News
US: Israel discriminating against Americans
Itamar Eichner
Published: 18.10.06, 09:08
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
56 Talkbacks for this article
31. Racial profiling not the same as racism.
DR ,   Florida, USA   (10.18.06)
If the US was smart they would have used racial profiling adn 9/11 would have never happened, but we are so politically correct here that things like that will always opccur. Israelis HAVE to be racist and have to keep an eye on arabs and Muslims that enter and leave the country, it's a matter of survival. So when people like #1 and others bash Israel, tell them to stick it where the sun don't shine, because they don't care if Israel survives or not.
32. The same State Department
Arie ,   Afula   (10.18.06)
that refers to wahabi extremism as a strength for the US; the same foggy bottom that refered t bin laden as a US ally in the fight for world peace; the same State department that always finds excuses for muHAMedan acts of mass murder. The same State department that utilizes al jazeera as if it was inspirational fact.
33. only an idiot does not discriminate
Bernard Ross ,   St. Anns Bay Jamaica   (10.18.06)
Those who do not discriminate are masochistic fools and will reap the rewards from terrorism. Discrimination has positive connotations also. In todays times it is wiser to distrust the arab and muslim first rather than take the chance. The muslims are the only ethinic group that does not stand up against terrorism because they believe it is alright in the furtherance of Islam.
34. Screw you america
Shiloh ,   Israel   (10.18.06)
Because a palestinian has an american passport DOES not alter their hatred for Jews. It only gives them another reason to bitch!! When will this political correctness end. Either they live like humans and not act like animals, or we never let them in to OUR country.
35. US is the most racist country in the world with
fadi ,   lebanon   (10.18.06)
discrmination against blacks, arabs, muslims, jews and asians... If u have any doubt read the reports of amnesty and see the level of discrimination, terrorism and racism against 'races' other than the white yankees !!!
36. just cause america now needs to mend its policies with
sharon ,   israel   (10.18.06)
the arabs after the failure of its policies and rice in the last lebanese war doen not mean that they should do this on our backs and against israeli interests .... This b*** Rice some days back said she will work to chieve her goal of a palesteian state .... Screw her and the american policies that sent us to war with lebanon against israeli interests and then tied our hands in action against hizbullah terrorists until israel reached this state of political turmoil which no one knows how it will end !!!
37. I have no problem with this.
Johnson ,   USA   (10.18.06)
38. Hilarious haters
Paul ,   Austin, TX USA   (10.18.06)
First of all, Americans will defend Americans before kow-towing to your miserable demands. Deal with it. Second, I'm curious how many of you flaming haters (looking at you, Shiloh) would come correct once your billions in aid dried up and your economy falters to 3rd world levels. Let's be blunt: you NEED us, not the other way around.
39. "Discriminating"
Uziel   (10.18.06)
It is rather profiling, which is done in a manner much more gentlier than the Americans use to do everyday with foreigners trying to enter their territory. I know Condi is a talented woman, but wasn´t aware that she´s a wondeful (arab) b**t licker. Damn of an unpleasant job.
40. WHY THE HELL AMERICANS JEWS CANT GO TO GAZA, OR WALK TO
Robin ,   Miami   (10.18.06)
WHY ARE AMERICAN OFFICALS GETTING KILLED DRIVING TO GAZA TO HELP THE '' POOR ARABS"? AND NO ONE SAYS OR DOES A THING? THEY HAVE THEIR OWN COUNTRY OF CEST POOL LET THEM FLY OUT ON A KITE. AND TO STATE DEPT. YOUR PEOPLE WERE KILLED DRIVING THE AMBASADOR TO AND FROM GAZA. WHY DONT YOU INVITE BINLADINS TO TRAVEL TO FROM JFK? BOTTEM LINE THEY ARE ALL, ALL ALL TERRORISTS AND HATE AMERICANS JEWS AND WHATEVER IS IN BETWEEN. DONT USE CITIZENSHIP AS AN EXCUSE TO ALLOW JERKY BINLADIN TERRORISTS IN AND OUT OF ISRAEL.
41. Israel
American ,   USA   (10.18.06)
is a joke- and you had better be nice to Americans or will will take your money and military AWAY- you stupid little country
42. Israel does not discriminate against Americans
Antonio ,   Haifa   (10.18.06)
These are Arab-Americans, and Israel has every right to deny them the priveledge of entry. If Arabs don't like it, they shouldn't come here.
43. #1
v. n.y. ,   usa   (10.18.06)
yes, it is a democracy. israel is very democratic....but don't confuse the extreme need for safety with democracy. a country can be democratic, but still face threats from outside visitors....therefore, they need to check these people out before they let them come in for whatever reason, noble or not. remember the tons of "muslim" tourists passing through american airports? some are also detained and questioned if they seem suspect. are you calling america not a democracy? 9/11 showed the world that people from the mid east and those that are from other countries like paki, afgan, saudi arabia, etc... yes. do need to be checked and questioned.....racism? no! safety? yes! you did this to yourself......we are just protecting ourselves. call it what you like, but it's unfortunately necessary. we learned our lesson well!
44. #35 fadi
v. n.y. ,   usa   (10.18.06)
usa discriminates against jews???? are you insane??? look at the privileged wonderful life we have in the states. not only that, we are aloowed to hold government and political positions. we are heads of universities....some of the best ones in the world, we are heads and ceo's od huge multibillion dollars companies, we are heads of organizations, media, investments and powerful financial institutions, we are scientists, nobel prize winners, authors, doctors, scientists, movie and media and technological moguls. have i left anything out? where do you get your information? or is it only wishful thinking on your part. you'd LOVE FOR THE USA TO DISCRIMIJNATE AGAINST YOU ONE INCH LIKE THEY DISCRIMINATE AGAINST THE JEWS IN USA. please, please...do us a favor....go read some fact books. read. it'll help you converse and write.
45. FADI IS A DUMBA$$
American   (10.18.06)
Hey FADI! If you have ever been to america you would realize this place is full and becoming over run by just about every other race. There are things in america that show racist against whites and the government even supplies extra help and aid to immigrants! Our jobs are being taken over by illegal immigrants who will accept less pay.....there is a tv network here called BET (black entertainment television) There is no WET , if you go to restraunts that are american food you will find all different colors working, you go to a mexican restaraunt it is all mexican......you go to a chinese restaurant you find all chinese working, ect. If a merican restaurant has all whites someone screams "discrimination" It is exactly the opposite here now cheesy mcPheesy! Whites are becoming the minority. Maybe you should visit here or learn more before you run your nasty little hate filled flap!!!!!!
46. TO: #35 Fadi
Ron ,   Los Angeles   (10.18.06)
You have no idea what you're talking about. I was born in Jerusalem to a Christian family and immigrated to the USA when I was 2 years old. I have never been discriminated against because I'm from the Middle East. America has provided me with the best education, work, life, and overall FREEDOM. America protects her interest from people like you.... Who around spilling hate against Americans and Israel. I'm sure you would give your left nut to come to the states and live the way I do...... As far as this article: I've listened to horror stories about people being denied entry to Israel because of their origin....... Since my family is of Palestinian decent, I consider myself American and that's it..... I plan a visit next year for the first time..... 2 weeks max, I hope I do not get turned away at Ben Gurion.... I would love to see my place of birth once in my life. People like exist in this world, all we want is peace...... Here in the states, I have many friends from all over the world.... what gives me the right to Judge them because they are Christian, Jewish, or Muslim. It's wrong, it's just wrong........
47. #42- Give me a Break
Ron ,   Los Angeles   (10.18.06)
Israel is a democratic country; I think I have every right to visit Jerusalem to see my place of birth. How would you like it if my government "USA" denied you entry into the States just because you are of Jewish Decent? I thought so...........
48. #44 & 45 - Well said....
Ron ,   Los Angeles   (10.18.06)
He'll never understand, what it's like to live in this wonderful country of ours!
49. Well done ISRAEL,arab americans arent´real arabs
Mohammed ,   Egypt   (10.18.06)
50. STOP BUYING ARMS FROM USA
dave ,   denvr,co   (10.18.06)
Maybe if Israeli's would stop buying arms from the USA and stop taking $1 US from every AMreican citezen a year ( yes that is about the amount) your country could cut the strings that hold it back from literally bombong anyone or any country that disagrees with your settlement policies.
51. Clueless Condi
Joel ,   New York, USA   (10.19.06)
the Arab behind kisser. She has no problems with American Jews being barred from Saudi Arabia.
52. Is US saying to Saudis, stop excluding Jews?
Zvi ,   USA   (10.20.06)
53. Adam #18 and US oganization
Josh   (10.20.06)
You suffer from having a good work ethic. The same can happen in a job in the US. You are simply ranking the Israeli work ethic where you work with the work ethic from the area and ecomnic strata that you came to know in the US. I traveled the US and have seen good, fair and really poor workers. I have had workers that couldn't consecutivly click the same five buttons on a computer. In general the Israelis are greatly influenced by military thinking rosh katan and everything will be ok. I have seen this quality even in their school teachers. If you notice Israelis are bound to one another better than American citizens, yet they do not have a high level of American kindnesses in their friendships nor with aquantences...so its not you its the culture. In fact I gave simple gifts as I would to a friend in the US and I lost or became a more distant friend to these individuals. Seems the rules are different here. As an American convert in Israel, I get discrimination from time to time even from Ethiopians. You just hold you head up do a barogus and they go into a cicling pattern for a few weeks. But in general, you have posted an opinion that could be viewed as discrimination against Israelis and likley will be. Fact is Americas or Isralis, whether Chistian, Jewsih or Muslim that come to the Palestinian aid are not liked by Isarelis in general as they are seen as aiding the enemy. In fact that is what they are doing. So in my opinion this discrimination is founded. What is worse is that if an American well organized way of thinking and planning were adopted by the Palestinians, Israel would have a more complex challenge. Look what it did for China who stole US production and industry.
54. #21 Ethnic cleansing is not taking a bath
Josh   (10.20.06)
Closing the border prevent ethnic cleaning attempts. Possibly you should learn what ethnic cleansing is. Ethnic cleansing is what the Palestinians and Muslims want to do to the non- Muslims-get rid of their ethnicity by killing them. It is not limiting border crosssing. Palestinian women are good and fat and breeding like rabbits. No one is starving or dying in mass numbers in the Palestinian areas because uncle didn't bring the bomb belts for exploding JR in a restaurant. Ooops the borders seal, no offing you children so that you can cleans Israel of Jews. Thus the opposite is true, JR can live another day and so can ten Israelis. If Israel were to cleans the Palestinians, there would be no territories to cross over into. Israel fights the Palestinians more often with kiddie gloves so quit lying.
55. What's wrong with this?
Brenda ,   Indiana   (10.21.06)
I believe Rice should have kept her mouth shut about this topic. Israel has the right to bare anyone from her country especially if Israel has proof or feels that these people pose a threat. I think that America should close our borders and send the 12 million illegals home that are here now and if Moslems want to be disloyal to America and think it's fine to be loyal and support terriorists then they should be rounded up and sent to the Moslem country of their choice. England should probably do this with their Moslem population since they think they should be loyal to terrorists. After all the people who tried to blow up those airplanes were home grown citizens. Any country has the right to police their borders, put up a fence, whatever it takes to secure their country against outside threats.
56. Can you learn love?
Caro ,   Fayetteville, USA   (12.27.08)
Christian, Muslim, Jew: we share the same God. Our religions came from the same area. Many of us share the same blood. I was given intelligence to solve my conflicts, but more important than that, I was given love, compassion, hope, charity, and faith to solve my conflicts. Love is the greatest gift from the God we all share. Acts of passion should not be judged by the courts, should not take life. Acts of passion are creative forces, and should not be confused with destructive desires. It is common sense that bombing someone won't make you greater than that person, but will only make their children want to bomb you back. The simplest once it is realized and embraced, yet the hardest thing we humans have to learn is LOVE. Hate is easy. Hate is base. Hate destroys our souls, our people, our ideals, our countries and can one day destroy our world. It's common sense. Stop killing and see if you are up to the real task of living. Are you up to the task? Can you learn love? Try. And if you fail, it is okay to try and try and try again. Please, I encourage it. Thank you.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article