News
Abbas: Gaza offensive a crime
Ali Waked
Published: 28.06.06, 14:44
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
61 Talkbacks for this article
31. #3 mike go back to USA.
(06.28.06)
NO NEED FOR PALIS SYMPATHIZER HERE MORON.
32. 14
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (06.28.06)
i'm being sarcastic - there is NO peace movement in gaza, and i do not believe that they can hate israel more than they already do.
33. If you cant do the time dont do the crime
(06.28.06)
34. To # 29
Monitor ,   Earth   (06.28.06)
You mentioned : Muslims like animals....hmmmmmm guess where I have read this senctence? It is in Tora, not only Muslims are meant by that, but all people except Jews. I hope you can say that to your friends in US and Europe
35. Michael of London
Rustum ,   London, UK   (06.28.06)
Honestly, the sheer gall and blatant racism of your post: "They must be taught that their actions are those of animals and be trained like dogs! " Who do you think you are? Have you no idea how deeply offensive your statement is. We all understand that Israel is going through a 'tense' time at the moment - but to call all Moslems dogs is simply a reflection upon your own thought power. Oh dear, oh dear, oh dear. It doesn't take much to bring out the rabid racist in some people. "Potty trained like dogs?" Would you go on BBC's question time and use the same language? Shame on you.
36. Mr. Abbas, KIDNAPPING is a CRIME & A MAJOR SIN AGAINST G-D
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (06.28.06)
Bible, Exodus 21:16 He who kidnaps a man, whether he sells him or he is found in his possession, shall surely be put to death. Bible, Exodus 20 YOU SHALL NOT MURDER Bible, Leviticus 24:17 If a man takes the life of any human being, he shall surely be put to death.
37. You brought it on yourself you Dumbasses
Jacob ,   DC   (06.28.06)
How many times can you poke at a bear, and get upset when it attacks you? You just found out. G-d bless IDF, watch out for their traps, and be careful
38. #36 HE HAS NO GOD HE HAS..............
ERIC ,   Israel   (06.28.06)
ALLAH the terrorist
39. To 34 - liar
Shai ,   Israel   (06.28.06)
The Torah was written 2500 years before the first Muslim. Muslims flatter themselves then to assume we have an opinion about them as Muslims. The attitude of the Jewish religion toward people who follow the basic laws of all religions (7 Laws of Noah) is in fact much better than you and most others have toward Jews. Jews do not require non-Jews to be Jews in order to go to heaven or be "saved" unlike most other major religions. You probably read one of those hate sites quoting things in the Talmud out of context. As an alternative, I suggest you refer to the following web page. http://talmud.faithweb.com/
40. Rustum @35 Sorry but I must agree w/ Mike..
Jacob ,   DC   (06.28.06)
Where are your moderate Muslum brothers? King Abdullah from Jordan is the only one I know of. Mike is speaking then therefore, of your crazy, psycotic, and self absorbed Radical Fanatics that I would have no problem if they just dropped dead right now as you read this. More moderate Muslums need to make their voice heard, and not just cry and whine "Free Palestine". Enter into communication and defend being moderate. Your moderates do hide from your Radical Imams, because the Moderates have a flawed view of Islam. Islamic Schools teach kids the true meaning of Islam, and watch how easy they become terrorists. Hence, acting like dogs. Your position is undefendable in my opinion.
41. "Chemical weapons" ?
ThornBird ,   USA   (06.28.06)
If they were that dumb, it would give Israel the right to level all of Gaza, and send the refugees to Egypt where they truly do belong.
42. #34 The TORAH is FROM G-D. You have BLASPHEMED G-D
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (06.28.06)
The Bible is from the Holy One - Ruler of heaven and earth. The disgusting things you write are NOT in the Bible. Do you not fear G-D? Bible, Psalm 119:120 My flesh trembles for fear of You, and I am afraid of Your judgments. G-D's requirement for all humanity is KINDNESS. Bible, Micah 6:8 And what does the L-RD require of you but to do justice, to love kindness, and to walk humbly with your G-D.
43. Gaza offensive
George ,   San Jose, USA   (06.28.06)
An eye for an eye will not level the playing field.
44. Nothing wrong with collective punishment
Steven ,   San Francisco   (06.28.06)
If it wasn't effective it wouldn't be used. In cases such as this, where there is collective responsibility , there should be collective punishment as well. Justice requires the punishment must on all levels fit the crime. And it's a no brainer that in this case justice seems to be in the process of being served. What the IDF has so far been doing is 100% appropriate and in fact overdue.
45. Jacob of DC
Rustum ,   London, UK   (06.28.06)
My position is untenable - that Moslems should not be bombed like dogs. Phew - it doesn't take much to bring out the rabid war-mongering blood-lusting Zionist fanatics does it. In any civilised society, the expression "moslems should be bombed like dogs" would not find acceptance. But not here... lovely little pilpulistic peregrinations to justify barbaric stances. Well done, Jacob. Great human. And, if Mike was only speaking of "your crazy, psychotic... radical fanatics" why did he not specify? His statement was a great big ugly generalisation. Next thing, you'll be writing in defence of Jibril from Geneva and Karen Umm Faswa from Sao Paolo.
46. #11 (Dickchard Hitching) and #28 (Karim)
Arabs against ,   war crimes by arabs   (06.28.06)
Thank you for your comments stating that collective punishment and bombing civilian infrastructures are war crimes. We as Arabs against war crimes by arabs have long sought for your support. Since you are obviously not hypocrites, we appreciate your condemning the indiscriminate kassam missiles fired at israeli civilians and infrastructure targets by arabs in gaza. Thank you.
47. Rustum
Jacob ,   DC   (06.28.06)
Where are your moderate Muslums? You did not respond to my question, just putting a bunch of words in my mouth and typos on your post to me. Micheal never said "Moslems should be bombed like dogs", nor did I. You are a lousy debater Rustum, either that or a 12 year old kid, in any event, that seems to be your intelligence. If you want to debate, the first rule is, don't put words in peoples mouths and try to represent it as what they said. No one innocent deserves to be bombed period, but your Muslum brothers kidnapped a man, which makes them coward dogs yes, and they deserve to be bombed. I don't want Gaza leveled, just as I hope you don't want the Jews in the sea. Do you? Be a man and answer sincerly.
48. Abbas is acting just like Arafat-pretend to be "helpful",do
NOTHING,Alan ,   SA   (06.28.06)
49. #15 ... in total agreement
kez   (06.28.06)
Palestinians are the only 'exceptional' race that never grows and produce except 'human bombs' and they whined like pathetic undignified fools when the intl. aid in billions are heaped upon them. What more do they want?? All they ever want is the blood of every Jew; a blatant outcry of jealousy because they didn't have the blessings from G-d! Palestinians are Arab refugees from Jordan and even Jordan don't want them back. Which Arab world are welcoming them into their land? They have taken Gaza but the land will never be fruitful for them.
50. Away
Sean ,   Glasgow   (06.28.06)
Away you go you ignorant little man. The Palestinians have no army they are about to be crushed and slaughtered for one Israeli soldier what of the innocent people when a government decides thats scores maybe even hundreds dead for a few freedom fighters who have been told not only to accept an illegal occupation of their land and lie down but to roll over and beg for mercy. Why would someone want to kidnap an israeli soldier? No wait a minute why would someone think that there only way of striking back is to strap a bomb to themselves? Have you ever really thought about and perhaps maybe consulted how the present conflict evolved to what it is today. Brutalise a people lock them in a cage like gaza and you will breed terrorists. Violence ncites violence!
51. Rustum the gloating sneering little manipulator
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.28.06)
always the same Ranter and Raver wanting to control - but never bringing anything that is part of the subject at question - Only wanting to control hatefully a Jewish Website an agenda hiding behind is words in trying to proclaim ...... he doesn't like violence ....... but being himself a violent person ... having used language against Jews ...... that is obnoxious and the last of taste of any post..... He lies about it and says he never did ..... but it was removed from this website http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3267360,00.html POST 22 and also http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3267360,00.html Post: 21: I kept the text - words against Jews that were Racist and vile
52. #51 Rustum
HBendor ,   New York USA   (06.28.06)
Rustum wrote, Quote:- Calling for 100 dead innocent Palestinians is completely beyond the pale. http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3267360,00.html… Unquote. Innocent Palestinians? Hmmm… Where can I find ONE? Could you point the finger in this direction, when they are ALL CLONES OF EACH OTHER? Now go and call me names, I would expect that from another 'Air head' from 'Perfidious Albion'. BTW did you read the book; THE AMRITSAR MASSACRE. 1919 General Dyer in the Punjab? Go read and educate yourself! For besides your grandiloquent verbiage there is emptiness akin the Sahara Desert in your Psyche.
53. abbas..
jason ,   usa   (06.28.06)
hamas delcared war on israel this is what war is about
54. Abbas the butcher from the Munich massacre of Jews talks
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.29.06)
about Crimes - this man - Arafat in a designer suit - has a nerve thinking of that - it is the constant behavior of Arabs to avoid their own terrorism and lynching - mayhem etc but turn around and treat the free world as the aggressor - what a nerve indeed Lies which doesn't let them go even red in their faces - because it is their way of life That's another reason why they are so backwards in any and all........
55. 28 Karim, Morocco : can your read ?No civilians got bombed
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.29.06)
on the other hand - You obviously don't understand - to fight Terrorism is Israel's right: Now stop posting silly stuff - it really makes you look stupid - and one wonders about your age - ability to understand facts on the ground International Law states that "protected persons may not be used to render certain points or areas immune from military operations," nullifying the Argument that the IDF violates Intl. Law. If a terrorist is hiding in a populated area and civilians are killed, then ALL legal and moral responsibility is on the terrorists` heads: "Palestinian Atrocities, Israeli Retaliations And The Laws Of War", By Professor Louis Rene Beres (Professor Department of Political Science, Purdue University, PhD. Princeton, 1971) http://www.israelinsider.com/views/authors/beres.htm Now either wake up to reality - or otherwise you are coming to the Jewish Website only to propogate and pursue vicious Propaganda Because you have an agenda of Israel Hate Israel Hate for Jews = Jew Hate
56. Mind bending atrocious racism
Rustum ,   London, UK   (06.29.06)
"Innocent Palestinians? Hmmm… Where can I find ONE?" Phew! and I wonder how you managed to convince so many academic institutions of your "neutrality". Academia in the service of the war mongers. There were many like you. Perhaps you are really the reincarnatino of Professor Schaeder of Berlin fame.
57. Rustum gloating sneering little manipulator Strikes again
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.29.06)
58. To Gabrielle: cutting power and water is a crime
Karim ,   Morocco   (06.29.06)
Your criminal IDF bombed a power station that cut electricity and water to almost 1 million people, who have MANY CHILDREN among them. My common sense tells me this is a crime and uncalled for, simply because one soldier was captured. It is revenge and collective punishment, which Israeli do best. I hate no Jews or Judaism. Why should I? is any Jew automatically an Israeli? I don't think so. There are many who are not Israeli and do not wish to be one! Israel is the problem and for that reason I have no respect for this criminal state of oppression and occupation. But I have respect of Switzerland. It is a peaceful state, worth of all praise.
59. 58 Karim: You need to grow up and stop
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.29.06)
telling me you like Switzerland - honestly - try your bubble talk with some other kids educate yourself for the 1000's time since you bore us on Jewish Websites - go and post in Your arab stuff - which is your speed now read my post 55 and don't come back you make NO sense - must be your age
60. #56 Rustum's name calling...
HBendor ,   New York USA   (06.29.06)
Academia comes is different colors and shades... Pardonez moi... I am a National of my country and I call them as I see them. Now if you want to call me a name, it is OK, for I will be wearing this on my lapel as a symbol of pride. The Arabs Rustum, do not belong in my PATRIMONY; the world has created 23 countries this past century for their self-determination. The Jews Mr. Rustum have only ONE country and they aim at preserving it for the ingathering of the Jewish Exile from around the world. I hope it is not too difficult for you to understand this simple truism.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article