News
Officers to Halutz: Mission in Lebanon was not completed
Ynet
Published: 24.08.06, 21:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
17 Talkbacks for this article
1. Halutz Got this Job from Yaalon only because Sharons yes man
Norman   (08.24.06)
He should resign just because he ignored the North and South. He prepared the army to expel jews instead of preparing the army against the hamas from the south and hiballah from the North. Olmert Halutz peretz and the whole Kadima Go home.
2. the guy doesn't think it's time yet to take responsibility?
moe ,   montreal, Qc   (08.24.06)
and it's not only you Halutz, it's everyone else who were responsible for this war, Rice and George Bush included, because they led you blindly to a demo war in order for them to know how to deal with Iran. http://www.newyorker.com/fact/content/articles/060821fa_fact
3. Boy, talk about an inaccurate caption!
sk ,   USA   (08.24.06)
The caption reads: 'I'll take responsibility' Halutz meets reserve paratroopers, says he's willing to take responsibility for Lebanon war What he really means is that he's a hack and hopes dearly to avoid getting dumped but knows that he may be dumped regardless. I guess he doesn't think that he, the Chief of Staff, is inherently responsible for the success of warmaking. (So is the PM & DM. No need to stop with Halutz.) Hey, let's get back to expelling Jews! Halutz is great at that.
4. Never Can Say Goodbye
M. Jackson ,   Neverland   (08.24.06)
I keep thinkin that our problems Soon are all gonna work out But there's that same unhappy feeling, there's that anguish, there's that doubt It's that same old dizzy hang up Can't do with you or without Tell me why Is it so Don't wanna let you go Chorus: Never can say goodbye No no no no, I Never can say goodbye...
5. Resign NOW
Moshe ,   USA   (08.25.06)
Resign Now Like a General Commander Before you are Forced to Resign Same going to PM and DM
6. halutz must resig-and take the 3 stooges with him
Arie ,   Afula   (08.25.06)
7. then resign
meni   (08.25.06)
halutz has his head so far up his a$$ that he can't even understand that he is to blame.
8. THE AUTHOR OF THIS CAMPAIGN WAS NETANYAHU
observer ,   Poland   (08.25.06)
when he met with Dick chini in camp david some few months ago,cause he knew the results that IDf will fail & the goverment will resign & his chances will be more to be PM,& he decided to get rid of all the kadima stupid leaders ,halutz reported to cabinet that it's even will be no need for ground operation ,he told that by air strikes the IAF can destroy most of Hizbollah infrastructure & missiles during 7-10 days ,all ministers agreed with him ,now he is saying "there is no military way to disarm Hizbullah" then why was the need to soldiers to be killed,2000000 israeli to flee from their homes & for such destructions in israeli infrastructure.i think all the cabinet ministers are mentally ill & cause of that all israeli people are suffering
9. WHAT DO U WAIT HALUTZ ? GO !
(08.25.06)
10. halutz
boris ,   nyc, us   (08.25.06)
is going to take responsibility, he will fire other people.
11. WHERE IS MOSHE YAALON WHEN YOU NEED HIM?
CLL ,   Tampa, FL USA   (08.25.06)
And wasn't Shaul Mofaz in the Israeli cabinet? Still, the minister of defense remained that labor leader? Good G-d, what did you expect to happen? Winning wars demand military people. Maybe Israel has a complex in regard to Lebanon considering the years of achieving nothing there. But what choice do you have but to fight the fight? I still have faith in the IDF. I only wish the USA was not mired in Iraq for I would have our troops standing in Israel shoulder to shoulder with our Israeli friends.
12. I'll be fat and bold if I have to . . .
Jorge Banner ,   Bs.As.,Argentina   (08.25.06)
I'll be fat and bold if I have to . . ., uh . . ., wait . . ., I already am. Mmmm . . .
13. UNBELIEVABLE
ARI ,   MONTREAL   (08.25.06)
Thomas Ricks, reporter, Washington Post: " ..Israel purposely has left pockets of Hezbollah rockets in Lebanon, because as long as they're being rocketed, they can continue to have a sort of moral equivalency in their operations in Lebanon." SHOULD THIS PROVE TRUE, HALUTZ SHOULF FACE COURTMARSHAL
14. If Needed ??
malcolm   (08.25.06)
Nobody "needs" him to take responsibility. He is either responsible or he isn't. By telling people he will "take responsibility" if THEY want him to, he is talking down to the rest of the country in the process of not being man enough to do it himself.
15. Take a hike
Jerry ,   Jerusalem   (08.25.06)
Whether you "Take" it or not, the responsibility is all yours.You made sure the soldiers had those cute little blue outfits with their cute little individual water bottles for the expulsion from Gush Katif, yet there wasn't enough food, water, equipment or any ideas about how to win the war in Lebanon. Take a hike, and don't let the door hit you in the rear end on the way out. Oh, and forget about your political career. You couldn't be elected dog catcher.
16. Restore Yaalon from retirement end
Mosche Dyan ,   Heaven   (08.25.06)
17. Stooges and Halutz
claudeB ,   France   (08.25.06)
please stooges was my favorite rock group in 69... Dont associate this name to Halutz "Pilote de casse". Merci/toda/ thanks Cld
Back to article