News
Only nuclear bomb can stop Israeli digging, Egypt MP says
Reuters and Ynetnews
Published: 12.02.07, 23:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
68 Talkbacks for this article
31. #2 It doesn't mattert -- muslims had problem blowing up the
AK   (02.13.07)
'sacred' golden- dome mosque in Iraq. Their ‘sacred’ shrines only serve as political tool to be used against us, the 'infidels.' The 'sacred' mosque of the rock rotted for centuries until in the 1920 was resurrected as a sacred islamic shrine for anti-Jewish political reasons and only willfully ignorant, including our politicians, academics and our press, are not aware of that well known, documented fact.
32. WHo is El Katatny
Peter ,   Toronto Canada   (02.13.07)
He is the leader of the Islamic Brotherhood Parliamentary Bloc in the Egyptian Parliament. The truth is that this guy speaks for the street, but not the government. This has always been the problem with Egypt. The moderate government does not represent the people. Egypt is a powder keg. Always has been, and always will.
33. who will replace Mubarak in a well armed Egypt
zionist forever   (02.13.07)
Israel needs to start looking at Egypt as a real threat to security see them as the Iran next door. A few weeks ago the Egyptian parliamnet formerly said that Egypt should get nukes after that idiot Olmerts remarks and now we have talk about tearing up the 1979 peace treaty. Mubarak might be responsible enough to only allow weapons smuggling to hamas and not to tear up the treaty and start a conventional war but Mubarak is an old man and there is no obvious succesor for when he dies so there is a good chance the muslim brotherhood or some other extremists are going to come to power after he is gone and they have never supported the peace treaty and would teaar it up overnright especialy considering that thanks to America Egypt has the strongest arab army with just about every advanced American weapon Israel has including one of the most advanced versions of F16s, JDAMS, M1A1 abrams tanks built under licence in Egypt, apache helicopters, modern radar systems.... Today Egypt is a much bigger millitary threat than it has ever been in the past and there is a growing possibility that war will eventually break out at the same time the US continies to arm Egypt to the teeth. This is certainly not the time to be giving the Golan to Syria. It wont take alot to unite the arabs and have them launch another war in an attempt to destroy Israel and drive the jews into the sea.
34. #21 Khaled
enzo ,   london,uk   (02.13.07)
But you "crazy messed up brainwashed muslim fanatic" didn't mind killing thousand of innocent people of all races on 9/11...!
35. Give #7 a break will ya?
Khaled ,   Lebanon   (02.13.07)
Some of you people should try to loosen up a bit. I mean She's a Lebanese like myself, and we're both making an effort to read Israeli newspaper, read the talkbacks, and try to understand your side of every story... At least give us some credit for that. We're not a bunch of undercover fanatics trying to introduce some propaganda into this forum... We're not closed-minded brainwashees who only get their news from Hizbollah's official TV and radio stations. We're just trying to open some kind of dialogue with those who have different views because as Libnaniyyeh said, a major problem we have is lack of communication... So let's try to keep an open mind about opposing points of view. I'd think, with all the talk here about how Israel is such a civilized country, that I shouldn't be the one telling you to this.
36. #21. even for 73 virgins???
Rehavam ,   Haifa   (02.13.07)
I'm not assuming. you ARE "crazy messed up brainwashed muslim fanatic who does in fact want to kill all the jews in israel... " ALL OF THAT and MORE. The "day after" Nasralla or some other roach will declear all dead muslims - SHAHIDS. He'll sat thay all VERY,VERY happy in jenna. each one of them got 72 virgins. He'll say all christians 5 sec before blast converted to islam and they WERY, WERY HAPPY in heaven. Of coase all jews are enemy of mohamed and they got what they deserved. He'll send some mutnat-muslims to "rebuild al-aksa". Islam got back "falestine", "honor", punish "evil zionists". bla bla bla... Never mind if it nucklear desert as long as it islamic. in last 15 years World seen 10.000 suicide bombings. One more (even if it big one) will not make impresion.
37. Egyptian MP not unusual
Bernard Ross ,   St. Anns Bay Jamaica   (02.13.07)
this is the real position of the egyptians; a few more of these MP's and the "peace" treaty is gone. Then what?
38. 7 Hey Lib.. time to get a life.. when the christian
freedom ,   canada   (02.13.07)
churches numbering five were burned in the west bank. I didnt here you then... Tough, really tough.. Its only by grace that all of Jerusalem is not under Israeli rule. Cant have it both ways... Now can you...
39. #21 "A nuke will kill muslims"
Robert Klein ,   Texas   (02.13.07)
Khaled in Lebanon; of course a muslim fanatic would never drop a nuke on Israel. Because a muslim would never kill another muslim. Shiite/Sunni in Iraq Iran/Iraq war. Afghanistan Pakistan On very rare occaisions, muslims actually harm muslims.
40. Mission Accomplished
Sandy ,   NYC   (02.13.07)
Israel has a single mission and that is not to negotiate for land. The strategy they use is to incite the muslims and make the west fight them. The 'construction' was precisely that and it worked. Good job. Rapture might be coming sooner than we think.
41. 21# So why are your countrymen planting bombs and kidnapping
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (02.13.07)
Israeli's up north? Is that your mirror crossing over into Israeli territory? These little skirmishes can turn into big skirmishes like 1973 did. And if backed into a corner like all the Arabs want.......these bombs are going to fly. Don't kid yourself that it can't happen. You will miscalculate just like last summer.....and everyone will pay the price. It's in the Arabs best interest to make peace. If they are to intolerant to do so then......your worst nightmare will eventually happen. Mistakes get made....just like Hezbollah did last summer.
42. The Day After
Dave Levy ,   Burbank. USA   (02.13.07)
If one hair, on one Israeli head is affected by a WMD fired by Iran or any other Arab-Muslim country, Damascus, Cairo, Beirut and Amman will all disappear in clouds of mushroom smoke. Then these bastards can go to their heaven to cavort with 72 virgins. Oh, I forgot the Aswan Dam, whose demise will floor the entire Nile...with predictable consequences.
43. #21
jason ,   usa   (02.13.07)
ever thought about a war head nuclear tipped?
44. Protect Israel - Re-take the Sinai
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (02.13.07)
45. to #22 palestinian
jul   (02.13.07)
Yeah right Palestinian! As a matter of fact , we all know that when the temple Mount and the Western Wall where in muslim hands, you used it as a rubbish dump...
46. to#35 Khalid, Lebanon
jul   (02.13.07)
Unfortunaly, you are a tiny minority:90% of your side behave show ignorance and behave as possessed lunatics. How do you justify a show on national TV where children are INVITED to become suicidal martirs? I think yoiu have to work hard to convince your people my friend
47. @7 and 35, welcome
Suzanne   (02.13.07)
I welcome your contributions. They usually sound sane, even if you happen to have a different opinion. Concerning the lack of "other" news in the Arab countries than the showing of dead Palestinian or Iraqi bodies over and over again, IS a problem in those countries. Does not mean that the comment of this guy is outrageous. I mean, a NUKE?
48. JERUSALEM IS NEVER MENTIONED IN THE KORAN!
Palestiniansareamyth ,   USA   (02.13.07)
Jerusalem belongs to the Jews! Mecca to the Muslims. End of story!
49. talking is cheap
Atilla Karagözoğlu   (02.13.07)
"Only nuclear bomb can stop Israeli digging, Egypt MP says " ******************** lets analyses these words ! All I see great stupidness. They cant create any politics but they love to use nukes !!! NUKES MEANS MILLION DEADS NUKES MEANS JUST BAD. only stupids talks to use nukes. create new politics instead talking non sense. why I am not a Leader in Middle East ? I am more okey than them. more young. more healty mind. believing in peace. loving human. and good looking :) Come on Middle East ! vote for me. Maybe I am not a prophet !!! but believe me I can put Middle East into dicipline.
50. Peace Treaties With Arabs.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (02.13.07)
Don't make me laugh - the most you can expect is a temporary state of non-war.
51. #21 Good morning Khaled
Cynthia ,   US   (02.13.07)
Do you really think Ahmadinejad would hesitate to nuke Israel for fear he would harm the surrounding Muslims/Arabs? He could care less about you. In fact, nuking Lebanon, Syria, Egypt, Jordan and the Palestinians would expedite his dream of Iranian dominance of the region. There would be no one remaining to stop him. Iran poses a global threat.
52. Nuclear bomb and Egypt MP
Arthur ,   Israel   (02.13.07)
This man has to be carefully analyzed! He may be breaching the peace agreement signed by his country. Why Israel trusts these people; I don't understand; and repeatedly make same mistake! “Land for peace” does not work with Arabs. They now know even Israel wins the physical war; but she is a looser at the UN table. This is failure on the part of UN; it makes the rules and does nothing to protect the nation who returns the land after loosing so many lives and astronomical amount of hard earned money. We are at the square one again! This time if land is conquered think of empting it totally and annexing it, don’t be afraid UN does nothing excepting condemning in strongest words (barks are harmless).
53. Bomb Israel..
Lynne   (02.13.07)
I don't think it's very wise to threaten one another with nukes.. we should start to figure out a new language other than bombs.. wars.. Mohamed el-Katatny knows very well that it is impossible to nuke Israel because the aftermath of using a nuclear bomb will affect the whole region and not only Israel.. let alone the humane and moral side in such an act.. the only way to save this region is by restricting the development of nuclear weapons in ALL countires (Iran AND Israel included)..
54. #21: just one example: think of last summer's war
Tobias ,   Germany   (02.13.07)
Dear Khaled, you think there won't be any muslim fanatics who dare to bomb Israel because they would kill not only jews but also christians and muslims, destroy not only synagoges but also churches and mosques? So what did your lebanese countrymen from Hisbollah do in last summer? They shot 4000 rockets into an area where also hundets of thousands of muslims live - e.g. Nazareth, Akko, Haifa... - they killed jews, christians and muslims: They regard jews and christians (no matter whether civilian or soldier) as legitimate targets, and after killing two muslim children in Nazareth, Nasrallah simply said: "Dear parents, you can be proud of your sons, because they died as martyrs in the righteous, holy war against the zionists." As far as I know, no mosque was hit by a katjusha rocket, but this is pure coincidents. They shot rockets to Akko, Nazareth and Haifa, where there are a lot of mosques. So you see, there are indeed muslims who don't see a problem with killing other muslims (as also many news reports from Iraq and Gaza confirm). Especially Nasrallah's statement after the killing the two muslim children showed it clearly: "muslim civilian victims of our rockets? even children? no problem - be proud of them, call them martyrs, blame Israel"
55. DR #1..
Lynne   (02.13.07)
your comments always incite hate and violence.. you never waste a chance in using whatever incidents take place to spit out your hatred towards Arabs and Muslims.. and then we find you complaining that Arabs and Muslims only hate!!
56. The Sunni Arabs destroyed the Shiites holiest shrine in 2006
Ken Jurist   (02.13.07)
What liars these Egyptians are. Here are the facts. The Sunni Arabs destroyed the Shiites holiest shrine last year. The Golden Dome Mosque in Samarra. Israel is reparing a damaged bridged. Someone said it best to me. The definition of an Arab moderate, is one that runs out of ammunition.
57. Most Arabs think like this Egyptian MK
Eric Ritter   (02.13.07)
What this Arab MK said, is probabaly how 80 percent of Arabs feel. Its sad that Amira Hass and Gideon Levy dont realize this.
58. Sinai is Egyptian!
Karim ,   UK   (02.13.07)
I have no idea what u guys on about! Sinai is an Egyptian land! u talk like its urs and u gave it away! u know what.... maybe its time to go back to ur legal borders.... and stop the occupation of other people with ur coward IDF (Israeli Dumb Fools)
59. He will be joining government; following Lieberman's example
(02.13.07)
Egyptians pursue the Israeli example; whether good or bad ! "You brought it to yourselves" is encouraged by the israelis.
60. Why is this not made more public
jackiekc ,   St Petersburg, FL   (02.13.07)
I have not seen anything about this Egyptian minister's comments in any Western media. Why is the rest of the world not condemning it? Maybe some publicity would be helpful. Your Arab friends do not hesitate to pull out all the stops when they are mildly upset. I think a second nuclear threat from a different country deserves some publicity. Maybe those idiots at the UN would take notice.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article