News
Geula Amir: Yigal didn't murder Rabin
Miri Chason
Published: 02.11.06, 16:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
27 Talkbacks for this article
1. He should not be in prison
Sagi ,   Israel   (11.02.06)
because he should have been hanged a long time ago.
2. We need to implement our death penalty
Avi   (11.02.06)
'Gali' is why Israel needs to implement its death penalty, selectively. Terrorists and murders like 'Gali', waist tax payers money for food, board, re-trials, pardons, and prisoner exchanges. Gali's mother is a poor excuse for a parent that has failed to educate her offspring; she is similar to those pathetic Palestinian moms that take pride in sacrificing their kids, to murder ours.
3. rabin
av ,   london.uk   (11.02.06)
igal mother is right .he had pourim gan
4. Free Yigal Amir
Dovid ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (11.02.06)
Free Yigal Amir. Lets find the true killer.
5. Yigal Amir Totally innocent!
Israel ,   England   (11.02.06)
6. sick
Michael ,   Haifa   (11.02.06)
There are some people here in Talkback who are even sicker than the Amir bastard and his Mum
7. Sure lady, sure ....
Secular Sabra ,   Israel   (11.02.06)
Read this @ http://www.barry-chamish.com/ Funny how it's the religious Right that lies about the facts . Why is that ? A telephone poll of 500 citizens proves nothing lady.... nothing at all . The minimum it proves is that 70% of the country want youre son to rot in jail. And proves that 30% of the country are as nuts as youre son is.
8. Free the Man!!!!!!
John ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (11.02.06)
Let Yigal go!!!!!! Everyone knows he didn't do it. Free Yigal Amir!!!!!!!!!!
9. May I speak for the majority
Kate ,   Jerusalem   (11.02.06)
Yigal Amir is a 1st degree murderer - by his own admission and with full legal evidence - including ballistics. I sympathize with the mom. It's her son and the idea of his guilt must be a tremdous heartbreak. But Amir is not the victim. Rabin was. His family is. His nation is. Pardon him? 90% thinking he is innocent? This is a fantasy at best - a nightmare at worst. People who take lives deserve no real life of their own. Rabin was a human being first, a hero second a controversial politician last. He will always be remembered. May his murderer rest only in the cage he deserves.
10. Reply to Everyone!
Dan ,   USA   (11.02.06)
To those that want the death penalty - absolutely not! Even if there's a .001% chance of executing the wrong person, then there should be no death penalty. For those that want him freed and said he's not the murderer. Are you crazy? There were witnesses, a security guard was injured and its all on film. Thats like saying John Hinckley, Jr didn't shoot Reagan! The only difference was Hinkley was crazy and shot Reagan for Jodie Foster not out of malice and cold blood.
11. Lord, I can't take the pain!
Dink ,   TLV   (11.02.06)
12. Mommy should listen to her own kids
Arie ,   Afula   (11.02.06)
Who admit they killed Rabin. He should have been executed a long time ago as every other terrorist should!
13. There are real questions about Rabin's murder --
AK   (11.02.06)
avoiding them does no good. There is a question of how many times was Rabin really shot? was he shot from both, the front and the back, as some allege? And then there is a question of time it took the limo to get to the hospital. The question how Amir was permitted to stay in the sterile area, without anybody challenging him. Those qustions will not go away and hanging Amir will not answer them.
14. Frey him
John ,   USA   (11.02.06)
His mother says he didn't do it? Of course she does. Who's mother wouldn't say such a thing about her son?
15. The brains behind.............
Avraham ,   Netivot   (11.02.06)
Yigar Amir might have pulled the trigger, but the person or persons who planned Rabin's murder are still free protected by Shabak. If we can release arabs with Jewish blood on their hands, we can also release Yigal Amir.
16. Yigal Amir
Ger ,   Raanana, Israel   (11.02.06)
His mother would be better off keeping her mouth shut.
17. It is FUNNY to see all you lefties NOT ANSWERING the BIG ?
JUSTICE and TRUTH ,   NJ   (11.02.06)
WHAT HAPPENED THAT NIGHT? WHO REALLY KILLED RABIN? WHY DID IT TAKE 20 MINUTES TO GET TO THE HOSPITAL, WHEN IT SHOULD OF TAKIN 2 MINURES AT MOST? HOW COULD IT BE THAT ONE OF THE SHOTS (THE ONE THAT KILLED HIM) CAME FROM THE FRONT? DID YOU WATCH THE VIDEO? DID YOU SEE THE REPORTS? Before you hang people find out the TRUTH. You want him dead so we shouldn't find the real killers, (people who are lefty, liberal, and non religious like you.) I'm NOT suprised on your behavier, you hate the jewish religion and if you could blame it on them with out suffering the cosequence the why not.
18. NEW FOOTAGE OF THE ASSISNATION
(11.02.06)
Just released today http://www.israelnationalnews.com/news.php3?id=114729
19. Amir is a terrorist
T ,   HaSharon, Israel   (11.02.06)
To give people like Amir's Mother a venue to speak is wrong. No other country on earth would allow this killer to live let alone have a voice.No one should ever have to hear from him or her again.
20. #17 - Law and Order
Kate ,   Jerusalem   (11.02.06)
You - sir - need a lesson in both law and order AND in human beings. Holding left-wing political views does not make a person into some monster conspiring against the poor likes of Yigal Amir. It is a political opinion/attitude/ideology. That's all. People who are left and right wing actually look the same and often sound the same and even go to the same movies and breath the same way. Y. Amir was tried and convicted on evidence by a judge. He passed through many hands on the way to his cage. Some were right wing and some were left wing. All placed him firmly behind the bars he now sees the world through. that IS truth and justice.
21. You all should ask for Oliver Stone
Just passing   (11.02.06)
to film the story of Rabin's murder. The conclusion would be that the Shabak killed him as requested by Arafat that wanted to be the only living Nobel price regarding the peace process. Let this muder rot in jail!
22. Yigal is innocent..........
Jessica   (11.02.06)
It was OJ who shot Rabin!
23. There is plenty of evidence
Am Israel ,   Ramat Aviv , Israel   (11.02.06)
that it wasn't Ygal's doing, even at the police. for example that piece of paper with the sript of the song, which was in rabin's pocket, has been displayed with a hole and a blood stain in it, while the nurse holding the original one at ichilov hospital was almost killed herself for wanting to put forth the real piece of paper having neither stain nor blood (or the other way around, but the point is that fake reports have been ordered). video and medical evidence, show the bullets were shot at range zero from rabin's chest. not from a good meters afar (as the closest amir got to rabin). someone else shoot rabin.
24. Take a look
(11.02.06)
at arutz 7.
25. Amir should be executed.....enough said.
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (11.02.06)
26. Distorting reality
Sharon ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (11.02.06)
How can his mother stand by his side like this? I would be ashamed of my son being a murderer! It is amazing how some people can distort the truth and seriously believe that it is reality they are talking about. Amir is where he is supposed to be and he needs to stay there! RABIN YOU ARE GREATLY MISSED!
27. Yigal Amir shot and wounded Rabin...
Asylum Aleikum   (12.08.06)
... but did he really kill the PM? I do not believe so. According to the autopsy report, Rabin was killed by a bullet that was fired point-blank. Watch a videotape of the shooting, and see for yourself that Amir did not get close enough to Rabin to fire the fateful shot. Behind Rabin's assassination was a man who benefited the most from the PM's untimely death. We all know who this man is.... Yigal Amir was just a patsy.
Back to article