News
Iran leader: I believe Israel will soon collapse
Reuters
Published: 04.01.07, 07:23
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
62 Talkbacks for this article
31. WHAT IS THIS OBSESSION HE HAS WITH US???????????????????????
Talula ,   Israel   (01.04.07)
32. To # 29
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (01.04.07)
Iran didn't defeat Israel. Iran defeated Lebanon. I suggest you look at post-war pictures of Beirut, etc. and compare those to pictures of Tel Aviv etc., and then tell me who won and who lost.
33. PARS ! 12,000 Iraqi died in the year of 2006
Atilla Karagözoğlu ,   Istanbul   (01.04.07)
I wonder what is Iran's responsibility about it as THE MOST POWERFULL COUNTRY IN THE MIDDLE EAST ? what I believe, Iran is for herself. Not for Islam. Not for The other Islam's nation. When you have a target (aim) as wipe out Israel ; IT IS A SIMPLE SIGN TO LOSE IN TODAY. If you look at Israel as little country in Middle East, you make a historical mistake. Accept or not, Israel means The US. The US means little country. This is reality. You can call me stupid. The US will not lose Its power many 100's years according my poor history knowledge. If Israel (and The US) dont listen her people right, there can be big lose in future for them. The People of Israel want to live in peace. The US people also want to live in peace. Believe or not, Islam Nations (My Nations) are not helping for peace. We are not that strong about WORLD WINDS ON US. If we dont care our own believe in right way, no one will have mercy on us. Our God ! He sure watcing us with care. He must expect we first take the real mean of the believe. We are for peace. But no one believes us. World people look at todays Islamic people (most of them) and all they see, many people even dont stay together. If we want to give A GOOD NAME TO PEACE we got to find some other ways instead of wipe out. Even !!! Jews belong to The God. Even Jews have good people. No one is step child of The God. Jews are not stupid. THIS IS A FACT. LETS NOT EXPECT THEY ACT AS STUPID. Lets we try to understand them. Lets try to give a hand to the people of Israel. IF THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL WILL HUG EACHOTHER WITH THE MUSLIMS PEOPLE....no politicians can stop that energy. There is a way for WORLD PEACE. Just one way. That is ; try to have good relation with Israel's Civilian People. If we have enough LOVE for the people of Israel (not politicians) The People of Israel will have strong support for WORLD PEACE. No King did able to keep the power in the history. and No King will have it forever in future. LETS HELP EACH OTHER. Love & Peace Atilla Karagözoğlu
34. to #30
pars ,   tehran   (01.04.07)
Dont forget jewish you insult to nation(iranian)that their king Cyrus the great has released your people from babylon prison,if he had'nt done this ,you and your people and your religion were in history books.
35. To #2 Malcom - Your comment is inane!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (01.04.07)
If you have something constructive to say then say it. I, and I am sure many others, would like to know on what you base your conclusion about Olmert. To make statements just to see your name in print is stupid. You might like to tell us where you come from. Are you perhaps Iranian? If you want to blame Olmert for something then blame him and his predecessors for the state of anarchy that Israel finds itself in today.
36. #28 has a problem identifying sarcasim
Judith in Haifa   (01.04.07)
37. he does not mean ot, he is kidding
1.5 Billion Muslims   (01.04.07)
Reality Check , World
38. EVEN A Child Of 5 Years Old.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (01.04.07)
Ahmadinejad says :".. soon we will observe the collapse of the Zionist regime (of Israel)". WELL, after every 4 years one regime is voted out - and another regime comes to power (in Israel - and so many other democratic countries). EVEN a child of 5 years old can make that prediction - and Ahmadinejad is PROUD to be able to make such a prediction. So, is he trying to FOOL the Arabs of Khuzestan - with his big words with empty meaning ??? It is a PITY that the Iranians has such a fool as President !!!
39. To #34
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (01.04.07)
You're right about Cyrus. He, actually, came up with a very enlightened Bill of Rights. Too bad that Ahmadinejad is not looking to him as an example. The fact that Cyrus allowed the Jews, who were then in Babylonian captivity, to return to "their homeland" establishes the historical fact that present-day Israel belonged to the Jews, at least, as far back as 590 BC. Somebody point that out to Ahmadinejad and to the Palis and tell them to cut out the BS about collapse and occupation.
40. To Pars #34. There is a HUGE Difference.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (01.04.07)
You write :".. if he (Cyrus the Great) hadn't done this, .. your people and your religion (would have been) .. history ..". You are WRONG for making that statement. The existence of a people or a religion is ONLY and SOLELY dependent on the Almighty - and on NO one else. There is a HUGE difference between ordinary people of this world, including King Cyrus the Great, - and the Almighty. BTW King Cyrus the Great was a great ruler of Iran. But NOW Iran has a President who is Fool Number One. I don't think the great Iranian people deserves such a man as President. So, get rid of him !
41. To. M. Hartley #39. Great Research.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (01.04.07)
Great research. Thank you.
42. To #41
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (01.04.07)
I can't find my shoes or car keys half the time, but I remember ancient history. What struck me most about Cyrus is his "Bill of Rights" that applied even to the captured countries and the inscription on his tomb; not at all that of one of the most successful and enlightened rulers of his time (not necessarily verbatim): "O man, whoever you are and whencever you come, for I know that come you will, I am Cyrus who won the Persians an empire. Do therefore not begrudge me this little bit of earth that covers my body."
43. I have to agree with the monkey this one time
ex Kadima sucker   (01.04.07)
Israel is not getting rid of oldmerde and all corrupted leftists. Both Iran and moderate-left here seek to see Israel wiped from the map. So yes he might be right
44. There is not enough energy...
Brisa ,   Illinois   (01.04.07)
..to support the continued undustrialization of China and India while allowing the US to contunue to consume 20% of the world's energy supply. China, Russia and India need Iran's energy, period. Their national interest's demand that they prevent the US from controlling Iran's resources. A military strike and/or an outright invasion would likely bring China and Russia to Iran's aid. (Note the TOR anti-aircraft system now being deployed courtesy of Russia) I don't think that WWIII with nuclear weapons is in anyone's interest. God knows that the Middle East is already heavily polluted with toxic depleted uranium weapons residue.
45. Cut the BS and Stop playing the victim
the american ,   austin, us   (01.04.07)
Israelis and Jews need to quit playing the perpetual victim it's so insincere it's disgusting. The fact is, that Israel is one of most powerful countries in the world, also it’s one of the few countries in the world and the ONLY country in the Middle East with Nuclear weapons - on top of this, the MOST powerful country in the world (my country) fully supports you morally, financially, and militarily. You know and most of the world knows Israel is not going anywhere. Iran’s President is using pure rhetoric to goad the American and Israeli governments while trying to gain support from Muslims around the world – he’s not a threat and probably won’t even be re-elected. You are so caught up by this little man because you feel the need to play the victim – the real threat in the Middle East is not Iran but the Wahabbi’s that run Saudi Arabia and give millions of dollars to fund Al Qaeda type militants around the world (the true source of sectarian violence in Iraq – case in point -> http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2006%5C12%5C30%5Cstory_30-12-2006_pg1_3 also the country where most of the 9/11 hijackers came from) . Iran hasn’t attacked a country in generations and def won’t be attacking one of the most powerful countries in the world. By the time Iran has the capacity to even produce WMD’s (in about 10 years) this President will be gone. It’s funny how this Administration and Israel can openly talk about a regime change in Iran and indirectly talk about attacking Iran; heck they can even attack other countries but somehow you justify it – yet when Iran’s president just talk’s about the collapse of Israel and questions a historical event he’s the most evil person in the world. How many innocent people have been killed by this strange little man’s rhetoric? Yet how many innocents have been killed and maimed by US and Israeli (mostly US) Missiles and Guns? Give me a break – open your eyes.
46. WOW
American ,   United States   (01.04.07)
I agree with the American from Austin number 45...this person sounds very intelligent...you made such great points and I am relieved to know that there are some Americans out there who are able to look past main stream media and form an intelligent and logical opionion based on REAL FACTS not FOX new propaganda!
47. Finally someone said something worthwhile here
The Briton ,   London, UK   (01.04.07)
to #45 It's hard to find the comments and thoughts of an evenly minded person on these types of website. You sir are indeed the silent majority. The rest of the BS shovelling, Wolf crying, ambulance chasing stooges on here seem to have a well coordinated agenda. They protesteth TOO MUCH! Our own lame duck Blair has just got in on the act too, looking for his legacy no doubt. May 10th cannot come soon enough.
48. #s 45, 46 and 47..
Lynne   (01.05.07)
Thank you... :) well said..
49. Iranian leader
Tom ,   Shelbyville, IL.   (01.05.07)
Holowhat? Yeah. Right.
50. 45-48
AJ ,   UK   (01.05.07)
Iran supports Hezbollah, Syria( home of Hamas,Hezbollah, and all the other 'Palestinian' so called freedom movements), builds nuclear technology with Russian help, and threatens to wipe Israel off the map and you think it's not a threat? So I guess Hitler's threats against the Jews were just rhetoric as well then? It;s time the world took this guy seriously.
51. re Cyrus
AJ ,   UK   (01.05.07)
Now in the first year of Cyrus king of Persia, that the word of the LORD [spoken] by the mouth of Jeremiah might be accomplished, the LORD stirred up the spirit of Cyrus king of Persia, that he made a proclamation throughout all his kingdom, and [put it] also in writing, saying, 2Ch 36:23 Thus saith Cyrus king of Persia, All the kingdoms of the earth hath the LORD God of heaven given me; and he hath charged me to build him an house in Jerusalem, which [is] in Judah. Who [is there] among you of all his people? The LORD his God [be] with him, and let him go up. I think this states why Cyrus facilitated the Jewish return because the God of Israel told him to!
52. to# 33
Babak ,   Vancouver, Canda   (01.05.07)
At least someone hear thinks before answering stupid comments, let us not get too wound up on what Ahmadinejad has said. Why don't you look at what is happening around the world. There are much more important events that require more attention than this. People of Israel and people of Iran are all humans regardless of their religious believes, and for that matter so are the people of Palestine. Ask yourselves if it is fair for Palestinians to be treated the way they are. Is it??? To# 30, Please do not mix up a nation with its government, don't insult a Nation.It is obvious you are an ignorant individual. If we are talking about Israel or US and its Policies we are not to confuse it with its people. Iranians have nothing against Israel or US people. The Iranian nation and the Israel nation have more in common than Iranian's have with any other Arab or any other Islamic nation excluding Afghanistan. For Example the President of Israel is of Iranian Descent. But the fact remains that still most Iranian believe that the toppling of our Shah was because Iran was becoming a powerful as an Islamic nation and it did not suit neither Israel nor US, so that is why some of us do not like either Israel or US and their Policies. But still I believe that with dialog we can resolve most of the world’s problem. And please don’t confuse our government with the great People of Iran.
53. Response to #14
Jc   (01.05.07)
Jesus will return, but no where in the sciptures does it indicate Mahdi will be with Him. Read Matthew chapter 24 in the bible,Hebrews 9:28, 1 Thess. 4:16-17, also all nations will rise against Israel in the last day , those who do will not escape unscathed. (Zech.12:2-3)
54. Israel has a nuclear deterrent
Mux ,   Manchester, UK   (01.05.07)
and Iran hasn't. Hey, just go for it. Start World War III. Tens of thousands of Israelis will die and hatred will rule the next fifty years but hey, you'll probably kill more of them than they do of you. Fingers crossed, eh? Pity about having to turn Israel into a military prison and irradiating half the Middle East, though. Could have been a nice place. Malformed grandchildren will be a shame too. Will waste a few billion dollars, you know. Standards of living will drop (as will the living, period). Security? Tourism? Trade? Israeli image abroad? Best not to think about it. But hey, there will be loads more dead babies on their side than on yours, and that must surely be worth it! It's just simple maths, like this test: Killing Of Enemy Children During Holy War = 1) Can't Be Helped, Such A Shame. 2) Can Be Helped, But God Really Doesn't Mind. 3) A Blasphemous Abomination Before The Lord And The Utter Triumph Of Satan, If You Think About It Logically. (Suicide bombers, American Presidents and various IDF personnel have the right to not answer this question. In this life, anyway...)
55. No threat
Robert Ham ,   Bristol, UK   (01.05.07)
I can't actually see any threatening statements here, in contradiction to Harissa's assumptions. If I'm not mistaken, the Soviet Union collapsed from within; there was no enemy that attacked it, causing the collapse. Ahmadinejad saying that Israel will collapse similarly to the Soviet Union is not a threat. Robert
56. #45,46,47...some thoughts!
DR ,   Florida, USA   (01.05.07)
I agree with you on some points, BUT, as you probably know, Israel has one of the best inteligence services in the world. They see and know a lot of things we don't. The CiA is also watching everything closely. We already know that Iran funds and trains Hezballah, a terror group, right? We know that Iran gives weapons to Syria which are then funneled to terror groups. We know that Iran sends insurgents into Iraq to kill American soldiers and innocent civilians, and to create chaos, right? You cannot ignore or deny any of these facts. I think the level of paranoia we see is too much, but we should be vigilant and aggressive when dealing with Iran, or else we will send them the wrong messege....one of weakness. This will only embolden them to keep up the "bad work". Israel cannot and will not fight this war alone. The US, UK, and others must help.
57. Another Hitler
Mannstein ,   USA   (01.05.07)
Oi vay gewalt another holocaust is on the way and not too soon.
58. To Babak #52. Dialogue Between Peoples.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (01.05.07)
You write :".. still most Iranian believe that the toppling of our Shah ..". ARE you suggesting that Shah Mohammed Reza Pahlavi (Shah from 1941 till 1979) was toppled by the USA ??? THE Shah was a great friend of USA - and with Israel on friendly terms. THE Shah was toppled by the uprising organized by the Ayatollahs of Iran - by February 11th 1979. Babak, if you present LIES as historical facts - than on what BASIS will the great (?) people of Iran engage in dialogue with the Israeli People. IF lies lies at the foundation of your history knowledge - than dialogue between peoples, as mentioned by you, will have NO meaning. This kind of dialogue is simply a WASTE of time.
59. here we go again
Neil ,   London   (01.07.07)
As a frequent visitor to Israel over the past 20 years it is so sad to see how so much of the country is succumbing to terrible hatred and racism. Iranians are not monsters and have, through democratic means, already curtailed much of Ahmadinejad's influence in the recent elections. Iranians are concerned with jobs, education and the economy, not with nuclear war. For Israelis to openly call for the destruction of another people based on nothing more than a supposition is truly a betrayal of Israel's heritage.
60. #59....have you been living under a rock?
DR ,   Florida, USA   (01.08.07)
I'm sorry if you missed the last two years but we have seen some interesting things coming out of Iran. 1. funding and support of hezbullah (a terror group) which hopes to destroy Israel.. 2. support for insurgency into Iraq, killing innocent people and US troops. 3., Advancement of a nuclear program which is not transparent to the international gaurd dog. 4. Countless threats against any country willing to stop Iran's nuclear ambitions. All of this and you still think they are a country with peaceful intentions??? Wake up man!!!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article