Opinion  Others
Prisoner swap and fatherless children
Rami Tal
Published: 14.09.06, 16:55
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
21 Talkbacks for this article
1. the way to prevent prisoner fiascos...
aaron ,   ra'anana   (09.14.06)
is implementing a death penalty for murder
2. Samir
yvon ,   T.O Canada   (09.14.06)
for lebanese Samir Kintar is a hero, who was ready so sacrify his life in order to do his job of going into Israel, and take hostages to make a prisoners swap for thousands of lebanese and Palastinians hostages in Israeli prisons. When you talk about the evil work done by Kintar, don't ever forget that Israel was killing innocent civilians in lebanon everyday throughout 70's up until now, and none of their masscare led to any kind of international trial or something like that. If Samir Kintar deserves to rot in prison, and if he is a monster as stated in this article, then what about all your PMs since the very beginning of Israel, and you generals? or you guys have a double standard, whoever attack you is evil, and you actions are good, no matter the level of brutality.
3. #2
Oded ,   Houston   (09.14.06)
Well, lets see you, dear yvon, handle someone smashing your 4 years old daughter to death. If this is not a monster in your standards then you have some serious personal issues to take care of!
4. Samir does not deserve to rot in prison
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (09.14.06)
He deserves to burn in hell.
5. Release Him........
Jessica ,   USA   (09.14.06)
And then kill him!
6. Death Penalty
Lew Glenn ,   Danville, California   (09.14.06)
I am absolutely in agreement with AAron in Ra'anana. The death penalty should be quickly applied to all murderers. This would both be just and would obviate unpalatable prisoner exchanges.
7. Marwan Barguthi's release will be part of the deal also :p
fadi ,   lebanon   (09.14.06)
8. Thank you Ynet !!!!
fadi ,   lebanon   (09.14.06)
i posted a talk back comment on #3 the idiot u didnt post it ... but my talk back regarding barguthi u posted !!! Why am not surprised !?? is it cause my other comment spoke about Qana ... u fight us with weapons but even if we want to retaliate by words is not allowed ... Thank u again !!!
9. Look at #8's comments - see how they talk
Oded ,   Houston   (09.14.06)
Dear #8, Thanks for using such kind words, This is a great example of the way you people handle criticism.
10. CAN NEVER BE RELEASED!
stuart ,   New York,USA   (09.15.06)
11. WHY IS KUNTAR STILL ALIVE?
DEBRA ,   USA   (09.15.06)
12. ISRAEL-GET RON ARAD BACK.
DEBRA ,   USA   (09.15.06)
FIRST THINGS FIRST. BABY KILLERS DON'T GET RELEASED.
13. agree with fadi
hanan ,   canada   (09.15.06)
Yah Fadi that has happened to me before, they didnt post my comments.hmmmmmmm makes you wonder why. And oded, what about #4's comments. this whole web site is full of hate. We just read it to see how much you are bothered by us. Oh Well. Pity is all I feel for you.Let's see if this makes it on.
14. Be thankful... Oded
Ilan ,   Ariel   (09.15.06)
When someone who wants to kill your family in front of you and then torture you to death has only the threat of words. Be thankful.
15. Kuntar only for Arad or Arad lost forever
No no no   (09.15.06)
16. agree with hanan
Amir ,   Dusseldorf, germany   (09.15.06)
Thats the manner of Zionism. They are like this. You can't get this out of them. They never behave like the rest of the human family. May God free us from this evil
17. The Torah does specify death penalty in some situations
Moshe ,   Jerusalem   (09.15.06)
The Torah also specifies what to do with those who kidnap our brothers and sisters. Of course, Israel has moved so far away from the Torah that we had just as well change our name to Gentilistan.
18. Fadi and freinds
Derek ,   usa   (09.15.06)
For your information there are several times when I typed long condemnations of Muslim thought and linked it to the Qu'rans text. I tried posting them. Actually ynet didnt print those i guess they felt it was to inflammatory. thought you should know it works both ways. so stop your pathetic whining. So suprise!!!! those dastardly ynet jews dont just omit your perspective...............
19. Israeli's held hostage
Steave Hoover ,   Penna., USA   (09.16.06)
I see Olmert has done a great job in securing the release of the three Israeli soldiers held captive. If I were an Israeli I would call for his resignation. The three Hostages should have been released a long time ago. Where is the outcry and where is the furor from average Israeli's demanding their release. Rise up and ask for Olmerts resgination. This is shameful that Israeli's would put up with this.
20. Through war, before, and after I been denied
atmawi ,   Historic Palestine   (09.16.06)
access to this talkbacks, I wrote many of them through the war, and non been published. Some of them was not even harsh to IKKF, but still not published. I myself did not get surprised, I born here, lived here, and know about Jews much more than what I know about myself. There is no democracy in Israel, It is a relative democracy when you compare it to Saudis Democracy. I did live the last election here in Palestine, I liked it very much howo people from no where came to practice the best democracy in palestine. I hate to thank President Abbas for it, but he deserve it.
21. Samir #2
L Reik ,   Tel Aviv Israel   (09.16.06)
Samir- Who was killing and imprisoning you in Gaza and in Lebanon in July 2006??? When Israel unilaterally withdraws from your territories- this is the result. You Palestinians must take a look at your own actions and stop blaming the occupation. Show yourselves trustowrthy and uphold agreeemtns to coexist and then you will be truly free and proud- rather than in terror explosions..
Back to article