News
Abbas says Gaza deaths are massacre
Ali Waked
Published: 23.10.06, 16:56
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
63 Talkbacks for this article
31. #7 I thought the attack and extermination (rats) was precise
redmike ,   tel aviv & london   (10.23.06)
32. massacre - see definition ...
redmike ,   tel aviv & london   (10.23.06)
'The act or an instance of killing a large number of humans indiscriminately and cruelly'. There weren't a large number killed and it wasn't indiscrimiate. Wrong word entirely !
33. "taking the initiative" scenario
(10.23.06)
Israel has decided to overtly recapture Gaza. This has been very obvious from the threats flying now and then lately. Bush applauded Sharon for what is called unilateral withdrawal. The problem is how to keep its image; Israel should only resort to "provoked" action. As Israel is almost always having the initiative; so why not taking the initiative of provocation. A simple solution isn’t it.
34. #25, I copmpletely agree...
DR ,   Florida, USA   (10.23.06)
Muslims never seem to focus on their own problems. They point fingers and blame everything on Israel and the west. They kill each other more than anyone else does, but then they scream bloody murder when Israel or the US hunts down some radical, terror-loving scumbags. When they finally wake up and start questioning their own culture, that's when we can work towards peace, but until then, it will be this cycle of stupidity.
35. Let the Savages Kill One Another...
David Kaber ,   Cincinnati   (10.23.06)
...then let the IDF finish off the "winner!" As Abba Eban said nearly 50 years ago, "The Palestinians never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity!" So what else is new?!
36. Jew-baiting
Saul ,   Barcelona   (10.23.06)
is a great time-tested way to unite arabs and moslems and gain their support. It's working for Ahmadinejad, it's working for Saniora, it's working for Abbas, though he must really be getting desperate. They are all, without a doubt, jew-haters, but the fact that they keep resorting to jew-baiting as part of an official policy only illustrates their own rather shaky positions. It's realy unfortunate that most of this and other Ynet talkbacks is addressed to jew-baiting of that troll Fadi. He is neither intelligent, nor imaginative enough to warrant so much attention. As a confirmed chauvinist he can never be persuaded to reexamine and change his views. He is simply too convinced of his own (self) rightuosness to be bothered with truth.
37. 7 TERRORISTS ! YNET THE ISRAELI AL-JAZEERA !
(10.23.06)
38. TO FADI
JACQUOT ,   Tel Aviv   (10.23.06)
We just make them happy! Now they are with 432 nice virgins. Why do you complain so much?
39. #30 do you think that Gazans are less human ?
#16   (10.23.06)
40. WHO CARES, THIS IS JUST THE BEGINING, TERRORISTS BEWARE
DAVID P ,   SANTA CRUZ, USA   (10.23.06)
41. abbas: "massacre"?
Arie ,   Afula   (10.23.06)
A comment like that from the butcher of munich taht has financed many terrorist acts against innocent Jews around the wold!
42. Jewish terror is damaging to US interests in mideast
jj ,   USA   (10.23.06)
43. Amazing
YedLIta ,   USA   (10.23.06)
Never seizes to amaze me how it is ok for arabs to kill other arabs (or blacks in Darfur) in thousands, but jews only supposed to wish them a good day when they see a bunch of them with the guns. Or maybe if they are reallu nasty - to ask them whom they intend to shoot this day. If it's other arabs - it's fine, we are not allowed to interfere, but if it's us they want to kill - we are allowed to smack their hands a bit, maybe ask politely for their guns.... It's a joke and a half.
44. #42, jj...awsome post!!!
DR ,   Florida, USA   (10.23.06)
Jews don't use terror, they kill it, moron! The US is allys with Israel for one reason, Israel is a democratic state in a sea of tyranical regimes that want Islam to rule the world...capish? Now, if you really live in the US, go read a history book, watch some history films about the ME and learn.
45. This is why there will never be "peace"
(10.23.06)
because when we have supposed "moderates'' like Mazen who are supposed to destroy terrorists within the "Palestinian border" call it a massacre when the IDF actually does his job. STFU Abu, keep rubbing that lamp, I am sure a Gin will fly out and save you Arabs, lol
46. No more massacres
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (10.23.06)
To paraphrase Golda Meyer: There will only be peace in the Middle East, when Arabs (Muslims) love their children more than they hate Israelis. That day may be long in coming, but come it will, and when it does and those "children" realize what was done to them in the name of Allah, I wouldn't want to be a Muslim parent.
47. Fadi, where is the victorious Nasrallah hiding today?
Cynic ,   USA   (10.23.06)
48. Palestinians killed because of other Palestinians
Steven ,   L.A. usa   (10.23.06)
If this happened because one group of Palestinians mistook another group of Palestinians who fired at them for Israeli solders and therefor caused the deaths of seven terrorists, I sincerely hope that many more of these mistakes will be made and hundreds if not thousands of Palestinian terrorists die because of it.
49. It makes me wonder what the real story is.
John ,   USA   (10.23.06)
Looks like from this report we will never know. So much disinformation. How many women and children were hurt or killed? How many of these guys were actually terrorist? How many were old people? Another polarizing incident to say the least.
50. JEWS will be held accountable
(10.23.06)
like any nazi on the planet- SOOn as USA totally wakes up- like the sleeping idiot giant it is- and they realize whom they have been welfaring- tick tock tick tock. the IDF nazi army will be held accountable for its massacres and murders.
51. @ 49, John USA
Pieter ,   The Netherlands   (10.23.06)
John, you sound like one of those leftwing activists from Europe. I bet you are from Europe, aren’t you?
52. Hey FAdi on Holidays dont cary guns you wont die
Mike ,   Israel   (10.23.06)
53. #49 no need for such information
(10.23.06)
the "operation" is for paving the way to recapture Gaza.
54. Pieter #51
John ,   USA   (10.23.06)
I'm just an ordianary America Joe trying to gleen the truth from all the BS. It's an impossible task, everyone seems to have an agenda. I do think that Europe tends to be in the middle when you examine the entire scope of opinions. On this specific story, you can get a wide range of takes depending on what you read. So like I said, we can never know.
55. #27, #28 white posphorus & legislature gap
(10.23.06)
White phosphorus (WP) sometimes causes deep burning of the flesh right down to the bone. It may be absorbed from the wound and cause toxicities of the kidneys and liver. Its smoke is very irritant to the respiratory passages. So, it is in reality a chemical weapon. A great controversy and arguing against its use as weapon against persons is underway. Other uses as smoke camouflage and burning material; not against persons may be the thing, which still may justify its use. WP shells are banned to be used ,as a general rule, in civilian areas even when there is military posts amidst these areas. It is a matter of time to reclassify it as a chemical weapon. So, now there is a "legislature gap". Israel with its so called "high morals" would not miss the opportunity to exploit this "legality vacuum" in a "noncivilized way" !
56. @ John, USA
Pieter ,   The Netherlands   (10.24.06)
John, you write to me: "I'm just an ordianary America Joe trying to gleen the truth from all the BS." First, your rhetoric doesn’t sound like somebody from the USA. Second, shouldn’t it be; I’m just an ordinary "American Joe" trying to glean the truth from all (of) the BS.?
57. Pieter #56
John ,   USA   (10.24.06)
I'm sorry to dissapoint you, but it's true. I'm an ordianary American. Maybe I don't spell very well sometimes. I never got "A's" in English class. I've been to Europe plenty of times. In fact, I've been to most countries in Asia and Europe. I like to say I'm a rather ordinary fellow living an extraordianry life. But my life is not so important. But again, don't believe much of anything you read from news sources. You can find different takes on almost any story has been my experience.
58. #32
israeli ,   israel   (10.24.06)
and it wasn't cruel - like point blank shooting, or beheading, or anything like that.
59. #30 mysterious wounds in Gaza; is it white phosphorus?
(10.24.06)
Gaza medics started reporting unseen injuries from Israeli weapons that cause severe burning and deep internal wounds, as well as amputation of organs or death, according to UK’s The Guardian. http://www.islamonline.com/cgi-bin/news_service/middle_east_full_story.asp?service_id=11896
60. Gaza medics and the guardian
israeli ,   israel   (10.24.06)
since when have these become a source of information? According to Gaza medics, a girl who sustained head injuries when she fell of some playground equipment, died in a missile attack. They later corrected the story and methinks AP (or Reuters?) had to kill the picture. Same Gaza medics reported a girl killed in a car crash as a victim of Israeli missile attack (it's always a double missile attack, never one, never three). The story was later corrected and the pictures killed. Gaza medics will report a wilted cucumber as having been killed by the Israelis. As to the Guardian, well, just like the old joke about the two leading Russian newspapers, Pravda (truth) and Izvestia (news) - there's no pravda in izvestia and no izvestia in pravda. And that's being kind to them at the guardian.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article