News
Protest in UK: Jewish organizations vs. Neturei Karta
Roee Mendel
Published: 19.12.06, 21:32
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
30 Talkbacks for this article
1. and the man answer my whole family
tea man ,   marjayoun leb   (12.19.06)
was annihilated by asmart bomb in Qana and another man said my whole family was hey fannihilated while they trapped in marwaheen then all cry and hug and promise to work for peace END of the story
2. Well done Jews of London.
(12.19.06)
We salute you and are proud of you. Come home soon.
3. Who are those traitors?
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (12.19.06)
Isn't it about time somebody names names, checks backgrounds and shows pictures of who and what those traitors are? Seeing those Jews with Ahmadinejad made me ill. And then I found an almost acceptable explanation in an article. In the meantime, however, the photos of a Jew almost kissing the man who has sworn to wipe out the Jews has gone around the world, doing their damage. http://tinyurl.com/ymaf7d
4. Good to see
megan ,   Israel   (12.19.06)
At last our UK Jews ate standing up and being recognized and well done to them, keep it up. As for neturei karta, they are dispicable and and whatever their argument is, personally I can't look on them as Jews.
5. to Ynet
abe ,   manchester   (12.19.06)
I call on Ynet, that enough is enough. PLease you dont need to mention Netirei Karta anymore. As a religous Jew,i deeply concemn their attendance of the Iran conference, but you, by constatntly mentioning them on Ynet, are painting all religous jews, with the same paint brush.
6. Neturei Karta -WHO
(12.19.06)
This GUYS are NOT Jews! They where kick out of their own nieborhood, and they ended it up were they belong in Iranian HELL. P.S. YES, I'm an Observant Jew, and you wont find any observant jew disagreening with me.
7. #5
Dati Lite   (12.19.06)
I disagree. Even the vicious chareidi haters here are slowly and unwillingly being shown that the Net Kreatures are a group alone, and should be exterminated. They'll still hate chareidim of course, its a sport here, but they usually calm down, for a few minutes, after eating a few shrimps, and shrieking about chareidim/ El Al ad nauseum. Boring lot, these stuffy chilonistim/iyot, unlike us.
8. and the man answe back
Leonard   (12.19.06)
Nobody denied there were nop casualties in the war in lebanon not o mention that some were armed militants but you deny the murder of 6 million unarmed civilian Jews .....slight difference tea man
9. good to see
JEWISH ,   USA   (12.19.06)
THEY ARE NOT JEWISH JUST LOOK LIKE JEWS
10. Neturei Karta
mark ,   london/uk   (12.19.06)
they are the true Jews who may have G-d's forgiveness at the end.Wow to those who do not condemn Israel. According to Talmud, G-d permits the Jewish homeland to be established only after the Messiah's second coming. You have all been warned.
11. Neturei Karta should be outlawed in Israel/UK/USA
Mel ,   USA   (12.19.06)
12. Anti-Zionist Jews are welcomed by all Muslims
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (12.19.06)
In Quran it is written that .. We made them(Beni Israel) excel the nations. Therefore Muslims cannot be hostile to jews but those who letf their religion and became Zionists.
13. Neturei Karta are extreme Pharisees
Jake   (12.20.06)
Just like in old times, when they aided invading empires and worked to annihilate Jewish sovereignty and independence.
14. Some Jews should be stripped of their DNA
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (12.20.06)
If some of these people are considered Jews, I should have, at least, honorary, Israeli citizenship. I would have gone to that holocaust conference for the sheer pleasure of spitting twice in the little asshat's face; once for all the victims of the holocaust and once more, in case I missed the first time. Now and then you just have to stand up for what you stand for.
15. Dear Mark:
marya ,   sacramento,USA   (12.20.06)
Better to keep your mouth closed and be thought a fool than to open it and remove all doubt.
16. CONGRATULATIONS TO JEWS IN LONDON
gabriela ben ari ,   jerusalem   (12.20.06)
17. Dear mark#10, I have not heard of such rubbish!!!
Joseph ,   LA   (12.20.06)
There have been jews living in Israel for the last thousand years! The holy Ari Hakodesh, the human angel who I think was a little more intellecutal then you or your Neturei Karta (alta-kaka) friends will ever be. If all these great kabbalists lives in Safed, Jerusalem, hebron, Haifa etc at their own danger of their lives HOW MUCH MORE so should the jews of the world live there today. If it's such a bad thing to live in Israel why do the hypocrits themselves live there? One more thing, to support enemies of your own people, to side with a nation that wants to wipe Israel of the map is more sinful then all of the negative commandments put together. infact they will be the ones suffering when Moshiach comes. Like the rebels against king david who at the end were punished so shall be the Neturei karta or any people who are for the destruction of Israel. May moshiach come quickly and in our days. It's never too late for them to repent and ask their brothers for forgivenes (while they still live in israel). Perhaps they should move to Iran or with Hamas in Gaza.
18. right venue, right words, right prayer, right people
gabriela ben ari ,   jerusalem   (12.20.06)
19. #10Mark, Messiah's second coming?
Jake   (12.20.06)
Your post belies the fact that you are not Jewish, only posing as a Jew.
20. I didn't exactly hear
bewildered   (12.20.06)
Any condemnation of NK by the great hareidi rabbis like Admorim from Gur, Karlin, Slonim, Belz, Habad, wiznitz, etc say A WORD about these NK
21. bad journalism
mordechai ,   jerusalem, israel   (12.20.06)
Ynet should ask itself why it is giving such prominant publicity to half a dozen sick jews who are running around supporting our enemies? Would ynet give the same publicity to half a dozen left wing kibutznikim if they would run around the world , supporting all of our enemies on the left? I believe not. Its simply an opportunity to make fun of and build animosity towards charadim. I don't believe it was done as a consious policy decision; It simply happened due to latent prejiduces.
22. Correction
Dr Winston Pickett ,   London, UK   (12.20.06)
Well done on a good piece of reportage. However, for the record, it was the Board of Deputies of British Jews which coordinated the rally and the corrrect spelling for the name of one of the key participants is Ben Helfgott.
23. To # 7 dati
charles ,   petach tikva   (12.20.06)
As long as the netoure karta are not excommuniated by the leading rabbi's of the world , we consider that they still belong to your religious world . Redarding charidi hating , you do'nt do much to be loved and more respected . Remember , stone throwers against the Gays , side walks , buses , El Al .
24. Charley boy
Tired   (12.20.06)
New olim should be taught to read - English as well, as then they'd know that ALL the Rabbanim HAVE excommunicated them, boring charlie boy. You're boring and monotonous ad nauseum. Chareidim, yawn, ElAl , yawn,Gay parade( you looked very chic), yawn yawn Are you French? One huge yawn then.
25. Well done Board of Deputies of British Jews.
#2   (12.20.06)
Come home.
26. tired
charles ,   petach tikva   (12.20.06)
My mother tongue is not english , but i did not see in any paper on the web , that they were excommuniated . I agree , their visit was condemned , by Rav Metzger , and Satmar rabbanim . But NOWHERE there was mentionned that a total CHEREM was put on them . NOWHERE . only condemnations , that's not enough . And hold your "shtinkende" words for your charidi friends , not for a GOOD Jewish Israeli citizen .
27. #12
(12.21.06)
show me one single jew anywhere who is not a zionist and doesn't love israel. zionism is judaism and is israel. period!
28. well tired ?
charles ,   petach tikva   (12.21.06)
Where have you read that ALL the rabbanim have excommuniated those friends of you ? Before telling someone to read correctly , try it yourself , and do not come with lyes .
29. anon # 27
charles ,   petach tikva   (12.21.06)
Not all Jews are Zionist . That's wishfull thinking from you . Sad but it's the truth .
30. Neturei Karta
havi ,   los angeles, US   (12.26.06)
Since Naturei Karta claims to be so religious, I just want to know where they found Kosher food in Tehran? and who was the meshgiah?
Back to article