News
Clinton slams PA indoctrination
Yaakov Lappin
Published: 08.02.07, 20:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
62 Talkbacks for this article
1. This is the first step of many....
DR ,   Florida, USA   (02.08.07)
How do Palestinians expect to have peace when they teach their children to hate? What kins of culture calls other nations "catastrophes"? These poor kids don't even have a chance at peace and love. They are fillled with hate from the mon=ment they are born. Palis will never have a state and never have a normal life if they keep doing this....very simple!
2. World Wide Mainstream Media needs to report this..
Frosty   (02.08.07)
But in America and EU it will not.
3. Mr Carter will see them as "Slogans Bestowed from Heaven" !!
KMR ,   Middle East   (02.08.07)
4. Clinton is such a obvious hack its pathetic...
Al ,   Canada   (02.08.07)
Ignore her...She is next to useless...In fact she is the head of the village of uselessness... Remember her pathetic rant.? .."Its takes a village to rise a child"...No Hilary it takes a parent.
5. What the hell does she know?
Ironcandle ,   Atlanta, GA   (02.08.07)
6. Right on target
Brod ,   USA   (02.08.07)
Senator Clinton is right on target on this issue. In fact, Rice and Bush should have condemned the Palestinian Islamist-Jihadists about this much earlier. It is time America and the West expose and pressure the dark forces to discard the hate indoctrination in their society. It is time the dark forces are pressured to turn away from their evil ideology. Until then, there will never be true peace in that region of the world.
7. #4 and #5...deal with the Issue at hand.
DR ,   Florida, USA   (02.08.07)
This article is not talking about Hillary. It is about Palestinian kids being indoctrinated into an evil societ of hate and death. What say you about this???
8. All talk and nothing else
Marcel ,   Florida   (02.08.07)
This shameless pollitician looking for votes is the wife of the one who brought Israel the Olso catastrophy and she has the nerve to open her big lying mouth. But then again it is so easy to fool the average Israeli ,he falls for anything more than once.
9. Shame on her coming against poor helpless people!
(02.08.07)
Stop being a hypocrate to get some Jewish money and support!
10. Hillary...Running and finally talking
Steven ,   San Francisco, CA   (02.08.07)
You know... this has been going on for YEARS! NOW she wants to talk about it to get the Jewish vote? B.S. Oh, wait, she's a Yankees and Cubs fan too. Everyone with a brain at least the size of a pea has known this and spoken about it for a LONG time already. Why now? Is she running for President or something?
11. Their version Sesame Street
Ryan ,   Calgary, Canada   (02.08.07)
Suicide Big Bird Bomber, The count is counting dead jews, Oscar is only mad at Isael, Kill an infidel Elmo, and poor Bert and Ernie got squashed by Haniyehufugus for being homosexual. What every happened to teaching your kids to share and play nice with others?
12. RE: Shame on her coming against poor helpless people!
Roy Galut ,   Selah Washington USA   (02.08.07)
Teaching Hate in text books is not the way to help poor people ....my understanding is that saudis are funding the production of these text books....Most Israelis I am sure would be willing to work with the palistinians if they would stop the violence.....but as long as Israels neighbors are insistant on removing israelis from the mideast Israel will continue to act in self defence.
13. This was a major part of the Oslo accords
Roscio ,   Rome, Italy   (02.08.07)
...that Arafat signed in the 1990's. Both sides agreed to immediately eradicate all propaganda from their textbooks and schools. Israel did so, but of course the Philistines never did... they have not honored a single agrreement, not even one with fellow Arab Moslems, in their entire disgraceful history. No matter Hilary's past, I am thrilled that a US candidate has brought it to world media attention again.
14. Bulldozers, Checkpoints, Killings Teach Love
M. Gonzalez ,   NY NYS   (02.08.07)
Oh yeah right, it's the books teaching the little Palestinian kids to hate their brutal occupiers, the Israeli Military Army. It's not their homes being bulldozed, or their olive groves being picked by nasty Jewish Settlers, while they are kept at bay, by IDF machine guns. It's not seeing their friends shot and killed, for throwing rocks at the U.S. provided Israeli driven military tanks patroling their streets. It certainly is not watching their parents humilliated, disgraced at Israeli checkpoints. God forbid, it would be the ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian people taking place since the inception of that Democratic state, Israel. Israel is so good them, so kind, why would they want to blow themselves up. Give me a F****k Break! How stupid do you think we are Hillary, you old hag!
15. re:Shame on her coming against poor helpless people!
Micha   (02.08.07)
Shame on you for supporting the vile education of otherwise uneducated people who do not have proper resources. To be perpetuating hate is only going to lead to badness down the road for the arab peoples. Their time has come. If you choose to continue the hate, then it will be your time as well. If you, instead, want to teach working together, then of course we are interested in that. Do you not have enough land already? Do you not have enough oil revenues? I realize that the sheikhs and princes and kings just fatten up their own salaries with oil revenues and divert it from the people who are truly the sweat and blood of the land. But we can all work together to change that. Trust me, we can work together or fail together. There is no other way. We all want justice.
16. this was NOT the tune she was singing in '98 with Suha
aaron ,   ra'anana   (02.08.07)
17. Textbooks with scewed history...do a internet search for obj
Roy Galut ,   Selah Washington USA   (02.08.07)
For those that need an objective voice from former terrorist and victms of arab terrorism that are from that region...Do a internet search on Bridget Gabriel a Lebonon christian Walid Shoebat a former palistinian Terrorist ..Note for those from nations around the mideast that have an interest in removing israel from the mideast these sources will more than likely be blocked on internet searches or access to those sites-.which should cause those interested in the truth to raise serious questions !
18. RE:World Wide Mainstream Media needs to report this..
Roy Galut ,   Selah Washington USA   (02.08.07)
You are absolutly right - the liberal media will not report it unless it fits thier agenda of electing a liberal candidate ...and then they will scew the facts to make them politicaly correct.
19. Re :Bulldozers, Checkpoints, Killings Teach Love
Roy Galut ,   Selah washington USA   (02.08.07)
Iam not a Hillary supporter ...however A Review of reasons homes are bulldozed and for checkpoints Ect are usualy because of suicide bombings ...rockets being launched into Jewish communities... Sometime I think folks that think like this perfer that israel throw away the concept of self defence....and accept the katusha rockets that hit thier communities and the suiside bombers that bloewup thier buses and malls..... perhaps bulldozing is a little harsh ....but I do think Israel has the right of self defense
20. Did anyone ask her
Tracy W   (02.08.07)
what is she planning to do about Muslim "education" in the US? Mosques and madrasses are teaching exactly the same thing in her own country. Would she or any other US candidate have the guts to address that issue?
21. the textbooks reflect the views of the leadership
alan ,   kodiak alaska   (02.09.07)
If only the political leaders from around the world would take notice of Hillary's remarks and apply them to the leadership of the Palestinean Authority and Hamas who announced in Saudi Arabia that they need to "liberate" their land, aka destroy Israel. For make no mistake, it is the leadership's position that there will be no peace with Israel until Israel ceases to exist. Why else the disturbing state sponsership of child abuse by teaching children to hate others
22. what about Israeli texts?
(02.09.07)
And are the Israeli texts fair towards the Palestinians? Are there any Arabs or Palestinians portrayed in a positive light in their books or media? I condemn PA indoctrination, as much as Israel's. But worse yet is Israel's criminal treatment of the Palestinians. Stop the Occupation, the collective punishments and compensate Palestinians for their losses and maybe then Israelis and Palestinians could start TALKING to each other and working towards peaceful co-existence. There are Israelis that need to admit that Palestinians exist and are NOT a myth! Palestinians also need to feel that Israel is not trying to wipe them off the map!
23. and these are the moderates
leroy ,   usa   (02.09.07)
24. # 22 judging from your questions....
Ivri   (02.09.07)
you havent read Israeli Nor PA's education books...or you wouldnt ask.IF you have read them...you would see the diffrence right away AND you would come on here and scream about it Can somebody screen the uninformed fools who post on here....PLEASE !!!!!!!!
25. You go girl! Now, no more kisses for Suha, okay?
Josh   (02.09.07)
26. AMAZING WHAT WE FIND OUT WHEN WE CHOOSE TO SMELL THE COFFEE
DAVID P ,   SANTA CRUZ, USA   (02.09.07)
27. Rhetorical questions only! #24
(02.09.07)
28. WHERE ARE THE KIDNAPPED SOLDIERS ???
(02.09.07)
COWARDS !
29. While I agree with Hillary
Joe ,   Ohio, USA   (02.09.07)
I've seen enough of her and her husband to last me a life time! GO AWAY!
30. Hillary the Panderer
JJohnson ,   Turks & Caicos   (02.09.07)
Does anyone believe she really cares about the content of Palestinian textbooks.
Next talkbacks
Back to article