I did not know that Rabbi Weiss was seeking the position of the Rabbi of Tehran. Or, maybe it is the position of the Imperial Persian Court Jester. Thanks, dude, but no thanks. Shame on you to deliver your fellow Jews to the hands of their enemies.

...for if he gives me his hand to shake I wil stare at him for a long time, turn my back and walk away, without saying a word. Naturei Kartas are the most disgusting and repulsive kind of human beings!

OH ! PLEASE WAKE UP! how naive ! we all know ( and you dont) that memri is a zionist propaganda machine and that is working anonymously (nothing is known about them) thus you cant check it. ok plus dear caroline i chalenge you to listen to the hole thing and what the oponnent said nooooooooo ofcourse MEMRI skips that and you know why because thats their system ,telling half truth and and showing things out of contest a dirty game witch shows what deze people stand for and their laiers on the payrole!

These so called rabbis are no better than our deadly enemies, i.e. Hizbullah, Nasrallah, Assad, Ahmadenejad, etc., and all the barbarians out there bent on our destruction. They are vile, immoral, and also live in the dark ages. No other words for them.

It cannot count itself as being religious or made up of g-d fearing Jews - but the opposite. It is ruled by yetzer ha'ra. Even the most hiluni Jew carries the spark and spirit of Judaism - whereas these people are an abomination in defiance and rebeliion against the Torah. If they insist on considering themselves Jews then they are the equivalent of Jews for Jesus, but maybe they should call themselves "Jews for Allah". They do not belong within the Jewish community in any way and they should not have rights as citizens by any definition of their being Jews.

Declare Jihad on the whole world, kill anyone who resists us or believes in a different god than Allah. Murder our own family members in honor killings, blow ourselves up in crowded markets, cafes and malls. Put car bombs on every corner of busy cities. Get real Faiza, Israel and Jews do not want war. The respond to being attacked. If you cannot see this, then you are either mentally challanged, brainwashed or just plain evil.

They number probably at the teens or twenties stop giving what they so desire the attention. In addition this is all a distraction of what has gone terrible for the state of Israel and the Jewish People. It is a oximoron that the Israelis are doing exactly what the neturei Karta are talking we expelled 10,000 of our brothers and sisters from Gush Katif we Brought Hamas to power we ran away from Lebanan under Barak we were silent when the Hizbalah armed themselfs to the teeth with the most advanced weapons from Iran and syria we demonized the settlers who fight courageiosly we all witbessed the shamefull yasamnikes hitting women and children with Batons. Finally the fruits that we sowed came to hunt us in the current disasterous war with .... The point lets learn the lesson and think about each other try to help each other stop the olmert stupidity of transfering thousands of more Jews to replace them with terrorist. Lets face it with all that has gone bad there were miracles everyday lets thank hashem lets do another Mitzvah Men put on tefilin women Light Shabbos Candles and Mikvah and lets give charity. Hopefully we will all witness what The Lubavitcher Rebbe Prophesized that Moshiach is on his way.

They do much less harm to Israel than Olmert and Peres. By the way, Israel is full of ignorant and disgusting people they have all the reasons in the world to despise it.

Beautifully said, with compelling logic !!!

Neturei Karta are being used as propaganda - but of course they don't see it. Those who live in Israel, don't work, but receive the social benefits should see if they would be better off in Iran, Syria etc. Of course they would do no such thing, they know which side their bread is buttered! They shouldn't turn their backs though, as radical islamists (like Hitler) can't tell one black hatted Jew from another.

yemach shemom may these so called orthodox jews have thier names obliviated. They do not represent orthodox jewery and are no more than a few people who belong in nut houses.

These "neturei karta" are not jews. As they say the Jews and Muslims lived side by side for hundreds of year with no problem they must leave Israel inmediately and go to Iran or any Arab country to be happy and wait for the Messiah to have their own Land.

Frankly, I do not understand what you mean - or as we say in Portuguese, 'qual é a sua'. There is good people and bad people everywhere and that is no reason for anybody to defend the elimination of a country! No matter what their convicition may be, Naturei Karta is at best very, very, very naive...and at worse colluded with the world's worst anti-semites, the ones with the will (and thanks G-d not the means, at least not yet) to destroy Israel! Really, Mosher, 'qual é a sua'?

Apart from the fact that I think these people are just plain nuts, I would be able to understand (not I stress agree with), but understand where they are coming from, if it wasnt for the fact that they go and shake hands with the most evil doers, cold blooded killers, people who brainwash children and get them to then blow themselves up with the intention of killing as many innocents as possible. And who gets cast as the bad ones, the Zionists, of course. If that doesnt show some warped sense of logic, I dont know what does.

We had Rabbis in the 30s and into the Shoah that kept stating the same mantra that these fanatical heretics proclaim: that we are not allowed to fight back against evil for it is the "will of G-d" BULLSHIT! Let's see if he stil smiles when the ayatollahs fire up an oven just for him!

I am sure it is a lot less impure! An Iranian spy in the guise of a rabbi. A massiv chillul Hashem.

Go live in Iran

Are there any Arab news websites with English versions that allow readers to post talkbacks ?

Including by non-Zionist and anti-Zionist groups(!): The umbrella group, comprised of Satmar, Bobov, Belz, Vizhnitz, Munkacz, Kiryas Joel, Monroe, and other communities - many of them openly and sharply critical of Zionism - termed the PLO sympathizers "evil associates of our enemies." The statement continued, "...their depiction in the local and international media in religious garb and prayer shawls marching arm-in-arm with Palestinian Jew-haters has besmirched the reputations of hundreds of thousands of decent Orthodox, hareidi and Hassidic Jews worldwide. Unfortunately this despicable minuscule group, who were ejected decades ago from our synagogues and communities for similar activities, do not accept or listen to the rulings of the leaders of our communities... They should under no circumstances, Heaven forbid, be associated with any recognized hareidi or Hassidic community... We hope and pray that these individuals will speedily realize the enormous damage they have caused to our communities and to the Jewish people at large with their evil undertakings, creating a major desecration of G-d's name on such a massive and unprecedented scale and repent for this terrible sin. Until that time they will continue to be unwelcome amongst Torah-observant Jews - who faithfully follow the teachings of their Rabbis - in all aspects of the private and communal lives." http://www.israelnn.com/news.php3?id=22548 This talk back was originally published by Yishai Kohen , YeShA, Israel on 3/13/06 on the page of http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3227231,00.html It was republished on 8/16/06 by ME1 Please reccomend \/ \/ \/ \/ \/ \/ \/ \/ \/

These people do not in any way represent religious Jews any more than does the KKK represent Christians. They are as bad as the worst of the self hating Jews and they have absolutely no place in Judaism.They are simply slime.

don't be fooled by his garb, beard and side curls) This guy went and kissed Arafat, His rhetoric endangers the lives of Jews and all peace loving, terror fighting, people everyware. he is; an Ignoramus, delusional naïve, Suicidal Idiots. Ignoramus: He doesn't know Jewish law, (code 329 and others) specifically, security laws of self defense, of any Jewish community no matter where on the planet, especially, In the holy land of Israel, given to all the Jews, for all time by G-d almighty. delusional Naïve: He thinks he's safer than Nick Berg, may G-d avenge his blood. Hebron Massacre 1929. Holocaust, pogroms, happened before 1948. Suicidal Idiot: This self destructive Jew is Like a cancer, a cell that looks peaceful, but its effects deadly. sick to death. That "rabbi" Leads an Infinitesimal minority With a corrupt moral compass. Its true that there was opposition by many rabbis to a secular state before its establishment, because they strongly preferred a state with religion as a fundamental guide, with hopes for the coming of the messiah "Moshiach" before the founding of the state. but once the state came into being, it was finally a accepted by all rabbis (if not as a state then at least as a huge settlement of Jews, in the holy land, that should be protected and supported by every Jew, regardless of messianic aspirations) except for this ignoramus whacko. Yet and all Jews are still waiting for the Moshiach, to bring peace to the world forever. This nut and his ilk are denounced and condemned by all Jews, who love and choose LIFE. For the true torah opinion Check out http://www.truepeace.org/rebbeview.html http://www.truepeace.org/torah.html

Probably he is getting $$ MM from Iran for saying this against Israel.

They sould DIE painfull deaths They are NOT JEWS and sertenly NOT RABBIS they have a mentel disorder worse then libaralisom!!! The IDF should treat them like Hamas!

Is it also because of the "Zionists" that your people blow up trais in India,kill school children in Russa,smash plains into buildings in New York,kill children in Samalya,and kill you owen people in Iraq???

For the Naive Arab that says he can't believe Judaism would kill an innocent. (see talkback #1) 8 million were killed by the rightous muslims in the Iran Iraq war; about 100 hundred a day are being killed in Iraq for the last 2 years. the Sunni's in Iraq were killing a solid 100,000 a year for every year they kept Saddam Hussain in power, but for some reason, Israel protecting her borders is a problem for Muslims. It is ok for a Muslim to kill a Muslim because they are cruel; but we can't have a Jew protecting themselves at the expense of a Muslim suicide bomber. I think they arrested some wonderful muslims in England trying to blow up thousands of women and children this week, but thats OK, they are Muslims not Jews... RIGHT!!!

just the name shows you how "aliens " these people are ! if they were not here , we will have to invent them :) i have to add that God has a strange sense of humor :) alexander

I don't understand what's your point. I said "they have all the reasons in the world to despise Israel", I never said I agree 100% with them. And to say that "There is good people and bad people everywhere" and that Israel is no exception is also naive. The proportion of "bad" people in Israel is higher than in Chuts Laaretz. Like my rabbi in Israel use to say "be Israel iesh pakhot Torah". The yetser hara is stroger in Israel. I'm sick of all this blind support for the rotten and anti-judaism State of Israel. I like the way Neturei Karta remembers all of us of how wrong Israel is.

In rebellion to the One great G-D of the Universe, Neturei Karta are liars and propagandists for global jihadists: http://www.intelligence.org.il/eng/sib/9_04/araf_ap17.htm