News
Hizbullah shoots down helicopter in southern Lebanon
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 12.08.06, 23:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
65 Talkbacks for this article
1. many people will die b4 the actual ceasefire implementation
The Phoenix ,   Lebanon   (08.12.06)
2. Why Israel Suffers
Marcel ,   Florida   (08.12.06)
If only Israel had shown overwhelming force at the beginning instead of liseining to bads advice from a bad friend. Israel's defeatist government makes sorry excuses for their incompetence and failure. The truth is that wimp politician Puppet Minister Olmert listened to Condi Rice to restrain the IDF and this is why Israel has failed to defeat Hezbollah. He put US interests above Israel's ,a serious crime and betrayal indeed ! You who voted for Kadima have your weak leaders and the death toll grows because of the defeatist mindset of the appeasers from Ehud Barak to Ehud Olmeret. P.M. Olmert waited for a month to get up the courage to do what he should have done at the beginning. The spineless political wimp obeyed the orders of Condi Rice and restrained the IDF for all this time. He was more concerned about U.S. interests than Israel's security and survival. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice called during the meeting, officials said, and Olmert told ministers after his half-hour conversation with Rice that the offensive would be accompanied by a new diplomatic push. http://apnews.myway.com/article/20060810/D8JDF1BO0.html Is this too little too late ? Only if the Hezbollah are SOUNDLY DEFEATED will Israel rise up from this disaster. Anythting else including this worthless ceasefire will feed the Islamic jihad against Israel. Israel in a state of stupor went along with the fake U.S. peace scam ,the Road Map . All this time Israel was lulled into a coma as their enemy Hezbollah & Hamas prepared for war. To this day Puppet Minister Olmert just can't say no to the devious Rice and her boss President Bush. The party of Kadima has truly led Israel ,forward to hell with their BUSH Road Map enforced appeasments and agreement and their failure to DEFEAT Hezbollah. Will Israel awaken from it's peace induced defeat at the hands of a phony ally who finds it easier to appease the Arab /Islamic world and sacrifice Israel and the Jewish people ?
3. "Injuries Reported"..????
Observer ,   Canada   (08.12.06)
You can't even make it to the crash site... Maybe the crew is having a coffee at the local "DUNKIN DONUT".... My 4 year old knows what happens when a helicopter crashes...But IAF doesn't..!!!!! Utterly Pathatic.....
4. So now they shooting down our helicopters??
Proud Grandpa ,   www.KingArik.net   (08.12.06)
OLMERT: You have NO moral right to send our boys to die! There's a UN cease fire resolution! You MUST bring the boys back home NOW! In 1st LEBANON war we lost 675 soldiers. DON'T GO THERE. Leave now. Save our soldiers' lives!!
5. It Was Only a Matter of Time
World Citizen ,   the world   (08.12.06)
before this was going to happen. I'm surprised that the Israeli administration hasn't admitted that the 84 casualties from yesterday weren't the result of a shoulder fired surface-to-air missle that hit a helicopter or two I wouldn't want to be an IDF soldier riding a helicopter going into a hot LZ today! Olmert and the IDF generals do not realize there has been a paradigm shift in the tactics of asymetrical warfare. You are not going to win with your cluster bombs or armor. If Hezbullah gets their hands on sophisticated SAMs even your vaunted IAF may be obsolete. It's time to smell the coffee. Start negotiations and retreat from Lebanon now.
6. Bonus point for Hizbullah...
Nab ,   Lebanon   (08.13.06)
7. When should we call it a quit?
Ari ,   Jerusalem   (08.13.06)
Mr. PM, how many IDFs blood do you want spell before you call it a quit? It is clear that you have not managed to squash Hizbollah terror group capabilities, and it is clear to us all that most of what you have said and declared about this crazy world was a lie! Your hurt us so much to a point that some is resorting to Hizbollah TV for true facts about our forces losses! Shame on you Olmert and shame on the rest of your incompetent government who brought us shame and smeared Israel face and ego into the dirt! Shalom
8. first priority...drop soliders into battle zone.
John ,   OH, USA   (08.12.06)
As a former US helicopter pilot in Afghanistan, I know that the first and most important objective is to drop the troops in the combat zone, which the IDF helicopter pilots managed to do. Although the helicopter was shot down, they completed their main objective, which is the most important thing.
9. Utter madness
jim ,   usa   (08.12.06)
When does this madness ends? I thought the war is over.
10. What more Catastrophes you have for us, Olmert;
Master ,   US   (08.12.06)
My brothers take the decision; all will support you, no need to go to Lebanon. Let Olmert go there for one hour. He is coward and will not do it. Your life is more important than occupying any territory. This idiot cannot understand the UN resolution but you can. He can’t understand your importance to us but you can. Come back, don’t stay any more, you will be killed. Hizbulla is everywhere, they know where you are but you don’t know where they are.
11. US & France back off. Let Israel destroy the Hizbullah.
Proud Grandpa ,   www.KingArik.net   (08.12.06)
The US wouldn't agree to a ceasefire if al-Qaeda was in Canada fireing rockets at them. France would put on their finest perfume and rouge and invite them in.
12. Helicopter down
cohen ,   Kiryat shmona   (08.12.06)
Please tell me this news is not true, what the hell are we still doing in lebanon? we are turning into a disgrace.
13. get out now
hector ,   Kiryatshmona   (08.12.06)
Why is it our media lies all the time, their is 4 members that died in that helicopter, till when will you censure the news? Olmert what the hell are we still doing in Lebanon? get the hell out ur killing our boys. I am going to Leave Israel for good this time.
14. England's attacks against planes : WAS A FAKE !!!
Descartes ,   FRANCE   (08.12.06)
scotland yard is near to reach this conclusion : all of it this was a BIG FAKE. By whom???? Still without knowing, but it was very good for Bush and Blair, and for Israel. I hope we are going to know much more : perhaps all of it ?
15. last dead soldier
another leb christi ,   paris   (08.12.06)
i this olmreit killed enought on both side nobody won we all lost when i say we i meen the civilian on both side he failed to do his mission which started with finishing hizbolla the 1 km then ets nobody wants to die for nothing its overs i personnaly do not want to be the last soldier or civilian to die especially that its over so stop now you harmed everybody exept hizbolla we thought you were the only one who can finish what we couldnt do you disapointed all of us by hitting everyone with no exception shildren didnt harm you or red cross or people burrying their dead 14 then 15 this is criminal act you should be sued by both sides quit now
16. you were worned!!!
Dom ,   France   (08.13.06)
he warned you guys that the south will be the grave yard of the israeli soldiers! take your boys back home!
17. DON'T MISTAKE "RAAD" WITH "WAAD" ROCKETS
Lebanese ,   Lebanon   (08.12.06)
both are moderated USA rockets
18. #4 Your name shall be "King Raki"
Hans ,   Markdorf, Germany   (08.13.06)
19. Evil diseases of Mizrayim to them
Hans ,   Markdorf, Germany   (08.13.06)
20. ..................CARPET BOMB MASSIVE ATTACKS NOW ........!
AVINU   (08.13.06)
WHAT YOU WAITING FOR ??????? ...................................................................... WHAT YOU WAITING FOR ??????? ..................................................................... HOW MANY IDF BOYS YOU WILL LET TO DIE ??????????????????????
21. Why more killing?
Mustafa ,   Egypt   (08.13.06)
Four more soldiers are about to be reported killed in Actions. Why? To capture more land for bargaining!! Who knows may be capturing more land would have negative effect. Could you restore their lives back.
22. IDF and goal
tim ,   chicago   (08.13.06)
I think the IDF wants to make a statement before the cease fire takes place but I think Huzbollah is making that statement loud and clear. we lost the war. Huzbollah won by a techincal knock out.
23. NUKE LEBANON AND IRAN !
(08.13.06)
24. to # 11
rocco ,   uae   (08.13.06)
you have to agree.hizbollah is destroying israel.sorry!
25. Let Cease Fire
rami ,   Tripoli, Lebanon   (08.13.06)
DEAR ALL looking for Peace? people leaving in south now they don't have homes don't have anything now to loose? every family at least lost someone WHY? now every family will have someone inside willing to fight against ISRAEL, WHY people ask yourselves these questions, WHY this WAR WHY NOT STOP and GIVE HIZBULLAH what he need, then wait and see if Hizbulla did any mistake, WE lebanese will be the FIRST who demand to Remove it
26. ISRAEL'S RIGHTS!
vit ,   usa   (08.13.06)
#1) Israel has the right to hold terrorists that have attacked Israeli citizens in their jails. #2) Israel has the right to defend Israeli borders from terrorists operating from Lebanon. #3) Israel has the right to send it's army into Lebanon to seek out and destroy Hizzbullah. #4) Israel has the right to use it's Air Force to attack Hizzbulla positions where ever they might be. (in civillian areas or in the open) #5) Israel has the right to exist as a Jewish state just like the 20+ Muslim states that exist. #6) Israel should and will care about it's civillians first - before the civillians in Lebanon. THEIR OWN CITIZENS COME FIRST! #7) Israel has the right to keep it's Army in Lebanon (as long as needed) if Lebanon does nothing about the Hizzbullah attacks on Israel. #8) Israel has the right to destroy anything in Lebanon that helps Hizzbullah. #9) Israel has the right to do everything in it's power to protect the State of Israel. Even if it results in many dead civillians in Lebanon. #10) If Hizzbullah does not cease and desist with it's attacks, the IDF will come back and it will be back over and over again! THAT'S A PROMISE!
27. #14
Pat ,   USA   (08.13.06)
What is your information source?
28. To Marcel #2
voova ,   lebanon   (08.13.06)
Is it that hard to assume the truth? You want to be part of a war and believe that your IDF soldiers would not be hurt. You are trying to make things so complicated just to avoid the facts and the reality. Keep it simple, assume the truth! War is not a game and cannot be experienced just by watching it on TV, we lived it, we knew it and we understand it and most important we assume its consequences. (I am not saying it is nice) Even " overwhelming force "could not have changed a thing, this is War Marcel, people die, the more it lasts the more will die. Do not think that this started with the kidnapping of the IDF soldiers, this was planned by the Israeli government since 2004, there waiting for any small incident to make up a reason and start this war, but they have misjudged there enemy, have committed war crimes against innocent civilians and killed more than 400 children. The only achievement is that Israel proved to the world that they are a " Terrorist Nation".
29. #8
Mustafa ,   Egypt   (08.13.06)
The operation was a success but the patient was sacrificed!!
30. IS THIS CEASFIRE??????
LOUBNANI ,   lebanon.LEBANON   (08.13.06)
congradjulation,i hope it will not be the last choper shoot down,sayeed NASSRALLAH promiss u ,it will be your grave and i hope to hear more nice news tomorrow,IDF welcom to the hell,something cannot understand about the israeli leader,how they accept the ceasfire then send their solders to die,no one have a prain and do this what the ISRAELI leader doing,i hope the mothers and family of the solders bring you to justice infront a war crime tribunal,cause they lies and they killed lebanies and israely people the same time,what is the meaning of ceasfire if THEY DONT STOP THE FIGHTING
Next talkbacks
Back to article