Jewish Scene
Beirut’s last Jews
Sefi Hendler
Published: 19.08.06, 11:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
46 Talkbacks for this article
1. look how arabs treat jews
tomer ,   tel aviv   (08.19.06)
Arabs in Israel cry all the time look what your people do to jews in their country. Why don't we treat arabs in Israel the same thing???
2. look how the arabs treat themselves
(08.19.06)
3. I am not saying he is lying, but could not he leave earlier?
atmawi ,   Historic Palestine   (08.19.06)
4. Jews need Israel/3/
Tom ,   Toronto,Canada   (08.19.06)
Why would you consider this man lying too begin with. Proof that at times every one can live in peace. Unfortunatley though the tide turns often against minoritys aka Jews in this region. Every-one needs a place of refuge.
5. 3 why should
Tom ,   Toronto,Canada   (08.19.06)
he leave it was his homeland, ( sound familiar) . the article also tells why he did not leave. Interesting that the focus is on Jews leaving rather than standing up for a opressed minority.
6. loyal
moe ,   montreal   (08.19.06)
the Jews, if they are loyal to the country they live at, no one will even look at them differently, lebnon is no different. but, when they live somewhere, and they think that Isreal is their country, and they got loyal to Israel more then their country of born, and they put Israel's benefits first, then don't expect the people will love them as much.
7. JEWS ALLOVER THE WORLD SUFFER
Lebanese ,   Lebanon   (08.19.06)
cause of israel's mistakes.Moshe himself is saying that before 1982 lived in peace with their neighbours.after israel invading lebanon in 1982 the relation to lebanese jews changed cause in south lebanon started to kill lebanese women,children & civilians.these civilians in south lebanon met IDF soldiers when entered Lebanon by throwing on them rice & flowers. every IDF soldier entered Lebanon in 1982 can tell the same thing what i am telling.Here starts the most important , israeli PMs & strategics are dumb or they don't dare about others opinions & freedom,& in both situations they are mistaken & this is the most important reason for what happened after in changing the relationship of lebanese people to israel soldiers & to lebanese jews,cause after IDF started after entering Lebanon as i said bombed Beirut for 2 months ,enforced lebanese parliamantary to vote for one president that many lebanese didn't want, started to dictate some political things to some parties plus kidnapping people & taking them to jail & supporting in south Lebanon the ARMY of SOUTH LEBANON that were all criminals & much much more bad things .So israeli must always think about the reasons from the beginning & not from the middle of the problem & to heel the disease you must treat the virus & not only by giving only antibioteq that only can remove the temperature.The virus here is the mentalitet of israeli strategics that won't dare about the rights of their neighbours palestinians,lebanese & syrians because there are clear UN resolutions 192 ,242 etc...which israel doesn't want to fulfil them & to end with the violence in all the region
8. number 3
yossef ,   france   (08.19.06)
YOU MEAN YOU'RE A JORDAN? anyway, your twisted mind shows how deep is your hatred.
9. to #6, Moe, Montreal
someone ,   TelAviv   (08.19.06)
Moe I guess your real name is Mohammad and probably you were born in some Arab country....so actually what you are saying is that in your case, you are still loyal to your Arab brothers and that would mean that the Canadians wouldn't respect you and won't like you? ....
10. Look how Jews treat themselves?!
Palestinian   (08.19.06)
They always bring atrocities and destruction on their heads. No one asked them to leave beirut I am sure. However, it is getting harder and harder to live as a Jew because of their own making. In most Arab countries, Jews live in peace no one attack them. If they leave, it is becuase they want to make aliyah, nothing more, nothing less. It is not our fault that Jews left almost from every place in the Arab world. Sooner or later, they will realize that they are loosing everything. They lost their homes in the Arab world, and they will be defeated in occupied Palestine.
11. #1, Arabs in 'Israel' are natives. They were born and raised
(08.19.06)
before most Jews come to Palestine. Meanwhile, Jews in the Arab countries are leaving because of their choice, and because zionism is making enemies all over the arab world.
12. to 10 and 11
yeery ,   israel   (08.19.06)
Tell that to my parents and grandparents who were kicked out of Yemen and Iraq in the 1940s and 50s because they were Jewish. You know better, stop lying please.
13. A reply to all who call for a single-state solution
Proud Zionist ,   Haifa Israel   (08.19.06)
Those of us who lived under Moslem rule all have similar stories to tell. As long as we played the role of the officially 2nd class citizen we were tolerated. We experienced Moslem rule first hand and will never let them rule over Jews again.
14. Jews in Lebanon
Mike ,   Lebanon   (08.20.06)
As Moshe indicated in his story, Jews were living in the best conditions in Lebanon until Israel invaded Lebanon. Come on what do you expect! you invade the country and you want the Shiiaa and Muslims to continue to share the brotherly love with you. The point that Moshe did not bring is the whole is the roof of the famous Magen Avraham synagogue was actually caused by an Israeli bomb when they were hiting Beirut because they did not want any Jew to stay in Lebanon. You can check Jews in Lebanon website and confirm the story. There is a difference between a Jew and a Zionist. Jews can live in peace with their neighbors unfortunatley Zionist have not been able to do that for more than 50 years. To all Jews please find your spirit and don't let the political Zionist movement ruins Israel for you
15. Lebanese (#7): one long run-on.
sk ,   USA   (08.20.06)
I assume that when you write in French you punctuate and capitalize correctly, no? Do you think anyone reads your long responses in "English"? Merely skimming, I conclude that you just don't understand the problem, which is that Arabs do not do diversity very well. Alas, you have a state that is extremely diverse. Lebanese elites are actually much more like Israeli eliltes than you might believe. They don't really understand democracy, but they are not (mostly) totalitarian either. They neither know about nor care about the man in street. They are dynastic. They are extremely corrupt, almost without exception. And they are too clever by half. The "Palestinians" were the spark that set fire to Lebanon, which was always rickety anyway, depending on the argeements among oligarchic familes (Druze, Shiite, Sunni, Maronite) to keep the country together. The Pals, as they always do, upset the balance.
16. Lebanese; Arabs are hated around the world.
Daisy ,   USA   (08.20.06)
Because they are terrorists!
17. Arab world educates to treat not Muslim Arabs as 2nd class
David ,   Boston, USA   (08.20.06)
Its been going on for the last century and just keeps getting worse. Not that Muslims like each other much either. Shiites and Sunnis hate each other. Look at Iraq and Iran. Arabs are committing genocide against Africans. Until the Arabs start learning history and respecting other people and religions the Arab world will be engulfed in war forever. Its their choice, but they will never be able to destroy Israel and force Jews from their land again. I see the Arab world getting more violent and many more deaths due to their intolerance. This pattern has been growing for decades since before Israel was RE-created. Whem the Arabs killed the NATIVE Jews in Hebron in 29 is just an example over the years of how it has nothing to do with Israel and everything to do with the violent teaching of Arabs through Islam. Granted, this isnt the entire Arab world, but the numbers are sizable.
18. #13
Chaim ,   San Fransisco   (08.20.06)
You are a fool. What does this have to do with the article?
19. #13
Ahmad ,   San Jose   (08.20.06)
By constitution, the lebanese president is christian. Therefore, it was christians ruling over everybody else.
20. Moe in Montreal
Michelle   (08.20.06)
"if they are loyal to the country they live at, no one will even look at them differently..." Does this logic apply to the muslims as well? Alot of muslims move to the West to live and are not loyal to their new countries at all.
21. #16
Mike ,   Boston   (08.20.06)
Typical American response. YOu have no clue what are you talking about. Terrorists are born when you take away everything from a human being his dignity, his country, his future. The only thing left is to blow himself up. So go read your history and just go back for few years ago when Bin Laden was still a CIA agent. This will explain to you how terrorists are born. trained by CIA
22. Girlfriend's family born in Iraq
Eyal ,   TLV   (08.20.06)
Chased out over the years by the iraqi's. The Jewish community lived well in Bagdad and Batsra but they always knew they were 2nd class citizens. The Jews always had to pay bribes to live a normal life. And the Arabs are so BIG on dignity they must blow themselves up to save their honour! To them everyone else is 2nd class.
23. To No. 21
NYC Girl   (08.20.06)
Sorry, but your excuses for terrorism don't wash anymore. Why is it only Muslims who use this method to protest their situation? According to your criteria, it's interesting that no Jews blew themselves up in Nazi Germany, nor did any blacks blow themselves up in South Africa under apartheid. But let's see how quick you'll be to defend these savages the next time somebody detonates himself in front of Faneuil Hall.
24. Iraqi Jews
NYC Girl   (08.20.06)
My husband's great-grandparents fled Iraq for Palestine around the time of the Balfour Declaration...decades before the creation of the State of Israel. They went from living a comfortable, upper-class existence in Basra to living a very difficult life with a lot of hardships. It wasn't because they were committed Zionists, rather it was because they saw the writing on the wall and left to insure the safety of themselves and their children, so it isn't true that the Arab regimes turned on their Jewish inhabitants only after Israel became a state.
25. Mike; Typical Arab terrorist response.
Daisy ,   USA   (08.20.06)
Arabs breed terrorists by teaching their children hate and violence at birth. Israel did not take anyone's country since neither a "Palestinian" country or people ever existed. You should learn history before spewing such crap.
26. Tel Aviv
To number 21 .. ,   Jules   (08.20.06)
You seem to have no clue .. if that was the case that terrorists are born when you take everything away from them - dignity future... If that was the case, the Jews should be the biggest terrorists of them all, however I don't see them blowing themselves up and doing crazy shit like that .. no we move on and build and create and provide a lot more then you think to this world. by the way try to be politically correct .. not all terrorists are male.. we have seen many brainwashed girls come blow themselves up in our country.
27. #21
Michelle   (08.20.06)
Typical appeaser's response. Take a good look around the world Mike. Terrorism at the hands of Muslims is everywhere. You can't tell me that three little Christian girls in Indonesia were beheaded because they somehow took a group of Muslim's dignity, their country and future away!!!! Or what about the gang of Muslim males raping non muslim females in Sweden? I could go on and on, but what's the use? You're an appeaser!
28. Good old Moshe
chris ,   Lebanon   (08.20.06)
Just as only 40 Jews remain today, tomorrow will be the turn of Christians if the situation doesnt get any better. Just as Moshe stayed in Leb to prove his right of being there, all Jews should have this same right. And to live in peace and compromise. Same for Christians in Israel.
29. #14 - Mike
chris ,   Lebanon   (08.20.06)
Mike, any idea where this synagogue is? bil tafaseel el moomilleh, pls?
30. #21
victor   (08.20.06)
Qualify a whole ethnical or religious group (arab, muslims) as "terrorists" is a racist attitude. And racism, including anti-semitism, is the root of all the troubles. By qualifying all the Jews of liars, of spoilers, and by accumulating the power, the nazis reached to a horrible point we never want to see reached again. The lesson we learn from that, despite the fact that there is a need for a Jew state and a right for the Jews to lead their own destiny, is that we should strictly ban racism. At least in respect for those who were victims of the Shoah. Let the israeli people defend themselves as harsh as required, but wisely, and wisely says : not in the name of racism.
Next talkbacks
Back to article