Add talkback 
Print talkbacks 
Government approves UN resolution     Ronny Sofer
31. Wishful Thinking
I agree that Israel is better off now but the whole point is that Israel could and should have been much better off provided the right leadership. Olmert et ale are on a learning curve i.e. trying and erring until they see the light. As they only understand figures, this is some of the well established rules (see 1948, 1956, 1967, 1973 ...): 1) Air force is in to support ground forces not the other way around. THE IS THE BASIC 101 IDF DOCTRINE. 2) A war is to destroy the hostile forces not to conquer land (except for Eretz Yisrael of course). 3) Always win a war before declaring a cease-fire. Otherwise put: IT IS GROUND OPERATIONS FIRST THEN DIPLOMACY. 4) Return on Investment to protect IDF armor and infantry is always attractive: DEPLOY THE ALREADY DEVELOPED ANTI-MISSILES SYSTEM. The cost of this system is peanuts compared to the cost of the destroyed armor, let alone the lives which could have been saved. 5) Return on investment to protect your civilian infrastructure is as well attractive: THE ANTI MISSILE SYSTEM IS TECHNOLOGICALLY READY, ALL WE NEED NOW IS THE US 25 MILLIONS TO BUILD THE FIRST UNIT (FOR INFO, A UNIT PROTECTS A 40KM HEMISPHERE) THIS IS PEANUTS COMPARED TO THE ECONOMIC COST OF THIS WAR. ON THE TOP OF THAT, IT GIVES LESS REASONS FOR ARABS TO REJOY. 6) NEVER EVER ASPIRE TO PEACE WITH ARABS BE THEM SHIITES, SUNNITES OR WHATEVER. WHY? BECAUSE THEIR HISTORY IS ABOUT KILLING, DESTROYING AND LOOTING. These are my words of advice.
Acher ,   Tel AViv   (08.13.06)
32. "Ceasefire"
And what about the three Israeli soldiers still languishing in the hands of terrorists??? The ceasefire should never have been approved until the Israeli captives are returned unconditionally!
Damon Besinsky ,   Israel   (08.13.06)
33. Israelis,why don't you gather already,
and,once a week(at least!), go ,IN BIG MASSES ,to the street to fight for Israel,untill you reach what is right? For example ,in my view:strengthening of Israel's army;investments in armaments' self producing,not to depend on foreigners;increase on health and education paterns for all;much clarity in government expenditures; resolution in muslims living in Israel's threat issue,both in security terms as well as in populational threat.,etc. If you see what is going on,why don't you react? The only way to resolv Israel's problems seems to be People's persistent voices and actions . Don't you think? Or do you think it will fall from the skies?
keren ,   sao paulo   (08.13.06)
34. OLMERT: LET GO TO WAR TO GET THE KIDNAPPED BACK
NO KIDNAPPED SOLDIERS NO ERADICATION OF HIZBALLAH NO ARMS LAY DOWN OF HISBALLAH HAMAS LEARNS HOW TO FIGHT HIZBALLAH KNOWS HOW TO INTIMIDATE 100 APPROX DEAD ISRAELIS AND THIS WILL HAPPEN AGAIN AND AGAIN AND AGAIN AND AGAIN. DONT GO TO WAR IF YOU HAVE TO APPEASE THE POLITICAL LEFT DONT GO TO WAR IF YOU WORRY ABOUT WORLD OPINION DONT GO TO WAR IF YOU DONT INTEND TO WIN I did not put a period at the end of any sentence because this is not ended
DACON9 ,   NO KIDNAPPED RETURN?   (08.13.06)
35. UN RESOLUTION of HATE, DECEIT & RACISM for ISRAEL
Extreme HATE: Responsibility for compliance of the resolution is given to UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan, infamous for his fanatical hatred of Israel. Extreme DECEIT: Equivalency is made between Iran's Hizbullah terrorist army' vicious unprovoked acts of war against Israel - over 3,000 rockets fired at Israel and Israel's self-defense operations which the resolution refers to as "offensive" military operations. Images show Hizbullah using high-density residential areas to launch rockets: http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/0,,19955774-5007220,00.html Extreme RACISM: The damage and destruction to Israel is enormous. Israel's economy is devastated. Destruction in some Israeli towns is far worse than experienced by most people in the Lebanese cities of Beirut and Sidon. Profound Jew-hate is revealed in the resolution which asks for financial and humanitarian assistance for Lebanon the aggressor - but no assistance whatsoever to Israel the victim. Extreme DECEIT: The Lebanese government and Hizbullah are one and the same. The US, EU, UN are fully aware that Hizbullah terrorists are part of Lebanon's government and that the Lebanon government actively colludes with Hizbullah: YNETNEWS (08.12.06, 16:52) Siniora accepts deal, praises Hizbullah ...steadfastness of resistance fighters in field was very important,' http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3290107,00.html Extreme RACISM: The damage and destruction to Israel is enormous. Israel's economy is devastated. Destruction in some Israeli towns is far worse than experienced by most people in the Lebanese cities of Beirut and Sidon. Profound Jew-hate is revealed in the resolution which asks for financial and humanitarian assistance for Lebanon the aggressor - but no assistance whatsoever to Israel the victim. Extreme DISHONESTY: In 2,000, the UN determined that Israel had withdrawn to the international border. The resolution places Shaba Farms - legally belonging to Israel - up for negotiation. The laws of nations forbids land taken through aggression. The US, EU, UN unlawfully seek to reward Lebanon/Hizbullah/Iran for their unprovoked war against Israel. Extreme RACISM and DECEIT: In calling for disarmament of all armed groups in Lebanon, the US, EU, UN are fully aware Hizbullah will NEVER disarm and know they are giving Lebanon/Hizbullah victory over Israel and a massive victory for Syria and Iran, who sponsor Hizbullah in Iran's war against Israel and the free world. In the global war to bring all nations under Islamic subjugation, the US, EU, UN deliberate empowerment of global jihad wickedly betrays Israel and the world's non-Muslims. Photo Fraud in Lebanon Aish.com's new movie:http://www.aish.com/movies/JP/PhotoFraud.asp
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (08.13.06)
36. It is very easy to talk when you are far away
For all those who have a sun, brother, cousin, friend, buyfriend, etc in the army are really suffering every minute that they spend in lebanesse territory. SO STOP THE CRITIZISM!! Come and live here and then earn THE RIGHT TO GIVE YOUR OPINION!
Mickey ,   Hertzliya   (08.13.06)
37. #25 &27 sooooooo right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Mofaz showed today he is the only one with Betzim in the knesset! He should stay, the rest should leave polotics with their heads in there tachats!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
antiterroist   (08.13.06)
38. to # 5
I see here a lot of complaints about how the war was mishandled but nothing about how to win. The problem is that this war should not have started.
Jim ,   USA   (08.13.06)
39. Olmert was just following
Masser Bushy Bush Orders
Arab ,   in the USA   (08.13.06)
40. to# 25 Oded So what would you have done?
Would you have told the only "friend" we have the USA to go to hell? Yes, the USA sold us out as we all knew they would. Oil is thicker than Jewish blood! Think about your statement. I also think the Cease Fire Agreement stinks. I thought that Wye Plantation stank and so on. But Oded and all the other Olmert critics, what is the answer? You know as I do and every other Israeli with a brain cell between his ears knows that we cannot jeopardize our support in the anti-Israel UN Security Council by the US. I wish we could and I wish that we could have blasted our way to every little hole in Lebanon. However, with CNN, Sky News, the BBC and every other news agency in the world showing false information about Israel, what else could we do? The first picture or video is the damaging one. The corrections aren’t even looked at. Who cares about Israel and our propaganda stinks! For our TV Channels the war starts at 4 PM unless there is a major disaster. "Hani's Room" is more important than putting Israel's case forward. Sometime it is better to be wise than to be right. I just hope that we are going to at least get the "support" of the USA and UK in getting not our soldiers, but our children Gilad, Ehud and Eldad, back safe and sound. As for Mofaz, Hezbollah re-armed on his watch as Minister of Defense in the Likud Government!
David ,   Karmiel   (08.13.06)
41. Excellent result
Well done Israeli government and well done IDF. You have really looked after us and acted with great responsibility with your measured response - we are very fortunate to have such a leadership. In truth I think the top layer of the IDF could do with a little fresh blood. We have learned a great deal of new intelligence from this war, certainly some of it should have been known beforehand! Maybe we have been concentrating our resources in the wrong places. In any event our new prime minister is coping well under fire in Gaza and Lebanon. Not perfect, but on balance I think that this government will get the job finished. In particular, they have resisted over reacting to a very dangerous situation. Jolly Jack Nasrallah has had a good pasting and no doubt we will be hearing in the near future just what kind of price Hizbollah has paid in dead terrorists and smashed infrastructure. This is all a wake-up call to the main event - dealing with the Iranian leadership. Yes we have paid a terrible price - b'zrat hashem it will not be in vain.
Ben Avrahom ,   Jerusalem   (08.13.06)
42. to # 35 Linda
thanks for speaking up for the truth and what THE REST OF US know. To the fanatical world, the rest of us are watching the rest of you. be careful. we know.
the rest of us ,   pennsylvania usa   (08.13.06)
43. I DON'T KNOW WHETHER TO CRY OR TO CRY
ben Avraham ,   Tel Aviv   (08.13.06)
44. #6
I agree with you, add to that helicopters and large number of Tanks. I hear that Sunday’s casualties are high too.
Jim ,   USA   (08.13.06)
45. Weak Goverment has to go
Peres Olmert and Peretz has to resign. They held back the military and could have one this war at the very beginning with a push to the Litani. The goverment response was kinda like anzio where the main general was afraid of casulties and the result the Germans rushed into the void and a bloody battlle took place. In the rush to do what the EU and the US wanted the israeli polical goverment was weak and did half measures to win the war.
Sam Weinstein ,   USA   (08.13.06)
46. Hezzbollah had no change
After a month of fights, it seems that Hezbollah was to become short on resources. The international pressure for stop of the war, left no room for Hezbollah to reject a UN resolution that the whole globe had approved on.
Lars ,   Finland   (08.13.06)
47. Can't see a cease fire taking place
What's going to happen at 8am tomorrow morning? - Will everyone set their alarms for 8am? Both sides will want to fire the last missile/rocket. I can't see this coming to an end at 8am in the morning. I just can't. We need to blast southern Lebanon overnight until nothing moves. THEN! we set our clocks to 8am.
Isabella ,   Israel   (08.13.06)
48. INEVITABLE ATTACK
In Ezekiel 38-39, God states that this is how it will come down in the final days. Russia and her Arab allies will attack Israel, but then God will show His wrath. On a secular level, the Arabs are only buying their time to launch what I believe will be an all out assault. The delays caused by a fruitless organization, the UN, only sets Israel up for an imminent attack, but with greater consequences. The Arabs are willing to lose millions of live to eliminate Israel. When they decide to launch this attack is only matter of time. Be strong and resilient Israel. Because no one cares for you more than yourselves, and the God fearing people of this world.
John Mounadi ,   Oslo   (08.13.06)
49. I am waiting to monday, thuesday, wednesday, thursday, frida
and waiting at shabbat, to sunday! workstation sunday, a little point at the way to freedom, to peace!
schulz ,   bad germany   (08.13.06)
50. ceasefire
What an embarassment for Hashem and his nation.
Reuven ,   Jerusalem   (08.13.06)
51. # 36 Sorry Mickey...
But I'd just like to let you know that ,even far ,we are very sorry too for all it is happening in Israel.
keren ,   sao paulo   (08.13.06)
52. ISRAEL WON 3 CHARACTERS:THE CLAWN,THE PINGUIN,THE BAQ BAQ
THIS WAR ISRAEL HAD CAUSED IS GOOD AS IT FINALY CONCLUDES MAIN CHARACTERS: 1_THE CLAWN:EHUD OLMERT IS THE CLAWNY CHARACTER AS AT THE BEGINNING OF THE WAR HE CLAIMED ISRAEL DESTOYED HIZBULA AND 70%OF ITS POWER SEEMLY MISSLES HAD BEEN DAMAGED, THEN WE FOUND HIZBULLA HAD WON AND DESTROYED SUPER POWER OF ISRAEL AND ITS ARMY 2_THE PINGUIN_AMIR PERETZ REALY THIS MAN LIKE THE PINGUIN WHICH HAS WINGS BUT PINGUIN THE ONLY KIND OF BIRDS CAN'T FLY....HE HAS NO EXPERIENCE IN DEFENCE AND MILITARY ISSUES THEN HE IS SUDDENLY THE LEADER OF THE BATTLE BUT WITHOUT WISEDOM... 3_THE BAQ BAQ:DAN_HALUTZ(IDF CHIEF OF STAFF) IS THE BAQ BAQ WHO HAS ALL KIND OF SUPER POWER WEAPONS BUT DOING BAQ BAQ...BAQ BAQ BAQ BAQ BAQ BAQ....BAQ BAQ ISRAEL
MENESHE PINES ,   JERUSALEM   (08.13.06)
53. Lbenan Is Coming Down To Rubel
I just heard that by tomorow morning there will be no lebenan the Isrealy army is inflicting heavy dammage with unbelievible distruction power, thats a final present to Nassaralla and his gang, good job Nasarala With his friend Kofi Annan
George ,   Germany   (08.13.06)
54. #5. Well said; unfortunately
I could not said it better; Now what?
Georgette ,   Los Angeles, US   (08.13.06)
55. to # 48
Oh Pel eease! Stop this brain poison BS.
Joshua ,   USA   (08.13.06)
56. Al Rosh Haganav Boer Hakova
Defense Minister Amir Peretz asked, during the meeting, to emphasize that "the prime minister's management of the war was excellent and sufficiently aggressive. His collaboration with me was precise.
Yedidia ,   Atlanta   (08.13.06)
57. Reuven # 50
Hashem does not care about the inhuman brutals even if they allgedly say that they are His chosen.
Mustafa ,   Egypt   (08.13.06)
58. will never make it!!
Olmert was barely able to manage Al-quds municipality, he was working as a shadow for Sharon and he will never work his way as PM.He will be held as war criminal in Lahie..
Ron   (08.13.06)
59. mofaz
Mofaz was responsible for sitting idly by wacthing hizbolah build up there massive arms store
Norman ,   Israel   (08.13.06)
60. mofaz
Mofaz sat by for 6 years and watched hizbolah build there massive arms store doing .....sweet f-ck all
norman goldberg ,   Israel   (08.13.06)
 Previous talkbacksNext talkbacks 
Add talkback 
Print talkbacks