News
Ahmadinejad: Holocaust made up to embarrass Germany
AFP
Published: 28.08.06, 16:43
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
100 Talkbacks for this article
1. Ahmadinejad
General Armchair ,   Melbourne Australia   (08.28.06)
Ahmadinejad at best you are a piece of shit that has escaped the sewer of Iran. More likely you are a psychopath who needs to be put down. I invite you to come to my house whereupon I will gather holocaust survivors and let them have their way with you. Then you will never again doubt that Jews suffered because you will see the pain in their faces as your life is extinguished on the way 72 fat ugly Iranian whores.
2. Ahmadinejad
NYC Girl   (08.28.06)
From all appearances, Angela Merkel is a very sensible woman who is not going to be moved by that maniac in Iran. Maybe he should spew his nonsense to George Galloway instead.
3. Very Smart Argument !!!!
fadi ,   lebanon   (08.28.06)
If europe (britain and germany) and the US sympathize that much with jews and worrythat much that arabs are terrorizing israelis why dont they take them back !!!! We wont stop you !!! Probably they wanted to get rid of the jews so they dumped them in palestine... i want to remind everyone here of a very famous speech by BENJAMIN FRANKLIN .... cofounder and president of the US ... where he alerted everyone of the anonimous threat called jewish immigration to the US .... i fully understand him :)
4. The Iranian "president" is another Haman...
Seek Truth   (08.28.06)
and he must be strongly resisted by all freedom loving peoples and must never be allowed to get nuclear weapons.
5. #3
General Armchair ,   Melbourne Australia   (08.28.06)
Fadi, you suffer from a very common Arab/Muslem disease, Denial! You can dream about virgins (because that is all you will get). You fail to see reality. ISRAEL IS HERE FOREVER! It is a fact, nothing you or any other country can do about it. Please Fadi, accept truth and don’t look for problems. Take up a worthwhile cause; look after your family and kids. Leave Israel alone, it will leave you alone. On the other hand, be assured that should any of your friends decide to unleash the wrath of the IDF in the near future, reality says Israel will not hold back fighting a surgical war compared to the indiscriminate bombings of Hitzbollah. As to your second misconception that Jews are not welcome in other parts of the world, yes you are partially right in that the only countries that don’t want us are Moslems, and we don’t particularly want to go to those places. As for the rest of the world, Arabs are being despised as they are seen to be breeding ground for terrorists. The world doesn’t trust you anymore Fadi, you Arabs and Moslems blow up and kill innocent people riding on a bus or flying in an airplane. Arabs and Moslems have a reputation of committing acts of hatred and terror. Jews are known for their contribution to science, medicine, law, philosophy, charity,. Are you starting to get the message Fadi?
6. #3, Fadi the idiot...
DR ,   Florida, USA   (08.28.06)
Anyone who agrees with Ahmedinejad, is obviously a brainwashed, racist idiot. Yes, Fadi, that means you too. Your citation of Benjaming Frankilin means nothing today. people were racist back then and it was acceptable to be a bigot. Now people see that the real threat to the US and Europe is extreme Islam and we are starting to see a trend against Muslims. People like you do not help your own situation...good job...moron!!!
7. #3. Very Smart Argument !!!!
Rick ,   Ocala FL USA   (08.28.06)
"i want to remind everyone here of a very famous speech by BENJAMIN FRANKLIN .... cofounder and president of the US..." Ohhhkay there Fadipants, slow down on the American History lessons, cowboy. It's extremely difficult to take you seriously or give credence to anything you say if you can't get the easy facts correct. I'll give you a hint.. He may have invented the stove and eyeglasses, and he was even the Postmaster General and organized a fire company.. but he was never president. Thanks for trying though!! Bye bye, now.
8. AHMADINEJAD IS A SICK MANIAC ! DANGER MANIAC !!!!!!!!!
AVINU   (08.28.06)
HE IS DANGER MANIAC !
9. To whomever questions Israel's right to exist: thanks, for..
Flavio ,   Sao Paulo, Brazil   (08.28.06)
..making crystal clear that the your ultimate objective , Iranian/Hezbollah/Hamas/etc supporters, is NOT creating a Palestinian state or anything like that, but simply to DESTROY Israel, to WIPE OUT the Jewish State, in other words, to FINISH what Hitler did more than 60 years ago. Thanks for enabling Western public opinion to realize this simple truth, one that so many others (and more sophisticated) enemies of Israel and of the jewish people try to disguise as a fashionable, politically correct 'anti-Israelism'. Thanks for the sincerity, for your eagerness to show your ugly and raw ideas a goals. Thanks for making people everywhere see how manipulative media can be and how deep, wide and long they, ordinary folks in USA, Europe, Latin America and Asia, have been deceived. Thanks for strenghtening the support that we, Diaspora Jews, give to Israel, a state we deeply love and care for. Summarizing it: thanks for being so primitive, so intolerant, so violent and so moronically stupid that really ANYONE can see what your intentions are.
10. Does not matter to him
Kato ,   Vancouver, Canada   (08.28.06)
He's only using this contraversy to further his political aims - more power to himself. He may spout off about the eradication of Israel but he won't follow through with it. So long as Israel exists, his control over the Iranian people will continue. He's harvesting their hatred of Jews to keep himself in power - same tactic used by all the Muslim leaders at one time or another. If it were not for the existence of Israel, these Muslim "brothers" would be killing each other for power. Sad but true.
11. Fadi
Jane   (08.28.06)
Listen, Hezbo-boy, most Israelis come from Arab countries, including Lebanon. Stop the Europe crap, as though that is the only place where Jews lived during the dispersion. Your hate blinds you to truth.
12. Ahmadinejad BARKING on the streets of Free-World
KMR ,   Middle East   (08.28.06)
13. 3#
israeli ,   haifa   (08.28.06)
we can debate about it for hours but as u say ur statement israelis can say: so y dont palastinians returning to jordan\eygept where they came from. anyway u and i know that u can amke this statement but u know that this will never happen.
14. Fadi: You don't need to lie
Walid ,   Cairo   (08.28.06)
Fadi, you are wrong on two accounts: Franklin was never president of the US and that quote you allude to is a fabrication. You don't help anything by spreading untruths.
15. Why is Ynet showing the posts of antisemitic scum like Fadi?
Jo ,   London   (08.28.06)
16. Fadi
MK ,   USA   (08.28.06)
To Fadi: I am sure Ben Franklin said no such thing. But we all understand how various people are nourished with these falsehoods. Perhaps Fadi is unaware of the fact that until many of the Arab states expelled hundreds of thousands of Jews 50-40 years ago, Jews have lived continuously in the Middle East for over 3000 years; long before Lebanon was a state, before the advent of Islam, and the founding of Christianity
17. To Fadi #3
Jonathan ,   Boston, USA   (08.28.06)
Hey, just a few quick suggestions for you... 1.) Benjamin Franklin was not a president of the US. He was an important diplomat durring the American Revolution, but never our head of state. 2.) Please remember you're posting anti-Jewish comments on the website of an Israeli newspaper. Thus, about 90% of the people viewing your comments are Jews. If you're hoping for someone to stumble upon your comment and go "yes, he is so right! amazing stuff", you may want to post on the Al-Jazeera articles instead. Oh wait, they don't allow free speech like that.
18. Very Stupid Argument
Jerry Sussman ,   Alexandria, US   (08.28.06)
Dear Mr. Fadi: Your comment is typically ignorant. First, Benjamin Franklin was not president. Second, the source of Franklin's supposed antisemitism is about as reputable as the Protocols of the Elders of Zion. You might wish to visit the Franklin Institue. http://sln.fi.edu/franklin/birthday/faq.html. Then again, most hate mongers never let the truth stand in the way.
19. Mr. Ahmadijerk,
Joshua ,   USA   (08.28.06)
Auschwitz ovens were not used to make Pizza!!! http://www.britannica.com/eb/art-17288
20. #3 - get an education
Kate ,   Jerusalem   (08.28.06)
You need to pick up a real history book. Not an article written by Hizbullah. You need to read this history book. When you finish - you are welcome to make comments on this site (as you are now) - and you will sound much less like a complete idiot. Maybe someone here will even take your comments seriously. Ahmadinejad's comments are printed in this article - not to "educate" us on "alternative views" - but to press just how ridiculous he really is. Notice Germany's response.
21. #3 Fadi is an example why there is an Israel
Sam ,   USA   (08.28.06)
Fadi, your foolish remarks and outrward stupidity are exactly what racism and bigotry in human genetic trash would believe. Racism is a form of stupidity and you should re-examen your motives. for the past 2 millenium Jews have been comming back to thier ancient land, as documented in many different conquering cultures of ancient Judea, including the Turks.Modern Zionismin the late 19th century, way before the holocaust, another fact you ignore. Benjamen Franklin was never a racist or bigot nor was Washington as Washington assured the Jewish community the country would neither support or defend religious bigotry (well documented for both people). You don't even see what you are doing. People like you justify the existence of Israel by continuously persecuting Jews. May I also remind you that the racist Arab Muslims expelled millions of non-zionist Jews from Arab countries, who now are living in Israel. Don't believe it? Look at Amir Peretz. Israel today is mostly Arab Jews or a mixture. You need to take the bow on this one. Your ancesters created the state of Israel and you continue the justification for its existence
22. Expedited order of Dolphin-class Subs?
S. Razor ,   Boston, MA, USA   (08.28.06)
I suspect that this letter to Merkel smoothed the way for the order of two Dolphin-class subs from Germany. If I was in Merkel's shoes, after reading the letter I'd be ready to rubber stamp any military equipment orders from Israel - and ask if you wanted the sport handling and full leather interior package.
23. Fadi, Mahmoud, and Other Ignoramuses
david ,   philly   (08.28.06)
1) Although sympathy for the Jewish people certainly played a part in the UN's recognition of a new State of Israel in 1948, the plan to create the new modern state existed long before the Holocaust. Political Zionism is a product of the late 1800's and early 1900's, and religious Zionism has existed since the Temple was destroyed in 70 CE. Thus, Israel is not a product of the Holocaust. 2) Israel's population does not comprise a majority of Holocaust survivors, or even a majority of Ashkenazi (European) Jews. The majority of Jews in Israel are Sephardi, i.e., they are Jews that were expelled or otherwise emigrated from Middle Eastern countries. If Mahmoud, piss be upon him, wishes to disband Israel and repatriate its Jews to their countries of origin, then the Muslim nations of the Middle East will have to open their doors to a large influx of Jewish people.
24. Fadi and Benjamin Franklin
Jerry ,   USA   (08.28.06)
Fadi, you have been duped. You fell so easily for an argument that supported your prejudice. Of course, you are only human, but we should try to make truth a foundation of our arguments, don't you think. http://www.adl.org/special_reports/franklin_prophecy/franklin_documenting_fraud.asp
25. Hey Fadi - you moron - the Franklin "speach"....
Andy   (08.28.06)
was exposed as a forgery. Point to a reputable biography of Mr. Franklin that espouses it.
26. #4 Who needs who
Sam ,   Canada   (08.28.06)
There are other countries that wanted Jews around to pick up their economy and create jobs for their people. The Arabs havn't had much sense in this regard. If it wasn't for oil in the ground, they would still be living in tents.
27. #3 -- Times Change
Ryan ,   Calgary, Canada   (08.28.06)
That was a threat at the time. But times change and thought changes as well as threats, jews and the west get along just great, the only problem is no one gets along with arabs. So in this day and age, it is you that is the threat and danger to our way of life, christians and jews get along just fine, the only trouble in the world we live in today comes from muslim extremists. Your unwillingness to adopt to the new world we live in is depicted in your statement, and your whole thought pattern is displayed for all to see with your unwillingness to adapt, that is why people say you are living in the stone age still. Looks to me like the pres of Iran is just trying to put a ripple in the coalition against him, or trying to gather friends which he lacks even in the arab world. Does he think the Nazi's will come to power again and unite with him. What a nutcase!!!! Anyone who follows this guy is on a path to doom.
28. Is he a genious or a madman?
Louis ,   GA USA   (08.28.06)
If I had to choose one, I would incline to the first as all his moves are calculated. he is a well read and smart person came from middle class. he is trying to stir a debate as he has never been disrepectful or low class. he has some arguments and he just tells them. isn't free speech all about this? talk, debate, and research and reach a result. what are jews afraid of, if it is a fact that Holocaust happened? he will be seen as a fool if it turns out he was wrong. you guys are showing that you are so anti free speech if it is not in your interests. of course ynetnews is an exception and admirable :) Don't underestimate him, don't call him monkey or Hitler as you will be missing a chance to get to know your enemy.
29. #3: Ben Franklin wasn't president, stupid.
s ,   USA   (08.28.06)
Just because Germany was so anti-semitic does not mean that Britain and the US were not anti-semitic. They were just more diplomatic.
30. AhMad
Captain America ,   USA   (08.28.06)
This letter comes as no surprise. Hitler was also delusional. Sooner, not later, AhMad and his Mullah masters must be taken down, just as Hitler was.
Next talkbacks
Back to article