Jewish Scene
Madonna may cut ties with Kabbalah
AFP
Published: 09.07.06, 23:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
40 Talkbacks for this article
1. We Can Only Hope
David ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.09.06)
2. Ignorance
G ,   Shomron   (07.10.06)
Kabbalah is not a sect Judaism, it is Judaism. It is the decoding of the torah, and identifying hidden codes and messages. You cannot follow Kabbalah, but you can surely be Jewish. Please Ynet, get some facts before you upload your stories. One further thing, Madonna is not a Jew, and therefore who really cares what she does in regards to "kabbalah". Trust me, we dont need a goy helping our religion.
3. The 'Orthodox Jewish Kabbalah sect'
Daniel van Dalen ,   Jerusalem   (07.10.06)
You guys are making total fools out of yourself. Madonna is a member of an 'Orthodox Jewish' sect called 'Kabbalah'? I don't know whether to laugh or to cry about this article.
4. It ain't true
NAAMZ ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.10.06)
She's fully devoted to this cause. Someone is just spreading this rubbish to harm Kabbalah.
5. Hopefully she'll return to the right religion-Christianity
DK ,   Haifa   (07.10.06)
She is a good Catholic woman and I really hope she'll return to her Christian roots instead of worshiping some bizarre mystical myth.
6. Not True
Shaka   (07.10.06)
Maddona has been in New York for her tour and while she was here she was at the Kabbalah Center for Shabbat and other events. So your sources or wrong.
7. DK; Madonna was never a good Catholic woman.
Daisy ,   USA   (07.10.06)
8. cafeteria catholic
rome   (07.10.06)
She's a cafeteria catholic. They always come back to celebrate christmas for the toys and x-mas trees, then go off and practice mystical religions.
9. DK, you are joking, right?
Joshua ,   Tel Aviv   (07.10.06)
If Kaballah is a "weird myth" then what is the "Trinity" and all the founding and practiced tennants of Catholicism? DK, that was a good one!
10. She should..
mordechai ,   Israel   (07.10.06)
stop this mystical ripoff and invest in real-estate in Israel.
11. good morning Madonna...
neil ,   USA   (07.10.06)
Good morning Madonna. As an orthodox Jew I can can tell you that you have been taken for a financial ride. Listen to your husband. He sees through all the bullshit. The Kaballah you are being exposed to is a fraud that will eventually clean you out financially.
12. What "religion" has so many pedophilles? Catholic maybe?
Bunnie Meyer ,   Santa Monica, CA   (07.10.06)
What "religion" had the Spanish Inquision?" What "religion" is overwheming the American continent with over population" Catholic Maybe? Kaballah is too deep for me to study, but bless the people who can dedicate their lives to it.
13. Funny....
Liraz ,   San Francisco, CA   (07.10.06)
mandatory eating and drinking of the "body" of christ. holy water. vows of chastity. the trinity. virgin birth. walking on water. death & resurrection in three days .... and you call kaballah weird? uh...ok.
14. madonna nonsense
Yerushalmi ,   Jerusalem   (07.10.06)
If she was serious, she would either become noachide or convert. There is no third way. If she would declare herself noachide, she would be accepted with open arms by most rabanim. Her nonsense with imitating wearing tefilin while half naked on a clip is the oposite what a serious noachide would do. Even though noachides are not obligated to be tzanua, they should have some respect for jewish symbols. Today there is a noachide council, if she was really serious, today there is a proper address where to ask what to do. There are muslims in that council, and there are christians. She can celebrate xmass and still be a proper noachide. And, yes, she should not give money to kaballah center, if she wants to donate, there are enough poor people she can give tzetaka to. Kaballah center has more then enough money. If she wants to give money, she should follow Warren Buffet's and Bill Gates's example. There are enough poor people that need help far more then those she gives to.
15. MacDonut, SHe's a material Girl, whatdoya expect.
John ,   NZ   (07.10.06)
16. Jerusalem, Israel
Juke   (07.10.06)
The "Kabbalah Center” is one big FRAUD and far from Orthodox. There are many true Kabbalist that have tremendous powers; unfortunately no one from the "Kabbalah Center" has those powers and their teachings are fraud. They are not orthodox.
17. Another Independent Newspaper Says...
kurt ,   san diego ca usa   (07.10.06)
The book ( Zohar) which is so inspirational to Madonna, is really a wonderful gift, meant to be read and enjoyed; It glorifies the Torah. This article about what an Independent Newspaper says is as meaningless as a TV soap opera.
18. why do we care about this?
yonatan ,   nyc   (07.10.06)
19. This is News?? Italia is news.
Mike ,   Israel   (07.10.06)
20. Islam is the way to go! There is only one God to worship!
Muslim   (07.10.06)
There is no God but Allah! and Muhammad is indeed his messenger.
21. DK....
(07.10.06)
Christianity is based on Judaism. You are using our bible. Your saviour is a Jew. If Judaism is a myth, so what's christianity?
22. Who's Madonna?
(07.10.06)
23. #2 - "Kabbala is Judaism"?
Tahl ,   Israel   (07.10.06)
As the brilliant professor Yeshayahu Leibovich, r.i.p, once said - "Kabbalah is the TRASH BIN of Judaism." And Madonna manages to make this trash bin look even more superficial and rediculous than it already is.
24. Catholics, please take her back!
Yacov ,   Ashkelon   (07.10.06)
Kabbalah was never meant as a toy for goy celebrities seeking another publicity gimmick. Time for the Catholics to take her back. We don't need her trivializing us.
25. criticize 'Kabbalah' cult leaders, not Madonna
Mordechai   (07.10.06)
Why are people attacking Maddona here ? I think she is mostly a victim here, having been used by a cult, who masquerade as 'Kabbalists'. The ire should be directed against the cult, not Madonna.
26. Its Nonsense
Davidq ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.10.06)
The Zohar and the kabbalistic movement that followed is nonsense. It draws on legitimate sources, such as ancient midrashim, aggadata, and the sefer yetzira, but its gist is highly divergent from the original meaning of those texts (just look at Saadia Goan's commentary on the Sefer Yetzira for one shocking example of such differences) and outright contradicts older, more authoritative sources in many places. Its Jewish midieval pop-culture that failed to go away and has wasted the time of entire generations who should have been focusing on mastering the Scriptures and Oral Law - and then the original aggadatas and midrashim. Its a total busha. And complete nonsense.
27. Real Catholics wouldn't want her back!
Tom Neuman ,   Melbourne, Australia   (07.10.06)
She was only about as Catholic as Bill Clinton was a faithful husband. She's nothing more than a promiscuous bimbo that flits from fad to fad, whether that be Pilates, Yoga or Kabbalah. Who knows, perhaps Sufi Islam might be next?
28. Madonna
GARY ,   Oklahoma City,USA   (07.10.06)
Amen brother this is about as stupid as it gets.Who cares??
29. bull----
Gary ,   Oklahoma   (07.10.06)
I will call my God another name and thank God I am not muslim!!!!!!
30. #5 good catholic woman?
linda   (07.10.06)
give me a break!!! she had sex on tv and you call he "a good catholic woman" Get of you high horse Mr/Mrs right religion! We cannot help it that she went to a cult, real kabbalah 'esther' will never understand.
Next talkbacks
Back to article