News
Gaddafi: Allow Jews, Christians entry to Mecca
Roee Nahmias
Published: 31.12.06, 15:13
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
40 Talkbacks for this article
1. gadaffi
joshua ,   amsterdam, holland   (12.31.06)
what a joke, to let jews and christians go around the kaaba. for what reason? to show their support for all the terror that comes from mecca's they should be allowed in the city to destroy it!
2. GADDAFI SPOKE WORLDLY WHEN SADDAM WAS CAUGHT
GADDAFI SPEAKS CAUSE ,   HE'S AFRAID HE NEXT   (12.31.06)
GADDAFI..GO TO YOUR OWN HOLE AND SAFE YOUR LIFE
3. Christianity
Sagi ,   Israel   (12.31.06)
is not a monotheistic religion. Encircling a black stone is voodoo. Gaddaffi is psychotic Religion is a crime agaist humanity.
4. First thing's First
Mike ,   Oleh Hadash, Cdn.   (12.31.06)
The House of Saud have to allow Jews on their soil.
5. The Places dont make any great difference
Atilla Karagözoğlu ,   Istanbul   (12.31.06)
Unless we remember why we created by The God. If someday we lose the places, would it mean we will lose our believe ? No one owns the places (any of important ones) No need to keep the places open until the last day for our belives continue to survive as long as our hearts dont deserve. NO ONE CAN KNOW THE OTHER'S LEVEL IN THE GOD. and THE GRASS IN SOME PLACES IS NOT GREEN !. lets remember that.
6. I Bet The Saudis Liked This Comment
Terry ,   Eilat - Israel   (12.31.06)
As crazy as he is, good old Qaddafi is making a valid point. If Islam were really a religion of peace & tolerence, that's what they should do. But, of course, it's not a religion of peace nor tolerence - it's not exactly a religion, more of a political movement. Qaddafi comes up with these gems from time to time.
7. mecca
Ariel ,   Jerusalem   (12.31.06)
Waaw, I can't wait to go and circle around that thing!
8. Breath of fresh air from the old dictator
JPS ,   Efrat   (12.31.06)
What a pleasant uttering from the aging Nasserite. He's nowhere near an octogenarian yet, so we can only assume that he's sincere in his remarks and not off his... well, his rocker sits on a different plane than the rest of ours.... It would be nice if some religious leaders would engage him further on this, as the spread of conciliatory tones would help cool the overheated religious fervor out there.
9. Terry #6
Khalid   (12.31.06)
Islam not a religion? We worship one God, we read from one book; sounds like a religion to me!
10. What a clown!
Rabih ,   Beirut, Lebanon   (12.31.06)
Who listens to this moron anyway?
11. #9 What about tolerance?
Dan ,   Israel   (12.31.06)
Muslims can visit sacred places in Rome, Jerusalem and elsewhere but non-muslims are not allowed to enter Mecka or Media. Jews once constituted a very large proportion of the population there before they were massacred and displaced by Muhammed's forces. No Jew has been allowed to enter there ever since. Is this an example of muslim "tolerance"?
12. No Thanks, Just leave us alone
john ,   nz   (12.31.06)
13. Great Business Man
elijah ,   Beirut   (12.31.06)
Yeah bring more tourists to Mecca. Later there will be a casino next the the kaaba.
14. Khalid #9
Terry ,   Eilat - Israel   (12.31.06)
You should know the origins of Islam. Your founder was as much political leader as religious leader. islam does not separate religion from political matters. Historically, religion was used to justify any regime. It is the same today - look at Iran, the Taliban, Saudi Arabia, Hamas, Hezbollah, etc. In my view, Islam is basically an ideology based on religion that seeks political domination. Sharia law does not distinguish between religious & civil matters. Almost all Muslim countries incorporate to some degree or another, Islam as the state religion. So, that's my answer - and worshipping G-d does not change in any way the nature of the ideology nor does having a holy book. A rather uncomfortable analogy would be an ideology like communism with a holy book "Das Kapital" & Karl Marx as prophet.
15. How About Dome of Rock & Al Aqsa Mosques?
Rick ,   USA   (12.31.06)
Non-muslims used to be allowed entry to view these mosques, but no longer. How about starting with opening them back up?
16. to#13.
mark ,   ca   (12.31.06)
Donald Trump must be exited!:-)
17. to #10.
mark ,   ca   (12.31.06)
He is not a moron. Still in power.
18. religion
arthur ,   england   (12.31.06)
its silly to say mohammedanism is not a religion. all religions i know of influence the political behaviour of their followers, whether by influencing their way of thinking, moral values, philosophical concepts or by having rules or examples to follow. religion; derived from religare (Latin) = way of life
19. Beit HaMikdash
Chaya ,   Bat Yam, Israel   (12.31.06)
When the Beit HaMikdsh (Third Temple) is built, it will be a place for all believers to come to. Will Qadaffi now be a target for some Muslim extremist?
20. to # 6, Islam is a complete well complied Religion, like it
SImon Mohammed ,   Falls Church, VA, US   (12.31.06)
or do not like it is your problem. and when you talk about the religion of peace and tolerance it is really when a mutual respect is there, but when people like you are not tolerant and peacful like you, who ever you are, then it is granted the total devine right to reciprocate. how this sound to you my friend?? I allowed my self to call you friend because i am muslim and tolerant and open minded. with my best regard to all
21. thanks, but, no, thanks
v. n.y. ,   usa   (12.31.06)
we jews have our wall and our temple and we face west to jerusalem. so, with all due respect, we are not interested in your black rock or religious beliefs and god who only creates ayhem, destruction and poverty around the world. keep your religion of peace and leave ours alone!
22. religion
Ben Wolf ,   New York USA   (12.31.06)
arthur, england religion is derived from religare (Latin) = to bind together. Religio (Latin) came to mean the rituals, superstitions, and piety engendered by these communal beliefs. An entire way of life it was not.
23. Will Qadaffi now be a target for some Muslim extremist?
Ben Wolf ,   NYC USA   (12.31.06)
Perhaps. But more likely for trying to have the Saudi king assassinated than for his silly babbling. Too bad. The Arabs would benefit materially from opening up to the world, instead of hiding their lives like their women, behind all-encompassing veils.
24. Quadaffi is right! Nt
(12.31.06)
25. #20...Simon
Craig ,   USA   (12.31.06)
You said: "...then it is granted the divine right to reciprocate." Tell me Simon, when did the Jews ever blow up pizza parlors, wedding celebrations,or busses, or fly airplanes into buildings?? RECIPROCATE??? You pathetic deluded hypocrite. Islam is a religion of violence and intolerance. It was spread from the very beginning by violence, murder and intimidation....and it still is. Simply look at Iraq if you think an exception to the Islamic rule to "tolerance and peace" must be made for Jews. Look at what Islamics do to other Islamics they don't agree with. Oh, let me guess....those aren't real Islamics right? Why, if Islam is a religion of "peace and tolerance", are over 95% of all terrorist acts perpetrated by Islamics? Open your eyes my friend, you have been lied to. The fruit of Islam is all around you; it is violence, hatred, intolerance, intimidation, deceit and bloodshed....,in times past and today! Read the history of Mohammed's life...the real history, see how tolerant the very founder of Islam was. We won't even go into how women are treated in Islam. Grow up Simon...before it is too late for you, before you are so brainwashed you can no longer even distinguish truth.
26. What #1 said shows that Jews shouldn't be allowed in Mecca
Lebanese in Canada ,   Montreal   (12.31.06)
27. What #26 said shows that Lebanese Shouldn't be Allowed in US
Jerry Sussman ,   Alexandria, USA   (12.31.06)
You are such a bigoted jackass that you do not even realize how patently offensive your own comment is. You smear the entirety of Jews with opproprium merely because you disagree with the views of one. I am Jewish. I have been somewhat pleasantly surprized by some of the more conciliatory remarks that have come from Qaddaffi since he decided to return to the human race several years ago. My reaction to his suggestion, if sincerely made, was one of appreciation not a venal, knee-jerk tirade of the kind to which you apparently subscribe. By your logic, I now may judge the entirety of Lebanese to be as stupid and as bigoted as you.
28. Mecca
Meir ,   Arad   (12.31.06)
I just cancelled my trip to Uman during Rosh Hashana, I am going to Mecca. LOL
29. GADDAFI IS JEWISH.....READ BELOW
zaq ,   ranaana   (12.31.06)
Guess what Gaddafi is jewish..... his mother was born into a libyan jewish family.....she was kidnapped as a young girl (8) by Gaddafi's father and kept eventually to have children with him So go figure, maybe someone should invite him over for shabbat or something......
30. 29 - where did you get this information?
Chaya ,   Bat Yam, Israel   (12.31.06)
I did some searching and found nothing.
Next talkbacks
Back to article