News
Bereaved brother: Israel should negotiate Shalit's release
Aviram Zino
Published: 03.07.06, 13:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
56 Talkbacks for this article
31. 22: We do not beg Israel as you do with US and EU
Adam ,   Gaza   (07.03.06)
Hey Goldwater...Stop your bullshit We do not beg Israel for money...It is our money stolen by Israel as land and culture. When we ask about money, we ask about our right, but not the way you do when you blackmail Germany for Auswitsch or when you beg US for money.
32. Rabid Anti-Israeli/Anti Semitic Incitement on Hamas website
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (07.03.06)
Rabid anti-Israeli and anti-Semitic incitement on Hamas-owned media Download PDF file (69 KB) http://www.terrorism-info.org.il/malam_multimedia/English/eng_n/pdf/hamas_incitement_e.pdf
33. Bring Gilad home
Chrisona ,   Chicago.IL   (07.03.06)
The point is not the issue of negotiating with terrorists. Nobody wants to do that, obviously. The point is retrieving young Gilad Shalit. That is the priority. Once he is back home, the issue of negotiating with terrorists needs to be addressed. as part of the larger problem of Israel's inability to root out terrorism.
34. Goldwater, shut it
Rustum ,   London, UK   (07.03.06)
Listen you stupid ranting little bint - this is the website of a newspaper, not some parochial little demonational website. Kindly refrain from purveying more of your untruths. Yedioth Aharonot is a newspaper - get it? Yedioth Aharonot is not a synagogue. Now back off and shut it and let the debate continue - everyone is just about sick sick sick to death of your racist rubbish - ending up with your diktats as to who may write and who may not. If you want final clarification upon whether YNET is a newspaper or a Jewish website, then write to the editors. You simply are one of the most atrocious foul-mouthed inhumane dictator-manquée in the world. Take your hatred elsewhere. Yes, take it to a "Jewish website" but not here.
35. Adam - she hasn't yet come down from the banana tree
Rustum ,   London, UK   (07.03.06)
36. 30 + 31 Adam desperate for recognition from
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (07.03.06)
his Arab buddies what A joke they are ........ ROFL
37. 34: Rustom, I fully agree with you
Adam ,   Gaza   (07.03.06)
38. Here again Rabid Anti-Semitic Hamas exposed
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (07.03.06)
Rabid anti-Israeli and anti-Semitic incitement on Hamas-owned media Download PDF file (69 KB) http://www.terrorism-info.org.il/malam_multimedia/English/eng_n/pdf/hamas_incitement_e.pdf
39. Intelligence & Terrorism Information Center
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (07.03.06)
Intelligence & Terrorism Information Center :: http://www.terrorism-info.org.il/engsite/home/default.asp
40. 36: Goldwater: you are a racisism stupid beggar
Adam ,   Gaza   (07.03.06)
41. goldwater's nemesis
Rustum ,   London   (07.03.06)
Amayreh dredges around the seedy underbelly of Judaism exactly the same way as you dredge around the seedy underbelly of Islam. You two should get together in a room and make babies. But only after you've been in a sulphuric mikveh, ya habibti.
42. Here again rabid anti-Moslem hatred exposed
Rustum ,   London, UK   (07.03.06)
Just read through the posts and anything by a Bunnie, Goldwater, Shani, Bendor -
43. 40 Adam: Gaza: now who has been doing all the begging ?
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (07.03.06)
You Arabs - but those days are over - No more of our tax money stop posting utter rubbish :::::::::::: Facts: International funds transferred to PA used to finance arms purchases http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Government/Communiques/2006/International+funds+transferred+to+PA+used+to+finance+arms+purchases+17-May-2006.htm The Funding for Peace Coalition just posted a summary of the Palestinian Authority accounts for the three calendar years 2003 - 2005. http://eufunding.org/accountability/PublishedAccounts.html Former mayor of Nablus went to the streets collecting donations for Hamas from the local population and said “These donations are our way of telling the world that we can live without them, and our children are paying what the Europeans should be paying,” http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2006/05/12/politics/main1616373.shtml PA Authority accounts & Their kleptocracy a la Al Capone (OUR TAXMONEY PAYS) http://groups.msn.com/EretsYisraelLeAmYisrael/general.msnw?action=get_message&mview=0&ID_Message=7062&LastModified=4675572613565911670 What Can We Learn from the Palestine Investment Fund Report? - Mark Sloman http://www.jcpa.org/brief/brief2-27.htm
44. 41Rustum is ranting with anger and internal Violence ROFL
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (07.03.06)
You are SICK - to start posting sexual stuff now - real SICK indeed you sick Muslim extremist
45. Irshad Manji website:
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (07.03.06)
The official website of Irshad Manji, author of The Trouble with Islam Today. Islamic reform - progressive Islam. http://www.muslim-refusenik.com/
46. Those Arabs that stand behind Israel
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (07.03.06)
ARABS STAND BEHIND ISRAEL http://tinyurl.com/dl2dm and : Walid Shoebat website - From Hate to Love http://www.shoebat.com/ So what about Wafa Sultan: (a MEMRI clip)... by listening to this - it is in Arabic and subtitled in English. Wafa Sultan, which was interviewed in chain Al-Jazeera in Qatar: She warns the islamist radicals and their idea: Don't miss this and pass along ! http://switch5.castup.net/frames/20041020_MemriTV_Popup/video_480x360.asp?ai=214&ar=1050wmv&ak=null what about Dr. Ali ......... http://www.faithfreedom.org What about Nonie Darwish tells it like it is www.noniedarwish.com http://www.charityadvantage.com/sss/NONIEDARWISH.asp What about Brigitte Gabriel Interview http://www.phyllis-chesler.com/db_video.html Fast Connections: http://tudorproductions.com/media/Duke_Brigitte_interview.wmv http://americancongressfortruth.com/media/Duke_Brigitte_interview.wmv Slow connections: http://tudorproductions.com/media/Duke_Brigitte_interview_s.wmv http://americancongressfortruth.com/media/Duke_Brigitte_interview_s.wmv
47. you go goldwater!!!!!!!
alan ,   frisco   (07.03.06)
we missed your debunking urls
48. #44
Rustum ,   London, UK   (07.03.06)
There was nothing "sexual" in my suggestion that you become Mrs Amayreh. Two people cut from the same cloth, same weave, same mentality. You just cannot look in the mirror.
49.  Militant Islam Monitor Their new website
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (07.03.06)
Their new posts http://www.militantislammonitor.org/
50. Gabrielle Goldwater
Adam ,   Falasteen   (07.03.06)
It is good that you b**** keep writing your own name and location. One day, the swiss police will be knocking on your door and dragging your vanilla ice cream a** away for hate crimes. Everything you post is full of hate and does not help even he Israelis.
51. no room for terror
jeff ,   chicago, USA   (07.03.06)
It is easy for many of you to wonder why Israel doesn't just release a bunch of suspected and convicted terrorists and terror supporters in exchange for one soldier. After all, isn't it worth it? Well, frankly, hell no! See, the proper way to negotiate the release of militant terrorists is through peaceful negotiation and reasoned dialogue. When Hamas kidnapped this soldier after murdering his fellow soldiers, they violated their own truce and lost any ability for negotiations. Plain and simple - kidnapping, extortion, and terror tactics MUST be met with military actions. Yes, in the past Israel has mistakenly negotiated with terrorists. The lesson was costly and the result is that NOW, in THIS situation, some of you seem to want them to do likewise. So what happens when you do what someone wants because they used terror? You encourage terror. The FACT is that terrorism, in any form, must be punished. The arab community would be better served by publicly condemning terrorism, not siding with terrorists. The reason so many now fear muslims is because of their two faced behavior when it comes to terrorism. They condemn it (sometimes) and then support it by decrying israel for reacting appropriately. What would happen if mexican terrorists kidnapped an american soldier? Or french terrorists kidnapped a british soldier? Or german terrorists kidnapped an italian soldier? What would happen? Full scale war. There is no negotiation and if anything happens to this soldier, gaza will be flattened and it will deserve it.
52. #50 and #51
Rustum ,   London, UK   (07.04.06)
Well said Adam. I will be opening the champagne the day we hear about the knock on that door and the arrest as part of the collective punishment of Genevans. Just look what their brilliant Foreign Minister said - they'll be rounding up the naafitha fi il 'uqad soon. And #51 - agreed, Jeff. No room for the sort of terror particularly enjoyed by some residents of Geneva.
53. deals for Gilad?
Hilda ,   USA   (07.04.06)
The only deal Israel should make is to tell Hamas--We have your leaders ; Every day that goes by that yu do not release Gilad we will kill one of your leadrs and then we will start in on the prisoners in the jails. Israel has to fight them as they fight and not show them any leeway.
54. Prisoner Exchange
Hilda ,   USA   (07.05.06)
To negociate an exchange one must have a poartner whom we can trust. Does anyone trust Hamas to keep its word? How do we know if the Cpl is still alive.(please G-d) And you have to know that if indeed Israel capitulates to Hamas' demand that noone will ever be safe not soldier or civilian from kidnap. Remember how Israel freed thousands ofsodiers for the remains of dead sodiers and they turned out to be bogus. Instead whyt not use those ministers who hve been arrested. Fight them like they fight--Threaten to kill one a day until Shalit is released--and then do it. I don;t think these guys want to go see their 72 vurgubs. Only the dumb underlings believe that junk.
55. Adam..31. 22: We do not beg Israel as you do with US and EU
Heba Dansk ,   US   (09.26.06)
Arabs living in Gaza or the West Bank not begging Israel for money. There is an issue of the "right of return" which must be addressed. Palestinian Arabs constantly repeat claims of rights based on Resolution 194, in particular the right to return to lands that are now part of the State of Israel. That position has no basis, certainly not in Resolution 194. General Assembly resolutions, unlike those of the Security Council, are non-binding and essentially are only suggestions. Resolution 194 does not use the language of "rights" or "right of return". The resolution does not specify the nationality of the refugees; recall that the Palestinian Arab refugees, who voluntarily left Israel at the urging of their leaders, are approximately equal in number to the Jews who fled persecution from Arab countries. Any "right of return" or right to compensation is equally present in Resolution 194 for Arabs and Jews. Since the resolution also specifies that its recommendations would apply to refugees who wish "to live at peace with their neighbors," Arabs would be excluded. It was the Arabs who began the war in 1947 and they continue to be at war with Israel today. Any ultimate resolution of this issue will certainly be in terms of limited return (perhaps limited to the few living Arabs who actually once resided in Israel) plus a forumula of compensation for both Arabs and Jews who were displaced by events surrounding the 1948 War of Independence. ----------------------------- No one (Arab or Jew) has a "right of return". Jews who fled Arab persecution from 1948 to 1956 should have no right of return to Arab lands, and Arabs who ran away in 1948 and 1967 should have no right of return either. This should end all argument. Yet the Jews accept this judgment, while the Arabs reject EVERYTHING. - Walid Shoebat -----------------------------
56. Rustum 35. she hasn't yet come down from the banana tree
Heba Dansk   (09.26.06)
Abraham is the father of the Jews. Who is your father ?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article