News
Hamas: Kidnapped soldier well-treated
Ali Waked
Published: 07.07.06, 20:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
45 Talkbacks for this article
1. What a joke that Hamas is.......however
Tal ,   Israel   (07.07.06)
nothing at all surprises me these days. For example: Bush administration voices concern over loss of life in IDF Gaza incursion (AP) Bastard! Two faced hypocrite! And if anyone wonders why there will be a prisoner release look to the west. Our arms have been twisted off the sockets. One would expect this from the EU, UN and the rest of the world, but the US! Bush is no better then the rest. Furthermore, if we wonder why Jews get no respect, why our blood means nothing to anyone, look to the very top. Hamas, Abbas and all the rest are mere puppets. Next time one decides to bash the idiotic left and the unending bias of MAIN STREAM MEDIA, look twice. The white house is sounding more left as the moments pass. Doing so under the pretense of lies at the expense of Jew blood. I have had it!
2. Talking is a Big Mistake
Dave Levi ,   Burbank. USA   (07.07.06)
Again, and again and again, Israel makes the same mistakes, they never seem to learn. Olmert says one thing, Peres another, Peretz something else and the intelligence czars contradict the aforesaid persons. Why in heavens name is Israel talking to Hamas to begin with? They should simply state the gov't (Olmert's) policy...we will not acqueisce to extortion, no release of anyone. You give us our soldier, and stop the rocket firings into Israel...then we might talk. Period. End of sentence. Now, we learn that female prisoners are having babies in jail. Okay, why did they commit crimes while pregnant? How did they become pregnant in jail I wonder, from other prisoners? Maybe the Arab prisoners, not having recourse to 72 virgins, chose the next best thing? I say over again, a 12.00 noose is punishment for capital offenses...until Israel wakes up however, don't hold your breath.
3. Don't negotiate with terrorist kidnappers ever
DANNY ,   America   (07.07.06)
Kill them and their leadership
4. Question
Jeremiah ,   USA   (07.07.06)
Why is it that when Israel takes Palestinians prisoners they are not described as kidnapped, but when Palestinians capture an Israeli soldier, it is described as a kidnapping?
5. Never
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (07.07.06)
You will never see that day coming. Israel will never release one terrorist under pressure. We will find Gilat and free him and will find the terrorist and kill them. Then we are going to set Gaza on fire.
6. No.......
Marcel ,   Florida   (07.07.06)
Stop the Israeli surender to Hamas. the only one thing lift here is to Nuke Gaza
7. FREE, FREE GALID
ALAN ,   FRISCO   (07.07.06)
WE WANT HIM BACK IF HE IS ALIVE, PUBLISH A VIDEO HE IS ALIVE AND HAVE A HAMAS REPRESENTATIVE SWEAR IT IS TRUE ON PAIN OF EXECUTION.
8. treat him as they treat Palestinine Prisoners
one Sol ,   jerusalem   (07.07.06)
I think they should treat him as good as they treat Palestinian prisoners and kidnapped Parliaments /Ministers....that is really fair. maybe no french fries for gilad...:0(
9. Answer to #4
Yariv ,   Tel Aviv   (07.07.06)
Because they (Abbas) don't claim that he is alive, and they never provided a proof that he is alive. The Red Cross has not seen him. Arab thugs in Israel jails even have TV, often cell phones, visitors, publishing and distributing letters, etc. And they are not taken as soldiers but are murderers and suicide bombers. No Arab was takes just for fun but you can be sure that they kill ANY Jew they can get hands on. OK.
10. .. anything about flying soccers? while we are at "it"
Nebojsa Yitzchak M ,   Toronto   (07.07.06)
Let’s say we recipprocicate something happened (any hurt) to our boy something will happen to their “boys” for certain.. one of ours FEW of theirs.
11. Don't Do It, Don't Give In
emanon ,   USA   (07.07.06)
The terrorists have never negotiated in good faith before this. Why should this time be aby different? This has gone beyond returning Shalit. This is about the waste of forcing good people off their land, having their land ravaged by terrorists and then reclaiming that land for the rightful owners.
12. You Jews abroad are pathetic!
Khalid ,   Gaza City   (07.07.06)
With all your tough racist talk, why don't you try living in the Holy Land?! Linda Rivera threatening to kill 1.3 million innocent civillians by "burning Gaza." And Marcel the idiot suggesting to nuke Gaza, thinking that Israel would be immune from the bomb. You don't know what it's like to live in Israel and you don't know what it's like to live in the Palestinian Territories, so don't comment please. You justify this invasion why? Because we captured ONE soldier, while you have captured 9,000 of our people, of which thousands are innocent. You have to know that people need to be treated equally, you have to know that you are not "chosen ones" and that all God's people are chosen. You have to start complying with international humanitarian laws. Then there might be peace. Stop your racism.
13. #4 your answer
Mike ,   Israel   (07.07.06)
When Israel captures terorists its does not ask for ransom. They go to trial and get sentenced most of the time. To bad we dont have the death penalty. But when Hamas cross a border takes a soldier and then ask in return to free prisoners thats kidnaping.
14. To #10
Oqua Tangin Wann ,   Planet Mars   (07.07.06)
Do you ever seen a flying soccer ?
15. Hamas is protecting the rights of the Palestinians
Review ,   USA   (07.07.06)
FIRST: The Palestinians are the native of this land. Jews, are coming from all over the world for fake reasons. For thos who will argue about the word Palestine its origine etc, Palestinians only mean the people living on this land prior to the establishment of Israel. Palestinians, whom in blood, are extension of all populations living in the Holy Land since pre historic times. Currently, their language is primarily Arabic. Same as in Lebanon or Syria. The Arabic culture prevailed. The Palestinians are extension of Canaanite Phoenecian culture, convert Israelites, and Arabs of the 7t centruy. Basicly, the Holy Land has been occupied with people since pre historic times. Israelites invaded the Holy Land for sometime coming with Moses from egypt. They were invaders, they mingled with the Canaanites and their cultlre disappeared. Thefore, present Palestinians, are more original to this land. They are descendandts of all this mingiling throughout thousands of years. It is not justified for Jews from russia and Poland to uproot the Palestinians and support that. A Palestinian is 30% Chrisitan until 1930s, where many christians had to leave because of the zionism movement. Many muslims and christians, also left to other parts of the Arab world. Jews, or Israeli Jews are new comers to this area. They come under the umbrella of Judaism to occupy. Certainly, Jews never built Jerusalem as they claim. It was built by the Canaanite or Jebusite who themseleves came from inner Arabian Peninsula.
16. Hamas is full of bull...t
Natan ,   USA   (07.07.06)
I a Hamas statement it is said: His treatment is being done well and in a humanitarian way in accordance with the orders of our religion," the group said. What a bunch of "bull"..the same way you treated Eliyahu Asheri last week ?you bastards! Now as for your call to the Israelis to pressure their government to abide by your demands or you will excecute Gilad(according to your religious laws??) So let me call on the Palestinians in Gaza to pressure Hamas to free Giald or (1) we will blow your ear drums with sonic booms daily. (2) you will not have electricity as long as you hold him. (3) you can forget what running water feels like .. we will make your life so miserable that you will regret the day you voted Hamas into power!!
17. #12...Khalid...
DR ,   Florida, USA   (07.07.06)
Although I agreee with some things you said, it is very hyypocritical to say that Israelis are racist. Your people teach their kids to hate from the minute they are born. You call Jews monkeys and dogs and are even willing to die if it means killing a few jews. Lokk in the mirror my friend. Your culture is one of hate, racism and terro and Israel will never treat you as equals when you hold these values and teach them to your children. Peace will come when all arabs and muslims start recognizing Israel, stop teching their children to hate Israel and when your people begin to be productive instead of destructive.
18. #5 IS AN IMPOSTER FALSELY USING MY NAME
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (07.07.06)
19. To #12 Khalid - The #5 Comment is AN IMPOSTER FALSELY USING
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (07.07.06)
my name. Ynet and Ynet readers know that I NEVER make those kind of statements. Also, I am quite sure the #6 comment is not Marcel. Marcel does not make that type of comment.
20. #6 to the fake imposter ALI at YNET
Marcel ,   Florida   (07.07.06)
Ali ,I will pray for you ! Like I said before to the phony shill posting as me . 'the fallout ,radiation would harm many many non moslems' So don't nuke Gaza just go in and kill every Palestinian with a weapon ,and seize all the weapons Got it ? you know ,defeat them . It's so sad that in one generation Israel has forgotten how to win ,how to fight and defeat the enemy. The left has shown weakness to the enemy and this has INSURED war . There is no stopping it ,unless Israel does Masada again ? With Olmert this is possible
21. Khalid, I will take that as a compliment
Cynic ,   USA   (07.07.06)
Usually what we hear coming out of Gaza is "Death to the Jews", so I guess I am fortunate to only being called pathetic.
22. #15 interesting argument but......
Cynic ,   USA   (07.07.06)
Funny thing is that Hamas and their ilk argue that it is muslim land. Problem is the Jews have been their long before the reliion of Islam even existed. Go figure.
23. To #12-Yes pathetic
Arie   (07.07.06)
That people like Olmert and peretz continue to prefer appeasement over security is definitely pathetic
24. to 14
Nebojsa Yitzchak M ,   Toronto   (07.07.06)
Not yet.. but pathological liars could put some interesting twist to it, I was hoping to hear a new "creative" leap. For example did you know that cartoons of "Tom and Jerry" are Jewish conspiracy? Iranian religious "ministry" come with that Tom (the cat) is Germany and "cute" mouse are Jews.. because Hitler called Jews an infestation of mice.. so cute Jerry was harrasing "poor" Tom and made mokery of the "clean nations". So flying soccers... I would not be surprised from those lying freaks to hear that Jews probably are taking their leaders to be "probed" into the Israeli flying soccers or something.. (perhaps they wish...).
25. #15 "Review"
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (07.07.06)
As in "Institute for Historical Review" What a complete load of bull scheiss.
26. #15
(07.07.06)
If you are saying Jews came from egypt to Israel, you are basically saying the bible is right. If the bible is right, it means that god gave us this land. It also means, as you say that everyone here speaks arabic, that if we were in egypt, it means we were not originated from them, or else why will they speak arabic and we hebrew? Our Jews come from all over the world, because the romans exiled us, from our land, renamed it from Israel to Phlistine and that's where the name origins from. You wouldn't know the word 'cnaan' if it wasn't for the bible. You wouldn't know your history if it wasn't for the bible. You wouldn't know what are days, what are dates, if it wasn't for the bible. The bible is true. That is not disputable, as a lot of the quran was copied from the bible. Quran contains hebrew words that were only in the bible. We, in blood, also come from this area. We were imprisoned by egypt and set free by god. If you don't want to be religious there are plenty of other explanations. Britain owned this land, britain gave us this land, thus, the land is ours. We shared the land until the arabs started fighting with us and wanted to take the rest. We conquered them, and now they cry. We've been attacked in 1967 so we will be destroyed, we have doubled our homeland's turf in 6 days. In those 6 days where we got attacked by mostly all arab countries (if it's directly or indirectly), we've had to conquer land to defend ourselves. Now you come here and cry about it, yet again. You kidnap our soldier, then you cry about us blowing you to hell (thats btw where you origin from). You attack us in plenty of wars, when we win, you cry 'occupation occupation'. You send terrorists to us and when we blow them up you call us war criminals. Basically, the holy land HAS been occupied with people since pre historic times. But we weren't the ones occupying it. Arabs invaded the holy land many times, in all of which they failed. It is not justified for Muslims from Jordan and egypt to uproot the Israelies and support that. Today, we have many christians living here. But show me how Jews get treated in arab countries. We also have plenty of muslims which we treat well. And also a lot of the muslim world runs to us when their own countries abuse them. Palestinians, or Muslim Palestinians are new comers to this area. They come under the umbrella of Islam to destroy and murder. Certainly, Muslims never built Jerusalem as they claim. It doesn't even appear in their own books. Every argument you make is bullshit, every thing you say can have the exact opposite arguement. You are not convincing anyone. I am the voice in your head which knows you are lying to yourself. Jews were here before anyone else was, this is not disputable. It says so in the bible, it says so in the quran. Adam and Hava are hebrew names, not Arab names or english names. Keep your propoganda to yourself, no one, especially on Jewish websites, believes your lies. Even the muslims know you're full of it. If god wanted you to have this land he would've given it to you. If the world wanted you to have this land, britain would've given it to you. Until you give the USA back to the indians, I'd suggest you log off.
27. #15 says it all and the world should listen
Allan ,   USA   (07.07.06)
According to #15 ( Review from USA) the conflict stems from Israel's existence -- and not a quarrel over the West Bank and Gaza. Those who naively believe that if only Israel gets out of the West Bank, then the Palestinians will end the conflict, take note. Once the conflict is seen from this perspective -- of absolute intolerance toward Israeli sovereignty -- then the resolution of the conflict requires a strategy other than simply "end the occupation of the WB and Gaza."
28. #12 khalid - Ezekiel 35
Marcel ,   Florida   (07.07.06)
Khalid you whine like a pitiful old dog on it's last bone.; I'm a Christian who has been to Israel many times and have seen the evil deeds of the Palestinin's first hand. My comment to you filisten who make war against the Jews . Why do you live ,you are better off dead or denouncing the lies of Israel's enemies . Soon the God of Israel will destroy all of you AS IT IS WRITTEN ; Thus says the Lord God: "Behold, O Mount Seir, I am against you; I will stretch out My hand against you, And make you most desolate; 4 I shall lay your cities waste, And you shall be desolate. Then you shall know that I am the Lord. 5 "Because you have had an ancient hatred, and have shed the blood of the children of Israel by the power of the sword at the time of their calamity, when their iniquity came to an end, 6 therefore, as I live," says the Lord God, "I will prepare you for blood, and blood shall pursue you; since you have not hated blood, therefore blood shall pursue you. 7 Thus I will make Mount Seir most desolate, and cut off from it the one who leaves and the one who returns. 8 And I will fill its mountains with the slain; on your hills and in your valleys and in all your ravines those who are slain by the sword shall fall. 9 I will make you perpetually desolate, and your cities shall be uninhabited; then you shall know that I am the Lord. 10 "Because you have said, 'These two nations and these two countries shall be mine, and we will possess them,' although the Lord was there, 11 therefore, as I live," says the Lord God, "I will do according to your anger and according to the envy which you showed in your hatred against them; and I will make Myself known among them when I judge you. 12 Then you shall know that I am the Lord. I have heard all your blasphemies which you have spoken against the mountains of Israel, saying, 'They are desolate; they are given to us to consume.' 13 Thus with your mouth you have boasted against Me and multiplied your words against Me; I have heard them." 14 'Thus says the Lord God: "The whole earth will rejoice when I make you desolate. 15 As you rejoiced because the inheritance of the house of Israel was desolate, so I will do to you; you shall be desolate, O Mount Seir, as well as all of Edom--all of it! Then they shall know that I am the Lord."'
29. It's funny a.k.a. pathetic
howard ,   pacific coast, usa   (07.07.06)
'we stress that negotiations are the only way out of this case and the sole way to preserve the life of the soldier and secure his safe return home' So why is negotiation not a reasonable approach to the much more painful and critical questions confronting the middle east? Hamas = hypocrites as usual
30. "he is being treated according to islam"
Arie   (07.07.06)
Other hostages treated according to islam: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2004/05/11/iraq/main616842.shtml http://seansrusskiiblog.blogspot.com/2006/06/russian-diplomats-executed-in-iraq.html http://terrorism.about.com/b/a/163770.htm And on and on!!!! slam is such a peaceful cult
Next talkbacks
Back to article