News
Foreign ministry: Lebanon flyovers harmful
Itamar Eichner
Published: 17.11.06, 10:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
20 Talkbacks for this article
1. Nonsense, overflights being highly beneficial
Uzi   (11.17.06)
is the reason for the vehement French objections. They are hostile rather than friendly and don't help to stop weapons smuggling fro Syria. So what if the French pull out? It makes no difference, it may be to Israel's advantage. Maybe Israel should call their bluff.
2. Deal With It! - A rececnt Pali quote
RIB ,   USA   (11.17.06)
http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1162378417972&pagename=JPost/JPArticle/ShowFull
3. #1 Die high is the benifit, indeed highly benificial
(11.17.06)
Your country would not bother collect corposes? even more their crime will die in the sky!
4. UNIFIL should close THEIR eyes
Jake ,   USA   (11.17.06)
UNIFIL should close their eyes to the Israeli overflights, just like they close their eyes to hizballah's arms smuggling. Seems that the worlds double standards against Israel will never stop.
5. France a "friendly" nation? with Hizbullah maybe
Ignacio ,   Zaragoza, Spain   (11.17.06)
But with Israel? Is this all what Livni can get? Olmert out before they destroy the Jewish land once for all.
6. UNIFIL can go
jay ,   Israel   (11.17.06)
Let UNIFIL leave. They are doing absolutly nothing to implement the resolutions and stop hezbollah re-arming so why are they there? To protect Hezbollah from Israel?
7. Let them pull out..............
Avraham ,   Netivot   (11.17.06)
Let them all pull out of Lebanon, they aren't doing anything there except protect Hassbulla & their smuggling routes.
8. To #2
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (11.17.06)
Nothing surprising, but good link. I bet, though, they'd swear up and down that those trucks are only full of tomatoes for the poor, starving people of Lebanon.
9. Stupid israeli pilots
Franz ,   Europe   (11.17.06)
If those stupid israelis pilots didn't conduct mock aerial attacks on European boats and troops maybe Europeans countries and International community would be more tolerant towards israel flyover in Lebanon.
10. Fly-overs
Stefan ,   Brussels, Belgium   (11.17.06)
I am a strong supporter of Israel, but, frankly, I fail to see any acceptable reason for these obnoxious fly-overs of Lebanon. Maybe IDA and/or Mossad have a good explanation, but to the outside world this rather looks like unnecessary and childish muscle-flexing than anything that can be justified on military-strategic, intelligence or security grounds. As a regular visitor of Lebanon I can only see that these fly-overs and the related sonic booms over Beirut fuel the hatred and the fanatism aimed at Israel within a growing group of Lebanese. Is that, and the increasing international disapproval, really what Israel wants and needs at this moment?
11. Mock air raids
angiolillo ,   usa   (11.17.06)
Why a mock raid on UN positions? Later, when they bomb, one IAF will claim a "mistake" because thet forgot to clear the mock target from their computer. Pathetic
12. Obnoxious flyovers
Marcel Abel ,   France   (11.17.06)
What does Israel need at this very moment ? Just showing off ! Or does she provoke Unifil knowing that its mandate is not to show off back. Stupid orders given to pilots who are playing the strong men and are nothing more than frustrated kids ! Go and fly over Iran ! It would be more useful !
13. To ungrateful person (5)
Marcel Abel ,   France   (11.17.06)
Thanks to France you are a member of EU. Remember of that, ungrateful boor. As a member you should not be forgetful of your duties. Ask Mr Zapatero or Zidane !
14. to (4)
Marcel Abel ,   France   (11.17.06)
Ask your friends to fly over Iran instead or yourself. (BTW : finish your bad job in Iraq). Would be more useful, but more dangerous as Iran's hands are not tied as Unifil's hands are because of you. Stupid remark !
15. friendly france?
boris ,   nyc, us   (11.17.06)
# 13, you just talk exactly like your thief -president O`chirac
16. OVER FLIGHTS ALMOST USELESS, JUST AGGRAVATION
Arik Silverman ,   MIlwaukee USA   (11.17.06)
IAF has been flying over Lebanon for decades, especially since 2000. What good did the overflights do? Hezbollah caught IDF completely off guard in South Lebanon. For all the overflights, Israel had NO IDEA what Hezbollah was doing. WILL THESE OVERFLIGHTS BE ANY BETTER???? It is a big mistake to provoke the Internationals with overflights that don't even produce any useful results. it makes it look as Israel is trying to provoke a fight with the UN monitoring force. THIS IS NOT GOOD.
17. must deal with unifil
iDub ,   nyc   (11.17.06)
israel must deal a fatal blow to french troops if they fire on iaf. any other way, it will be percieved as another loss by idf.
18. Boris (15)
Marcel Abel ,   France   (11.18.06)
It's so difficult (for you) to argue without slandering ? Come on American Boris, where do you know Mr Chirac from, I tell you he is a man of honour and I consider a great privilege to be French in a country led by Mr President Chirac ! USA and France are faithful allies brought together with the same fundamental ideas. Whatever headlines you read from time to time, nothing could break our friendship, so you !
19. Yes, Arik Silverman (16)
Marcel Abel ,   France   (11.18.06)
You are right. Some flyovers are considered to be verging on absurd, even hostile provocation. We have not come here to be mocked at, but to help. If our presence is no help, we could go home. France and the other members of Unifil are not just your scapegoat, Israeli officials.
20. french peacekeepers
chaim ,   miami beach USA   (11.19.06)
It is reported that the French peacekeepers in Lebanon have unsheathed their “Peacekeeping Anti Aircraft Weapons” and try and shoot down any Israeli reconnaissance flights that enter Lebanon airspace. Before I give my comment I have just 1 question are the French Forces that were sent to maintain the cease fire “not the peace” as such “peace” is non existent and the UN 1701 is being flaunted by the Lebanese as not binding upon them, then pray and tell me for whom did the French Forces introduce an Anti Aircraft defense system. What I do fervently hope for is, that the French do engage in a hostile act against the IDF air forces and are decimated by return fire from the IDF and then the entire contingent of Unsavory Nobodies acting under the UN either abandon their protection of the Hezbollah Terrorists or Israel finally just abandons any hope of finding any justice emanating from the UN and ignores any edict or resolution adopted by that useless organization. Any resolution adopted by that body of clowns is in any event unenforceable.
Back to article