News
'Palestinian Genocide Day' instead of Holocaust Day
Itamar Eichner
Published: 31.01.07, 10:56
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
103 Talkbacks for this article
1. Spain has been a warm friend of the Jews for 1,000 years
Moshe ,   Beit Shemesh   (01.31.07)
they are saying this as 'criticism of friends.' also Spain has been at the forefront of human rights for 1,000 years.
2. Time to roll up sleeves and fight ignorance
JPS ,   Efrat   (01.31.07)
Politically correct do-gooders who don't even know they are re-writing history are making work for us. There's no shortage of well-meaning Jews who are short on knowledge and quick on the jump to equate the Israeli-Palestinian conflict with Nazi-Jewish history. The only solution is education. I think we're also going to have to reach out more widely. It could be that as the WW2 generation dies off we'll have to talk about the Holocaust in the context of 40 million dead in WW2, and make the distinction that the 6 million were not just "collateral damage", but were targeted for extinction. Mayor Leon's ignorance is alarming, and is indicative of the work that has to be done to educate people to what the Holocaust really was.
3. It is amazing how well Pal Proaganda works.
Michael ,   Israel   (01.31.07)
They have many simple minded people around the world convinced that they are victims of a terrible genocide when it fact it is their own intolerence, hatred and uncompromising positions for the last 60 years that have brought them to their current situation. Geobbels would be proud.
4. Islamic Caliphate
Muhammad   (01.31.07)
Spain has already been recaptured by the muslims the only thing to do now is destroy Israel to re-establish the islamic caliphate...
5. Congrats to Spain, and a fact about Spain's 1000 years
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (01.31.07)
First I congratulate Spanish town who show sensitivity to Plaestinian suffering. There is certainly Holocaust or better to tell, there ARE Holocausts in history against Jews. But Zionists abuse this fact to justify their Genocide in Palestine. On the other hand Spain is never a jewish friendly country, neither historically nor most recent. Historically We have a considerable population of Jews migrated from Spain 500 Years ago escaping from Spanish Inquisition. Turkish Jews still speak spanish and they call Spanish "Jewish language".(Not Hebrew suprisingly) Neither most recent history of Spanish Franco Fascism may be taken Friendly to Jews. I hope their move on Palestinian Genocide is not a driven by Anti-semitism but humanism and by their consciousness about Zionist abuse of Holocaust.
6. Spain?
Latrina Goldfarb ,   Medway   (01.31.07)
People of Spain wake up! One day the Muslims will demand the end of the occupation, and the return of Moorish Spain to the entire Muslim nation.
7. The hatred of Old Europe
Sari ,   USA   (01.31.07)
Since when did a genocide result in a population multiplying? New Europe is Old Europe and hate for the Jews comes from the mothers' milk. When will you people learn? Forget it and move on. By the way, a small town in England called Bolton did the same exact thing. Are you surprised?
8. Shouldn't we commemorate "Islamic Suiside Bombers Day"??
KMR ,   Middle East   (01.31.07)
9. Anti-Semitic Spanish pigs. The inquision lives on
Efi ,   Tel Aviv   (01.31.07)
Moshe (comment 1), you are a naive man in the extreme. If you believe these are criticisms of a friend, I don't want to know what criticism by an enemy are! Cancelling Holocaust day and putting in genocide Palestinian day are actions of anti-Semitic pigs, nothing less.
10. What? Genocide denial?
RedStarYeast ,   USA   (01.31.07)
11. A warm friend indeed Moshe
david ,   Tel Aviv Israel   (01.31.07)
Yes Moshe. The inquisition really emitted such warmth and friendship towards the Jewish people. I am overcome with gratitude.
12. remembering holocaust not only for jews
peleg   (01.31.07)
many many people sufferd and were killed in the war, not only jews, so it's an insult to all people
13. spanish holocaust day
tony ,   London UK   (01.31.07)
to Moshe, Bet Shemesh Do you not about the Spanish Inquisition in 1492 how can Spain have been "a warm friend of the Jews for 1000 years what nonsense!
14. Isabella back? Poor Eurabia!
nell ,   switzerland   (01.31.07)
15. Spain's Shameful Antisemitic History
semsem ,   New York, USA   (01.31.07)
Not surprising considering Spain's historical Antisemitism and ignorance. This so called "Genocide" is a blood libel and outright lie.
16. Viva Palestina!
Ricardo ,   Jerusalem, Palestine   (01.31.07)
Palestine: was, is & always here.
17. Tayfun
Atilla Karagözoğlu ,   Istanbul   (01.31.07)
we should better not talk about Our Jew Brothers and that spain subject. It is not our business. It is not nice Tayfun. It is not nice. I dont mean hurt your feelings. You are from where I am from. that gives me responsibiliy. thats the reason I did share my opinium with you, here. you are always my own brother. TALK SOMETHING ELSE, PLEASE.
18. palestinian genocide
abed ,   jerusalem   (01.31.07)
both nations had suffered
19. suggestion
israeli ,   israel   (01.31.07)
I strongly suggest that Israel start acknowledgind and commemorating the genocide of South America's native population at the hands of the Spaniards who may have forgotten. Also, to remind the Turks such as Tayfun that it is imperative they remove the plank from their own eyes before they start judging others, we should also acknowledge the Armenian genocide. War crimes are war crimes, and before anyone slams Israel, they should take into account their own wrong doings and put everything into proportion. Genocide is the massive, systematic destruction of a nation. That is why after WWII European Jewry was reduced by some 6 million, and practically wiped out. The atrocities committed by the Nazi are well documented and no on can claim ignorance. The so-called Palestinian Arabs are only multiplying - whatever Israel may be doing to them does not qualify as genocide since it not - ethnic oriented, massive or indiscriminate. Arab propaganda is simply reinventing the dictionary. And how easily and eagerly some fall for it!
20. genocide
solemnman ,   katushaland   (01.31.07)
Something must be done about Israel's peculiar form of genocide!! In 1948 ,when the state was established ,.there were 150,000 Palestinians living in Israel .Due to Israel's most bizzarre form of genocide there are now roughly 1,500,000 Palestinians living in Israel-a tenfold increase.If the consequences of this strange mode of genocide are not abated ,should there be yet another tenfold increase,there could be as many as 15,000,000 Palestinians living in israel in another 58 years.
21. Palestinian Genocide??
Daniel ,   Tel Aviv   (01.31.07)
I think some people have forgotten the meaning of genocide... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genocide Isnt it the Arabs who wanted to wipe-out the Jews and Israel? I dont remember Israel having committed genocide against the Palestinians, or anyone for that fact. Anyone who says otherwise is a revisionist of history and is following a set agenda - i.e. delegitimisation of Israel. “You may fool all the people some of the time, you can even fool some of the people all of the time, but you cannot fool all of the people all the time” - Abraham Lincoln
22. spain is islamic land for all time
zionist forever   (01.31.07)
Sharia law does state that any land occupied by muslims is muslim land forever. The muslims once ruled Spain this means Spain is officialy islamic land so is it surprising that in this islamic land they are talking about remebering a non existant palestian genocide instead of the holocaust which affected the jews.
23. suffering, even dying, is not the same as genocide
NL ,   Israel   (01.31.07)
Genocide is targeted killing aimed at annihilation of a particular subset of the population. Israel clearly didn't do this in 1948 since there were many Arabs who remained in Israel and were unharmed and untargeted. Over 60 percent of Arabs in the mandate fled without seeing an Israeli soldier. Yes, Arabs died in the conflict (so did Jews) and I'm sure that was sad for them. I'm sure it was sad for them to leave, but for people to call this a genocide is dangerous fallacy.
24. No Spain is not an Islamic Country but ...
Ali ,   Lebanon   (01.31.07)
they are standing with what they think is right...You guys beleive that the Holocaust tool place and so on ( nothing against that) and u have friends all over the world supporting that like Germay, USA and so on and this is good for u. However, I don't understanf why anything being done for the Palastians is taken as an offence to those who died in the Holocaust. I have a question here but please only people using proper language respond: Why do u guys get really offended when someones denies that the Holocaust was as big as u think it is? I mean u guys brag about being a democratic state...where is democracy here. But look if you tell me that this hurts the feelings of 20 or 30 $ jew , then why were you blaming muslims for feeling offended when everyone started creating Cartoons on Prophet Mohammad. Just to let u know before answering me back, I beleive that the Holocaust took place.
25. Moshe
Jane   (01.31.07)
Apparently you forgot the Inquisition which took place only a bit more than 500 years ago.
26. I got to talk now
Atilla Karagözoğlu ,   Istanbul   (01.31.07)
GENODICE !!! THAT İS SO-CALLED BAD CHRISTIANS JOB. LOOK AT WORLD HISTORY, THE OWNER OF MOST GENODICES ARE SPANISH, GERMAN, RUSSIAN AND THE OTHERS.... THEY WERE CALLING THEMSELF GOOD CHRISTIANS ONES. I BELIEVE THEY WERE THE WORST AND FAKE ONES. I dont need to say I respect and love normal good Christians.
28. Lets say NO for Future Fights in Genocide Format
Atilla Karagözoğlu   (01.31.07)
Last night I have seen a movie on TV for 25 minutes, the last part of it... Anyway... The movie called something with APRIL. I just cant remember the name. it was in some African country. many deads, kids, women, man...I mean everywhere dead bodies... that was a movie from real life.... There was a father was looking for his little doughter`s dead body in the classroom where there were all dead kids... I HATE FIGHTS.... I HATE WARS.... I AM AFRAID TO SEE FUTURE FIGHTS COMING IN GENOCIDE FORMAT... I AM AFRAID.
29. #24 Mass murder of millions=cartoons of Mohammed????
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (01.31.07)
What kind of demented retarded freak are you?
30. Holocaust - a matter of belief?
Isragirl ,   Qiryat Yam   (01.31.07)
I grew up in Soviet Russia. There, Holocaust wasn't questioned. There, Holocaust didn't happen - nobody talked about it, nobody mentioned it, nobody admitted, reminded nor discussed the sad facts of Ukrainian, Lithuanian and other groups of Jews being rounded up by hundreds and led to the nearest forest for mass execution. So for me Holocaust never existed until at the tender age of 12 a boy I grew up with told me that he was sorry Germans hadn't finished all of the Jews off (I didn't let him copy from my homework). So the knowledge of the Jews being massacred by the Germans and by the locals was there, it just was not acknowledged as a tragedy, but rather as an unfinished project left for the future generations of Europeans. Now, someone like Ali from Lebanon can allow himself to say that he BELIEVES that Holocaust happened, as if he was talking about Marians landing on Earth. Ignorance was the reason for both the Inquisition and the Holocaust. Are we reliving it already?
Next talkbacks
Back to article