Culture
The fine qualities of olive-tree uprooters
Chanoch Daum
Published: 31.10.06, 00:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
23 Talkbacks for this article
1. This is written by the same guy
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (10.31.06)
Who has worms in his ass. YNet is really scraping bottom.
2. Radical Muslims pray with as much zeal and sincerity
Michael Steiner   (10.31.06)
What does it prove? I don't have anything against the settlers of Yitzkhar. If they want to live there, that's their business. But the State of Israel should have nothing to do with them whatsoever... - or with any settlement or settler, for that matter.
3. Great Article!
Shlomo ,   Yitzhar, Israel   (10.31.06)
Just one little critic, it is very easy to speak ill about everything, but it is hard to keep it inside buried. Learn to keep it inside and not to speak Lashon Hara. Thank You, I hope you come back soon.
4. Can we stop it with another blood libel
Saul ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.31.06)
Even if it was true which it isnt, there is no need to use a huge brush to call every single Jew outside the green line a tree uprooper.
5. Last paragraph confusing
Steve ,   USA   (10.31.06)
B"H One might equate the nice people described with murderers with that last paragraph that does not tie in too well with the rest of the story. I actually do not see the tie between the two, Yigal who was put on trial for an accusation and these people have no accuasation of crime pending even. I think it underscores that somehow a large segment of Jewish soceity can be incited against without it crossing the radar screen just as easily as media leaks about Katsav can occur for four months without a formal charge of crime being filed. These Jews deserve better coverage than THAT ynet. If these are innocent citizens, not guilty of any indicted crime, they deserve to be treated as innocent and even patriotic citizens. Quote: So you gave Amir and Trimbobler a conjugal. I don’t mind that you decided to cater to the murderer's needs, but I feel I should tell you that eventually - and I am trying to speak mildly and not reveal my plans - if I should not feel the urge, young Mr. Daum, Yigal Amir will have no urge too.
6. Having No Fence is a Flaw?
Jew ,   Eretz Israel   (10.31.06)
Does Hawara have a fence? Does any Arab village anywhere have a fence? You know why? Because they're not afraid. And you want Yitzhar to have a fence? Not being afraid is a weakness in your eyes? You are the weak one. Wake up.
7. Goebbels had a family too
Ilan ,   Ariel   (10.31.06)
When I read Heir Steiner I can remember that Goebbels also had a family and really we are all human. The campaign against settlers is nothing short of a blood libel. The bad acts of a few are elevated into a racist stereotype for the purposes of propaganda. That the propagandists are evil and calculating people doesn't erase that they are still people. Most of the people in Yitzhar are law abiding Israelis who serve in the army and fulfill their obligations to the the country. No amount of deceit can alter that fact.
8. Abu-"Steiner"- Arabs are the real settlers!
Daisy ,   USA   (10.31.06)
Tell your people to end the occupation of Jewish land. By the way your "Jewish" charade is beyond old. Stop it now!
9. This Article really makes no sence
Israel ,   Israel   (10.31.06)
Ynet you really are looking for articles you dont care what content is put in to them. You should go to the 1st grade and ask the kids for there stories. I think, I think I am done with Ynet.
10. What is the point of this article
EM ,   Ra'anana   (10.31.06)
What newsworthy value did this item contain? We now know that Mr. Daum is less extreme right wing than his brothers, he finally visited them after 6 years and now he thinks the guys in Yitzhar are good dancers. WOW...
11. #7 and Goebbels
Michael ,   haifa   (10.31.06)
If Ilan from Ariel wants to raise that spectre, he should understand that Goebbels can be on any side of the political spectrum and he himself is consistently doing a good job at playing the role
12. Can 1 article overcome the sea of hate
Hezy ,   Israel   (10.31.06)
Can one article overcome the sea of hate directed against the settlers by the media?
13. How can a settler "stealer" have good qualities?
perpetual_dream ,   Jerusalem   (10.31.06)
Is stealing allowed in these dancers torah? This article doesnt make sense at all... if u'd like to tell ur bro something give him a call
14. asd
sad ,   sad   (10.31.06)
sadsad
15. SCOOP! Settlers are humans also !!!
Aaron ,   Ra'anana   (10.31.06)
16. #13 settlers are retreivers not stealers, go back to arabia
gabriela ben ari   (10.31.06)
17. OLIVE TREE UPROOTERS
Eli ,   Israel   (10.31.06)
Sure they dance, men only. Their sexist and racist attitudes are despicable. They are the Jewish equivalent of Hamas; total fanatics who refuse to give one inch. They are akin to Yigal Amir (may he rot in hell soon) and Baruch Goldstein (may he rot in hell, the mass murderer). Because of people like them (and there are many amongst our Arab neighbors) we'll probably never have peace. Theirs is an evil path and I hope they will someday disappear and their memories be erased. Peace be upon us all, we need it.
18. To Eli
Secular Sabra ,   Israel   (10.31.06)
Amen to that , brother.
19. #17 #18
happy jew   (11.01.06)
neither was at a bus explosion i guess
20. #17, 18; Phony Jews or wimpy, dhimmi self-hating Jews?
Daisy ,   USA   (11.01.06)
What a bunch of LOSERS!
21. Adolf doesn't like me. boo hoo
Ilan ,   Ariel   (11.01.06)
22. actual Torah
aaron   (11.01.06)
we all seem to be a bit confused, the Arabs are not Ger Toshav and halachicaly have no right to be in Eretz Yisrael anything that drives them out, be it olive tree uprooting or Baruch Goldstein, is a great Mitzvah.
23. Avoided his brother for 6 years? What a coward.
Ziv ,   Newark, NJ   (11.02.06)
This guy didn't visit his brother for 6 years because he didn't like the politics of his brother's town? What a loser. I'm also totally unclear why he is so insistent that the town erect a fence.
Back to article