kidnapped while doing his duty. Enough already!
16. American Dave Levi
Jewess ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.27.06)
Maybe you don't know that many Israelis cannot afford to buy or run cars ($6/gal gasoline) and that buses run only infrequently if at all between homes and schools, etc. Schools do not provide buses for students like in the US, but parents have to arrange it separately and it costs, too. Reality is it would be great, but there are sacrifices for Jews to live here and one is taking risks with our lives and even our children's lives every single day. That does not mean we should be made criminals for it or that every effort at rescue should not be made because of it. STOP BLAMING THE VICTIMS!!!!!!!!!!!
17. #7
mimi ,   ny   (06.27.06)
you are not a jew.you are a dhimmi,liveing in londonstan.
18. #14
Jane   (06.27.06)
Whatever your politics, any person should be able to go anywhere without fear of harm if he has no ill intention,
19. #7 who are these people
Don Saliman ,   Nahal oz, Israel   (06.27.06)
It could be that the terrorist in the west bank kidnapped an Israeli. What should Israel do,say pretty please. This Dud was last seen in Jerusalem on his way home and he lives in the wet bank. It will not explode in your face as you are save and sound in London. My soul as an Israeli and a Jew is a very proud soul. I am outraged that a, Jew like you, will condemn Israel for trying to find an Israeli citizen that may have been kidnapped. I guess you have been watching too much of the BBC and reading the Guardian. Tell me,if a Jew was kiddnapped in England would you condemn England for going house to house trying to rescue him? By the way, I am embarrassed,that a fellow Jew,is anti-Israel, like you.
20. American Karen R
Jewess ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.27.06)
Once again, this is Israel, not America and hitchhiking is a way of life here. I am a grandmother and I hitchhiked to work for two years from my home in Judea. I was not paid enough to afford to buy a car. Jews hitchhike with their fellow Jews, people who live like them. These roads were built by our taxes and connect our communities to the cities. We have every right to use them and expect to be safe on them. When an Arab has been successful kidnapping a Jew it is usually because he has dressed himself up to look like a Jew. This is how the car bomber got a ride with the people from Kedumim and then blew up those who had thought to do him a kindness. IT IS NOT ILLEGAL TO TRAVEL BETWEEN YOUR HOME AND SCHOOL OR WORK!!!!!!!!!! THE ANSWER IS NOT TO CRIMINALIZE THE VICTIMS BUT TO RID OURSELVES OF THE TRUE CRIMINALS. STOP JUDGING ISRAELIS BY AMERICAN STANDARDS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
21. #15 right on the money
Joe Tawil ,   NY,USA   (06.27.06)
you are right , no one in his right mind would just go Hitch-hiking in the West Bank , while Palestinians are not allowed to travel between town and villages for work or schools ....this is simply arrogance and disrespect at highist order ...those teens are so brian-washed it seems , they lost touch with reality ....God helps us all
22. after "black september" from jordan,give them a black july..
stephane ,   france   (06.27.06)
that they will remember for ever.make them pay very hard what they do to the jews.kill all the terrorists and all the europeans who will try to lick their ass during the battle.don't forget that if the pals had our army and we were with their weapons,they would have exterminate us since a long time ago,without any hesitation(like we have too much).never be human to them,they are barbarians! no mercy! show them that to kidnapp a jew is not only the worse for us but also for them.
23. Advice to the kidnappers
nour ,   gaza   (06.27.06)
If I were you I would do my unsurpassed effort to release the poor kidnapped soldier, just to have mercy with his parents, siblings and his intimate companions; we both do not need to feel more pain. However it would most likely be a lesson to those who brand Palestinian being terrorists as well as a slap in the face of the government and those who demand for a bloody response.
24. When I lived in Israel I hitch-hiked too
Karen R ,   USA   (06.27.06)
I know what you're talking about - having lived in Israel for years - and also being a citizen. However, never would I have attempted to hitch-hike in an Arab area. I agree with you that it is difficult to get around. Perhaps there should be designated hitch-hiking areas which are guarded, and hitch-hiking is forbidden outside of them. Perhaps more regular buses would help. But I stand by my proposal that haphazard hitch-hiking should be forbidden. BTW those roads weren't built by YOUR tax dollars but by the tax dollars of those INSIDE the green line. And maybe the neighbors wouldn't dislike you so much if your friends quit destroying their property and trying to force them out of their homes? When I lived in Israel after the 6-day War nobody thought of "annexing" the territories - that craziness came later.
25. #23
Jane   (06.27.06)
Nour. Enough slaps in the face. It is the right thing to do. And one right thing leads to another right thing. And who knows what that could lead to?
26. 14 # 18
marijke ,   libanon   (06.27.06)
steeling land is an sick intention
27. This is what happens when the IDF is a paper tiger
Caligula's Horse ,   Solomon's Stables   (06.27.06)
When all our tanks and planes can do is some shufuni ya nas, once used to be a small and smart army, today it's big, sluggish and run by pathetic politicians.
28. #23
Joe ,   Brooklyn, NY   (06.27.06)
Maybe if more people thought like you Palestinians would not be branded terrorists, and nobody would demand that the Israeli government provide a bloody response. However, those who do kidnap soldiers and settlers, and those who do fire rockets at schools and hospitals in Sderot, kibbutzim near Gaza, and Ashkelon unfortunately have a louder voice than you do. People who fire Qassam rockets teach a lesson to those of us who supported the disengagement. The only logical inference is that if Israel left the West Bank, there would be Qassams and Katyushas falling on Jerusalem. And you wonder why Israel is in no hurry to actually end the occupation!
29. missing teen
Sofie ,   Israel   (06.27.06)
And what is a marijke(dutch woman) doing in Libanon?
30. #7 - Kim, the word "Jew" is capitalized
Zionist ,   Israel   (06.27.06)
Concentration camps were for sending Jews to the ovens en mass for extermination, like when you call the exterminator and he kills all the cockroaches in your house. Jews were also thought to be morally equivalent to insects in the Nazi psyche. Claiming that any part of the West Bank is a concentration camp is insane and clearly ignorant on your part. I'm willing to bet that you're an avid reader of the Guardian because statements like these are classic anti-Zionist material. You don't even know that Jews live in the West Bank, so how do you expect to pass judgment on a conflict you have no clue about? Please, study up. Learn the facts from normal sources, not the left wing crap going around in Londonistan. You have no idea what you're in for in a few years if you people don't wake up.
Next talkbacks
Back to article