News
Bomber's brother: We're happy Muhammad is the hero
Ali Waked
Published: 29.01.07, 20:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
100 Talkbacks for this article
61. let me explain
v n.y. ,   israel/boston   (01.30.07)
if you desire an explanation to an act so horenduous, so insane and so inhumane, all you have to do is read the kuran. however, before reading the kuran itself, do me a great favor and pick up a book called WHY I AM NOT A MUSLIM by IBN WARRAQ. this particular book, a masterpiece of research, fact, and reason will shed all the light needed on why this particular individual did what he did and why this act is so encouraged in the muslim world and the kuran. the book's title says enough and it says it all. another excellent text i recommend is THE TROUBLE WITH ISLAM TODAY by irshad manji. a muslim calling for an immediate reform in islamic dogma, religion and laws. another excellent source would be THE GREAT THEFT by KHALED ABUEL FADL. all three authors are experts and leading authorities on islam and its law and ways of practice. i teach the subject at an ivy league university and have done extensive laborious research into the phenomena you cannot understand. however, there is a very simple explanation. all you have to do is read these books. my students tell me they are indeed a huge eye opener for those trying to understand what is going on not only in the middle east, arab/israeli conflict, but also in the mindset of the palestinian extremist and regular person these days. please read!
62. Don't be so hard on her, she'd probably be lynched for tears
Sam ,   Virginia, USA   (01.30.07)
63. #10 - A little American "tough love".
Michelle T   (01.30.07)
It hurts, but you're right.
64. #61 you are hillarious
erik ,   new york USA   (01.30.07)
"all three authors are leading authority on islam"? LMAO. never heard one of them. Here's a piece for your info- Islam DOES NOT recognize commantary on any issue thats in koran- Suicide and homicide is a crime just as it is in any country's law / moral standard. At least make sense when you try to spread misinformation. LOL holly crap you are funny. ciao.
65. Mohammed's special monsters
Dave ,   Montreal, Canada   (01.30.07)
Another fine example of what the worst the emmissaries of Islam have to offer to the world; Death, destruction, misery, anger, vengence, hate...Who in their right mind can possibly state with a straight face that this religion has anything positive to offer? It may be time to rethink a strategy to completely undermine this religion of peace.
66. mental illness
Tom Breese ,   Covina, CA, USA   (01.30.07)
Civilized people cannot regard this young man's suicide as anything less than cowardice born of a demented soul, born of a very sick culture, wrapped in false faith. To hijack a religion, pervert it, and attempt to cloak this bloodlust in this synthesis is, at very least, not legitimate. Legitimate Islam must rise above its cowardice and speak directly loudly, directly and openly against this inexcusable behavior, or it will cease to be regarded as legitimate, having been subsumed by the violent ones.
67. Punishment and Deterence for Suicide Bombers
Umm El Kul Naqba   (01.30.07)
PUNISHMENT AND DETERENCE FOR SUICIDE BOMBERS In such cases where the family is proud of the murderous actions of one of the member, then the family is complicit in the murder and must pay - An eye for an eye. Blowing up the house is not enough. Just like the Netura Kartei that participated in the Iran Holocaust farce are now barred from entering Israel, the whole family that endorsed the murderous act in Eilat are viable proxies to pay the price for Muhammad Saqsaq's terrrorist act. I will agree with those that suggest waiting for the right time to carry out the required retribution/punishment/determent. As long as PALs are killing each other, we do not want to give them a reason to stop and redirect their terror against us. When the time is right, we should directly carry out the punishment on Muhammad Saqsaq's family - Eye for an Eye.
68. SICKOS that Amira Hass, Gideon Levy and Aloni suppo
David Stoler   (01.30.07)
Golda Meir was so right... the blood shed will only stop when the Arabs value the blood of their children. (note: I have 12 grandchildren and I would give my life before allowing them to do anything as un-Godly as blowing themselves up and kill innocents) This family of worshippers of the cult of child sacrifice are the ultimate in barbaric fanaticism and evil. Like the Nazis, these cultists allowed themselves to be brainwashed into believing that good is evil and evil is good. Just like at the beginning of the Intifada in 2000 when there were terrorist attacks E-V-E-R-Y D-A-Y, until we finally took measures to protect ourselves. The checkpoints, the seperation fence, they all contributed yet you Israel haters cry apartheid! WE KEEP THEM ON ONE SIDE FOR A REASON! Are you listening Amira, Gideon and Aloni! ____________________________________________________________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Everyone is raving about the all-new Yahoo! Mail beta. http://new.mail.yahoo.com
69. #56 - Real Victims
Tracy W   (01.30.07)
A good PR campaign in the West is way overdue. The only ones the media gives voice to when giving the Israeli point of view, is the Isreaeli Left. Always. To be "evenhanded" after telling all the details of Palestinian suffering, the Western media have features regarding the Holocaust or other Jewish issues, but never anything about the killings of Jews by Arabs or Arab voices filled with threats and hatred. That's something that the average Western audience never hears about from mainstream media.
70. Good comments, Ryan
SAM ,   USA   (01.30.07)
Hows the recruiting comming along for the next Crusade? I will be first in line to join up. It seems it is the only thing scum like this understand
71. We need victory
Doug Miller ,   Miami Beach, USA   (01.30.07)
The response to this reprehensible atrocity much be made painful to the perpetrators. The criminals who run the terrorist gangs who claim credit for the murders must be eliminated. If that includes Abbas and Haniyah, so be it. The homes belonging to the killers' families must once again be bulldozed and the parents and siblings must be expelled. The families then won't be so proud of their mass murdering relatives. Arms transfers, military training and money transfers must be ended. The borders must be closed again and check points re-instated to keep the murderers away from their intended victims. If these minimal things aren't done then the Arabs will only be encouraged to kill us. We need to send them a clear message that Jewish blood is no longer cheap.
72. During the past year, these kind and gentle Israelis who are
Apartheid ,   Methuen USA   (01.30.07)
so appalled by violence, killed 742 Palestinians, injured 3753, and arrested 5671. Among the number killed were 144 children ( the youngest three days old), and 532 women including pregnant women, mothers, elderly and five with special needs. Israel also invaded Lebanon, bombed villages and infrastructure and killed 1400 civilians. In the last days of the war while peace agreements were already in place, the Israelis carpet bombed south Lebanon with a cluster bomb known to have a high failure rate, thus in effect 'mining' the entire region. Since the end of the war, these cluster bombs have killed 30 and maimed 180, so far, in much the same way that a suicide bomber kills and maims. In the light of these events you all sound ridiculous.
73. Muhammad is the hero ??
Roy Galut ,   Selah Washington USA   (01.30.07)
Issacc , Ismael ,Jacob & esau woulld roll over in thier Graves .....They learned how to live togather in peace..... time has come for Arabs to make peace with thier bother Israel and constructivly live togather.... Psalms 83
74. the hero? or Zero!
Pierre ,   Valleyfield, Canada   (01.30.07)
Murder is murder. Even if is in the name of God, which is even worse, because it's calling God a liar.
75. #72
Pierre ,   Valleyfield, Canada   (01.30.07)
I agree with you. An eye for an eye has never been the answer to violence. But, if you permit me, sometimes, it's better to kick ass and give a taste of the medecine than stay put and do nothing. Sorry.
76. Bible, Proverbs 3:3 Do not let kindness and truth leave you
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (01.30.07)
Bible, Proverbs 4:4 Keep My commandments and live
77. to Muhammad's brother
(01.30.07)
And why don't you blow your own ass off, right here, in Nunavut. Plenty of space, and cold weather that might help you think straight! But of course, just like your kin, you are gutless. Can't face life. Too hard to think!
78. Haniyeh & Abbas: time to meet your virgins!
John Smith ,   San Francisco, USA   (01.30.07)
It's the only answer. Ice them both. They're the "leaders" of this snake pit. Let them take responsibility - the ultimate responsibility.
79. RE 72. During the past
Roy Galut ,   Selah Washington USA   (01.30.07)
There be some problems on the Israeli side ..However the media playsdown the fact that Hesbulah delibertly place thier rocket launchers next to civilian shelters to maximize the policical fallout for the israelis..... I suspect even if the israelis were to totaly surrender all thier weapons folks like your self would cheer whenever a hesbulah rocket or suiside bomber blows up and maims israelis and would shockup casualty figures as israely propaganda Do an internet search on "Bridget Gabriel" she is lebonise and has a story to tell...
80. #72
(01.30.07)
and all that clearly WASN'T enough..............
81. Cursed! Hashem reigns
Josh   (01.30.07)
Unemployed, only daughter died (huge downfall for large Arab families abound), and pained because of infighting. Say no more. Look at the people who have cursed lives and make sure you don't anger G-d as they have.
82. Kadima must go!
Y ,   Israel   (01.30.07)
The bomber had the same message as Abu Mazen (the "moderate" who has tea with Tzipi Livni): stop fighting each other, turn your guns against Israel. We need new, zionist, patriotic leadership!
83. Foolish Mother(s)
Arthur ,   Israel   (01.30.07)
Mohammad’s mother is the most stupid mother on the earth [so are other suicide bomber’s mothers]. Your son is gone for nothing; his soul will remain on this earth for 10000 years according to ‘G-d’s suicide laws’ and then go to hell for further punishment(s). [Your religious leaders don’t tell you the truth; they get paid for teaching you wrong things in favor of your political gang!] And in which G-ds name you are encouraging your sons to kill Jews? You trust in one G-d, G-d of Ibrahim, Isaac and Yaakov, right? So we the Jews trust in the same G-d, G-d of Abraham, Issac and Yakov. So; you are killing the people loved by your G-d. Where do you think your son will go? To the heaven to enjoy 72 virgins? Where G-d himself have not a single wife! Now think of the rest of your family; if IDF is instructed; you will not have roof over your heads. And real sense you will a refugee in your own land through your own Government!
84. Keep your believe LADY
Atilla Karagözoğlu ,   Istanbul   (01.30.07)
I dont blame you. even you wrong, you think you are fighting to DEVIL. I blame your ELITES. I blame your next door. How can these two people staying as next doors ? ONE POOR....SO THE OTHER ! KEEP YOUR BELIEVE. FIGHT. EVEN YOUR WAY IS TOO WRONG. NEVER STOP. THEY WANT YOU TO NOT LOSE YOUR WAY OF FIGHT. SO DONT LOSE. WHO ARE THEY ? well, not me , this is all I can say.
85. Attila, YES, I BLAME the Mother
Esther ,   Ofarim, Israel   (01.30.07)
And I use the word "Mother" loosely. She gave birth to a child she was supposed to protect, to nurture. She KNEW he wanted to do this. She didn't try to stop him. She is HAPPY about what he did. She is just as much a twisted, perverted murderous... thing as her son.
86. Stop to use These two poor !
Atilla Karagözoğlu   (01.30.07)
bad judges we are ! very bad. do you think these two poor ALONE ? well, not. NO. even their way is 100 % wrong. they are not alone. WHO LEFT THEM THIS POOR ?
87. #61 erik
v n.y. ,   israel/boston   (01.30.07)
by the way, the reason you have not heard of IBN WARRAQ, the author of WHY I AM NOT A MUSLIM, is because this name is a pseudo name. the real author had no intention of revealing his true identity lest he end up like salman rushdi with a FATWA on his head. i am sure you know what fatwa is. however, to give this scholar credit for a wonderful master piece of islamic doctrine explanation, this wonderful text was endorsed by dr. joseph hoffman of wesminster college, oxford university, england....a leading authority on islam. go look up dr. hoffman for your information. you may laugh at me all you want, but surely notg at an oxford university professor. additionally read the following world experts on islam. well known and brilliant in their analysis of history and religion as related to islam and muhammad.... d. pipes w. tisdall i. goldziher w. muir a. geiger s. hurgronje a. dashti g. h. bousquet it may sharpen your mind and lessen your ignorance. happy reading.
88. 72 Actually I think you have lost it entirely.
freedom ,   canada   (01.30.07)
Where do you live, in normality... It makes me wonder anyways it takes many people to make the world what it is.
89. Apartheid 72
Margaret   (01.30.07)
People like you who hate Israel always exagerate the number of fatalities to try and make Israelis look as bad as possible. I even heard one blogger say just recently Israelis killed over 4,000 Arabs this year,which of course,is totally absurd. Even BTselem a very liberal human rights group in Israel puts the number of Palestinian dead at much lower figures then you did. And of course,probably most of the dead were not innocent little babies,pregnant women, and small children like you claim but armed terrorists who would have loved nothing more then to murder innocent little Israeli babies,pregnant women and children. If it weren't for terrorists using women and children as human shields most of them would probaby still be alive. You think the Palestinian terrorists care about their women and children? Why did they constantly shoot at each other endangering their own families. The other day a 2 year old baby and 6 year old child were killed during the gunbattles between these terrorists. You don't say a word about that your only outraged when the Arab kids are killed by the evil Jewish soldiers. Also, if it weren't for that horrible "Apartheid wall" and Israeli intelligence there would have been many more Israeli deaths,which I am sure would have made you just real happy,so get off your moral high horse and quit pretending like you care about innocents who are victimized in this conflict. By the way, almost everyday dozens of innocents are killed by suicide bombers or other acts of terror in Iraq. A few months ago,Iraqi Muslims killed more fellow Muslims in one month then those evil Israeli Jews killed Arabs in almost 7 years of conflict. Funny how do gooder humantarians like you never say a thing about that.
90. The solution is simple
Jerrold Cohen ,   Seal Beach, CA USA   (01.30.07)
Get out of the West Bank, take down the Wall, give Palestinians equal water per person, pay back the Palestinians the 2 million trees Israelis tore down or bulldozed, including the 3/4 million olive trees, rebuild the houses you blew up in revenge, and suddenly you will have the best of friends as your next door neighbors, the Palestinians. But will Israel ever do it? NEVER. Israel is not known for sanity.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article