News
IAF sex scandal ends with incarceration
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 14.09.06, 20:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
24 Talkbacks for this article
1. This thing goes straight up to the presidency....
all thepresidentsmen ,   Frenchlettergate   (09.14.06)
2. Rape memory never ends......
Miriam ,   Israel   (09.14.06)
The young girl who was raped by the soldiers will live with this memory forever. 21/42 months shows that the military courts do not take rape seriously. The rapists should have received life and never be allowed back on the street to hurt any another young girls. Shame on our military!
3. I thought
w ,   washington   (09.14.06)
I thought bill is the only one who has sex.
4. 10-14 days of incarceration
Jerrold Cohen ,   Seal Beach, CA USA   (09.14.06)
I hope their prison has a golf course. And of course gourmet meals. After all, 14 days of incarcerataion is an almost unbearable punishment.
5. #2
J K ,   NYC, USA   (09.14.06)
Military Court is different from civil or criminal court, but this sentence is ridiculous, even if it were to be believed that this young girl consented. The older soldiers should have known better. This sentence is a joke. These guys should be getting at least 3-5 years for their crime and for conduct unbecoming.
6. If I were a rapist I'd love to be in Israel.
James ,   Toledo Oho USA   (09.14.06)
7. iaf sex scandal
debbie ,   israel   (09.14.06)
To #2 Miryam, I believe the article said they were accused of having sex with the girl, and not accused of rape. I don't know what the usual sentence for rape is, but I don't think they were accused of that, only of having sex with her, which of course is bad enough. Where in the world were her parents through all this! Young children boys AND girls, need supervision.
8. ignorantia legis non excusat!!
Ozanam Melchior ,   rome -italy   (09.15.06)
I think in Israel you're not serious enough to belong to the so called "the West". What made me shivering in all this case is the the statement issued by the "pseudoJUDGE" read the last paragraph of the article".....troops were unaware of the teen's agea and believed it to be 16" what a shame!! For those who had ever studied law in any western country know that IGNORANTIA LEGIS NON EXCUSAT, this is the principle which was established by romans and is still valid todate in all civilized countries ofcourse Israel is not!!
9. Will they be lockedup with or without that girl?
Alan ,   SA   (09.14.06)
10. Such a fuss over1 girl-can u imagine the rush over72 Virgins
Alan ,   SA   (09.14.06)
11. They wernt charged with Rape -only for Intercourse
Lex Patria ,   Forum Romana   (09.14.06)
12. Will the last Israel Gov employee going to jail for Sex ...
Myron ,   London   (09.15.06)
..please remember to switch of the lights in the Government Buildings
13. If I were a rapper, I'd love to be in Oho USA
(09.15.06)
14. 6: IAF pilots just want to be in the cockpit....
(09.15.06)
15. All soldiers have sex with teenagers - it's the done thing
(09.15.06)
16. Stop your hypocricy. Consider the opposite now.
Tahl ,   Israel   (09.15.06)
Let's all imagine, this dude who's only 14, but is highly developed for his age, looks older, talks older, his parents ignore him and let him run about free, he's surrounded by these sex-starved amazon vixens, one of them "takes advantage" of him, and shows him the joys of sex. Then she tells her vixen friend of this sexually-budding dude, and next thing you know - the whole pack of vixens are taking turns on this "poor" guy, screwing his brains out over and over. He obviously "suffers" from every moment, since he lies to them about his age and tells them he's older and "legal"... So, let's consider this case. How many of you people, who lash out with such moral indignation at the accused soldiers, calling to put them away for life - would cry out with the same zeal, against the rapist vixens? Would you call the dude a "gang-rape victim", or a MEGASTUD??... I bet most guys would probably curse their luck for not being in his place! To all those who would start yakking about how rape is always performed by men - there was NO rape here! To all those who would say "what if it were your own daughter?", I would say that if I'll have a daughter one day, I'll watch her like a hawk till she's 20. Seriously now, what is the only difference in between what happened, and my fictional story? The ONLY difference is the victim's sex. Absolutely nothing else. Point being? Society is much more patriarchical, chauvinistic than you think. A double-standard exists when judging men and women for the same deeds. There are plenty other examples. Look at the tart who tried to seduce Ramon, and undermined his entire credibility for one stupid kiss that SHE started, or the one whom president Katzav supposedly "raped" and then asked to serve another term with him. Am I the only one with balls to bring up this issue?
17. Sentence - too light ??
Clippers ,   SE Asia   (09.15.06)
Whether the 14 year underaged girl consented or not to sex with these hooligans, it is still considered as 'Carnal Rape'? Now, what happen if the young girl was the daughter of the Base Commandant? I bet he will not circumsize them twice but even having them excoriated !! Call for re-sentencing punishment for the rapists or have Col. Amir to leave.
18. Sex,lies and Israeli servicemen
Leila ,   USA   (09.15.06)
I bet that would make a good movie.
19. 72 virgins NOT the same thing
Leila ,   USA   (09.15.06)
Atleast those men wait for Heaven to get their girls,They do not commit rape here in this world
20. Myron @ London LOL
Leila ,   usa   (09.15.06)
21. #15 NO WAY
Leila ,   USA   (09.15.06)
Sex with teen agers should nevr be allowed especially non-concentioual sex with an under age child.incase you didn't know age 14 is a child an adolescent
22. What Did They Do That Was So Bad?
Ben Dover ,   USA   (09.15.06)
Gee - 21 to 42 days for rape! What an injustice for these brave lads who have just finished doing their sacred duty of killing women and children in Lebanon.
23. israel becoming a very immoral state
tal   (09.15.06)
24. Israelis think they can do whatever they want
Doug ,   Chicago, USA   (09.16.06)
Israelis are arrogant elitists like Americans; both groups think that their lives are more precious than anyone else's, both groups think that they're God's gift to the human race, etc. Many Israelis are taught from a young age to think of themselves as the 'poor victim', and when you constantly think of yourself as a victim, it somehow becomes more acceptable to treat other people like dirt.
Back to article