Jewish Scene  Rabbi Levi Brackman
A deadly epidemic sweeping across our world
Rabbi Levi Brackman
Published: 23.03.07, 11:14
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
51 Talkbacks for this article
1. Quite obvious! How many desparate Jews did blow up in WWII?
Jew ,   Israel   (03.23.07)
2. this is our strength, we love death
palistinian ,   usa   (03.23.07)
and death will bring us glory and afterlife you can not handle it because you belief is not strong enaugh and that is way you are going to lose in the end i am just telling you the truth believe me i can see it coming for us death is a tool
3. Dear Rav Brackman
Teimani ,   Europe   (03.23.07)
I agree with you that the initial "diagnosis" of "kamikazi" bombing was wrong. It is not poverty or lack of opportunities that leads to this "illness". However, keeping to the analogy, you might want to consider the following in making a better diagnosis. Like with every contagion, there is the pathogen and environmental/social conditions that nake people more vulnerable to catching and spreading the pathogen. One must try to deal with both the pathogen and the enviro-socio-conditions that help it. Sometimes it is easier to deal with the latter. IMHO, the latter in this case, is a perception of injustice in the muslim/arab world and an a perceived sense of muslim/arab weakness to correct this injustice in conventional ways. The "pathogen" is hard to identify. But if I were to hazard aguess it is a hybrid of unenlightened western domination of the middle-east and morally bankrupt middle-eastern leadership. So to deal with the pathoden begin with more enlightened western domination that supports leadership that more closely identifies with tehir constituents. To deal with the "unhygienic" enviro-social conditions: well work towards justice in the middle-east, and ideally in the whole world. That is "tikkun" in ivrit. Unfortunately, the cat has been let out of the bag and the clock is now ticking. What is now an epidemic may become a pandemic. The sovereign world power(s) have been given an ultimatum to pursue justice. Europe appears to be leading the way. Sincerely Teimani
4. Excellent analysis.
Yisraeli   (03.23.07)
5. rabbi not well informed
sara   (03.23.07)
The rabbi is not well informed about the topic of suicide bombings.His generalisations are somewhat political and do not understand the conditions of the suicide bomber's life.He sits in his study and reflects on a phenomenon he does not really care to understand. It seems to be one more opportunity to express his racism against the Muslim world.
6. You created the suicide bombers
(03.23.07)
By treating the Palistinians like animals since more than 50 years , look at this boy which have been beated by the IDF , this one if he bacame a suicide bomber who hast to be blamed here ..... you remeber Irgun ?? , you remeber King David's hotel bombing ?? if you forgot ... here it is . http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_David_Hotel_bombing was this an act of deperation or a barberian act too ??
7. Useless article.
Benjamin ,   TA Isreal   (03.23.07)
Just repeating banalities. There is no any kind of analysis, no attempt to dig into social or psychological roots, no explanation how suicidal bombers recruited, what kind of people become bombers and what not, are there significant opposition in the Islamic society to suicidal bombing or not. No research at all, just repeating what everyone know anyway. But I wouldn't expect anything better from the person promoting enterprise approach to religion.
8. rabbi,does Judaism condone murder?
vijaya   (03.23.07)
Rabbi,does Judaism condone murder? In 2006,17 Israelis were killed by the Palestinians,1 was a minor and 6 Israeli soldiers were killed. 666 Palestinians were killed in 2006 by the Israelis,half of whom were not even engaged in any hostilities.141 were minors. Does Judaism believe in the indiscriminate bulldozing of houses,the arrest of innocent civilians and the setting up of people in fenced areas,with checkpoints at every turn?And withholding millions in taxes collected from these same people? And preventing the free passage of goods in and out of the country and choking the econonomy of a people because of its superior military power? Does Judaism condone the illegal Occupation and Settlement of other people's lands?
9. To Pails
Jellybean ,   Chicago   (03.23.07)
If you love death so much why are you living in the USA? Go back to Palestine and blow yourself up! WHIMP!
10. No. 2- No Glory in the Afterlife
(03.23.07)
NO virgins and NO heaven. The afterlife for you will be Hell. Suicide does not equal strength. Get that sorted in your head. On this day, do one thing, choose life.
11. Where did suicide tactics get the Japanese?
Barry   (03.23.07)
Only to persuade the USA to use 2 atomic bombs against them in preference to conventional war tactics. The Muslim world should remember that the USA now has over ten thousand nuclear weapons including city busting H-Bombs
12. #2 What are you doing in the USA?!
Logic ,   Israel   (03.23.07)
What a stupid mistake by the INS to let you in!!!
13. #6...how about suiceide bombings in Iraq?
DR ,   Florida, USA   (03.23.07)
Did Israel create those too? You are a delusional, brainwahsed idiot to say these things. There are many opressed people all over the world, yet Muslims are the only ones that do this. They kill each other everyday in Iraq, attacking mosques, markets etc. Is this Israel's fault too? Get real!!!
14. No Difference
James Biga ,   Colorado Springs USA   (03.23.07)
Your words will fall on deaf ears. To admit that the doctrine is barbaric would mean that people have to admit there is evil and that we have an enemy. This violates the la-la land they are trying to build.
15. Jewish strenght, life, Palestinias, death, No. 2
Jorge ,   Tegucigalpa   (03.23.07)
That is the only Arab "creation" a culture of death, destruction, nothing doing with building a society, civilizing societies, a doctrine of relentless hate for anyone and anybody not believing as they do. No.2, no matter what, that is why, you alredy lost, the WORLD HAS LEFT YOU BEHIND, everyday more so.
16. 6 - understand, indeed!
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (03.23.07)
it is interesting how a few isolated acts throughout the history of the world, where someone would sommit suicide murder, that in every case save one, suicide murder was repudiated and each society treats it as a shameful act, though actually happened, that is not to be repeated because of the perverse motives that are antithetical to whatever cause it was that was being fought against. not for the palestinians, though. instead of repudiating it, they glorify, encourage, and proudly seek further depths of depravity (see http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3380073,00.html). you can blame a number of sources for the creation of suicide bombers, but palestinians have perfected and multiplied the most disgusting combination of quasi-religion, racism, hate, and butchery as the highest virtue of both young babies and the eldery. personally, i think the occupation affords a chance for salvation for palestinians against such a death cult, if they would only embrace it as a positive thing in their lives.
17. #2 & others
R. Alkalai ,   USA   (03.23.07)
Go outside tonight, and look upon the stars. See how countless many there are. They expand into infinity. All of life and matter is constantly expanding and creating more life. This is the way of G-D-and Creation. All of life is a sacred miracle that only G-D can create. It is from hubris and vanity that man exalts himself to think he has a divine right to destroy life because he believes that his own beliefs should exist exclusively, or that his actions ensure passage into Paradise, or salvation. G-D created many life forms, G-D created many peoples. Our physical bodies are animal form-and like all manifestations in this plane of existence, we feed from the land, expell waste, breathe oxygen, and procreate by sexual organs. In death, we leave the physical body behind. It decays and becomes, once again, of the earth. Only the soul exists. As such, we no longer require food, expell waste, breathe air, or pro-create, or experience physical sensations. There is no physical body to require such needs. But what does remain are the desires of the ego- that which is still attached to this plane, and waiting to be removed from the soul, as they are no longer needed. Why then, would one even require a reward of 72 virgins, when we no longer have sexual organs, or earthly physical manifestation- unless of course, we are still bound to lower desires? Such desires are nothing more than lust of the physical body. That is why it is considered sin- it holds us in bondage to lower form only, and thus, far away from G-D. To believe that others who do not believe as we do, should convert or perish, and to end our own lives in that belief, is an insult to G-D's perfection. G-D created many peoples, and many life forms. Spiritual evolution belongs to the soul exclusively, not to any mortal in an attempt to govern another's soul. Therefore, no human can ever demand of another's soul. Only G-D can demand of the soul. If you can be convinced to hate to the point of killing others, or yourself, then evil has already overtaken you. Such obsession creates the compulsion. Spiritual teachers and political leaders that intentionally provoke, and indulge such emotions, thus enslaving others to perform the sins of obsessions, are the practitioners of the darkest of arts, as they cause the soul to be earth-bound. Thus, the soul has no peace. Palestinian, it is not that we are not strong. It is that we respect what G-D created, beyond vanity, hubris, and the ego's perverse need for "glory" in the afterlife.
18. racism by callers
lakshmi   (03.23.07)
The poor quality of some the callers' comments indicates either their racism or their ignorance. They should spend some time studying the history of the Palestine-Israeli conflict. Unfortunately,the Rabbi himself is setting a bad example by calling suicide bombing a 'barbaric doctrine.' The Palestinians call them martyrs, for defending their people against a brutal Occupation. Every life,whether Jewish or Palestinian is important.If the Rabbi does not uphold this sacred truth,then he is,in my opinion,not fit to lead a religious community. A previous caller, cited some important stats.Please look at them and understand the situation.
19. #6
Margaret   (03.23.07)
What about all the violence committed against the Jews by the Arabs like the riots of 1920 and 1921 when dozens of Jews were murdered by Arabs in Jerusalem and other parts of Palestine,or the Hebron massacre in 1929 all these atrocities occurred years before the King David bombing. What were the Arabs retalating for those murders about? Your just another in a long line of hateful people who like to blame and scapegoat the poor Jews for everything wrong in this world.
20. Vijaya
Margaret   (03.23.07)
Do you think the British and Americans were more morally culpable for the conflict in World War 2 than the Nazis, because thousands of more German civilians were killed then Americans and British civilians, when allied forces bombed German and Japenese cities? Are you aware or do you even care that more Palestinian children have been killed by Palestinians this year then by Israelis including a 2 year old boy yesterday, and a 7 year old girl a week ago? Are you aware that many Palestinian children are taught by their parents,teachers, and relgious leaders that to die killing Jews,including Jewish children is the greatest thing in the world? And that almost every week a Palestinian "youth" is caught at a checkpoint with pipebombs,knives or another weapon mean't to kill people? Does any of this concern you at all, or are you here to only condemn and badmouth Israelis because you hate the Jews like many people do today?
21. Stupidity is also an ingredient of becoming a suicide bomber
Drumgoole ,   Newark NJ   (03.23.07)
The postings in response to Rabbi Brackman's article show how difficult it will be to stop this evil. I hope that #2 is a phony who wrote his posting declaring his love of death as a tongue in cheek satire of suicide bombers. I fear that #2 is serious. Others who wrote show exactly how easy it is to sort of function in society despite low intelligence and without a soul. The moron who wrote about the Irgun's bombing of the King David Hotel is a case in point. What did this have to do with suicide bombing? It was an attack on the British that was a bombing(NOT A SUICIDE BOMBING) and it was condemned by the Jewish community in the Holy Land. The other nonsense of pathogens etc also showed how a little knowledge is dangerous when one does not understand analogies. Since so many suicide bombers are very young and totally brainwashed by their elders, the pathogen is the brainwashing and the environment of parents who raise their children in a violent and brutal culture. How disgusting that a culture that forces women to wear a veil and engages in honor killings of women who have been raped would promise a sexual orgy to men who engage in suicide bombings. What kind of crazy evil is this? Finally, the idiot citing his hallucinatory statistics (666 Palestinians killed) shows the complete lack of morality of this sydrome. What are the statistics of murder among Shites who are killing Sunnis in Iraq and vice versa by suicide bombings?
22. who is Rabbi Levi Brackman ????
(03.23.07)
who is Rabbi Levi Brackman??? Jews!!! soooo this has to be negative views about muslims......
23. wild dog analogy
david   (03.23.07)
in india and africa they have wild dogs. they roam around in packs and attack everything in their path. a pack might attack a large animal that might kill a dog or two but in the end they will kill the animal. that is the psychology of suicide bombing. it is suicide for the first dog to attack but the culture of the dogs is so viscious that the dogs no longer think for themselves
24. two suicide types; which of which is worst OR preventable ?
(03.23.07)
25. It's the 72 virgins!
Yacov   (03.23.07)
It is those 72 virgins that are causing the suicide epidemic. No virgins, no homicide bombers.
26. # 6
JAN   (03.23.07)
No my friend, it is hate that has created suicide bombers. You and your people wallow in it and feed off of it. You try to kill your enemies as well as each other. So when someone from hamas puts on a suicide vest and blows up people from the fatah side of town who is the one that created the suicide bomber? Hamas or fatah? Your logic makes no sense, but then again radical muslims NEVER make sense.
27. Palestine history
vijaya   (03.23.07)
Margaret,do read Palestine history,all the way back to the establishment of a Zionist state in Palestine. Theodor Herzel who wrote Der JudenStaat(1896) and was one of the major founders of Zionism,claimed that a Zionist state,would defend Europe against the barbarians. In my opinion this is racism. In re: to hating Jews,no I do not hate them.The international community is just at the end of its patience over a conflict,which is the longest one in modern history. Do read historian Ilan Pappe's The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine.It shows very clearly that the Nakba of 1948,the expulsion of the indigenous Arab population from their villages was a deliberate preplanned act by the Jewish leaders.It was not just the result of war.Villagers were driven out at gunpoint,their homes firebombed,grenades thrown into houses and so on. And today's brutal Occupation does no credit to Israel.The sooner Israel and its supporters come to the table and negotiate Peace the better for both Palestine and Israel,and for the world community.The Beirut Initiative of 2002 is being reconsidered.It is all there and Israel has to come to the table. And by the way, there are many Jewish Peace organisations working towards that end.Do communicate with them.
28. "rabbi", then how come
Khalid   (03.23.07)
you only see suicide bombs where there is war and desparation? there are no suicide bombers in saudi arabia, indonesia, uae, morocco or any muslim nations where there is no war against the u.s. or israel. suicide bombers are in iraq, afghanistan, and occupied palestine, do you find any similarities in these three countries?? oh right, they're all UNDER MILITARY OCCUPATION!
29. Tipping Point Misquote
Aliza ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (03.23.07)
Malcom Gladwell wrote about Micronesian PERSONAL suicide, i.e. where the individual does not inflict physical harm on those around him. While I agree with the issue of suicide epidemics you are writing about, it's wrong to misuse someone's study to make your point.
30. #2-Ah, that explains your miserable cultural mediocrity.....
Cameron ,   USA   (03.23.07)
and failure among the living. It all becomes clear 'Success through death' What a masterful strategy
Next talkbacks
Back to article