News
Peretz to IDF: Develop anti-rocket system
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 24.08.06, 20:34
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
54 Talkbacks for this article
31. 14 Moe Im beginning to think that you
freedom ,   canada   (08.25.06)
like fascism.. What gives, surely you cannot like Canada, as we have freedom of speech, sexual equality, religion separate from the state, religious tolerance.. So why do you like Canada?
32. 17 I honestly could not agree with you
freedom ,   canada   (08.25.06)
more. Im not jewish, but I have been disgusted since Ive been quite young that there has been so much antisemetism in the region. Seriously, why dont those leave the west bank that dont belong there. To me it seems the jewish people have been there forever and there are many places were arabs can settle. Why fight over pure desert??
33. To # 28 Miki: thanks for the straightforward answer, but..
Flavio ,   Sao Paulo, Brazil   (08.25.06)
...not I'm a little bit lost on the subject, for in $21 you criticize #20 comment, which I belive to be quite reasonable and consist - bu then, I' m not vey acquainted to weapons system. Anyhow, it seems to be unanimous that Phalanx is inadequate. Can you pls refer me to some additional material on Barak, preferably in English (ki haivrit sheli lo maspikah kdei lehavin inianim techni'im)? Todah!
34. Anti rocket system needed
Faisal ,   Hyderabad India   (08.25.06)
State of Israel have to go ahead with this project to stop rockets fired by Hizbullah and Hamas coz safety of civilians is much more important too. Israel leaders seems to be also corrupted. First leaving Lebonan after 18 years of occupation without agreements in 2000 , second being silent for all those 6 years when Hizbullah was storing missles. that time only they should have worked on this Anti rocket systems but they cancelled this deal. Israel have to secure it borders as well as try for peace with it neighbours , Golan heights and Sheeba farms problems should be settled first then Palestinians should get they lands too , Having all weapons are not enough for peace , for real peace weapons dont work , Israel will fight like this many wars and many resistances groups will be born again and again , just the names will be changed but the aim will be the same to liberate thier lands. Resolution 1559 will not change any thing unless Sheeba farms is under Israeli occupation. USA will use Israel for control ME oil fields and other resources , but the immiediate war will come on Israel not USA , Israel have to act by its own now , what Israel wants , Peace or war .. and If the war will start , nothing will happen to USA nor to the leaders of Israel and Iran, only innocent civilians will die from both sides and the whole ME will burn. Israel have to think abt its citizens first and stop itself being a part of USA big plans of oil.
35. A FLYING KEVLAR CURTAIN - OR LASER CURTAIN
andrew ,   miami,fl   (08.25.06)
- ATTACHED TO HELICOPTERS - GIVE ROCKETS SOMETHING TO HIT OR LASER CURTAIN - FORCEFIELD
36. Iranian/N.Korean/ et. al/ nukes.
Frank Leech ,   San Diego, CA, USA   (08.25.06)
The residents of Damascus, Pyonyang, Tehran, Moscow, Beijeng, et. al., need to know that, should their leaders employ nukes, these sites will be reduced to piles of burnt-out cinders, along with all of their military facilities, rendering them naked to their enemies. Any questions?
37. #30
jack ,   USA   (08.25.06)
sure beats knowingly firing and dropping cluster munitions and phosphor bombs on children
38. #23
jack ,   USA   (08.25.06)
WRONG Israel doesnt BUY anything and that soon will change my friend. we the american tax payer are getting very tired of footing the bill fo you amoral morons
39. Tsahal Must First Develop A Spine, Some Muscle & Courage
Wanda Segal ,   San Angelo, USA   (08.25.06)
40. Peretz-a-Blustering
malcolm   (08.25.06)
More talk - talk - talk .... and just to save his hopeless situation. Don't they get that everyone including the enemy knows that this government is a bunch of triers not doers. Instead of doing the basics of security, it's endless bullshit.
41. Anti rocket system
Me 16   (08.25.06)
waiting at Rafael,no? Costly? Shame there are no zillionaires donating to THIS, and to footing the bill for the cost of the life extending cancer drug (one of them probably brings it into the country).....hmmm....
42. #30 -in tht case israel are a few steps ahead!
Lamia ,   UK   (08.25.06)
In tht case- israel must be more than a few steps ahead! Arent israel the 4th biggest most advanced army in the world? and thus they have much more advanced and more precise targetting missiles. Yet they still choose to "terrorize innocents" with their "accidents" like the one in Qana and Tyre! Come how can u have so many accidents with such precise laser guided missiles! SO yes Israel is the one tht is more than a few steps ahead- if the criteria for tht is "terrorizing innocents" "Hizballah blindly fires rockets at innocent civvilians"- israel purposely fires missiles at innocnet civillians- or if these incidents really are "accidents" - the poor US taxpayers need to be providing more nappies to the israelis!! (thts diapers for u yanks out there!)
43. learn from the past
switzerland   (08.25.06)
tehilim neged tilim this is the best anti-missile . Don't you remember the first gulf war in 1991? When the golanies in the rear were knitting socks for the front line inTel Aviv ?(arts2 dixit) How many scuds fell in Israel ? something like 39. How many casualties? one or two ,of heart attack or improper use of gaz mask. This was not derech hateva and the proof is that when people began to laugh and say that those scuds were not at all effective 1scud fell in Saudi arabia and made 200casualties. This means that derech hateva it could have been (G-d forbid) an average of 7800 casualties. Awful! But after the danger was over did we thank hashem for this miracle???? Today is rosh hodesh Elul "Tshuva Tsdaka Tefila . Hodesh tov umevorach le kol am Israel.
44. Here is a video of the system
Israel   (08.25.06)
Watch this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IcmI6UnR4gg
45. Why not use the Vulcan mobile anti-aircraft
jason white ,   afula,israel   (08.25.06)
46. The best anti-missile system...
Ironcandle ,   Atlanta, GA   (08.25.06)
...is to stomp seven shades of shit out of your enemy when you decide to fight him. We still have not learned that lesson.
47. #45
(08.25.06)
See #41
48. rocket deterrent
hamish ,   hefer, israel   (08.25.06)
there is no need to develop a system to shoot down rockets from across our borders. the present alarm system just needs a small addition - connection to an automatic launch system which fires back ten rockets for every one sent to us. advertise this throughout the media. if they dont fire, the return system does not fire - simple!
49. Reply: to Frank Leech
Anon ,   South Africa   (08.25.06)
Typical American. Along with billions of dollars spent on the most advanced technology, comes a great amount of responsibility. Ignorance is a weakness, not a strength.
50. anti-rockets
mymon ,   Tel Mond israel   (08.25.06)
Thanks #44. This video should be viewed by as many people as possible, and we should decide for ourselves who is to blame for not having it introduced in our army. In my opinion, the blame rests squarely on the Finance Minister who cut the defence budget- Bibi.
51. #38 jack you don't know jack-s--t
(08.25.06)
and if you prefer to support groups like Hezbollah, Hamas and al-Quaida, then you are the amoral moron. Our country (America) along with Europe has given billions to the Palestinians and the PA under Arafat squandered it on terrorism and gave the money to his insufferably greedy wife living in France. Israel has never asked America to fight any wars for it. If you don't want to pay your taxes to support democracy in the Middle East, so be it, but have fun in jail.
52. #4
v. n.y. ,   usa   (01.13.07)
i am not a military defense system expert, but i do agree with you 100% the nautilus is impractical, costs too much and is heavy to transport. however, as you suggested, there are many such thechnologies used by the us that can be modified to address the long and short range missile threat. it can be done much faster than the 4 years the israeli military predicts will be needed for the new systems they are working on with the help of the usa military. israel must work in improving whatever technology they already have to address missiles threat. they don't need to start from scratch here. unfortunately israel doesn't have the luxury of time and unlimited funds at its disposal considering how hard and fast the iranian government wants to implement its destruction.
53. #11
v. n.y. ,   usa   (01.13.07)
considering that MOST of the idf fatalities during the recent war was from the hizbullah tank missils, yes, you are 1q00% right. they should develop these anti tank missiles since i believe they were very instrumental arsenal against the invasion into lebanon and tracking down of hizbullah. these missils were a surprise to the idf in tanks and this problem should be addressed now!
54. #38
V. n.y. ,   Usa   (01.13.07)
YES, ISRAEL DOESN'T BUY BECAUSE THEY HAVE THE TECHNOLOGY. ISRAEL NEEDS THE FINANCIAL BACKED SUPPORT FROM YOU GUYS IN THE USA. HOWEVER, THE AMERICAN MILITARY RELIES HEAVILY ON ISRAELI MILITARY TECHNOLOGY AND IN FACT WORKS VERY CLOSELY ON AMERICAN MILITARY EQUIPMENT WITH ISRAELI TECHNOLOGICAL DEFFENCE AND RESEARCH COMPANIES IN ISRAEL. AMERICA DOES IN FACT BUY TONS OF EQUIPMENT FROM ISRAEL AND RELIES HEAVILY ON ISRAELI TECHNOLOGY FOR ITS MILITARY, NAVY, AIRFORCE AND ARMAMENTS. SHOULD SOME NUKES BE SENT BY IRAN TO YOUR PART OF THE WORLD, THANK ISRAEL FOR BEING THE FIRST NATION TO JOIN IN DEFENDING YOUR ASS.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article